top-rated free essay

The Crisis of over-Criminalization

By Lamar22 Oct 15, 2009 920 Words
Crisis of Over-Criminalization
What is over-criminalization? Over-criminalization generally insinuates that laws regulating public decency and morality is a distraction of sorts to law enforcement officials who could be spending time solving more important crimes rather than dealing in an individual’s personal fixation. Unnecessary reliance upon law enforcement officials to execute task for which it is ill suited has formed serious problems for the administration of criminal justice. (Kadish, 1967) The idea of criminal law enforcing morals on individuals deemed indecent is completely ineffective and it hinders effective law enforcement on actual menacing behavior. With law officials paying more attention to the immoral acts of others, the true crime of America is slipping through the cracks. The use the term over-criminalization is complete understatement in terms of criminal law. While certain legislative rules of morality may be already tagged onto specific crimes such as rape and murder, those same views may very well be improper to broaden its outreach to other aspects of our lives. It would be reasonable to ask: how far into the private lives of citizens may government-sanctioned views of morality properly intrude? One of the main reasons that question can be asked is because of the constant intrusion of sorts in the way of policing personal life preferences. For example, there are many Americans who live a dangerous lifestyle by drinking and partying and having sex with whom ever they please. In some cases they are practicing sexual activity with the same sex. Here is the kicker; there are constricting laws of morals that don’t allow that sort of activity among people in various parts of the U.S. In Texas (among many other States) they have the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA), which is a law banning same-sex marriages. (marriage.about.com) That law is a prime example of over exerting moral standards. If people sodomize one another in a consensual manner, it should be there own business to decide if it is right or wrong. Another issue is the use of particular drugs or alcohol by the people of America. Individuals who drink on a daily basis are frustrated with restricted bar laws now. Some people have to drink in the bar and stay there. They are not allowed to leave and drink out in public or to be drunk in public for that matter. Alcohol has been legalized and yet there are some many restrictions. The same goes for tobacco products. People can no longer smoke in their favorite bars or restaurants because of many restrictions on smoking. Why can’t people smoke what they want? Why can’t people drink when and where they want without the law getting involved? The very simplified answer to both of those questions is Over-criminalization. The soul purpose of over-criminalization is for the law to have complete control of everything that we do as people, as a nation. In essence, the intrusion is inappropriate and the American citizens personal ambitions should not be left to the law to decide. Right now in the United States there is a feeling of over-criminalization, as many Americans believe their lives are being regulated by criminal law. Many American feel betrayed by the criminal law processes because they feel that the restrictions and regulations of so many personal activities infringe on their constitutional rights. The American people have every right to feel that way. One thing that most American do not like about strangled hold their personal and consensual dealing is the fact that pornography is being scrutinize in the U.S. “All jurisdictions have laws that punish the sale, possession, and distribution of obscene material, and most have statutes defining lewdness or public indecency (Schmallger, 2003).” The people of America would like to be able to view certain adult material in the privacy of their own homes. Like wise, they should also be allowed to purchase whatever entertainment they please to, as it is in their personal interest. The law should have no input what so ever in what people are allowed to view, purchase or perform in as long as there are consenting individuals. The law should control no Americans’ individual rights or personal lifestyle. “If the first Amendment means anything, it means that a state has no business telling a man, sitting alone in his own house, what books he may read or what films he may watch.” –Justice Thurgood Marshall (Schmallger, 2003). No one could have ever stated that better than Justice Thurgood Marshall. It certainly is the truth, so why are there so many concerns about the American peoples’ personal dealings? The answer you may get from the law would be indecent or obscene or immoral. Yes, we need laws against criminal acts in the United States but laws against morals seem to personal to have enacted. The principles of a man or a woman should be held to his or her own standards and not the law. The simple fact is there is a crisis of over-criminalization in America, but the question is: What are we the people going to do about it?

References:

Schmallger, F. (2003) Criminal Law Today: An Introduction with Capstone Cases (2nd ed.) (UOP Special Edition Series) Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall. Retrieved March 22, 2009 from the UOP ebooks collection Stritof, S., Stritof, B. (2009). Same Sex Marriage License Laws. About.com: Marriage. Retrieved March 22, 2009, from http://marriage.about.com/cs/marriagelicenses/a/samesexcomp.htm

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • The Criminalization

    ...influence, to provide infrastructure needed by the donor for resource extraction from the recipient country, or to gain other kinds of commercial access. There are all kinds of aid: Emergency aid, development aid, official development assitance or ODA, private giving, cash aid, in kind aid, air priorities, logistics etc etc. In develop...

    Read More
  • Crisis Blown over

    ...Case Study 4 ± Crisis Blown Over Ques 1. Do you think that the Bangalore-based company had practiced participative management? Answer. During such a crisis the company and the union both showed great sense of oneness. They both come together for solving the problem and thus ensured that the employees and the employers both don’t suffer th...

    Read More
  • crisis

    ...Before we contemplate answering such a question the first thing one must aim to understand is the specific meaning given to the term 'crisis.' It has to be put in some context. If by crisis one means that the prison system is teetering on the brink of collapse then the evidence available would suggest that there is no crisis at all. However the ...

    Read More
  • Crisis

    ...Beginning in the 1960’s the distribution of federal and nonprofit funds have given students all over the United States the opportunity to pursue post-secondary educations. Although this method has given students the ability to go to college financially, the majority of the students are not able to pay the money back when finished causing debt....

    Read More
  • Criminalization of Marijuana

    ...grade (the intervention group) and students who did not (the control group)." This is just one example of the millions of dollars wasted on the government's war on drugs. In my opinion, and those of many others, the entire "drug war" is a huge waste of money and valuable human resources. And where marijuana is concerned, there has been no subs...

    Read More
  • Crisis

    ...10 Rules of Crisis Management By Brian Ellis, EVP/Crisis Communications & whatcanbe Lab After 10 years in the news business and 20 years counseling clients how to stay out of headlines when a crisis strikes, I’ve developed 10 basic rules of crisis management. 1. Being Unprepared Is No Excuse. My father was an officer of the U.S. Army. ...

    Read More
  • Crisis

    ...dismissive. "As far as planting the seeds of the next crisis, bear in mind that leverage is still falling, so I don't see the problem at this point," he says. In Krugman's view, concerns about ageing populations, looming health costs, the changing nature of the workforce in a digital age and competition from Asian economies for jobs, are for ano...

    Read More
  • Criminalization of Marijuana

    ...The Criminalization of Marijuana Corry Countryman ENG 210 Mrs. Rippard November 18, 2010 The issue of criminalization of marijuana in the United States is becoming a big one. Marijuana was first federally prohibited in 1937, when very few Americans had even heard of what it was. To this day, there are between 95 to 100 million Amer...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.