2/1/2013
At first Nanda was against the whole arranged marriage idea she says “Had anyone tried to arrange my marriage I would have been defiant and rebellious”(pg128) and I don’t blame her for thinking that way because in this American society we’re taught to get to know a person then to “fall In Love” but once she got to India and talk to many young well educated women she figure out why arrange marriage wasn’t that bad one of the girls even said “My marriage is too important to be arranged by such an inexperienced person as myself. In such matter, it is better to have my parents’ guidance.” This made perfect scent, because parents do know best, and only want the best for their child. Most people in the united state rush into things like relationship and marriage. Like the saying goes “whatever you rush into you rush out of” a lot people get a divorce. At the end Nanda says “the positive aspects of arranged marriages appeared to me to outweigh the negative. In fact, I thought I might even participate in arranging a marriage myself” so Nanda’s outlook on marriage became more positive as the essay ended.
I personally think “Love Match” is better because no matter how perfect a person seem in front of your parents they might be different when you’re only with him. Most people show off to parent and have a different side to them. Another reason is say u wanted to get a divorce you really can’t because the family will be in your business and its going to be very awkward towards your parent.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Serena Nanda fails to write an impartial argument for arranged marriages versus "love match" marriages like those in the United States. She neglects to present the positive aspects of choosing a partner for marriage opting instead to keep the focus on the negatives. Her argument for arranged marriages is weak and unfocused leaving the reader to doubt her logic. In her attempt to persuade the reader to supporting arranged marriages, she actually emphasizes the negative effects of them. Reading Arranging A Marriage in India, strengthens the idealistic values of romantic love and exposes the flaws of arranged marriage including the extreme limitation of potential partners, inexperience and ignorance of the people, excessively traditional and sexist…
- 660 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The past three years have been really hard on me. I moved to Columbia when I was in the 10th grade and, I had to totally start over with friends and a new school. My life was simple and I thought I didn 't have to worry about anything. I began to see my mom spending a lot of her time with the same guy, and every chance she got she would go see him. I then realized this was much more then a "boyfriend" and that this could lead to a more personal connection. Because of this new relationship developing I began to discover that this could lead to a change in my life. A change that I would never forget and that it would hurt me emotionally for a long time. The very moment my mom told me she was getting married, I realized that she would be leaving town and I would have to change my home.…
- 1670 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
Author Serena Nanda begins the article by introducing the concept of arranged marriage in India. Nanda then begins to describe a filed trip to India and her direct experiences with arranged marriage. On this trip, Nanda met many young men and women whose parents were trying to match them…
- 465 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In the article “I’m Happy with an Arranged Marriage” by Gitangeli Sapra it discusses her view of arranged marriages. Ms. Gitangeli is for arranged marriage, she stated that people who get married for “love” has a 40% rate of divorce. She also states that arranged marriages have a lower rate of divorce for the fact that the couples do not want to start a wrath between their families.…
- 462 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
First reason I think in the same way as view 2 about arranged marriages and love marriages because I feel people should trust in themselves more than parents or a matchmaker. Based on a love marriage which mean two people trust in themselves more than someone else advice to them or decide for them of they have to do, and about choose someone to be a marriage partner for them. Just like in the Catalyst 2 book on page 93, chapter 4, reading 2, view 2, and paragraph 6 mean that they can understand their own feeling, their own decision and their mind better than just listen from someone telling them about their own future was like. Instead of let their family get involve in future partner; they can learn and…
- 462 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
It is natural for everyone to need or have or want a companion to shares their lives with. It is thought normal of young adults to want a spouse and a family of their own. In relationships it is that passion “falling in love” is the dominant aspect of young adults (Berger, 2010, p.412) Intimacy is when two people know each other well enough to share secrets, as well as engage in sexual activity. Commitment is more time consuming and requires work, dedication, shares possessions, in some cases child-rearing responsibilities, and the capacity to forgive. In some international familes arranged marriages commitment is first before intimacy and passion. Domestic violence sometimes occurs but male figures of the bride usually oversees common ground is the husband is too demanding. Arranged marriages hardly ever do divorce, there’s tremendous effort in keeping the family together as well as social and family support is offered.…
- 1303 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
All in all, I support arranged marriages. What I thought was taken away (their own decision) was not. Supporting arranged marriages not only has its own benefits . Such as wedding tab would already be picked up. It also it is a decision to allow the parents to participate in this religious/ tradition affair. Serena Nanda gives us another perspective that she herself did not have until after. Arranged marriages are not that bad after her. Their decision was not taken away from them but it was wanted. Their decision became a family decision. Which I…
- 438 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
“The Radical Idea of Marrying for Love” is written by Stephanie Coontz. She talks about how marrying for love is not as common as everyone thinks. She shows the facts about how love is only a bonus to getting married. This article makes everyone that reads it appreciate how lucky they are to actually love their partners. The thesis of this piece of work is that everyone should enjoy what they have in life, because love is such a special gift that we all take for granted.…
- 655 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
After reading the article Arranging a Marriage in India my first thoughts were why would any man or woman want to marry someone they are unfamiliar with, no nothing about them. I had the same mind as Serena Nanda who is the woman who got to experience it all while her trip to India. Of course my opinions had changed after reading the article, although I never had a problem with arranged marriages because I had been aware that some cultures do that as a lifestyle, but the idea of it kind of sounding like the parents are selling the daughter. As Serena mentions that how in the U.S we find the one we love and then marry after a few years of dating if it’s the right one of course, but now divorce rate is very high and it’s usually because it’s cheating or you just get tired of being with the same person. But how a women in India see it, they marry the guy that the parents have arranged them with and they seem to have a very flow and happy marriage, but how can that be? Is what I ask myself? They are people who have never talked or seen before yet they enjoy each other, although I like the idea on how when they marry they get to know each other and they aren’t tired of each other because it’s just the beginning of their marriage, it’s kind of like dating in U.S only they’re married. They interview with Sita, Sita mentions on how her parents have experience and they know what’s best for her when picking the right guy for her to get married with. While they are picking boys for her Sita doesn’t experience dating her parents do all the work for and all she does is goes to school and enjoys her youth she has more time to spend on her life instead of worrying about the man she might marry or boys. Sita’s reasoning was very understandable and I feel like I connect to that idea and that maybe it wouldn’t be a bad idea to have an arranged marriage, but I know that it really isn’t for me. Education in man is very important when the parents of a soon to be bride is looking…
- 875 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Not only were arranged marriages common in the historical era in which the story takes place, but often women were still seen as property. Women were nothing more than a form of animal, to be used and exploited for “arm-candy,” sex, powerful men in her family, social or economic gain, and dowries. Women were forced into marriages with men they didn’t love, and often barely knew. They were simply pawns in a mans world and were used as such to benefit the men who ‘owned’ them. A man would always own a woman; she would never be free. Her father controlled her every move- until she was married. Then her husband took her decisions over. Even upon becoming a widow, if she had any sons, they would control their mother lives and make decisions on her…
- 182 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
The arranged marriage process is extremely precise and long so spouse will truly be able to compliment each other. A spouse is chosen so they will perfectly, or as close to perfectly, match their future spouse and family to limit chance of divorce or unhappiness. For a bride, looks are taken into consideration but character is of even more importance (Nanda). Since the character of a person is so highly valued and analyzed in marriage, it is made certain that the bride will be compatible with her new in-laws and that she will be a harmonious new addition to the family. In Serena Nanda’s experience of arranging a marriage, the mother refused certain people because she knew they would be incompatible and create nothing but conflict within the household. In one case the mother refused a potential bride because her family came from a class much higher than their own (Nanda). The potential bride who came from…
- 675 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Paper includes a strong topic sentence that clearly expresses an opinion of the topic. 5 pts.…
- 903 Words
- 4 Pages
Powerful Essays -
There are many factors that play a major role in marriages and lust for one another is one of them. In the essay “Arranged Marriages Get a Little Reshuffling” by Lizette Alvarez a journalist for The New York Times, writes that “Lust does not a lasting marriage make”(156). The author is saying that lust does not last in a relationship, and it is one of the main reasons marriages does not last long either. I agree with this, but lust is one of many other factors that make relationships work…
- 504 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Today there are many different types of marriages that are widely recognized; however, monogamy and polygamy are most commonly accepted. While looking for marriage there are many reasons for someone to choose a desirable mate. Looks, personalities, fame, power, money and love are just a few of the things that people may search for when choosing who they want to marry. Many people today feel that love should be the primary factor in marriage, however “very rarely in history has love been seen as the main reason for getting married” (Coontz 378). The views toward different types of marriages from the 1600s all the way up until today are introduced in the article “The Radical Idea of Marrying for Love”. The author Stephanie Coontz explains and informs readers how some cultures and religions viewed love as a basis for marriage then and today.…
- 654 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
I found this essay to be very interesting and new to me, because it gives insight on a very important aspect of a culture that is not known to most Americans. I like how the author grabs the reader’s attention with the use of several personal experiences of dating involving potential husbands for an arranged marriage. This essay also relates to my topic of how important parental approval is in marriage, because it shows the extreme end of the spectrum. Arranged marriage takes parental approval to an extreme, and allows me to give evidence of how important parental approval is to some families from other places. Although, the author uses great strategies to convince the reader of her beliefs, I still do not feel that I would like to be involved in an arranged marriage. I do realize that there are some pros and cons, but I would rather meet someone who I really love and marry that man.…
- 274 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays