Preview

Similarities Between Stalin And Hitler

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
766 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Similarities Between Stalin And Hitler
Stalin and Hitler: Similarities and Differences

Stalin and Hitler emerged when political and economic instability had crippled the USSR and Germany in the 1920s. They began making improvements which encouraged their people to believe that prosperity awaited them. This notion was unfortunately a delusion as both figures would eventually rule by decree. Despite treading on different paths of dictatorship, both figures still find some commonalities.

Two prominent differences would certainly come to mind when distinguishing Stalin and Hitler. The first notable difference lies in the fact that both men had reigned over different territories. Stalin was the dictator of the USSR whereas Hitler was the ‘Führer’, leader in other words, of Nazi Germany
…show more content…
Firstly, both political figures had opposing perceptions on the role of women. Stalin considered women as men’s equal and thus restricted the practicing of gender discrimination in the USSR (Trueman, 2015b). Hitler, on the other hand, perceived women as men’s inferior whose sole duty was to conceive several children (Waugh, 2001). Secondly, both men had conflicting insights concerning racism. Stalin would refrain himself from coining any racist remark when delivering speeches (Waugh, 2001). Such caution could be enumerated by the fact that Stalin was a communist, which consequently resulted in him having to abide by the rubric of promoting equality (Waugh, 2001). Hitler was however very critical when referring to Non-Aryan residents, especially the Jews (McAleavy, 2002). His claim that the Jews were solely responsible for all German setbacks could be used to emphasize how much he resented the Jews (McAleavy, …show more content…
Firstly, Communism existed in the USSR before Joseph Stalin came to power (McAleavy, 2002). The USSR consequently became a one party state and Stalin’s opposition would thus come from his own political party (Waugh, 2001). Hitler, in contrast, faced stiff competition from different political parties during the 1920s (Waugh, 2001). The Great Depression and President Hindenburg’s complacency would consequently provide Hitler with a breakthrough (Waugh, 2001). The consolidation of power was complete when Hitler received sufficient national backing to pass the Enabling Act (Trueman, 2015a). This gave him the authority to dissolve all rival political parties (Trueman, 2015a). Secondly, the affluent in Nazi Germany could manipulate political reforms for their role in providing Hitler with finance (Waugh, 2001). Stalin on the other hand had no such obligations as communism ensured that all resources and decision-making was controlled by the government (Waugh, 2001). Finally, Stalin preferred being addressed as ‘Uncle Joe’, as he believes that this title promotes the brotherhood shared by communists, whereas Hitler tends to get flattered when addressed as ‘Führer’ (Waugh,

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Hitler commands the Germans to invade the Soviet Union in 1941 – this was Hitler’s greatest mistake, but was luck on the Soviets side or was it all just the leader Stalin’s good tactics and leadership? Even though Stalin was a mass murderer and a ruthless leader, he did one thing right. After the Soviets were losing battle after battle Stalin let his commanders fight the war as they knew it, did not interfere with their plan and stuck to his word, unlike Hitler did. Stalin let his commanders be true commanders and did not use them as puppets or for his own use. He was a true leader stuck to his word which is why I think the he was successful at leading his nation to victory. As the war continued the number of errors that Stalin was making got…

    • 379 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Adolf Hitler and Winston Churchill were leaders of two very different countries. Hitler was the overseer of Germany, while Churchill was the Prime Minister of Britain. These two rulers were on different sides of World War Two. Because of this, Hitler and Churchill had different views about political ideologies, treatment of their citizens, and goals they wanted to achieve.…

    • 377 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The initial similarity they shared was in foreign policy as both dictators only had a handful of allies and ignored requests from other countries ' leaders. Hitler especially once he was firmly in power, totally disregarded the limits installed on Germany at the Treaty of Versailles, such as the ban on Germany to have any air force or submarine, and could only possess an inconsequential naval force of just six ships and an army of a mere one hundred thousand men. Additionally, they were not to have any forces placed in the Rhineland; the narrow piece of land running next to the border with France. Hitler condemned such constraints enforced by the Versailles Treaty and recommenced the national military draft ' the initial move in defiance against the treaty. The subsequent invasion of the Rhineland followed soon after, declaring that it had always been part of Germany 's historical fatherland. The invasion of Poland the followed to conquer the country 's national resources to bolster Germany 's military. Germany was still reeling in huge debt from the First World War. Likewise, for Saddam Hussein in 1990 - despite constant international warnings - he invaded to annex Kuwait with the excuse that Kuwait was historically part of the greater Babylonian empire, and laid claim on Kuwait 's rich abundance of oil.…

    • 974 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    While they were both very odd men, no one can say that were not extremely smart in the military operations, both of them running strong, effiecient militaries, which they used to conquer much of Europe, they were both quite found of infantry based warfare, Hitler invented the Blitzkrieg, or "lightning war" which he used to quickly capture a good chunk of Eureope. While Stalin…

    • 413 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Hitler and Stalin were both cruel dictators around the time of WW2, but to what extent were these two men similar? Firstly they were both dictators throughout WW2; however they were both of different beliefs. Hitler was a fascist and Stalin was a communist, however they were both such extreme versions of these beliefs that they were, in many ways alike. Starting with childhood, Adolf Hitler was born on April 20th 1889 in a small Austrian town called Braunau, near to the German border. His father, Alois Hitler was an abusive drunk similar to Stalin’s father, Besarion Vanovis Jughashvili. This evidence suggests that perhaps the bad relationships these men had with their fathers, who made very poor role models, may have had some contribution to the turnout of these dictators.…

    • 1415 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    It’s one of every human's natural desires to acquire power. Because of this, almost all attempts in creating complete equality in society fail. The book Animal Farm by George Orwell was based on the Russian revolution and how it failed. The fault of this lies with Napoleon…

    • 404 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When they assumed power they did much for their countries. They both pursued vigorous economic plans that balanced each countries' budgets, which had not been done in years. Napoleon balanced the budget in 1802, the first time it had been balanced in over seventy years, and Hitler managed to balance Germany's budget by 1938. Both men ended unemployment in their countries with nationwide projects, however, neither Hitler nor Napoleon came up with the idea. The programs of Hitler were proposed by Georg-Hans Reinhardt and Hjalmar Schact, and the programs of Napoleon came from many different people. By eliminating the economic crisis in their countries and establishing a feeling of national security, they raised national pride and patriotism to amazing levels.…

    • 615 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    However, they share much in common. They both wanted to be perceived as chosen individuals, as leaders who are artists (Stephen Reicher, 2005). Also, both of them promoted their power in a way of totalitarian leadership. By totalitarianism, we understand the unlimited authority and power. And clearly, Hitler reached that level when he destroyed any political apparatus that could be able to bring him down as the country leader (Heifetz, 1998). Similarly, after Mussolini called himself…

    • 2272 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    This economic hardship gave rise to anger and resentment among its populace who were looking to their leaders for solutions. The German’s were so desperate for change that the perfect atmosphere was created for the rise of Adolph Hitler. He offered just the elixir the people were looking, someone to blame for their misery. “Due to the widespread suffering caused by the Great Depression, the political and socioeconomic climate of Germany was ripe for a new government to take direction and rebuild its state’s power. The people were looking for someone to blame, a way to recover and a way to forge ahead from the economic crisis at hand.” Hitler seized on this desperation and found the perfect scapegoats for people to blame for their misery which led to the advancement of his agenda. Hitler told the German people what they wanted to hear which was inspiring nationalism. This motivation of nationalism for the vast majority of German people, to follow the Nazi doctrine, regardless of its diabolical tenets. They were not to blame for their current predicament and Hitler had the perfect solution to rebuild their broken economy. The power of both of these messages thrusted Hitler into power. It should be noted that Mussolini's rise to power was driven by nearly identical themes…

    • 721 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hitler also used the growing fear of communism to gain support. Middle class and wealth ‘Junker’ particularly liked Hitler stand on communism.…

    • 1974 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pol Pot vs. Adolf Hitler

    • 1229 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Successful leaders often share multiple similarities in the choices they make with their power; however, there also tend to be numerous differences between the executions of their respective rules. Though Communist leader Pol Pot and German nationalist Adolf Hitler can be compared in several ways, there are also myriad differences between their ascendancies. The social dispositions and executions of Adolf Hitler and Pol Pot, although similar in several ways, also differed for numerous reasons during their supremacies.…

    • 1229 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hitler and Stalin

    • 427 Words
    • 1 Page

    One of the most famous men for using his power for evil is Adolf Hitler. Everyone today knows all of the hatred and diversions he brought to the world. Hitler had a dream and this dream was to have one race with blue eyes and blonde hair. Of course not everyone in the world had those features so his big plan was to annihilate everyone who was different or stood in the way of him conquering his dream. Hitler’s rise to power did not take long. Hitler was very charismatic and had many followers. Like today how actors and stars sometimes act out just to get noticed Hitler started many protests and little up-roars in streets when he began to get involved in parties and groups and that’s how Hitler came to be noticed. Just like Joseph Stalin, Hitler came into power at a time of high instability in their countries and they both took advantage of it to gain political support for their totalitarian causes. Hitler was intrigued by Marxism while Stalin was fascinated with Fascism. Hitler like Stalin made use of an elite body guard named The Joseph Stalin and Hitler both sought to blame other people for the problems that were playing in their countries at the time. For Hitler it was the Jews and for Stalin he saw capitalism as a great enemy. Like Hitler, Stalin ruled with an iron fist and used terrorism to enforce his will on people. Hitler and Stalin were both skillful in many areas but their best was propaganda. They could twist their words and manipulate people into believing what they had to say. Hitler made many speeches, but the one that proved he used propaganda was his final speech he gave before his treason. Stalin on the other hand was able to hide his manipulative skills better but in his speech to the Fifteenth Congress in 1927 it had many lies within it. The success of these two men was mostly attributed to their politics and new ideas.In conclusion, Joseph Stalin and Adolf Hitler had many similarities in their rise to power. To me the things that stood out the…

    • 427 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The World War II era brought out many leaders, but two that were commonly acknowledged were Franklin D. Roosevelt and Adolf Hitler. Both men were very popular and were known throughout the world for their choices. The men had differed personalities but some traits were the same in both of them. The similarities and differences when comparing the two men are extremely noticeable.…

    • 353 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One thing the two fierce leaders shared was fascism. Although not completely similar because of Hitler’s Nazism had racism involved towards the Jewish. They were both supported by the middle class, industrialists, and military. Also, they had censorship, indoctrination, and secret police. Economic functions had been controlled by state corporations or state long with a one-party rule and supreme leader.…

    • 520 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hitler and Stalin

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages

    To start off this comparison and contrast between the two great leaders, I would like to take in to account that both of them gained absolute power in the similar period of time. As we know Hitler was declared chancellor of Germany in January 1933, a few years back in 1929 Stalin emerged as the great leader and by the early 1930s he was unstoppable having no opposition that can stop his reign. There were just individuals who threatened him from time to time. After the both leaders came in complete power no or little opposition was facing them.…

    • 785 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays