Test-Tube Babies Analysis

Only available on StudyMode
  • Download(s) : 1795
  • Published : October 7, 2012
Open Document
Text Preview
Cynthia Katasi
Professor Stagnaro
In Vitro fertilization: Analysis of Ruth Hubbard’s Article. “Test-Tube Babies: Solution or Problem?”

Ruth Hubbard’s “Test-Tube Babies: Solution or Problem?” first appeared in Technology Review in 1980. Hubbard addressed her audience with an initial objective tone, revealing the built up to her credibility on the issue of in vitro fertilization. Hubbard having specialized in biochemistry of vision and women’s health enforces the sense in the reader that she is to be trusted on this topic. Hubbard spoke at a time when in vitro fertilization was still a new developing technology as oppose to now. She spoke directly to society although at a certain point in her article; she focuses on a specific group of her readers. Its central purpose is to cause awareness of the unforeseen dangers and consequences of in vitro fertilization and to take a clear stand on the use and the further development of the technology. Hubbard appeals to her audience’s emotions with shifts in tone, division and classification, and comparison in the article. Hubbard begins her article in an objective tone, telling her audience “In Vitro fertilization of human eggs and the implantation of early embryos into women’s wombs are new biotechnologies that may enable some women to bear children who have hitherto been unable to do so. In that sense, it may solve their particular infertility problems.” Hubbard is able to develop her credibility by showing knowledge of what in vitro fertilization is and what it can accomplish for infertile people. She demands the audience’s authority because she shows that she knows the topic she’s discussing and is aware of different views. Hubbard then goes on to rebuttal the idea saying that “this technology poses unpredictable hazards” and urges the society- “It is therefore important that we, as a society, seriously consider the wisdom of implementing and developing it further.” This is a plea to society to think...
tracking img