The Lacanian Mirror: Reflections on Oldboy

Only available on StudyMode
  • Download(s) : 172
  • Published : June 5, 2008
Open Document
Text Preview
The Lacanian Mirror: Reflections on Oldboy

According to Jacques Lacan in the “The Mirror Stage”, the stage is “an identification” in which the subject undergoes a transformation by assuming an image in the mirror (34). There is a “jubilant assumption of his specular image by the child” (34) as he admires the wholeness of the reflection and longs to identify with it. At the same time, however, the wholeness of the image is compared to the fragmented condition of the child’s body and is, thus, met with envy and a desire to dominate the threatening and sinister double. This early stage of development “situates the agency of the ego, before its social determination, in a fictional direction, which will always remain irreducible for the individual alone” (34). As Lacan elaborates, “this moment in which the mirror-stage comes to an end inaugurates, by the identification with the imago of the counterpart and the drama of primordial jealousy… the dialectic that will henceforth link the I to socially elaborated situations” (37). This entry into the Symbolic Order together with the restoration of language to the child brings the mirror stage to an entirely different level. The individual then undergoes a lifelong series of identification between his ego and the imaginary attributes of the object, thus contributing to the dynamism of the self. Therefore, the ability to think of the self as other and vice versa defines the idea of I and is the fundamentals of selfhood. Often seen as a metaphor for subjectivity, the mirror stage highlights an individual reflection and perception of the subject being studied.

Oldboy, by Korean director Park Chan-Wook, is a dark and compelling film about the idea of revenge which blinds the characters into violence. Oh Dae-su, the male protagonist, was held captive for no apparent reason in an isolated room, being constantly watched by his captors. After 15 years of solitary confinement, he is released and he seeks to find the truth which soon catches up with him and he finds out that the imprisonment is just a prelude of the greater terror that is to come. Lee Woo-jin, the mastermind behind the elaborate plans, challenges Dae-su to uncover the underlying reason for his confinement, putting the former’s life at stake, with that of the latter’s love interest, Mido. The discovery of the truth leads to another twist in the story, one that is too much for Dae-su to handle. A warped tale of vengeance and hate, the film seeks to uncover the violent and terrifying aspects of human nature.

In the film, it is observed that mirrors and its reflections are used as recurring motifs in the movie. This I found interesting, as the Lacanian concept of the mirror has been applied as a film theory by a number of critical writers such as Christian Metz and Laura Mulvey. Madan Sarup draws on their work in his book, Jacques Lacan, discussing how “the cinema involves us in the (Lacanian) Imaginary” (146) by drawing a parallel between the film spectator and the child looking at the mirror. It is, therefore, suggested that the mirror within the diegesis works as a reflective apparatus on two levels, for the character and the spectator simultaneously. With this in mind, the cinematic screen can be easily likened to a two-way mirror, often used for unobtrusive observation. Like in the set-up of the two-way mirror, the side of the observer has to be in darkness in order for him to remain undiscovered, which is similar to the cinema theatre. In this essay, I shall argue that while the mirror serves a practical function in the narrative or as part of brilliant cinematography, it also works as an imaginary two-way mirror in which the spectator and character reflect upon their ideal self, with the former being able to invade visually into the latter. By analyzing three scenes from the film, Oldboy, I shall examine the use of the mirror within the diegesis and what they symbolize for both the characters and the spectator...
tracking img