Preview

Case Study Thomas Green: Power, Office Politics, and a Career in Crisis”

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
914 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Case Study Thomas Green: Power, Office Politics, and a Career in Crisis”
Problem:
In the case of “Thomas Green: power, office politics, and a career in Crisis”, it describes the dilemma of Thomas Green who works in a company called Dynamic Display. Thomas was recruited as an account executive, and then five months later, he was promoted as a Senior Market Specialist directly by the President Shannon McDonald. Thomas’s boss Frank Davis hadn’t expected to choose Green as the new senior market specialist, and he was very dissatisfied with Green’s work style and performance three months after the promotion. After being informed that Frank Davis had emailed McDonald about his concerns about Green’s performance, Green was getting really worried about his situation and not sure how to explain his perspective to McDonald. I’m going to analyze the issue for Green and suggest solutions to solve the problem.

Conclusion and Recommendation: Green had strong ambition and willingness to achieve a high selling growth for the company. However, Green was so concentrated on goals without observing the surrounding situation; it caused a failure for him to adapt his work style. Plus lacking a managerial experience, Green wasn’t able to look at issues based on a structural and long term view. Thus he would decide to avoid interactions with Davis after the first criticism, rather than improving his performance and rebuilding the relationship with Davis. In addition, both roles that Green and Davis had were dependent upon collecting information; however, it seemed that Green didn’t submit to Davis’s request at all when he was required to send information. Besides that, Davis and Green’s divergence in work style and personalities had also contributed to the problem. Green prefers to deliver his ideas directly to clients and talk through issues face to face, while Davis would rather to prepare memos and presentations when a meeting was set up. Moreover, both Davis and Green didn’t seem to trust each other very much, thus Davis had to require Green to keep

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Outrage at Eastern

    • 1205 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Many pivotal managerial principles and practices are exemplified in the Case Study, Outrage at Eastern. In this particular story a manager, Charles Jackson, is faced with many difficult decisions regarding problems concerning one of his workers at Eastern Plating. One of Jackson’s workers named Marty Reid is accused of molestation of his stepdaughter. His allegations are made public in a recent writing in the “Evening Beacon”, the daily paper of the 10,000 town’s population. Reid also has his wife going against him as well, which automatically makes him guilty to the majority of the town. When Jackson reads the paper he immediately understands what he might be faced with in the next upcoming days of work. However he has not made up his mind with what to do with Reid and his future in the company. Jackson takes the necessary steps and evaluates the situation, covering all bases, before coming to a decision or making judgments. Jackson finds himself faced with a dilemma. He could fire Marty Reid and keep many employees happy and motivated, or he could wait until the trial comes to a decision. However if Jackson waits for the trial to come to a decision, Marty could be hurt in the meantime by one of his workers. Jackson is also faced with a lot of pressure from the entire company while they eagerly wait for him to make up his mind.…

    • 1205 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Case Analysis

    • 474 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Jim Donovan has recently accepted a new position as president for the company Famous Products. He has been asked to fly in to Milwaukee to take a look at the facilities and meet with the former president Don Bird. Jim is so excited and confident about his new position that he doesn’t think twice about his meeting with Bird. Upon his arrival Bird welcomed Jim to the building then brought him into a huge conference room where a bunch of other men in business suits sat. Bird made it openly clear he was not pleased that Jim would be taking over in front of everyone; this was obviously a huge shock to Jim. Jim was not prepared at all for Bird to react this way, we will discuss the mistakes Jim made before he got to the appointment, Jim’s reactions and what he should do during and after the meeting.…

    • 474 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Dick Spencer Essay

    • 1909 Words
    • 8 Pages

    In this case Dick Spencer, a well-known employee of an aluminum producing company worked his way up the ranks from being a successful salesman to a plant manager. However through his transition of roles Dick experienced some pitfalls. In the following paragraphs I will discuss the main contributing factors to Dick’s success as a salesman and the issues he faced as a plant manager and provide informed alternative solutions.…

    • 1909 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Treadway Case

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Treadway Tire Company: Job Dissatisfaction and High Turnover at the Lima Tire Plant is a brief case written by co-authors Skinner and Beckham. The case generally pertains to issues dealing with morale problems and high position turnover among those that hold the position of foreman. In this case, Ashley Wall is the Director of Human Resources charged with finding solutions to the issues within the Lima Tire Plant. Since Ashley Wall works for the Lima Tire Plant, she will have to face some political issues in regards to managing the action research project as an insider. A written replication of the key issues, contextual lens, and power relationships will offer more understanding of Ashley Wall’s charge to uncover solutions to the issues that the Lima Tire Company was facing.…

    • 1112 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    This case study is about a General Manager at Green Mountain Cellular Telephone Company ( GMTC), Erik Peterson. New to his position, he faces a multitude of problems that quickly put him in over his head, although he does not realize it. The parent company of GMTC, Cellular Communications Inc. (CelluCom) was founded by a charismatic and capable leader, Ric Jenkins. He had grown the company over time to be among one of the Top 20 Cellular Companies in the industry. Erik had never worked in the cellular industry prior to taking the position at GMTC, but he very much wanted to be a part of it. When Ric Jenkins personally made the position offer to Erik, he freely admitted that there were serious startup problems and the position was one of high-exposure within CelluCom because the Green Mountain area had potential to be very profitable. Erik accepted the challenge, but soon found out about the “serious startup problems” Ric Jenkins had mentioned.…

    • 2391 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    This case puts the emphasize on the conflict between Sunderland and Morgan due to the harsh situation which is Sunderland had to deal with Attain’s Content Director, Mike Morgan, and Sunderland’s most important customers Gramen Equipment Company. Morgan, having a Master’s degree from project management, got a background from the small company for the software making and specialized in lean manufacturing training. When it comes to the management style: Morgan loves more chilling, relaxed and entrepreneur surrounding, but not some kind of the bureaucratic way to manage the enterprise, and he leads his team members to follow his own way. He is portrayed as “supporter and partner” and his teams appraise him a lot. Like Sunderland, Morgan went straight to Chama, and is on the same level of the organizational hierarchy as Sunderland whose style of management is depicted as “formal, and efficient, always setting expectations at the outset of a project” she is also criticized for being somewhat inflexible and overly demanding at times. In terms of relations with clients, Sunderland is reportedly “stubborn in the mud” in her notions to achieve exactly what clients really want . However, her experiences still achieve her expertise and confidence for managing massively, high-profit accounts, and she also has a great strategic mindset and provides insightful critiques, suggestions as well. In the other words , Morgan , roll up his sleeves and pitch in whenever needed, would try his level best to protect and guide his own teams and subordinates in terms of being criticized for their works or be misunderstood by the seniors ; on the flipside, Sunderland is not afraid to speak her mind . She really pushes the entrepreneur to the best products for their clients. However, the…

    • 1678 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Answer 1] Frank Davis, marketing director, is an excellent strategic player. He sorts through all of the possibilities, though short term, and find the best effective way to move forward. As he had just been promoted from the position of a senior market specialist he for sure was competent and experienced in the way things should be done. He got used to a precise planning of an every detail, schedule and documentation. That depicts him as a highly organized person with perfect managerial skills. David’s strong analytical strength mixed with his 15 years of experience in Dynamic Displays enabled him to visualize 10% growth rate. Davis has authoritarian leadership style who keeps strict, close control over followers by keeping close regulation of policies and procedures given to followers. Davis seems to be direct and to the point, as well as being very well adjusted to the bureaucracy at this level of management. When it comes to work style he is meticulous in details and requires that recommendations and strategies be justified using hard data. He prefers to stay in a positive mindset in order to keep moral up. Davis pays much attention to the office politics, strong efforts and enthusiasm of the employee. Davis is more of the initiating structure, which is proven to increase job performance. Davis expected to be treated like a veteran employee who has gained much knowledge over the years he has worked in the department. He wanted the ability to show his skills in knowing what would be best for the department. As a supervisor, it is Davis’ expectation that Green comply with provided recommendations for changes in attitude, behavior, and communication. Answer 2] Thomas Green is portrayed as visionary. He could see where market is going in the long term and he could think of related…

    • 2399 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Office Space

    • 1175 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This paper discusses the film office space within the context of corporate leadership and group development. It examines the way in which the movie represents conflicts and issues with superior subordinate relationship dynamic and how and why they are important to understand in today 's business.…

    • 1175 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Martha Rinaldi

    • 1994 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Martha Rinaldi, an enthusiastic and over-ambitious Marketing MBA graduate, accepted position at Potomac Waters over Deep Dive Pizza. She made this after carefully analyzing both the organizations (Exhibit 1) and then choosing her career growth and development over the monetary benefits. An intelligent career decision turned out to be a struggle as her relations worsened with her teammate and manager leading towards the decision of whether to stay or to switch internally or accept the standing offer at a smaller company.…

    • 1994 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Thomas Green

    • 5256 Words
    • 22 Pages

    After reviewing the following case study, I have concluded that both parties are responsible for the lack of synergy between the employee, Green, and upper-management, Davis. The underlying root cause of these problems occurring in the office is from the lack of respect the co-workers have for one another. There are several other possible underlying root causes of these employee-managerial altercations such as Thomas Green’s immense amount of confidence in himself, or Frank Davis’ approach on how to handle certain situations, however, the lack of respect for one another is the root cause of the inappropriate challenges to authority Green has expressed, and the ill-favored atmosphere Davis has created.…

    • 5256 Words
    • 22 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Nice Guy

    • 1332 Words
    • 6 Pages

    This case study begins with Paul Kennedy on a slow morning commute in Cleveland. During his drive, he’s worried about his wife and family, his boss, his associate, a stranger in a nearby vehicle, and even about the state of the Cleveland Browns. He is also excited about his plans to expand Daner Associates into the European market and his impending promotion to CEO. But when Paul meets with his boss, Larry, that afternoon, he discovers that he has been misreading signals. Larry is actually considering Paul for the number two role in the company and considering promoting another Daner executive, George, into the CEO position.…

    • 1332 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    FMB&T Case Study

    • 1247 Words
    • 5 Pages

    This case study is all about a bank by the name of FMB&T. Recently, the CEO and President of FMB&T, Marshall Pinkard, received an e-mail from a Vice President of the company, Ayishia Coles, who also happens to be the company’s Chief Information Officer. Ayishia reported to Marshall with several frustrations. She was having problems with her job because she didn’t have clear cut responsibilities or authorities, which had caused her some trouble in how to deal with people who had come to her for IT solutions. She had expressed that employees from several departments had come to her with problems she could not understand because they were poorly described. She had also expressed that these employees that came to her expected immediate results, but when she tried to be an administrator or facilitator, her efforts were not responded to with open arms. The other departments’ problems seemed to all be very complex and required a lot of time for the IT department to fix, which irritated the other departments in the bank. Ayishia’s last frustration seemed to be that the IT department seemed to simply work in applications development and only had a responsibility to fix the problems of the other departments in the bank. She noted that the IT department had some good ideas for business strategies involving IT developments, but their ideas seemed to be shunned or neglected. Marshall seemed to agree with Ayishia in her request for a formal copy of her authorities and responsibilities, but also pondered the idea that maybe Ayishia had uncovered a major organizational problem throughout the bank.…

    • 1247 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Into the Fray

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the case called “Into the Fray” there is a conflict between two candidates of a new position after the resignation of the manager of Lafleur SA, Lucien Beaumont. The main reason of that conflict is the differences between these two candidates. One of them is Micheal and the other one is Danielle Harcourt who is the global category director for vodkas and liqueurs of the company. Both of these two directors are successful in their jobs but; the difference of them is their ability of politics. Danielle has strong relationships with the existing employees of the company and she tries to take the new position in Lafleur by using her relations with them. She talks with everyone and tells her future plans, so she tries to get the support of other workers in the company and introduce her for getting new job. On the other hand Micheal is a task-oriented person. He does not engage with political relationships within the company. He trusts his success therefore he believes that he does not need political relationships with other employees. That is why he does not talk with anyone in the company. However when he realizes what Danielle tries to do, he confers his best friend Albert and his wife. They tell him that he should also play politics like Danielle does. However when he figures out that he received a new offer from the CEO of the company. I think it means that he loses the position of Beaumont and it is because he despises the importance of political relationships within the company.…

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Case Hard Times

    • 328 Words
    • 2 Pages

    It was a difficult time for the company, nobody wanted to buy advertising space. Even the telesales team leader Rob Grewal was finding it difficult to close more than one or two deals a week. It was the worst time for young Duncan Black to join the department – particularly since it was his first job. But once time he closed a deal in Bluebird`s most prestigious publication with Paxham’s Menswear. Many were unhappy because everyone of salespersons has tried to get Paxham`s hundred times, especially Rob. He felt that it would be fair to split Duncan’s commission between everyone in office. And one time the phone rang when Duncan was not in the workplace. Rob answered and took the order. He stole one of Duncan’s clients.…

    • 328 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Into the Fray

    • 1058 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In American world, people do what they have to do to get to where they have to in other to succeed in the business world, and based on the information given about Michael’s situation, none of his colleague demonstrated legitimate political behavior and that is because everyone wants the position he his fighting for and they all did what they felt they have to do to get to their desired position. An example that was giving in the text was “he notices Danielle Harcourt--the global category director for vodka and liqueurs and Michael's chief competitor for Lucien's job-networking with some of the Paris executives at a launch party for one of Michael's brands. She has also reached out to at least one of his direct reports.” It was also mentioned in the same text that before he could confront Danielle that he his also interested in the positioned, he got a call from CEO Pierre Hoffman and that was when the proposition was laid to him about the work offer in China.…

    • 1058 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays