Preview

What About Bob

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
545 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
What About Bob
After watching the movie What about Bob, I chose to write about the Character of Dr Marvin, the psychiatrist who goes on a vacation with his family and finds Bob, one of his multi-phobic patients, following him everywhere because of being attached to him. Dr Marvin chooses to act negatively to what Bob is doing and shows three different ways or mechanisms to deal with his anger. These mechanisms are denial, projection and displacement.
As a result of being provoked and followed all the time by Bob, Dr Marvin feels angry and stressed, he shows some obvious mechanisms to cope with his internal anger. The first way that Dr Marvin shows is denial which is choosing not to recognize an emotion or a problem. Throughout the movie we get the sense that Dr Marvin envies Bob. He feels that Bob is taking all the credit for things that belong to him. For example, he feels envy because his family loves Bob for being sensitive and a good listener, while he is not, and he gets into a condition of denial because he refuses to admit that he may be jealous from his multi-phobic patient.
The second coping mechanism that Dr Marvin shows is projection, which is putting his faults onto someone else. Dr Marvin is very angry with Bob that he constantly projects his anger onto him. Being a psychiatrist, he should consider the fact that Bob is a patient who needs treatment, but instead he blames anything that goes wrong in his life on Bob. For example, not being very good in front of the cameras when he is in Good Morning America, and behaving the way he does with his wife and kids.
The third defense mechanism that we see with Dr Marvin is displacement, which is transferring emotions from the original source to another. Dr Marvin's anger gets uncontrollable and instead of being the one who helps people manage and control their emotions, his own emotions get out of control. We see Dr Marvin yelling all the time to Bob and to his family. He displaced his anger and hatred to Bob on anything

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    He mentions to him that he makes his evaluation after 3 sessions. Resistance begins after this and continues for several sessions. Because the psychiatrist was trying to give an evaluation of Antwone, this movie gave an example of a counselor’s assessment rather than simply finding a diagnosis. On a side note, Dr. Davenport, as a psychiatrist on a navy base, would be used to this type of resistance, but watching him sit around patiently waiting for Antwone to say something was surprising for me. I would have expected him to take his not talking for the first 3 sessions as part of his evaluation and just send him on his way. Instead Dr. Davenport patiently waits, reads, eats, and watches until Antwone finally slips up by clearing his throat, which strikes up a conversation. During the first official session, Dr. Davenport waits for him to speak, as if taking on a person-centered approach and waiting for him to share. Antwone feels uncomfortable and asks if he [Davenport] is supposed to ask him questions. The response to this was not what I expected. I thought Dr. Davenport might come out with how he normally does his sessions, a schedule of things, or even a comment…

    • 745 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The therapist would most likely teach one to stop behavior that would lead to an increase in anxiety, such as body vigilance. The therapist may also use exposure therapy, to have Wally directly address his fears in a safe environment, where he can learn to adjust to his anxiety. Also, because Wally has felt a little depressed I might subscribe anti-depressant medication, which could relieve such symptoms as anxiety, or intense fear of disease. (http://www.mayoclinic.com…

    • 556 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    His disruptive behavior is a result of not properly taking his medication. Richard is very upset with his English teacher because he feels she is not going to pass him, and if he does not pass the class it will hinder his transition to the next level. The instructor however is very concerned about the student’s mental stability after reading his essay. The student indicated in his writing that he suffers from paranoid schizophrenia and has issues with taking his medication because of how it makes him feel. Out of concern for the student, the instructor immediately called Mr. Tim, Dean of Special Programs.…

    • 880 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Albert Ellis is very famous for his contributions and known as the father of cognitive-behavioral therapy and also the founder of Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy (REBT). In the beginning Ellis was tried to develop Rational Emotive Therapy (RET), that now called Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy (REBT), because he was disappointed with psychoanalysis style of treatment and feel that it did not worked for everyone. Ellis based his work on the basis of the concept that individuals' beliefs strongly affect their emotional functioning and their behaviors. Ellis called our negative beliefs irrational beliefs because they made people feel depressed, anxious, and angry and lead to negative, self-defeating behaviors (shamekia Thomas)…

    • 110 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    These two therapies allowed Robert to realize he has a problem, and needs to learn to manage his condition. Robert has a good attachment with the family therapy session, because it has allowed him to re-establish a strong connection with Mary. Weaker connections include Robert’s teenage children, Matt and Emily, and his co-workers.…

    • 1757 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Uncle Bob

    • 942 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Looking at the situation at hand it’s was easy to that my Uncle Bob was in a sticky situation. Though he was caught for speeding it came to a surprise that he was placed in back of the squad car. But then I realized that obliviously the charges that my uncle was facing in California were obviously federal charges. For example, transporting minors cross state lines or transporting narcotics across state lines. When dealing with federal charges they follow you know matter where you go. So when they pulled up the informatio from my uncle driver’s license on the computer everything came up along with his charges. And if he is facing extreme charges he should have never left California until all charges were dealt with.…

    • 942 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the movie it is uncovered that desensitization and exposure therapy appear to be the methods used in Bob’s recovery from his problems. He was able to untie his internal knots and make a mental breach and surmount his phobias. Dr. Marvin regressed into an immature state of mind. He starts to lose the attention of his family causing him to harm and drive Bob away from his family. After his psychotic breakdown of attacking Bob he has a catatonic state. Catatonic is characterized by a lack of movement, activity, or expression.…

    • 340 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In this character analysis paper the character of Jenny Curran from the award winning movie Forrest Gump will be the subject of discussion. This paper will present an analysis of the Jenny’s personality as it is applicable to Psychodynamic theory. The paper will present my rationale for the choice to use the Psychodynamic theory to describe Jenny Curran’s personality. In addition, this paper will present a description of the psychodynamic theory utilizing the work of Sigmund Freud regarding personality development. The paper will contain a description of Jenny Curran, as well as, an analysis of her personality utilizing Psychodynamic theory focusing on structure, process, growth, development, and change. This analysis will indentify psychopathologies, which developed as a result of the Jenny’s life experiences. Furthermore, there will be a description of other variables by the writer, which indentify internal and external factors that contributed to the development of Jenny Curran’s personality.…

    • 1418 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Garvey plans for Joon falls under the cognitive branch. A cognitive behavior approach works by changing maladaptive thinking and behavior. Most therapists use cognitive behavior approach to patients suffering from depression, anxiety and psychosis. Unlike a psychoanalytic approach, this technique acknowledges that there are behavior that cannot be controlled by rational thinking and that a change in the environment will help a person’s alter their behavior and thinking to external and internal stimulus. This is different from a psychoanalytic approach, where therapists try to understand unconscious behavior to later diagnose its patient. In the movie, “Bennie and Joon”, the therapy that Dr. Garvey proposes falls on the cognitive behavior approach. For example, at min of the movie, Dr. Garvey explains to Benny that a group house will be the best for Joon since she will learn to form both interpersonal relationships and work under the guidance of clinicians. And at min, she retaliates that a secure and controlling environment will be effective for Joon’s mental illness. It is evident, that Dr. Garvey seeks to treat Joon’s mental disorder by changing her exposure to her previous environment, with the hope that this will also alter her behavior and her attitudes to distinct stimuli. Though, Joon eventually chooses to stay with Sam in their own apartment, it is clear that a caring and controlling environment help Joon with her disorder. But,…

    • 1350 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Schizophrenia and Client

    • 2895 Words
    • 12 Pages

    Bob Tyler, a 40-year-old male, is brought to the emergency department by the police after being violent with his father. Bob has multiple past hospitalizations and treatment for schizophrenia. Bob believes that the healthcare providers are FBI agents and his apartment is a site for slave trading. He believes that the FBI has cameras in his apartment to monitor his moves and broadcast them on TV.…

    • 2895 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In Makeover, the first chapter of Listening to Prozac, an extensive example of a patient’s response to Prozac is recounted. Tess, the patient, was the product of growing up as a “parent child”. Having no father, an alcoholic mother and nine younger siblings, she developed independence and self-sufficiency early on. As an adult, her professional life flourished but her personal life suffered. Constantly seeking out relationships with abusive men which invariably had demoralizing conclusions, her self esteem began to diminish, she felt unattractive and the needs of her family weighed heavily on her, leaving her stressed and tired. As a result of confiding this in Kramer, her psychiatrist, she was prescribed Prozac, an antidepressant. Tess’s reaction to the drug is best described as a psychological makeover. Prozac globally altered the aspects of her personality. (Kramer 13). Tess’s timidity developed into social prowess, the usual…

    • 1198 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Hank shows several signs of Freudian defense mechanism. He shows signs of projection, regression and rationalization. For example when Hank saying Sally broke up with him because of his weight and that she is shallow, he is the one showing signs of insecurities. Also him saying his being over weight is probably due to genetics. Lastly, when he says he was about to break up with Sally as well. He retreats to his child like ways by eating and smoking because he had a rough week at work.…

    • 88 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is with great pleasure that I was able to talk to five of the greatest psychiatric minds William James, John Dewey, Charles Darwin, G. Stanley Hall, and Leta Stetter Hollingsworth. These five psychiatrists contribute majorly to the field of psychology. I was blessed with the chance to be able to ask each of them a question. Allowing me to see these great thinkers in their element of greatness.…

    • 1427 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Since Ray is suffering from depression, the psychoanalytic process that might be effecting Ray would be “denial.” The term “denial” could be described as someone who refuses to believe in something that they truly have. This might be the result of many reasons, like for example, people or family members considering something to be shameful of having. Ray’s grandmother has been hospitalized for reasons that Ray does not know, as his family refuses to say because they believe that what the grandmother has is “shameful,” and what might the grandma have is depression as she as well have been suffering from long spells and mood swings. Since Ray’s family believes that by having depression is shameful, Ray tries to block the thoughts of having depression and refuses to take any form of medication because he is denying the fact that he has depression.…

    • 364 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    cognitive therapy

    • 451 Words
    • 2 Pages

    2. One of your best friends feels that he fails at everything he does and that his life isn't worth living. When you suggest that he talk to a psychotherapist, your friend responds, “Talking won't help. The more I talk about myself, the more I think about my problems. The more I think about my problems, the more depressed I get.” Explain why your friend's comment illustrates his need for cognitive therapy. What procedures would a cognitive therapist use to help your friend overcome his negative feelings?…

    • 451 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays