• Medical Ethics Abortion
    rights over her body are more important than the life of the person or part person in her womb.”[2] A Woman’s Right to Self-Defence Judith Jarvis Thomson presents the following hypothesis:[3] a woman becomes pregnant and then learns that she has a cardiac condition that will cause her death if...
    Premium 3197 Words 10 Pages
  • Is Abortion Ever Justfied?
    truth this example holds, as we will see it is also important to think of some persons as being physically dependent for the sake of analogy when Judith Jarvis Thomson's violinist is considered. However, like birth, viability is determined by contingent factors that change with medical and technological...
    Premium 2458 Words 6 Pages
  • The Implication of Abortion
    involved that she should be allowed to make the choice as to whether to continue or to terminate her pregnancy. According to philosopher Judith Jarvis Thomson: “a great deal turns for women on whether abortion is or is not available. If abortion rights are denied, then a constraint is imposed...
    Premium 2270 Words 6 Pages
  • Research Paper
    Controversies,” in Kenneth Himma and Herman Tavani, eds., The Handbook of Information and Computer Ethics (Hoboken: Wiley, 2008), pp. 131-164. Judith Jarvis Thomson, "The Right to Privacy," in Michael J. Gorr and Sterling Harwood, eds., Crime and Punishment: Philosophic Explorations (Belmont, CA: Wadsworth...
    Premium 1288 Words 4 Pages
  • Pro-Abortion Essay
    weighed more heavily. In adherence to considering the mothers rights, I will also examine the principle of autonomy. In doing so I will refer to Judith Jarvis Thomson’s thought experiments (2007, p. 353-362) to provide perception and help determine under which circumstances this may be applicable. In terms...
    Premium 2606 Words 7 Pages
  • A Modern Controversy: the Case of George Tiller
    to prohibit abortion would be to infringe upon the rights of the mother. One of the more interesting illustrations of this point comes from Judith Jarvis Thomson. She asks you to imagine that you wake up one morning to find yourself in a hospital bed. You are connected to an unconscious man in an adjacent...
    Premium 8889 Words 22 Pages
  • Abortion
    prevents the mother from having a future like ours even though the fetus itself has a future like ours. However, the self-defense theory of Judith Jarvis Thomson (Doing Ethics 180), author of A Defense of Abortion, can be applied here. Since it is the fetus which puts another being’s life in danger and...
    Premium 1484 Words 4 Pages
  • Preferential Hiring
    Turkish Obligations Code, clause 41, p451 1982, Turkish Constitutions, clauses 25,87. P21,45 Simon,Robert. Preferential Hiring: A reply to Judith Jarvis Thomson. Jstore Database. Retrieved in: 01.04.2011...
    Premium 1411 Words 4 Pages
  • Abortion: Moral and Social Problems
    going through with the abortion, according to them. The third moderate position argues whether or not one is obligated in protecting the fetus. Judith Jarvis Thomson, a moderate, said “the fetus has a right to life but not a right to sustain that life by using the mother’s body against her will” (P 171)....
    Premium 2202 Words 6 Pages
  • Ethics Paper - Abortion Debate
    entitlement to personhood and you cannot kill a child with your genetic characteristics or to avoid the responsibility of social parenting. Judith Jarvis Thomson’s thesis gives us a graphic description of a violinist who without your consent, is attached to you and relies upon you for his/her life...
    Premium 2780 Words 9 Pages
  • Abortion Ethics
    who are not up to the standard of personhood do not have rights. 6. Judith Thomson’s defense of abortion: Suppose the fetus is a person or human being and has the right to life. Is it always wrong to have abortion? No. Thomson argues that abortion is morally permissible for some cases of abortion—pregnancy...
    Premium 2911 Words 10 Pages
  • Abortion: Morally Permissible or Impermissible?
    circumstances provided by the philosophical views and also from biological development principles of science in general and some views mentioned by Thomson, which would make abortion morally permissible. Don Marquis expresses that abortion is seriously immoral with very few exceptions to justify abortion...
    Premium 2534 Words 7 Pages
  • Politic
    cannot stand up to rational criticism. For these reasons, they argue that the conservative view should be rejected. g. Thomson and the Argument of The Sickly Violinist Judith Jarvis Thomson presents an interesting case in her landmark article “A Defense of Abortion” (1971) in order to show that, even if...
    Premium 8408 Words 21 Pages
  • Exam 1 - Philosophy
    good cannot exist for a being that is not. Eventually, one cannot benefit the patient as a whole by making him dead. 6. The elements of Judith Jarvis Thomson’s example that make it analogous to the situation of pregnancy due to rape are the one who was plugged into the unconscious violinist was...
    Premium 3161 Words 8 Pages
  • Euthanasia
    and Passive Euthanasia." The New England Journal of Medicine (1975): 78-80. Ronald Dworkin, Thomas Nagel, Robert Nozick, John Rawls, and Judith Jarvis Thomson, et al. "The Philosopher's Brief." http://cyber.law.harvard.edu/bridge/Philosophy/philbrf.htm, December 1996....
    Premium 1928 Words 5 Pages
  • abortion
    become an astronaut, but few will achieve that. The mother is an actual person and so her rights must take precedence over a potential life. Judith Jarvis Thomson gave the analogy of a famous violinist to defend abortion. Doctrine of Double Effect This doctrine accepts that abortion may occur as a...
    Premium 1757 Words 5 Pages
  • Difficult choices
    Degrazia, David, & Mappes, Thomas A. (Eds.), Biomedical Ethics (pp. 713-714). New York, NY: McGraw-Hill Publishing Company. (7th ed.), Print. Thomson, Judith Jarvis. (1971). A Defense of Abortion. Brand-Ballard, Jeffrey, & Degrazia, David, & Mappes, Thomas A. (Eds.), Biomedical Ethics (pp. 479-487). New...
    Premium 1817 Words 7 Pages
  • Abortion: a Word That Causes a Great Deal of Controversy
    think of what happens to our bodies as something that is happening to us, which allows that person the right to make choices about their life. Judith Jarvis Thomson argued that abortion is morally permissible even if a fetus is viewed as a person with full rights. She states that we are not morally required...
    Premium 1832 Words 5 Pages
  • Carribean Studies
    pro-life argument, while a negative answer would support claim (2) in the central pro-choice argument. Another family of arguments (see the section on Thomson, below) relates to bodily rights¡Xthe question of whether the woman¡¦s bodily rights justify abortion even if the fetus has a right to life. A negative...
    Premium 3612 Words 9 Pages
  • The Ethics of Abortion: Pro-Life vs. Pro-Choice
    into a utilitarian moral framework. Excerpt. Thomson, Judith Jarvis. "A Defense of Abortion." Philosophy & Public Affairs, 1 (Fall, 1971). This article is reprinted in the three collections edited by Cohen, Baird, and Feinberg respectively. Thomson is a professional philosopher who has done extensive...
    Premium 2005 Words 7 Pages