Preview

Trading Places Sociology

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1529 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Trading Places Sociology
The concept of class can be defined as the order of people divided into sets based on perceived social and economic status. Trading Places takes on the role of displaying a comedic view towards the differences of class in the 1980s. Through the juxtaposition of contrasting classes between the characters Winthorpe and Valentine, the movie Trading Places reveals the major differences of class and shows the underlying effects these differences have on people in American society. Trading Places exemplifies class conflict in American society through the reversal of roles between two individuals of different classes. Billy Ray Valentine and Louis Winthorpe display the reversal by having Valentine become rich and Winthorpe become homeless and poor. …show more content…
Take the Duke brothers for example, they are: racist, arrogant, and greedy. The myth that moral character has something to do with economic success is fragmented due to the fact that the wealthy Duke brothers are the complete opposite of morally just. Another good argument to incorporate from the article is when it mentions how people living with inheritance have a general head start on what they want to do in the world. Take into account Winthorpe and Valentine, two opposite class citizens. Winthorpe was born into inheritance and managed to attend Harvard University while executing an average, or even below average, performance of his job at the brokerage firm. On the other hand, Valentine was poor and homeless, however both the Duke brothers knew he could perform the job very well based off the information Valentine knew about people and the way stocks worked. Tying it back into head starts, Winthorpe has had a head start his whole life, yet he still manages to fail at being a good employee, while Valentine has to battle and show that he could take on the job of being the managing director. Even in the article, the writers mention that “education is thus often seen as the primary means of upward social mobility” (McNamee and Miller 281). …show more content…
In the article Destructive Power of Money by Karl Marx, Marx discusses the complex relationship between money and people who possess it. One assertion Marx makes relates to the two Duke brothers in Trading Places, about how wealthy people can “...have, through the power of money, anything…” (Marx 289). The Duke brothers are millionaires and have control of anything they desire, so they deem it necessary to wager one million dollars on a bet regarding the central plot of the story: Valentine, a homeless man, switching roles with Winthorpe, a wealthy stock broker. The amount of money and the willingness to take forth in a million dollar bet sparks conflict over the wealthy class and how they are portrayed in an arrogant way. That amount of money could help people in need, rather than being tossed around off bets. Incidentally, the differentiation of class is vividly illustrated by the Duke brothers’ greedy scheme, leading into further characterizations of how class types are portrayed in film. Also, the main idea that the rich fear being poor is explicitly stated in the movie where Louis Winthorpe says: “I had the most absurd nightmare. I was poor and no one liked me. I lost my job, I lost my house, Penelope hated me and it was all because of this terrible, awful Negro.” The poor want

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Chapter 1 introduces readers to the town of Maycomb, its appearance, its inhabitants, and the particular attitudes of many of its people. Find a sentence or a paragraph which illustrates each of the following attitudes/ideas. Quote at least a portion of the sentence or paragraph and give the page number.…

    • 1009 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Class is split up into three main categories; Upper Class, Middle Class and Working Class. Class basically means people of a different social or economic value. There is a sharp contrast between Eddie and Mickey’s class. In the modern world it is hard to define what class someone is in. In that time; the class of someone could be defined so easily by what television you watch, where you live and etc.…

    • 1278 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    tim blixseth essay

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages

    When I was younger, I thought money ruled everything but in reality it doesn’t. Working hard doesn’t apply anymore in today’s economy. Most of the people who are wealthy have grown into the money or inherited from their ancestor. People hold the wealthy to a higher standard/power therefore they think they are better than the middle/lower class. Even though money is a great asset to have, it can be a liability. As I read the essay about Tim Blixseth, he was an individual who was not impressed or got excited about how much money he and his family had. He wanted to be low key, an average middle class person who worked hard for what he got not just given. In the story “Living It” he tells us how he would wake up in different locations each night.…

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Comm 315

    • 1285 Words
    • 6 Pages

    American social classes can be defined as: lower, middle and upper class. Social classes systems are defined by various factors and characteristics such as: income levels, occupations, educational background, net worth, personal possessions and ownership. (Bucher, 2010). Moreover, superficial factors play an integral role in defining one’s social class. Clothing, hairstyles, vehicles, jewelry, morals, and attitudes are examples of superficial factors that describe social class within society. (Bucher, 2010). Social class distinctions between societal groups and classes can be observable or concealed. The purpose of this essay involves a personal observation of a social class that is diverse from mine. Moreover, a personal action plan will be created based on the information and knowledge gained through my personal observations. The personal action plan will discuss ways to improve my diversity consciousness and awareness.…

    • 1285 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Today people show how much money they have in different ways that don't include just plain saying that they have money. They hang out with certain people and go to certain places. Some people want to change their social class. For example a poor farmer’s daughter may want to associate with the upper class rather than the lower class where she came from but to do this she would have to change “social class.” This is what Gatsby did. He was born poor and worked his way to money. He wanted this change in social class and he went for it. Some people think this is no big deal to change social class because you surround yourself with who you want to be like. I think that it is stupid to change social class. There is no point. Everyone should accept everyone no matter the social class. If they don't do this and accept you as you then why would you want to associate with them?…

    • 706 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    little to no wealth (The Great… 5). In the novel, the rivalry between classes is shown in…

    • 839 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    On the other side, the whites and wealthy people were thinking about how to improve the taste of the meal, how to amuse themselves by beating African American, or the new clothing they brought or they will purchase the ones they are interested in. Just like the wealthy people don’t understand why poor people were worried about will there be enough food or not, the poor people don’t understand why wealthy people always have to get new clothing. Especially, the poor people were the servant of the wealthy people at the time, who will care how servant feels or what they think. To white and wealthy, the poor and African American were a either good or bad tool for them in different ways. Using “Jane Eyre” and “The Old Chief Mshlanga” for comparison, there’s a lot of similarity between the differences caused by race and class separation. The connection between the white/wealthy and poor/African American shall be no relation, but the rule maker and…

    • 392 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Trading Places Refutation

    • 1084 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Two decades after first making its big screen appearance in 1983, Trading Places has proven to be a timeless comedy and can make even the most cynical person crack a smile. The film has all the aspects of a great film which include, award winning actors/actress, screen play, directing, and an interesting storyline. Trading Places is truly one of the greatest comedies ever produced and is sure to bring big laughs for first time viewers, but has received some mixed reviews over time. One such critic, Dennis Schwartz, states his opinion saying, “director John Landis indulgently directs this preposterous lighthearted one-joke comedy that channels the well-worn theme used by The Three Stooges and "The Prince and the Pauper" of hereditary vs. environment” (Schwartz). Dennis then goes on to say, “Though it has some comic moments, they soon give way to tedium as it loses its screwball comedy format. As a satire on capitalism or genetics, it has surprisingly little bite despite pretending to say something about the business world and the social classes. It should appeal mostly to those clinging to the simple-minded populist notion that they can skewer the elites in a general way, as it modestly scales its aspired low heights with slick but witless dialogue and fails to register any moral complexities.” Also, he gives a brief overview of the movie and cast as well as saying, “The popular film, crassly appealing to the crowd 's basest instincts, insultingly tell us you are better off being rich than poor.” However, contrary to Dennis’s beliefs Trading Places is not your average comedy movie. It has a rich story and helps to bring new life to an old concept of heredity vs. environment. Dennis’s description of Trading Places is unfairly evaluated and gives no evidence for why he believes the movie is so preposterous and deserves a second look.…

    • 1084 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    These characters overcome the limitations imposed on them by the Gentlemen and ultimately triumph over them. By cooperating with one another, the heroes are able to wrest control from the Gentlemen and consequently thwart their plan. The choice of the term “class” is purposeful in this interpretation; these classes may be understood as representations of the classic socioeconomic hierarchy – the aristocracy, represented by the Gentlemen; the bourgeoisie, represented by the Gentlemen’s thralls; and the proletariat, represented by the citizens of Sunnydale and the heroes of the text – or as representations of dominate/subordinate class interactions along any other determination; racial, sexual, etc. The plan of the Gentlemen, then, may be understood as a manifestation of class domination.…

    • 1297 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    There is a social sarcasm: what we can say now the third generation of people who have long been accustomed to live off our charity that we have with them, whom we have created - their millions (Vonnegut, Kurt). These people do not work and do not want to work. They carelessly dropped his hands; they are not human self-esteem. Business success gives unlimited power. People who have money are often convinced that born to power, but power can be for its carrier hell. People with money consider themselves extraordinary. Their Law: "Always pretend to be good - fooled even the Lord God." Leff indicates that this novel can be seen as utopia since it mostly discovers the problem of dehumanization (Leff, Leonard). Nevertheless, it also emphasizes the importance of human nature within the formation of the business since being poor does not always mean being not…

    • 783 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Social class in America is a subject which always has and always will continue to affect our daily lives. The video "People like us: Social Class in America" offered several depictions of class in the U.S.. The video's depictions ranged in accuracy in terms of its definition of social classes. However the video itself caused me to realize the great affect social class has on my life as well as the lives of those around me. Classism in the United States is a very big, yet silent prejudice that is continually causing many problems in our society.…

    • 977 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The 1920s’ was a hectic time period for many young and wealthy people living in New York City. Many entrepreneurs took advantage of these economic opportunities and profited greatly. Although, some took their wealth in strife, to benefit others, some people misused their new power. In the novel The Great Gatsby, F. Scott Fitzgerald shows how money and power are often abused.…

    • 483 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Class in America

    • 480 Words
    • 2 Pages

    1. (1)Myth1 : “ The United State is fundamentally a classless society” and “ class distinctions are largely irrelevant today” are wrong.…

    • 480 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Inheritance

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages

    As inheritance itself shows how those who are already wealthy lessen the chance of others having the same opportunities to rise up. Haslett states, “...for people to be productive it is necessary not just that they be motivated to be productive, but that they have the opportunity to be productive”(Haslett 128). Giving everyone an equal footing and shared starting points brings about not only a larger group of minds, but a set of people that now also have a higher motivation to strive. With an equal opportunity stance there is the removal of the possible potential of great minds being set back due to a lack of personal resources.…

    • 918 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays