Preview

ENG/215: The Relationship Between Collaboration And Argument

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1105 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
ENG/215: The Relationship Between Collaboration And Argument
ENG/215CA
10/5/2013
The Relationship between Collaboration and Argument Collaboration papers could be considered by many as one of the easiest papers to do, but also considered but others as difficult to accomplish. Both of them have their advantages and disadvantages, but it is up to the person to decide which method is more useful to complete the assignment. It is seen by most people that a collaborated paper is an easy assignment because the amount of personnel involved on the paper, the amount of time that requires to perform the research of the material that wants to be included in the paper, if several people are after the same topic. Different resources are used to supply the material to the team such are books, newspaper articles,
…show more content…
Writing a collaborated paper could also be considered a learning experience, members can learn from others, members from different backgrounds and culture can be really helpful to have a mix of ideas to be included in the paper. To others, a collaborated paper could be a huge headache and very difficult to do due the disagreement by the members and all the ideas by each one of them. Every person is different, and so are the ideas. Each member has a different opinion, thoughts, and different way to see things. We might not agree in some things with others during the process, arguments, yelling, and discussions are more likely to happen, so a plan and a team leader is recommended to ensure things run smoothly before they can get out of hand. Numerous amount of ideas are brought up to the table and each member explain his or her point of view to the rest of the members, some might have suggestions and some might agree, not 100 %, but at least some of the members are on the same page. These are ideas are all put to the side and used to make the final product, but it not always easy to reach this point of the process. Arguments papers could take several hours and in occasions day, the …show more content…
Some of the positive points about doing a paper alone is that all the resources will be reliable and valid for the paper, there is no argument with others, and the writer’s ideas are going to be the only ones used for the paper. Negative points about working alone are the amount of time used by only one person to do all the work, it might take long hours to be able to find use all the resources and find what is needed to complete the paper. Another negative point about working individually is the lack of support by others, no suggestions or opinions from others about the paper could be difficult, there is always good to have another set of eye to review your work or extra help from someone to maybe see or think from a different point of view and also to ensure that the material covered is the correct material to avoid submitting a bad paper, which at the end, there is only one person to blame for, the writer. In most cases, during the learning process to write a paper, it is not up to the student the decision to work as a team or alone, but once again, it is a learning process where mistakes are going to be made, either working collaboratively or individually, a lesson is learned that in the long run will result on the improvement

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Mgt 311 Business Plan

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages

    |Collaborating- when the parties’ involved |Coming up with a solution that all parties |Coming to an agreement that all parties are |…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    True collaboration: Collaboration is a joint effort between two or more people, free from hidden agendas, to produce an output in response to a common goal. However, Collaboration works best when relationships are treated as genuine partnerships.…

    • 352 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Edn 677 Assignment 1

    • 481 Words
    • 2 Pages

    According to Mr. Chen, the benefits of collaboration helps to create projects and learning from each other. When students learn from each other (not so much the teacher) students helps Bridge the gap among different cultures. Sharing of ideas through different languages helps students learn from one another and can prepare them for the very diverse world that we…

    • 481 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Teamwork improves communication, it isn 't just about exchanging information - it is about ideas, feelings, hopes and desires, we find this when we communicate with people we trust and respect. It is also about all those things that make us the individuals that we are.…

    • 1401 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Through the reading of An Argument Culture by Deborah Tannen, I have come to understand what has always been apparent; we live in a vocal society that will challenge what they do not agree with. Tannen states, “American tradition has geared toward the promotion of antagonism.” We believe that our opinion matters and most times that it is the right one even without further information to back our point in the argument. American society pushes the act of debate and refuting what is heard, the “argument culture” so to say encouraging from a young age to argue for your position. Our society relies on debates to choose our public officials, holding, as Tannen refers to them, “verbal wars” allowing the candidates to bash each other and then make promises that relate to only to what we think but not what is most correct or best for the general public. Our lives are now based not off of open discussion and opinion but off of a two sided argument where only one side can be considered the right opinion otherwise risk, “scouring the margins of science or fringes of lunacy to find it.” Tanner also discusses the point of high technology communication, a newfound reliance on texting and email has caused a lack in communication skills between people especially in today’s youth. Tanner states that, “One of the most effective ways to defuse antagonism between two groups is to provide a forum for individuals from those groups to get to know each other personally.” She feels that we must teach people to communicate as effectively as we do over media in person to help shape how we do business in the future. While many jobs now require and rely on you to be capable in media usage it is still important to have verbal and personal communication skills necessary to advancing through life. Tanner states that we must end this two-sided way of thinking to help end the argument culture. By ending this we must discourage debating whenever possible…

    • 871 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    This writer agrees with this author regarding collaboration. The author stated " Collaborating is working together with different types of people to attain a common goal." Collaborating is a great style for team building within the health care system. When leaders identify a common goal, bring members together, and allow all individuals to have input in reaching the goal; the true root of the problem is solved. One of the draw backs to collaborating is the time involved. Additionally, collaborating requires strong leadership to be effective. Also the writer stated a valid point in compromising can be a temporary solution for a resolution. Nursing is a stressful profession and conflict should be resolved as soon as possible to prevent…

    • 123 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    What are some advantages of working alone on a problem? Explain your answer with at least one example. Working alone has the following advantages;…

    • 258 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    When debating on a topic or pacific subject I prefer to debate one on one, but that is not the only way debating is done it is also done in groups and this can be a benefit in some situations and can also be a problem in some cases. When having a group debate it gives you a broad approach with having more than two people opinion, it’s going to be a harder fight, but you will get more than one standpoint on the argument. A group debate also provides diversity amongst the topic, the argument should still be based on facts and proven research but will also be debated different due to different peoples approach. Another benefit that I can see with a group debate may be strength in numbers if the group is one sided on the debate they can outnumber the opponent and win the argument they can also help brain storm and recognize different weaknesses in the opposing argument. This strength in numbers can be both a benefit and a drawback it just depends on what side of the argument you are on. I have never been in a group debate but I have seen a few on T.V. and from what I have seen it is hard to get your thoughts completed before someone is trying to respond to what you just said and when trying to wait for someone to finish their thought you may forget what you wanted to rebuttal or someone else may jump in front of you and now you have more than one comment that you want to respond to. When dealing with groups it’s a lot to process at one time and you have to be on your toes because you have more than one opponent coming at you. There seem to be an equal number of benefits as drawbacks in group debates I also think that the topic is a factor if it is a broad topic then it should be for a group debate and if it is for a narrow topic then it should be one on one.…

    • 365 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Factors such as diversity, attitude, learning, and work styles can affect collaboration in a number of ways. Diversity affects collaboration, because there may be someone in the group that is very intolerant to diversity, and closed minded. Attitude plays a big role in collaboration, because if everyone in the group has a good attitude then collaboration is easy, however, if even one person in the group has a bad attitude, it can turn the entire group attitude negative, making collaboration difficult or even impossible. Learning and work styles also greatly affect collaboration, because as I mentioned previously, everyone has a learning style, as well as a teaching style, so the more people in a group, the more likely it is that everyone learns the topic to the best of their ability. As for work styles, this can cause problems when it comes to collaboration, because everyone in the group has to agree that the assignment should be done in a particular way, and a particular work style may not fit with that persons said work style. That also goes with learning how to be…

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Issue Of Gun Control

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages

    When I work alone, I rely on myself to keep track of all parts of the task I’m working on, which can at times prove stressful. However, working with my group on this project meant that I wasn’t required to take care of everything, and that I could depend on the other members to complete their parts of the project, which brought a little peace to my mind and allowed me to work somewhat more effectively as I researched and wrote the paper. My group members also influenced me in that they offered different approaches to research and were able to show me methods and interpretations that I myself had not thought of. These different perspectives brought together allowed me to become more efficient and successful at using resources and thinking through problems I encountered during the project. Also, during the writing process, my group members gave me their opinions and input regarding my work, and in some cases they pointed out mistakes and inconsistencies which I had not recognized in my own work. This not only improved my writing and the paper overall, it allowed me to recognize those mistakes in the future and become a stronger writer and better member of the group. Overall, working with my group for this project proved beneficial in creating better conditions for research and writing, as our unique standpoints brought together shaped the paper and the project…

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Collaboration also allows for the writing process to be more productive, gain feedback from group participation and proof reading. This way goals would be achieved more efficiently.…

    • 401 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Collaborative Writing

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages

    If you ever have worked on a committee, task force, or project development team, you probably know the frustration of group work. If you’re lucky, you also know the joy.The nature of your experience depends on two factors: whether the individual participants share common, clearly defined goals and whether they know how to work together.All of this, of course, applies to collaborative writing, a collective activity that – perhaps as much as any other – requires that participants hold their egos in check and that they be willing to compromise.Here are some tips on how to succeed in collaborative writing:Determine your purpose. Identify both your general goal and your specific objectives. Be clear about what you want your audience to do as a result of reading or hearing your message.Analyze your audience. Identify your audience’s perspective, values, biases, concerns, and culture. If you are writing to both a primary and a secondary audience, consider how they might differ.Formulate an outline and determine an organizational format. Determine the major components of the project. You also might want to agree on subject headings and format. Clarify the degree to which individual team members may depart from the broad outline.Choose a team leader. Define the team leader’s role and responsibilities. As Charles Brusaw points out in The Business Writer’s Handbook, the team leader usually "does not have decision-making authority, just the extra responsibility of coordinating the team members’ activities and organizing the project."Assign writing tasks and other duties. Decide who will be responsible for gathering information, conducting research, producing the document, distributing copies, etc. Decide whether to use a single writer or multiple writers. If you use multiple writers, assign the different parts of the project.Establish a schedule of deadlines for drafts and revisions. Schedule the first deadline…

    • 618 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When dealing with collaboration, keys element are present. In order to collaborate freely with others, trust must be within the atmosphere. Often at times, parties are fearful to put his or her trust in another party of whom they work with, fearing that the task will not be completed . If both parties share a common goal, then collaboration in the workplace works very well. The environment is a key element to have when collaborating with other because it creates a calm and positive atmosphere to leave room for positive brainstorming. The first step to collaboration is communication. It set the tone to find the common group for the ‘win-win” solution for all parties involved.…

    • 1831 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Andrew Carnegie – a famous businessman, the King of Steel once said “ Teamwork is the ability to work together toward a common vision. The ability to direct individual accomplishments toward organizational objectives. It is the fuel that allows common people to attain uncommon results ”. Some people like to work independently, while others would prefer to work in a team. Is it more important to be able to work with a team or to work independently? Depending upon different personal traits and working environment, people will have different answers to this question. However, working as a group to complete an assignment and working alone to complete the assignment seem totally opposite.…

    • 569 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Another reason why having two individuals collaborate on a task is better than having one person work alone is because of the fact that each person can provide feedback and assistance to each other. The reason being is because a piece of work’s quality is weighed upon the opinion of others. When a person has someone to contribute their opinion on a piece of work, he/she can improve his/her work based on the constructive criticism given. An example of this is the peer-editing bestowed upon students whenever constructing an…

    • 718 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays

Related Topics