AJ Calvert
This cartoon depicts corporate interests in the end of the 19th century. Further analysis of the cartoon shows that the “people’s entrance” is bolted shut (a metaphor for the middle to lower class, who feel that large businesses and monopolies have gained substantially more political power than their counterparts. The sign in the back states, “This is a Senate of the Monopolists, by the Monopolists, for the Monopolists.” This is another way of criticizing the government with a somewhat satirical approach. The size of the businessmen in comparison with the Senate is another representation of their control over the Senate. The Monopolists are depicted by representing their interest in various industries (such as coal, iron, steel, oil, copper, etc.) and the impact that those industries have on the senate. These oversized monopolists represent large corporation owners of the day, such as Vanderbilt, Carnegie, and Rockefeller. The overall theme of this cartoon is political corruption, and it intends to bring the issue to surface on a larger stage.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
U. S. Sen. Harry Reid of Nevada is being investigated regarding a pay-to-play plan that involve two past attorneys general of Utah, said a country prosecutor Wednesday.…
- 596 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In document A it shows the picture named “Puck”. In this picture it shows the workers on the bottom, putting all this work into holding up this company up, or in the picture the ship and the owners or the business men do nothing but make all the money. This truly shows that the owners should be counted as “Robber Barons” mostly because they aren’t helping anyone but themselves by making other people to do their job, and not paying them even close to what he could pay them. In document D it demonstrates the picture “The Great Race for the Western Stakes 1870”. In this document these two men are competing to build off the railroad, but the difference is, Vanderbilt, the person on the left of this picture, with the two R.R’s is very successful and rich and just not giving anyone else the chance to have any success, while the one to the right just wants to try and expand his R.R company, but Vanderbilt, isn’t letting that happen. In document E this cartoon is titled “The Trust Giants Point of View”. This document shows Rockefeller looking down upon the Whitehouse, making a point that he’s bigger and better than everyone with his oil industry. All three document show these men showing that they are “Robber Barons” by how badly they treat society and how they look down on everyone else.…
- 411 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
[2] Ronald L. Watts. “Bicameralism in Federal Parliamentary Systems,” in Protecting Canadian Democracy: The Senate You Never Knew, ed. by Serge Joyal. Montreal & Kingston Mc Gill-Queen’s University Press, (2003): 67.…
- 3508 Words
- 15 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Kennedy begins his speech in a news conference in regards to the hike in steel prices by utilizing strong diction and pathos in order to address his serious concern for the nation’s economic well-being. He appeals to the crisis of economic distress by mentioning in paragraph 2 how the nation is “confronted with grave crises…devoting our energies to economic recovery…while servicemen risk their lives…asking union members to hold down their wage request, and that the Americans will “find it hard to accept a situation in which a tiny handful of executives whose pursuit of power and profit exceeds their sense of public responsibility can show such utter contempt.” He joins united with the people of the US “185 million Americans” who made sacrifices, while on the other hand, he takes another privileged group- the “tiny handful of executives” – and sets them apart separate. A US versus them distinction is a critical justification for the contempt and righteous indignation that Kennedy heaps on the steel companies.…
- 283 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Josephson, Matthew. The Robber Barons the Great American Capitalists, 1861-1901,. New York: Harcourt, Brace and, 1934. Print.…
- 2538 Words
- 73 Pages
Powerful Essays -
While the initial stages of big business trace back to pre-Civil War America, it was not until the post-Civil War time period that large corporations effected on American society. From Rockefeller to Vanderbilt to Carnegie and all in between, these men and their businesses had unprecedented influence on American life. John Rockefeller created the Standard Oil Trust, with the intention of his business, Standard Oil Company, becoming the oil monopoly; short after, The Homestead Strike against Carnegie Steel aroused massive public support for unions. Likewise, big businesses’ growth and influences brought about a decline in the cost of living and the birth of a new political party. As a whole, the rise of big business in post-Civil War America caused a downward economic spiral while simultaneously increasing American hostility toward government and corporations, ultimately leading to the birth of new political and philosophical movements.…
- 1940 Words
- 8 Pages
Better Essays -
2. The implied power of Congress comes from the "necessary and proper clause" which is also referred to as the elastic…
- 315 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
This allows corporations to indirectly support political leaders, but ultimately they cannot voice their concerns. The essay also argues that corporations do in fact deserve to have the same protections since they are not technically able to vote, but must pay taxes. Without the ability to have free political speech, these corporations technically do not have any way to influence any decision that may affect their businesses or trades. The essay…
- 687 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
As businesses began to form and grow into huge monopolies, the impact they had on the government and politics grew as well. The government at that time had a lassiez faire outlook on businesses. They did not find the need to be involved in business affairs. However, when these mammoth companies controlled all aspects of a particular staple in the American society, many wanted the government to step in and regulate it. The extremely wealthy men who owned these companies were also able to control the government in some ways. As depicted in the cartoon entitled “The Bosses of the Senate,” the entrepreneurs of that time are shown as giant men looking down on all the other “less important” people of the senate. This shows that these men believed that they could not only control the business world, but also the political world as well. The picture also shows a door labeled “Peoples Entrance” with a sign below that says closed. Some people believed that the idea of democracy and governing by the people was slowing decreasing and being taken over by the huge trusts. A sign also hangs above the men of the industry which reads “This is a senate of the monopolists, by the monopolists, and for the monopolists,” showing that…
- 1149 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Because of the large monopolies and trusts controlled by businesses, corporations often had a lot of political power. As we see in Document 3, Senators were often appointed to office by party leaders who were being directed by large corporations. This added to the political corruption of the time, because any political job position was now able to be bought. The purpose of the political cartoon in Document 3 is to illustrate how industrial trusts were running the government, which is important because at the time most people were either oblivious to, or didn’t do anything about, the injustice that was going on in politics, and this raised awareness to the fact. The most influential voices in the battle against political corruption were the People’s Party. They argued for more public participation in governmental procedures, and for better treatment of American workers (Document 5). This new political party and its ideas reflect how the negative effects of industrialization reached every sphere, and the backlash that the industrialization received.…
- 872 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
This time, however, it was not the votes of immigrants but the pockets of the captains of industry which facilitated such graft. In his political cartoon “The Bosses of the Senate,” editor and cartoonist Joseph Keppler epitomizes the susceptibility of the Senate to the interests of big business trusts. In it, one can discern the intimidating faces of the large trusts overlooking their browbeaten puppets(G). A sign hangs above them proclaiming “this is a Senate of the monopolists and for the monopolists.” Because monopolists donated to politicians ensuring their election, they expected a return investment therefore intimidating them into protecting the trusts and such horizontal integration which enables their profiteering. A prime example of said monetary expenditures is the election of 1896 which fostered the emergence of the fourth party system. Marcus Hanna was the monopolist responsible for greasing McKinley’s election into the White House through his donations of $16 million. Industrial tycoons undermined the virtues of capitalism, overwhelming smaller competition by bribing railroads and the government alike. Indeed, George Rice, a competing oil company owner to Rockefeller's Standard Oil described how Rockefeller colluded with railroad companies which offered Standard Oil lower rates to transport his oil (J).…
- 1426 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
“In this congressional legislature, a bare majority of votes can enact commercial laws; … create the most oppressive monopoly upon the five Southern States, whose circumstances and productions are essentially different from those of theirs, although not a single man of these voters are the representatives of, or amenable to, the people of the Southern States. “…
- 565 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
As the business industry boomed and fewer people controlled them, many people changed their views on the role of the government in economic and social affairs. The majority of the people believed in laissez-faire. People did not like the big gap between the rich and the poor in America. Most Americans disliked powerful governments and strict regulations of the economy. The growth of huge industrial and financial organizations and the increasing complexity of economic relations scared people but at the same time they were greedy for more goods and services. Powerful businesses were looked at as a threat to society. If one company rules the entire trade it could raise its prices because it has no competition. It was the monopolists influence that worried people the most. They did not want big businesses having more “say” in the government. As the monopolists were continuously criticized, they rose to their own defense. Rockefeller stated that he wanted to improve the process of refining oil so that it could be sold and made cheaper (Carnes 473). The first political action because of big businesses was first dealt with by the State and only dealt with the railroads. It wasn’t until the Wabash,…
- 758 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
This political cartoon was made to inform the American citizens about Trump’s tax reform. We know it regards Trump’s political reform due to the short speech he says, and we know it is Trump due to his dress which represents the one he had during his political campaign. The audience are the American citizens and we deduce this because the tax reform is done for the American. The political cartoon is made to underline how the tax reform will not help the middle class but the rich part of the population. We know this due to the contrast between the word “lie” and Trump’s short speech. The format is a political cartoon. It is political due to its theme, the tax reform, and it is a cartoon due to how it presents itself in an exaggerative sort of ironic and criticising way.…
- 245 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
In the past century, people continued to express an increasingly discontent view of Congress especially true when one looks back before the Clinton Impeachment debacle As the size of the nation and the number of congressman have grown, the congress has come under attack by both public influences and congressman themselves. Yet looking at one congressman's relationship with his or her constituents, it would be hard to believe that this is the branch of government that has come under suspect. In "If Ralph Nader says congress is 'The broken branch,' how come we love our congressman so much?" author Richard F. Fenno, Jr., provides insight into this view and why, through congress coming under fire, constituents still feel positively about there congressmen. Although congress is often criticized, its fine tuned functioning is essential in checking the power of congress without hindering the making of legislation…
- 759 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays