Preview

Blade Runner And Frankenstein Comparison Essay

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
957 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Blade Runner And Frankenstein Comparison Essay
Mary Shelley’s, ‘Frankenstein’ and Ridley Scott’s, ‘Blade Runner’ both take social fears and reflet them. They show aspects of Film Noir, Gothic literature, Romanticism, The impact of Science and natural philosophy, Crime fiction and Post modern literature. The two texts, although different in overall context, have many themes, ideas and values which closely link them to each other while still portraying differences. The image that I have chosen to portray these similarities and differences is a self composed drawing of a monster who ‘is’ destruction and a little girl reaching for the flower that destruction is holding out too her. This illustration, at first glance, shows death and destruction brought about by humanity, the darkness within humanity and possible reconciliation of peace. …show more content…
It represents a connection with nature and purity and was conveyed in ‘Blade Runner’ when Roy released the dove from his hands as he was dying. The dove is being followed by the monster which makes us question, “Is the monster really as bad as what society has portrayed it too be?” This question can also be proposed by the fact that the monster is holding out a flower to the young girl. The ‘monsters’ in my image, ‘Blade Runner’, and ‘Frankenstein’, are not accepted within society as equals too humans but are instead perceived as a threat against humanity. Ironically, humanity is destroying itself without any doing of anything less than human. This is shown in my image by the smoke fumed industrialised buildings, the nuclear weapon, guns, bombs, sewerage, bullet wounds and arrows. All of these human made weapons represent a society which is destroying itself, and the idea that creations destroy the creator. How is it that we as humans can create nuclear weapons to kill one another and we are not perceived as monsters or threats against humanity? What is it that has made society recognise the ‘Monster’ in my image, the Replicant’s and Frankenstein’s creation as

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Humanity’s rejection of the natural world in favour of the unnatural pursuit of technology to prolong life is a major concern in both Shelley’s Frankenstein and Scott’s Blade Runner. In the world of Frankenstein, nature is an important aspect of a person’s life and beliefs. Shelley conveys Victor’s desire to conquer nature through the use of his narration such as “new species would bless me as its creator…many happy and excellent natures would owe their being to me.” The monster is then used as a metaphor for the inevitable consequences of the exploitations of nature. She therefore uses Frankenstein as a warning against the rising industrial revolution. Similarly Scott uses Blade Runner to warn society against the exploitation or nature through the rise of consumerism in the 1980s. The long shot of a dark dystopian Los Angeles after the opening credits juxtaposed with jets of fire from oil refinery towers warns the viewer of the consequences of consumerism through the exploitation of nature. There is also a lack of natural imagery such as plants and animals seen in Blade Runner and the use of chiaroscuro lighting gives the world a very…

    • 362 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Though composed at different times, the themes portrayed in both Frankenstein and Blade Runner are evidently influenced by their own respective contexts – the early 19th century and late 20th century. These texts put forward an exploration of humanity and morality, the value of nature as well as individualism as these themes and values are perceived in each context.…

    • 778 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Nature and its interaction with human emotions are central concerns for both “Frankenstein” and “Blade Runner”. Romantics’ nature is depicted as a healing power and a source of subject and image; in blade runner, the natural worlds pleasing qualities are seen to be abused, e.g. of this is in the opening, where a dark, decayed and dystopian Neo noir world is shown. The detrimental consequences due to carelessness when dealing with the natural world, resulted in the disappearance of its beauty which was an idea constantly feared and warned of by Shelley in Frankenstein.…

    • 3115 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    How frank represents the context of 1818 are both warnings to the evil of technology…

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Shelly and Scott reflect, nature and the natural world in the texts they create, Frankenstein and Blade Runner using literary devices and societal context. In Blade Runner, Scott uses the aspects of the 20th century tradition of dystopias and film noir as literary devices. Throughout Shelly's work of Frankenstein, the romantic and sublime themes of the era are examined as literary devices. The appreciation for the natural wonder of the world is evident throughout Frankenstein when Shelly emphasises to the reader, the sweeping landscapes that are stark, barren and majestic, nature therefore is used as a literary device to simulate the readers sense of emotions, an example of this is when Victor walks through the Alps to relieve himself from…

    • 362 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    The existential question ‘What is it to be human?” despite context, continues to be relevant to society. In “Frankenstein” this is explored through Victor Frankenstein and the Creature. Written during the latter part of the Romantic period, Shelley is commenting on and reacting against the rational, scientific paradigms of the Enlightenment, placing emphasis on the Romantic traits Individualism, Imagination and Nature. Victor Frankenstein is very much endowed as the Gothic protagonist, being portrayed as a cold and distant character that is unquestionably a genius and dependent on natural sciences. In “Bladerunner” the creator, Tyrell, is portrayed in a similar fashion. The 1980s gave rise to capitalism and consumerism and thus the film lends itself to such qualities. Tyrell is also a detached character who is more concerned with creation than the consequences as seen in his statement “commerce is our goal here at Tyrell. ‘More human than human is our motto”. Both creators are highly revered which can be seen in the opening power shot of Tyrell’s ziggurat, pyramid shaped building towering over Earth and in Victor’s relationship with his family and Walton. These characters represent the scientific, rational aspects that both composers were reacting against, in turn providing a warning to society about the consequences of such thing. The opening prologue of “Bladerunner” displays certain hostility towards the Replicants. The words scroll across the black screen in an almost clinical way stating “Blade runner units had orders to shoot to kill…This was not called an execution.…

    • 1190 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The 1818 Gothic Novel 'Frankenstein' written by Mary Shelley and the 1982 science fiction film 'Blade Runner' by Ridley Scott both challenge the values of the societies in which they have been set, expressing the composers' critique of the advancement in science and technology, the consequences of irresponsible creation and the hubris of an individual to overcome nature's power. It is through these common themes that the texts have the ability to represent and evoke fear, anxiety and…

    • 1099 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Through a comparative study of Mary Shelley’s novel Frankenstein and Ridley Scott’s film Blade Runner it is possible to gain an understanding of the notion of what constitutes humanity. Despite bearing different contexts, the texts embody parallel values that reveal the fundamentals of human nature. Shelley uses elements of Gothic literature and Romanticism to highlight the value of moderation through Victor Frankenstein’s pursuit of knowledge and the resulting ramifications. Similarly, Scott’s film, set in 2019, reflects concerns of the late 20th Century and the consequences of emerging technological advancements and globalisation. In addition, Scott demonstrates Post Modern views of the nature of our existence in a world of rampant corporatism. Ultimately, both texts are shaped with the values of their respective contexts but each explore the dangers associated with the usurpation of God by man, emphasising the inexorable nature of humanity.…

    • 1034 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    To what extent does your comparative study of Frankenstein and Blade Runner suggest that the relationship between science and nature is an important universal concern?…

    • 1488 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    * Prometheus represents on who has defied and challenged the natural order; one who has transgressed on forbidden territory. His actions are not couched in connotations of courage or heroism but recognised as reckless and without any thought to the possible consequences.…

    • 935 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mary Shelley’s nineteenth century epistolary novel, Frankenstein (1818), and Ridley Scott’s late twentieth century post-modern film, Blade Runner (1992), bear striking similarities when studied as texts in time, as they both aim to warn humanity about attempting to usurp of the role of God in creating life. However, their respective contexts mean that the way in which they present notions about humanity differs. Shelley and Scott have extrapolated their various concerns born from their respective contexts regarding the confusion and anxiety that results when mankind pursues their knowledge without regard for their responsibilities. Shelley presents us with humanity’s flaws, which are evident in the way they have neglected what they have created. Scott portrays a futuristic world that has become horrifically debased and inhumane, as mankind has failed to maintain the natural order after overstepping scientific and technological boundaries. Both composers conceptually focus on the parental duties of creators toward their creation and the consequences of abandoning them. Through their different styles and techniques relative to their respective audience, each composer is extremely successful in presenting the changing values and attitudes respective of their eras.…

    • 1116 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The idea of ‘disruption’ is explored within Blade Runner and Frankenstein through the interference of the natural environment due to scientific progress. Such a conflict between nature and science within Frankenstein, stems from the contextual backdrop of the 1800 Romanticism movement, a backlash against the age of Enlightenment and its rationality through scientific experimentation. In an attempt to warn her audience of the horrifying consequences of disrupting nature, Shelley utilises a Gothic-Romanticist style, and motifs such as the sublime and soothing nature versus monstrosity as shown in the lines, “the valley that is more wonderful than the sublime”, juxtaposed with the appearance of the monster as “yellow skinned, black eyed”. Whilst Victor warns Walton to, “avoid ambition...in science and discovery”, his character development, alluded to as the ‘ancient mariner’, whose hubris of overreaching the boundaries leading to his downfall is contrasted against his perfect childhood, again reiterating Shelley’s warnings about the consequences of disrupting nature. Likewise Scott…

    • 1036 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mary Shelley’s 19th century gothic novel Frankenstein and Ridley Scott’s 1982 film Blade Runner both explore the fears relevant to their contexts. While these texts were composed in different time periods, a parallel that exists between these texts involves man’s testing the established moral and ideals of the time. Both texts deal with the possible ramifications of scientific advancement and the outcomes for society as a whole; this idea has proven to be a timeless concept. These texts convey cautionary messages regarding the moral consideration of the responsibilities of scientific endeavour, which are still relevant today. Each composer considers the implications of scientific progress in their contexts; Mary Shelley was strongly influenced by the ideals of Romanticism while also being exposed to the new theories of galvanism. Scott composed Blade Runner in a time of commercial enterprise and controversial experimentation, namely in-vitro fertilisation and cloning. The themes explored in these texts reflect the concerns of the time in which they were composed. Although both texts share concerns about the impact of science on morality, their representation of the possibilities of the inevitable societal change differ, emphasising that texts are shaped by context.…

    • 910 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    To what extent has your comparative study of Frankenstein and Blade Runner developed your understanding of the personal struggles experienced by individuals?…

    • 834 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Both ‘Frankenstein’ By Mary Shelley (1818) and ‘Blade Runner’ composed by Ridley Scott (1992) express the concerns of the dire consequences that come as a result of the need for control. These texts were heavily influenced by the rapid growth of technology although reflecting different eras. They highlight the dangers of excessive ambition and the threats to the natural world from different perspectives.…

    • 1063 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays