Kuyumchyan 2 that require hard physical labor. They, just like any others pay taxes and dues the same way as others who have entered the United States legally and therefore provide a revenue to our nation.
The jobs held by illegal immigrants are low wage jobs that high-paid skilled workers do not take, because of this, the need for more work for higher paid and skilled workers increase. Not only so, because of the fact that they are paid less, the prices on things such as restaurant meals and such are decreased to meet with the amount of money that immigrants make. Giving amnesty to those who have actually worked a long time for the country would grant the United States more benefits, because then most all immigrants would be required to oblige by the United States and pay taxes, instead of only some that do already now. Because of this, the revenue generated by tax revenue would boost the United States economy and granting an immigration status would give illegal immigrants incentive to pay for taxes and be part of the decision making of the nation they live in by voting or by just being accepted participants. The obvious counterargument regarding having an impact on the economy is that illegal immigrants take jobs away from those who are here legally and are natural born citizens. According to those people, it becomes unfair to those unemployed who are legal. A quick response to the critics is the fact of outsourcing. Big companies and not only so, small companies, often outsource their work to other nations such as China, India and etc. to cut costs and therefore leave the legal immigrants and citizens unemployed. Not only so, deporting a huge percentage of the work force, who are illegal immigrants, would put a huge toll on the economy because prices would sky rocket and companies would be drained of workers because high-skilled unemployed workers wouldn’t take jobs that pay a lot less and require a lot more work. One negative impact on the economy and job market illegal immigrants have is on high school dropouts and young teens, but then they wasted
Kuyumchyan 3 their opportunity to better themselves in their career choices and should live with the consequences. To expand, another reason why amnesty is a better solution for illegal immigrants is because it is practically impossible to deport more than one million people who are in the United States illegally “The number of illegal immigrants in the U.S. has dropped by nearly 1 million” ("Number of Illegal Immigrants" 1). It is not as if a law is passed mandating all illegal immigrants to be deported, that everyone who is here illegally would step up and chose to be deported. The concept of trying to find millions of people who are illegally sounds bizarre enough, carrying it out in actuality would be more bizarre. The need for so many immigration workers and task forces to do this job would put a lot of strain on the revenue of the United States, would make a lot of people work more than they are required. Besides, by the time the first million people are found and deported, another million would find a better way to enter the United States illegally. It would become a never ending cycle that would keep happening until those who are here are granted amnesty, but at the same time, border patrolling and laws are made stricter to discourage illegal entrance. Giving amnesty shouldn’t just be done freely, but rather by making people pay a fine, show a proof of residence and tax paying and also background checking. The counterargument regarding this would be the fact that giving a free pass to those here illegally and it is the same idea of again trying to find the more than one million people who are illegal immigrants. For the first part, no matter if amnesty or deportation is done, illegal immigrants are going to come in, but rather than spending the money to fund in finding the illegal immigration, border regulations can be stricter by using the money to get new officers and patrollers. For the second part, when you give a good reason for someone to step up
Kuyumchyan 4 such as legal status, most of the immigrants would step up and pay the fines and go through the “hassle” because they would know that they can work and live without any worries.
Furthermore, another reason for amnesty is that everyone has an equal opportunity to support their family. Most of the time, illegal immigrants come to the United States because they can’t make it in their nation and that’s why they come to work and support their family. Being a nation that gives opportunities to everyone, the United States should do the same with illegal immigrants “We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness.”( "The Declaration of Independence" 1). Giving amnesty to illegal immigrants would provide yet another incentive for the illegal to work harder and devote themselves to support their family and be a proud citizen of a nation that accepts them. If they have lived here and paid their amount of dues and fines, they should get the same freedom as others to help their family. Amnesty should be given to those immigrants that show at least some form of obliging of the United States laws such as tax paying, even if a bit, which would be a positive for both the immigrants because they would get their statuses and the United States because they would get revenue. If deported, most of the immigrants are going to find another way to come into the nation because they need to find a way to support their family. This is where the counterargument comes in, which is that it is not fair to those who are here legally and work and pay taxes to support their family. Even though it is a good point, by requiring illegal immigrants to pay fines and taxes, they would become as legal as any other legal immigrant. In conclusion, illegal immigrants should be given amnesty but at the same time, be required to certain objectives and dues. Immigrants are a big part of the United States, will it be regarding culture or economic stance, so therefore illegal immigrants shouldn’t differ as much
Kuyumchyan 5 from legal immigrants. The benefits of giving amnesty outweigh the cons. The fact that illegal immigrants have an impact on the United States income, that rounding up the millions of illegal immigrants would be practically impossible, and everyone has the right to support their family are the reasons why I believe illegal immigrants should be given amnesty. At the end of the day, no matter the solution, immigrants are going to find a way to enter the country illegally because the nation they are part of doesn’t provide the opportunities for them to succeed in life, or rather live a normal life. The United States is a forgiving nation that gives freedom of opportunity to even those who are the least fortunate, and illegal immigrants shouldn’t be different.
Work Cited
"Number of Illegal Immigrants". OCBSNEWS. 7.14.2010 .
"The Declaration of Independence". OCBSNEWS. 7.14.2010 .
Cited: "Number of Illegal Immigrants". OCBSNEWS. 7.14.2010 . "The Declaration of Independence". OCBSNEWS. 7.14.2010 .
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
There is a myth about immigrants stealing jobs from Americans, that is nothing more than a myth. Immigration actually provides a benefit to the national economy, whether the immigrants crossed the border illegally or not. It all comes down to “specialization of labor”.Which is a powerful force in an economy, benefiting small and large businesses. Workers produce more when they occupy specialized roles, so businesses can offer higher quality products at lower prices. The fact that foreigners are so eager to pick crops, clean beach houses, and bus tables allows more Americans to enjoy a wealthier life and…
- 545 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The time has come to try Amnesty again. If the U.S puts Amnesty in motion, we can get more legal immigrants. Illegal immigrants don’t have their documents so therefore they won’t be accepted into most jobs and they won’t be able to do much legally here in the U.S. If they’re not doing anything or contributing to our country, then why are they here? They’re taking up space, jobs, and money and we need to do something about it. Many of us U.S citizens work hard for our money and to provide for our families and it’s not fair to have illegal immigrants take or limit our wages. Illegal immigrants impact our economy and the lives of our citizens. Their willingness to work for low wages is having an impact on the amount of jobs that are available for U.S…
- 487 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Due to the fact that deporting the illegal immigrants would be a difficult task and a costly one as well, it would be better off just giving them amnesty and have them here in the United States to contribute to the workforce and the consumers population, meanwhile resolve their status as immigrants to citizens. As seen in politics, immigration is a very hot topic to this very day. We see immigration being used by the politicians to get the people to vote for them. When the immigrants come to the U.S. they aren’t coming for no reason, they come for a more prosperous living style, better suited economy as well to support their family in their home country. There is controversy to this subject matter such as they consume the American public services…
- 912 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Moreover, the illegal immigrant workers usually travel far away from their homeland to America and some of them even “risk their lives in dangerous desert border crossings, or entrusted their lives to the brutal rings of heartless smugglers” (Bush 554) just to earn a living in the states for their precious family back in the homeland. This is because the illegal…
- 1363 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Imagine being in line at a convenient store and a Hispanic man is in line in front of you at the counter purchasing food and gas. Chances are that you might not even know it, but he just happens to be an illegal immigrant. Through purchasing that food and gas, he just contributed to the economy as a consumer by paying sales tax. This is just one small example of the several ways illegal immigrants contribute to and positively affect the economy of the United States. For countless years there has been a controversial debate over whether illegal immigration has a positive or detrimental effect on the economy. It has especially…
- 3560 Words
- 15 Pages
Best Essays -
The first way immigrants affect our economy negatively is that there are 3.7 million houses owned by unlawful immigrants, unlawful meaning illegal. This causes a net fiscal burden of about 54.5 billion dollars every year according to the article titled The Fiscal Cost of Unlawful Immigrants and Amnesty to the U.S. Taxpayer. The next example of how immigrants can affect our economy in a bad way is explained in the article titled Is Illegal Immigration an Economic Burden to America?, taxpayers pay around $52 billion to educate illegal aliens’ children. That is a crazy amount of money to pay for people to get educated that aren't even U.S. citizens. The last example of how immigrants affect our economy negatively is that according to the same article, “illegal immigration costs U.S. taxpayers about $113 billion a year at the federal, state, and local level”. That is a lot of money to pay for people to come into our country illegally. All of these negative ways that immigrants affect our economy just listed, came from illegal immigrants, not legal…
- 657 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Each year hundreds of thousands of immigrants cross the borders illegally. Now, who can blame them for wishing to come to the United States, wanting to provide a better life for their families and having the ability to earn a better income? Do not blame them for their desires; however their actions should be questioned. For someone who wants the American Dream, crossing the border illegally is not the path to make that happen. The U.S. Government has had various bills they have been attempting to pass that would grant amnesty to the illegal immigrants in the country, and their families still on the other side of the fence. Nevertheless, the costs involved in the amnesty of these illegal immigrants would be passed along to taxpayers. Although amnesty for illegal immigrants whom are already in the U.S. is proposed, amnesty should not be granted because it rewards those breaking the law, and it is bad for the economy.…
- 1595 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
There has been migration to the United States of America, ever since founded. Since the majority of American people are not from Native American descendants, it is safe to say that the majority of people in America are the product of immigration. The United States is a nation of immigrants, as reflected in its motto e pluribus Unum (from many, one). Ever since the United States was founded, it has had a magnetic force to all sorts of people from different parts of the world. People arrived to America to take advantage of, freedom of speech and economic opportunities. In recent decades, however, the increasing presence of illegal immigration has been troubling to many. Scholars have…
- 2218 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays -
One reason why immigration should be allowed freely into our country all started a long time ago. As early as the 1600's when Americans were using Africans as slaves, the Americans brought these Africans over to America for their own benefits (American Immigration: Assimilation? If so, to What Degree?). As soon as these Africans came to America their title from Africans changed to African-Americans. This means that they are in fact American. After slavery stopped in later years, the now African-Americans had the chance to go back to their homelands, but refused to (American Immigration: Assimilation? If so, to What Degree?). They were so used to being around their American masters that, they now knew how to speak English. This helped them live strong in America, because they already had an advantage over most other immigrant, because they were fluent in their home language, and the American language (American Immigration: Assimilation? If…
- 1040 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Due to the presence of illegal immigrants the wages are kept flat or depressed and the employment rates for legal US citizens decreased.…
- 692 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Illegal immigration is a growing problem in the United States. Some may argue that illegal immigrants keep the economy moving slowly by filling up low-wage jobs, but it also has a negative effect on the United States: taxpayers are paying billions for state services, overcrowding in certain places, and "illegal aliens" fleeing to other countries after committing a crime.…
- 559 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Illegal immigration does have undeniably negative economic effects. Native born workers are faced with the dilemma to accept the job at a lower wage or to leave that field of work altogether. Some economists have found that undocumented workers have lowered the wages of U.S. adults without a high-school diploma or education. It could be argued however that this would encourage younger native born citizens to…
- 709 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
One of the most important advantages of the immigrants is that they help our economy. Many Americans complain that immigrants take their jobs. However, what they do not realize that the jobs immigrants take are the job most Americans in do not take. “[…] enter the underworld of undocumented migrants: working on farms, as day-laborers in construction, as servants and maids, or in sweatshops and meatpacking plants” (John B. Judis). Immigrants, especially illegal immigrants, are doing the hardest works in America that keeps America progressing. Moreover, Immigrants will help the United States economy with opening bank accounts, buying homes, and starting businesses, further stimulating the U.S. economy. For the result, immigrants can impact the economy in a positive way. Immigrants start businesses…
- 1066 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Since undocumented workers generally don't pay income taxes but do use schools and other government services, they are seen as a drain on government spending. Nearly 26 million legal and illegal immigrants settling in the United States since 1970 cost taxpayers a net $69 billion in 1997 alone, in excess of taxes those immigrants paid. This represents a cost of $260 in…
- 665 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
“It’s about the economy.” These are the words of President Obama on the immigration topic when he gave his state of the union address. But when this topic is brought up, so many mixed emotions are heard, felt, and even seen. On one side they say that legalizing illegal immigrants can help boost the economy and even complement the U.S workforce. On the other, they say that legalization will only entice more foreigners to cross the border illegally. Whatever the opinion, this is an important issue that has been brought up for a long time and no definitive solution has been implemented. This issue is one that makes you wonder whether legalizing immigrants would be good, bad or the impact it would have on the economy.…
- 735 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays