Preview

Why Do Undocumented Immigrants Become Citizens

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
733 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Why Do Undocumented Immigrants Become Citizens
There is an estimated 11 million illegal aliens living on United States soil. The government shouldn't allow undocumented immigrants to become citizens because it would cost American taxpayers, the immigrants increase the crime rate as it is, and they indirectly increase the unemployment rate. To begin, creating a pathway for immigrants to become citizens would be a heavy financial burden on existing taxpayers. According to Carrie Dann, a political reporter for First Read, “The conservative Heritage Foundation [think tank] estimates that granting a path to citizenship for illegal immigrants will cost US taxpayers at least $6.3 trillion”. The US cannot afford to fall deeper into debt, so granting immigrants their citizenship would be detrimental …show more content…
To explain, “If labor and immigration laws were enforced...[it] would create up to 14.4 million job openings, satisfying a good many of the 17.2 million jobless legal residents of this nation” (Confer). One major factor that brings immigrants to the United States is the opportunity for jobs. If these immigrants were unable to find jobs, the likelihood of them staying here in America is slim. If there is approximately 14 million illegal immigrants here in the U.S. and majority of them have jobs, then getting rid of them would free up jobs for American citizens. Giving these jobs back to Americans would help the economy because they would pay their taxes. Some might argue that illegal immigrants are an asset to the economy because they will work for the lowest wages. For instance, “The city has a thirst for people who will work for $5 or even $3 an hour” (Rayner). Nonetheless, these low wages that immigrants work for do not save the United States enough money to pay for the billions of dollars in federal expenses. According to S.J. Miller, “Illegals...cost American taxpayers $10 billion yearly in federal expenses alone”. This shows how the benefits that come from immigrants are not great enough to suppress the burden they bring to the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    “Results suggest INS intercepts 9.3% to 16.0% of travelers attempting illegal entry at a POE, and that INS mistakenly admits 2.95 to 5.45 million illegal immigrants at POEs annually” (Morrel-Samuels). These people escape from the political oppression or their religions while the others come here to seek a better life for them and family. Although they come to United States by this way or that way, they are causing nationwide problems. The illegal immigrants who are not English speaking workers and the illegal immigrants will take jobs away from American people because they will work for cheaper wages. Honestly, they bring good benefits to the U.S economy in the process of work. Moreover, “Economic theory predicts that immigration will redistribute income by lowering the wages of competing American workers and increasing the wages of complementary American workers as well as profits for business owners and other “users” of immigrant labor” (Borjas). This is the reason why many businesses hire them to work. However, the primary problem of immigration is security. These illegal immigrants may be terrorists and wanted criminals. They come to the United States to attack, escape the arrest, or…

    • 1375 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Immigration to the US should be legal firstly just based on the fact that the roots of this country are tied to large immigration flows of individuals from a variety of areas throughout the world. Next, immigration should be legalized because despite the argument that these individuals are taking over American jobs, they are actually not affecting unemployment rates at all. American companies benefit from being able to pay low wages and send more money to its investors or stockholders. If they did not have the opportunity to offer these positions to immigrants then surely they would spending their budgets on machines that would replace their work. Another reason to consider legalizing immigration in the United States is to gain a sense of cultural competence. When a country is exposed to such a large variety of cultural differences among its inhabitants then they are more likely to appreciate those of another background and begin to build a sense of unity or community between each other. Finally, immigration should be granted to illegal aliens because it will lower the welfare rates that are currently catastrophic within the Unites states. The idea that a nation can positively flourish and grow economically should be the goal of every country but…

    • 1113 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    This short but information intensive article focuses on Immigrantions hold on the economy. The author makes verbose claims that Immigrants are the only cheap labor available to do unskilled jobs (Jacoby,1). This is supported with the fact that in 1960, half of native born men were dropouts who wanted to work in cheap labor, but today less than 10% do the same. By pointing out the decline in able bodied native born men who filled the unskilled jobs that are the backbone of the American economy, the author points out that the jobs these immigrants are doing support the lower income jobs that native born americans are doing, Jobs such as a waiter or foreman (Jacoby,1). The article also denies the claim that Americans would pursue jobs that immigrants are occupying by proving that in order to properly provide a good pay, they would put themselves out of business (Jacoby,1). Simply, other countries would be able to out do American business and farm owners because they have much cheaper labor. So in a sense, we are lucky to have these immigrants, they do the jobs that Americans won’t, they are the support beams of the economy, working the lowest jobs, but does it positively or negatively influence their own political attitudes? Positively, is what the influence should be, while at the moment, immigration itself has been thrown on the national…

    • 1318 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Com/220 Final Project

    • 1950 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The overflow of undocumented immigrants is cause for concern for many reasons. There are too many underpaid unskilled workers hired over native citizens. According to Opposing Viewpoints (2012), “wage and salary differences demonstrate how illegal and unskilled immigrants place downward pressure on wages by providing an incentive for employers to choose them over natives”. Immigrants are known to work jobs that most American’s shy away from such as agriculture work, factories, food preparation and cleaning services (Opposing Viewpoints, (2012). Employers rather hire unskilled workers because they can pay low wages, increase productivity, and work long hours and in poor conditions. This affects citizens because it denies them of the opportunity to find work and get paid well.…

    • 1950 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Immigrants, will it be legal or illegal, have a very big influence on our economy. Most of the jobs that are held by illegal immigrants are jobs that don’t require a lot of skills, rather require hard physical labor. Being a nation that stresses the concept and idea of going to school and becoming successful in life by becoming a “highly paid CEO” or the next great doctor, jobs that are held by immigrants are jobs that people who are born and raised in the United States wouldn’t hold. Because of this, immigrants provide a playing field for jobs that most others wouldn’t take, such as working in environmental services, landscaping, and other forms of work…

    • 1560 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Immigrants play a critical role in our nation, boost our economy, and know that citizenship is morally right decision. People of all ages have been continuously fleeing their countries from war, persecution, and poverty. Immigrants have been willing, immigrants have been hardworking, and immigrants deserve the right to become a U.S…

    • 642 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    One important reason that undocumented immigrants should get a path to citizenship is that costs too much money to deport undocumented immigrants. According to Charles E Schumer, Upfront magazine 2016 In 2013 the Senate passed a bill that would have done just that right thing our Reform Bill would have established a tough but fair Pathway to citizenship. What Senator Charles Schumer to saying here is the evidence helps my claim by giving information about spending money on the the undocumented people the money could be used for hospitals and other needs. Now some might argue that sending undocumented immigrants back might help our country from trouble. But the argument that cost to much money to deport undocumented immigrants.The key…

    • 341 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Undocumented immigrants contribute to the economy and create jobs. Due to their lack of education and English skills, undocumented immigrants tend to pursue low-skilled jobs. Because the average American is more educated, they tend to pursue high-skilled work instead. As a result, undocumented immigrants tend to fill menial jobs that are necessary yet undesirable to Americans. Immigrants “do not compete with skilled laborers – instead, they complement them”(Davidson). The differences between these two working classes allows specialization to occur as skilled workers are able to focus on tasks they excel at while low-skilled workers are hired for basic tasks. “Economies...works best when workers become specialized and divide up tasks among themselves” due to increased productivity and skill advancement (Davidson). Moreover, businesses benefit since undocumented immigrants are willing to work for lower wages and increase overall productivity. As low costs allows businesses to gain more profit, the economy also prospers since more business is conducted and more people can be hired. This situation also minimizes the attractiveness for businesses to outsource to less developed countries for their cheap labor or automate labor for lower variable costs. In effect, the existence of undocumented immigrants in the workforce creates new jobs and keeps jobs from disappearing in America. Similarly, the increase in population also…

    • 622 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    National Issues Forums mentions that each year an average of about one millions immigrants are admitted into the United States as permanent residents. There are about hundred thousand people on long term temporary visas, mostly foreign students, guest workers, and cultural exchange visitors. On the other hand there’s an estimated 11.1 million immigrants now live in America without legal papers. Cost and benefits are always debated. Although I agree with option one “Welcome New Arrivals” because I believe that’s what makes America great for freedom. Also American dream comes from combination of diverse culture. Doesn’t matter where you come from or what you look like, you should receive the same opportunities as others. But then again I believe it should…

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Immigration is one of the most infamous topics today in American culture. The million dollar question is whether or not we should let immigrants in; legal or illegal. In my opinion, we should let immigrants in that are willing to go through the process of becoming an American citizen. Legal immigrants are tolerable, but when we start to see illegal immigrants hop the border in big packs, our economy starts to plunder with the mass amounts of immigrants we have to care for.…

    • 537 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Nation of Immigrants

    • 1146 Words
    • 5 Pages

    A common argument among those opposing further immigration is that foreigners take U.S. jobs and cause unemployment among the displaced American workers. In the July 13, 1992 edition of Business Week, a poll states that sixty-two percent of non-blacks and sixty-three percent of blacks agree that "new immigrants take jobs away from American workers" (Mandel and Farrell 2). Among some American, this notion may be popular, despite its erroneous founding. Julian L. Simon, author of The Economic Consequences of Immigration states that “. . . immigration does not exacerbate unemployment. . . Immigrants not only take jobs, but also create them” (Simon 96). While immigrants work at necessary jobs to keep the United States functioning effectively, their purchases increase the demand for labor, leading to new hires…

    • 1146 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    The general stereotype of immigrants in America is that they are lazy and will ride welfare and food stamps until the day they die. Much to the dismay of those who scream about lazy immigrants, this stereotype is almost entirely false. In fact, due to the Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity and Reconciliation Act of 1996, signed by President Bill Clinton, new legal permanent residents cannot collect food stamps or any form of welfare for their first five years in the U.S. (Binswanger). After five years of residing in the U.S., many immigrants will have established lives and not even need welfare or food stamps. Immigrants also help to repair America’s damaged economy by paying back more in taxes than what they use in social services (Hernandez 68). In fact, “Immigrants….will pay a net $80,000 more in taxes during their lifetimes than they collect in government services” (Griswold). Immigration is also helping to repair the balance in social security as the Baby Boomers die out (Hernandez 71). Hernandez also elaborates that legal immigrants are providing a net benefit of $611 billion back into social security (71). Legal immigrants to the U.S. are not abusing the welfare or food stamps system any more than those citizens that were born in…

    • 1039 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Should illegal immigrants be granted citizenship?Well that's a tricky question.Immigrants do help and hurt our country.They send the money they earn back home,but they also create their own jobs,that make jobs for Americans.…

    • 264 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Of the 11 or 12 million illegal immigrants in this country, it is estimated that around three-fourths are currently employed. This equates to eight or nine million jobs that Americans are not able to have. By deporting illegal immigrants, we are creating eight million jobs for our citizens and not some other country’s. With almost 95 million Americans unemployed, eight million jobs will have a dramatically positive effect on our economy.…

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Illegal Immigrants also contribute to the economy as well to the government. Offering to get paid low wages, the immigrants help companies compete with low priced products from other companies. By granting citizenship on the illegal immigrants, the tax revenue would also increase by 4.5 billion dollars in a span of three years according to the Congressional Budget Office. This would be a big aid to the economy as well to the government. It would also as well increase the labor force as more people retire and this would benefit the…

    • 452 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays