top-rated free essay

A Comparison of Marx's and Weber's Theory on Class

By Maurice51 Aug 15, 2013 893 Words
A Comparison of Marx’s and Weber’s Theory on Class
by Mauricio I. Miranda Jr.

1.Marx’s Theory
Karl Max’s theory on class essentially is premised on the fundamental principle that human societies are divided into two classes: the bourgeoisie or the ownership class that controls production and the ploretariat or the working class that provides the labor for production. He said that human societies progress through class struggle between these two. He asserted that the system of capitalism or the “dictatorship” of the bourgeoisie is run by the wealthy classes just for their own interests. Eventually, he believed, the capitalist system would self-destruct and replaced by socialism. Under socialism, society will be governed by what he called “the dictatorship of the ploretariat or the working class in a “workers’ state” or a “workers’ democracy”. Eventually, socialism would be replaced by a “stateless” or “classless” society called communism in a process of socio-economic change, the aim of which is the toppling of capitalism through organized revolutionary action.(1) In a communist society, the concept of " development of each is the condition for the free development of all". A classless society will take place in which “human needs rather than profit would be motive for production. In a society with democratic control and production for use, there would be no class, no state and no need for money”. (2)

2.Weber’s Theory
Unlike Marx who viewed social class to be determined by a person’s relationship to the means of production, Weber believed that a person’s social standing is determined by his skills and education. Weber’s brand of social distinction is marked by his three-sided stratification model in which he saw political power as interplay amongst “class”, “status” and “group power”. Marx and Weber though were in the same page when it came to the idea of social stratification, which to both were undesirable. Marx believed that eventually, stratification would be gone along with capitalism and private property. On the other hand, Weber believed that the ideal situation for society is in providing “equal opportunity” within a competitive, capitalist system. (3) Weber, a German, got most of his ideas on social stratification when he studied the social structure of Germany. He realized that social distinction is more than simply ownership of capital or being a provider of labor. He saw many member of the German society who were not rich but were politically powerful. He observed too that there were many Germans who were wealthy but lacked prestige and power because they were Jewish. (4) To Weber, there are three independent factors that form his theory of stratification hierarchy: class, status and power. (5) •Class: A person’s economic position in society. Unlike Marx, Weber did not see this as the main factor of stratification. •Status: To Weber, political power is not anchored on capital value alone, but in one’s individual prestige, social honor or popularity in society. •Power: A person's ability to make people do what he or she wants. A good example is a politician or a government official who owns little property or status but hold power over others.

Theory That Best Describes Class in the U.S.
Of the two, the theory that best describes class in the U.S. is that of Weber’s. All the three independent factors that form his theory of stratification are present in the U.S. social structure namely, class, status and power. a.Class: Corporate America is peopled with top executives who control and hold power over industries and firms that they do not own. b.Status: There are many well-known writers, artists, educators, media personalities in America that hold great influence but not much economic worth. c.Power: The world’s most powerful person, the President of the United States, may have little property but has great power over the fate of people all over the world as Commander in Chief of the world’s mightiest armed forces.

Which Theory Works Best?
The position of this paper find the Weberian Theory works best in so far as American society is concerned. All the elements of Weber’s theory of stratification are present in America and are the norms when it comes to classifying its social structures. In the economic front for instance, investments, a form of capitalism, is what is sustaining the American way of life. Today, it appears to be the effective economic model in sustaining majority of other countries of the world. Even former die-hard communist countries such as China and Russia have embraced it as well. In conclusion, we are in agreement with the proponents of capitalism who attest that it is the greatest wealth-producing system known to man which benefits mainly the ordinary person. (6) References

1.Craig J. Calhoun (2002). Classical Sociological Theory Wiley-Blackwell. ISBN 978-0-631-21348-2.
2.Marx, Karl and Engels, Friedrick. “Manifesto of the Communist Party”. Selected Works. Volume 1; London 1943
3.Jones, Helen (1997). Towards a classless society? Psychology Press. ISBN 978-0-415-15331-7 4.Leander, Anna (2001) “class, Weberian approaches to”. In Jones, R.J. Barry. Routledge Encyclopedia of International Political Economy, Entries A-F. Taylor and Francis. ISBN 978-0-415-24350-6 5.Stark, Rodney (2007). Sociology (Tenth Edition ed.) Thomson Wadsworth 6.Friedman, Milton. Capitalism and freedom. (Chicago): University of Chicago 1962.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Weber's Theory of Social Class

    ...Weber's Theory of Social Class Class, Status & Party Marx saw class divisions as the most important source of social conflict. Weber's analysis of class is similar to Marx's, but he discusses class in the context of social stratification more generally. Class is one dimension of the social structure. Social status, or "social honor," is anothe...

    Read More
  • Marx's Theory of Class

    ...Marx's definition of class. It's strengths and weaknesses. - Although the concept of class has a central importance in Marxist theory, Marx does not define it in a systematic form. Marx left this problem of producing a definition of the concept of social class until much later. The manuscript of the third volume of Capital breaks off at the ...

    Read More
  • Karl Marx's Theory of Class

    ...Capitalism is the idea of a company or corporation owning and controlling all the means of society. In Marx’s terms these owners would be known as the bourgeoisie. The bourgeoisie control the socioeconomic system and have the proletariat work under them, essentially keeping themselves wealthy and in control. The system was so harsh that even i...

    Read More
  • Marx's Theory of Class

    ...The theory describing class as determined by social relations of production stems from the revolutionary German philosopher, Karl Marx (1818-1883). Ultimately, his social, political and economic ideas rose to prominence and greater recognition following his death. Marx himself grew up in a content middle-class home and it was only thirty year...

    Read More
  • Marx's Theory on the Fall of Capitalism

    ...Germany's oldest cities, Marx was the first economist who infused history, philosophy, economics, sociology and political theory all into his work. Marx was ahead of his time, his theories were ground breaking, only time would tell whether his predictions would come to fruition. Marx's main claim was that capitalism would eventually fall due to ...

    Read More
  • Critically Assess Marx's Theory of Class and Stratification.

    ...Marx class theory derived from his belief that class divisions are not found in all forms of society; classes are a creation of history. For Marx, classes are defined and structured by firstly, who owns or has property and means of production and who does the work in the production process, secondly the social relationships included in work and ...

    Read More
  • Marx and Weber's Theories of Class Structure in Modern Society

    ...most influential overview of how industrialization has affected the modern social formations. According to his industrialization gave us two new classes, which had evolved from the old feudal society. The bourgeoisie and the proletariat (Bradley, 2006: 134-135). The bourgeoisie in England, the new economically dominant class. At the beginning...

    Read More
  • Marx's and Weber's Conceptualizations of Modernity

    ... Marx’s and Weber’s Conceptualizations of Modernity The choice of how to define and describe ‘modernity’ has always been a contested subject. For Marshall Berman, the concept of modernity may be best expressed in Marx’s line “all that is solid melts into air” because modernity is seen as a “maelstrom of perpetual disinteg...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.