Preview

Comparing Foucault's Discipline And Punishment

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1183 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Comparing Foucault's Discipline And Punishment
College involves a process that has been deeply engrained in our brains ever since we were young’uns. The concept of conformity is widely accepted and promoted in that particular social institution and other similar ones in society with the same design and concept, which functions to essentially debilitate and control specific demographics. For instance, there is not much distinction between elementary school, middle school, high school, and college. Similarly, they all involve following both unwritten and written rules, social norms, and conduct in a religious and attentive manner or else there are extreme consequences that must be faced in response. Evidently, those social institutions do not allow much freedom and individuality to be permitted. …show more content…
This discrepancy can also be seen in other social institutions in which conformity is strongly advocated. This is not surprising because school is really nothing more than a normalized prison in society. In Michel Foucault’s Discipline and Punishment, he discusses the plague in the seventeenth century that led to a variety of measures taken to adequately deal with the problem running rampage at the time. Some measures taken concerned “a strict spatial partitioning: the closing of the town and its outlying districts, a prohibition to leave the town on pain of death, the killing of all stray animals: the division of the town into district quarters, each governed by an intendant” (page 282). Through those actions, order was able to be accomplished in the midst of the plague. The lepers, who were suffers of leprosy were individuals considered to be abnormal during the plague and forced to separate from society in order to create a “pure society”. As a result, discipline was created and a disciplined community was able to be maintained without any issues. The situation of the plague shows clearly how institutions implement techniques to measure and supervise those that they consider to be abnormal through disciplinary mechanisms. In the case of the plague, discipline was able to be achieved through the fear of the plague. Clearly, modern disciplinary mechanisms are extracted from those techniques, …show more content…
This is evident from the foundations of schools and other social institutions that are based on the concept of the panopticon. The panopticon is an institutional building designed by Jeremy Bentham, an English philosopher and social theorist. His panopticon involves a building containing a tower located at the center, therefore allowing each cell of a prisoner or schoolboy incarcerated to be seen. Michel Foucault says, “Full lighting and the eye of a supervisor capture better than darkness, which is ultimately protected. Visibility is a trap”. In the same retrospect, the same false ideology can be applied to education since similarly, it is also a trap. Evidently, there are so much problems that exist in the educational system. Schools are associated with the provision of knowledge and promotion of individual growth, but it does not solely and adequately allow it because schools teach you what to think instead of how to think. In addition, the panopticon disallows individuals to communicate with the warders or other prisoners. The permanent visibility allows there to be a sense of power provided to the warders. Through Bentham’s design of the panopticon, he suggests that the functioning of power should be visible and undetectable so that the prisoner can see the tower, yet not know whether or not they are being observed. This disciplinary mechanism is

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In Michel Foucault’s Discipline and Punish, he states that “[a] real subjection is born mechanically from a fictitious relation” (202). Real is the idea that something is fixed, permanent, and immovable. Fictitious’ however, is something that is not real or true. He that is exposed to the understanding of his actions and accepts the accountability to act spontaneously under the constraints of his own power becomes a standard to his own exposure. Basically, explaining that if you fake something as small as it may be could cause the outcome to be painstakingly real. That is, to say the gaze of those observing us is a chiasmus. Chiasmus is a verbal pattern where the second half of an expression is composed against the first with revised elements.…

    • 434 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This was a signifier of the important influence for new techniques of disciplinary technology which lead to surveillance. Foucault wrote a book ‘Discipline and Punish’, where he used Bentham’s design as an argument of knowledge and power. “The panopticon brings together power, control of the body, control of groups and knowledge (The inmate is observed and examined systematically in his cell).” [1]Foucault explains the use of the panopticon, the controller from the middle tower is able to see the individual inmates in their cells. He later in his book goes on to say, “The Panopticon is a marvellous machine which, whatever use one may wish to put it to, produces homogeneous effects of power.”[2, page 202] What he meant by this is, where ever you put the panopticon to use it can be in prison or in schools, the power will act in a certain way within it. Each person who is held within it, are constantly in the watchful eyes of the observer and are kept isolated. The reason why it is marvellous is because the concept is unusual as well as clever, whereby one single person is able to overpower many…

    • 616 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Its primary goal was to “generate a symbiotic relationship between the observer and the observed” and would provide those inside with a “clean, well-lighted, and relatively pleasant environment, and the warden with the most efficient means of control through minimal effort.” (Bak 40-41) Physically, the Panopticon is a wheel-like structure with a central tower and connecting cells protruding from its center, making it possible for a single person to monitor the populace. The directive of the structure was to make the authoritative power between inmate and warden irreversible by making “the subject visible and the observer’s presence unverifiable,” similar, in concept, to a two-way mirror. (Bak 41) The prisoner had no means of counter-surveillance while the observer would be able to keep each cell in sight at all times. The concept may seem effective, but only for the observer. In implementing the use of the Panopticon the psychological health of those being observed declined sharply. As a result, “panopticism grew literally from a "house of certainty" into a societal mode of inquiry and inquisition reminiscent of Orwell's Big Brother or Fitzgerald's Doctor T. J. Eckleburg.” (Bak 42) Beginning as a tool of benevolent control, the Panopticon developed into a disciplinary weapon. Whether it is present or merely threatened, surveillance proved to…

    • 1047 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In his concept of the panopticon, Foucault adopted Jeremy Bentham’s prison design as a metaphor for modern disciplinary power. According to Foucault, discipline is invoked through an individual’s consciousness of permanent visibility and surveillance, resulting in compliant and self-policing behaviours as if constantly being watched (Nettleton, 1997). Engrained in this concept is Foucault’s notion of discourse, where he asserts that power is fabricated through language and practices, acting as leverage in legitimising power (Nettleton, 1997). In turn, discourse influences how expert knowledge and ideologies are constructed and maintained within social institutions and processes, and the ensuing power relations observable in society (Nettleton,…

    • 1594 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    What is more, the structural-functional approach shows society as a relatively stable system of interrelated parts that keep society operating in an orderly way while members generally agree on the morality (Sociology 22). By analyzing college through this perspective, college can be seen as a stable educational system which operates by way of cohesive parts which include the administration, faculty, and students who all take on respective responsibilities. Certainly, all parts of college work together to keep society operating in an orderly way by providing students with an education in order to strengthen the US workforce. Additionally members of the college system collectively believe the pursuit of higher education is important and morally right because by attaining a higher education, personal improvement and overall societal improvement is likely to be…

    • 920 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Foucault’s interpretation of punishment differs to a large extend from Durkheim’s. The first believes that punishment is utilitarian and instrumental in nature, and the second argues that it is mainly moral and emotional. Foucault fails to accept that there are aspects of the penal system that malfunction, a problem which is not present in Durkheim’s study because of the sentimental principles of punishment. However, Niveen was not punished by the society after upsetting their ‘conscience collective’; instead she was punished by psychiatrists and counselors. The modern juridical system punishment transformed the mother into a failure in front of the people. If she would have been punished in a more physical and violent way, as it used to be,…

    • 211 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are so many individual groups of students, it is difficult to conclude upon what is the mandate that we as a high school society should conform to. Many different groups of people exist within a high school and they can coexist, while being the individual that they wish to be. From clothing, to grades, to culture, many factors can separate students from society, or student body, and these students can be the individual they wish to be without having to conform to other students or society as a whole. Ironically, these individuals usually become trend setters, turning their individualism into conformity for…

    • 685 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Another way to look at it is, “The tendency to behave in ways that comply with social norms that are contrary to one’s private beliefs is known as conformity” (Scher & Thompson, 2007, p. 1). Whether it is a college student giving in to the peer pressure and drinking or using drugs or conforming to a government or society that promotes genocide, the issue of conformity can explain behaviors. Personality traits may play a major role in affecting the level of one’s conformity (Scher & Thompson, 2007).…

    • 1515 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Panopticon Research Paper

    • 631 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Bentham's Panopticon, the idea of a prison with a singular central guard tower with a few guards to watch every prisoner. Sounds like a horrible idea doesn't it? Well, only if its not explained correctly. Bentham's Panopticon is the idea of a prison with a singular central guard tower with a few guards to watch every prisoner. The difference is the guards can look around and clearly see every prisoner, but the prisoners have no idea when they are being watched. This creates, in the minds of the prisoners, a thought and feeling of always being watched even if they are only seen about once an hour. If Bentham's theory is a good idea for prisons, what’s the difference with using it in schools? The way the panopticon will be approached is the only difference, but the bones are the same. If attendance in school is only taken randomly a few times…

    • 631 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The storyline of the book, Discipline and Punish discusses the history of the penal system that exists today. He also takes the opportunity to focus on how it has changed from decades before and what factors have contributed to such a drastic change. Foucault also uses his ideas of power and discourse to debate how they have both influenced the rise of the form of modern day punishment that we experience today. The author also relates the penal system and the process of it to reflect the sense of social control that is used today. In essence, he relates the modern system of punishment to the ways in which we control the society today. He also reveals in a different light the how the foundation of the penal system is also reinforced into society…

    • 1100 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    1984 Panopticism

    • 994 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Designed by Jeremy Bentham, panopticism lays a heavy emphasis on the importance of effectively educating the youth. Education in a panoptic society is suppose “to ‘fortify’, to ‘develop the body’, [and] to prepare children ‘for a future in some …work’” (Foucault 224). A panoptic community allows children to be placed into their most natural learning environment so they can be most effective in their society as an adult. From an early age, children would be split up into specific careers paths so they could become most effective and whatever is most natural for the child. Once the children reached the end of their education, they would be on route to aiding the society through their specific expertise. However, in…

    • 994 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Panopticon

    • 1087 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The author of the essay “Panopticism”, Michel Foucault gives his opinion on power and discipline in Panopticism. He describes Jeremy Bentham’s “Panopticon”, a tower in the centre of a room which has vision to every cell, generalized for prisoners. In simple words, it functioned in maintaining discipline throughout the jail. It’s most distinctive feature was that; prisoners could be seen without ever seeing. Prisoners would never really know when they are watched and when not. They are always under the impression that someone is keeping an eye on them continuously and if anything goes wrong, or they make mistake, they would be punished severely. Since, a prisoner would never know when he/she is watched, they have to be at their best. In a sense, if a society had a panopticon, the world would be much more productive when power and discipline is concerned. Panopticon does not limit itself to prison cells, however it can maximize potential in a hospital, school, factory or wherever discipline plays a role.…

    • 1087 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    For every individual attending college is an accomplishment and addition task to fulfill in their lives. You are given the opportunity to work towards a degree of interest in the real world. For the individuals that are living on campus have the opportunity to express freedom and self-deliverance in their life. From ages new birth to eighteen the decision and choices were made for them by parents or authority figures. Adults have the final choice of the school the child attends, upbringing, and nutrition intake. Parents were always told to give their child a proper meal three times a day on a weekly basis.…

    • 478 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Dating

    • 330 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Nowdays, teenage students of age nearby 18-25 where they come to college-a place where you are freedom, free from restrictions imposed in schools, now you have an independent identify. Though college run classes, carry out activities in regard to the knowledge being imparted but rules are followed to a certain extent.…

    • 330 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays