Accounting Education: an international journal
Vol. 20, No. 3, 275 – 294, June 2011
‘A distinguishing factor’: Oral
Communication Skills in New
F. ELIZABETH GRAY and NIKI MURRAY
Massey University, New Zealand
Received: August 2009
Revised: January 2011; May 2010; January 2011
Accepted: January 2011
Published online: March 2011
ABSTRACT This study into the perceived importance of oral communication skills in accountancy included the collection and analysis of quantitative and qualitative data from a national survey of New Zealand accountants, followed by a series of semi-structured interviews. Survey and interview data reveal agreement with existing literature: New Zealand accountancy employers find all oral communication skills somewhat important and a number of specific skills extremely important, but employers also report seldom finding the required level of oral communication proficiency in new university graduates. The study produced an inventory of 27 individual oral communication skills that will be useful to similar investigations in different national contexts. Additionally, the findings of this study may be useful to curricular development both in the New Zealand and international contexts.
KEY WORDS: Oral communication, workplace communication, listening, presentation skills, telephone skills
Academics and practitioners do not always concur but, in the case of communication skills in accountancy graduates, these two sets of stakeholders are in firm agreement: both written and oral communication skills are extremely important in the accountancy work- place (Albin and Crockett, 1991; Albrecht and Sack, 2000; Borzi and Mills, 2001; Hock, 1994; Johnson and Johnson, 1995; LaFrancois, 1992; McDonald, 2007; Morgan, 1997). This agreement extends across international boundaries, as a number of studies around the globe have reported the high value placed on communication skills, for example in the UK (Morgan, 1997), USA (Smythe and Nikolai, 2002), and Australia (Tempone and Martin, 2003). In New Zealand, the site of the present study, academic studies into
Correspondence Address: F. Elizabeth Gray, Department of Communication, Journalism, and Marketing, Massey University, Wellington, New Zealand. Email: firstname.lastname@example.org
0963-9284 Print/1468-4489 Online/11/030275 – 20 # 2011 Taylor & Francis DOI: 10.1080/09639284.2011.560763
F. E. Gray and N. Murray
the importance of communication skills in accountancy and the challenges of teaching those skills (Gardner, Milne, Stringer and Whiting, 2005; McLaren, 1990) have multiple corollaries in the workforce. Accountancy job advertisements regularly request both oral and written communication skills; competency in oral communication is emphasised on the website of the New Zealand Institute of Chartered Accountants (NZICA); and oral communication is an explicit component of the assessment structure of the PCE2 examination, which concludes the second (and final) stage of training towards becoming a Chartered Accountant in New Zealand. However, both formal studies and anecdotal evidence suggest that new accountancy graduates often do not possess communication skills sufficient to meet the demands of the workplace, particularly in the area of oral communication (Adler and Milne, 1994; Courtis and Zaid, 2002; Gray, 2010; McLaren, 1990; Zaid and Abraham, 1994).
Students in New Zealand may graduate with a university degree in accountancy after three years of full-time study. (Accountancy may also be studied in less rigorous programs at polytechnics and institutes of technology.) The intensity of the university programs of study, which are accredited by NZICA, means students have a challenging workload of technical study and very limited opportunity to take elective or ‘liberal’ courses. Of course, limited...
References: Adler, R. and Milne, M. (1994) Communication skills and attitude, Chartered Accountants Journal of New
Zealand, 73(11), pp
Albin, M. J. and Crockett, J. R. (1991) Integrating necessary skills and concepts into the accounting curriculum,
Journal of Education for Business, 66(6), pp
Albrecht, W. S. and Sack, R. J. (2000) Accounting Education: Charting the Course Through a Perilous
Future (Sarasota, FL, American Accounting Association)
Ashbaugh, H., Johnstone, K. and Warfield, T. (2002) Outcome assessment of a writing-skill improvement initiative: results and methodological implications, Issues in Accounting Education, 17(2), pp. 123–148.
Baker, W. M. and McGregor, C. C. (2000) Empirically assessing the importance of characteristics of accounting students, Journal of Education for Business, 75(3), pp. 149–157.
Beaufort, A. (1999) Writing in the Real World: Making the Transition from School Work (New York: Teachers
Birreli, B. (2007) Lack of English locks out migrant accountants, In the Black, 77(1), pp. 14.
Borzi, M. G. and Mills, T. H. (2001) Communication apprehension in upper level accounting students: an assess- ment of skill development, Journal of Education for Business, 76(4), pp. 193–198.
Cooper, L. (1997) Listening competency in the workplace: a model for training, Business Communication
Quarterly, 60(4), pp
Courtis, J. K. and Zaid, O. A. (2002) Early employment problems of Australian accounting graduates: an explora- tory study, Accounting Forum, 26(3), pp. 320–339.
Crosling, G. and Ward, I. (2002) Oral communication: the workplace needs and uses of business graduate employees, English for Specific Purposes, 21(1), pp. 41–57.
D’Aloisio, A. (2006) Motivating students through awareness of the natural correlation between college learning and corporate work settings, College Teaching, 54(2), pp. 225–229.
Davies, C. and Birbill, M. (2000) What do people need to know about writing in order to write in their jobs?
British Journal of Educational Studies, 48(4), pp
De Lange, P., Jackling, B. and Gut, A. (2006) Accounting graduates’ perceptions of skills emphasis in undergraduate courses: an investigation from two Victorian universities, Accounting and Finance, 46, pp. 365–386.
English, L., Bonanno, H., Ihnatko, T., Webb, C. and Jones, J. (1999) Learning through writing in a first-year accounting course, Journal of Accounting Education, 17(2 – 3), pp. 221–254.
Ford, L. (2009) Improving training transfer, Industrial and Commercial Training, 41(2), pp. 92–96.
Frankfort-Nachmias, C. and Nachmias, D. (1996) Research Methods in the Social Sciences. 5th ed. (New York: St Martin’s Press).
Freeman, J. (2003) The science of conversation: training in dialogue for NNS in engineering, IEEE Transactions
on Professional Communication, 46(3), pp
Gardner, C., Milne, M. J., Stringer, C. and Whiting, R. (2005) Oral and written communication apprehension in accounting students: curriculum impacts and impacts on academic performance, Accounting Education: an international journal, 14(3), pp. 313–336.
Gendall, P. (2000) Responding to the problem of nonresponse, Australasian Journal of Market Research, 8(1), pp. 3–18.
Gray, F. E. (2010) Specific oral communication skills desired in new accountancy graduates, Business Communi- cation Quarterly, 73(1), pp. 40–67.
Gray, F. E., Emerson, L. and MacKay, B. (2006) ‘They don’t have much in their kitbags’: equipping science stu- dents with communication skills for the workplace, Australian Journal of Communication, 33(1), pp. 105–122.
Guest, G., Bunce, A. and Johnson, L. (2006) ‘How many interviews are enough?’ An experiment with data saturation and variability, Field Methods, 18(1), pp. 59–82.
Hall, W. D. (1998) The education of an accountant, Massachusetts CPA Review, 62, pp. 34–38.
Hayes, J. and Kuseski, B. (2001) The corporate communication culture project: studying the real world of business, Business Communication Quarterly, 64(2), pp. 77–85.
Henderson, S. (2001) The education of accountants: a comment, Accounting Forum, 25(4), pp. 398–401.
Hock, S. (1994) The 100 most influential people in accounting: communication skills top list of student advice,
Accounting Today, 8, pp
Islam, G. and Zyphur, M. (2007) Ways of interacting: the standardization of communication in medical training,
Human Relations, 60(5), pp
Jacobs, K. (2003) Class reproduction in professional recruitment: examining the accounting profession, Critical
Perspectives on Accounting, 14(5), pp
James, K. and Otsuka, S. (2009) Racial biases in recruitment by accounting firms: the case of international
Chinese applicants in Australia
James, M. (1992) Essential topics and subtopics of business communication: are we teaching what employers want? Business Education Forum, 46(4), pp. 8–10.
Johnson, L. M. and Johnson, V. E. (1995) Help wanted—accountant: what the classifieds say about employers’
expectations, Journal of Education for Business, 70(3), pp
Kemp, I. and Seagraves, L. (1995) Transferable skills—can higher education deliver? Studies in Higher
Education, 20(3), pp
Kim, S. N. (2004) Racialized gendering of the accounting profession: toward an understanding of Chinese women’s experiences in accountancy in New Zealand, Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 15(3), pp. 400–427.
LaFrancois, H. A. (1992) The marketing of an accounting graduate: characteristics most desired by CPA firms,
Journal of Education for Business, 67(4), pp
Maes, J., Weldy, T. and Icenogle, M. (1997) A managerial perspective: oral communication competency is most important for business students in the workplace, Journal of Business Communication, 34(1), pp. 67–80.
McDonald, P. (2007) Preparing tomorrow’s workforce, Financial Executive, 23(8), pp. 52–55.
McGowan, S. and Potter, L. (2008) The implications of the Chinese learner for the internationalization of the curriculum: an Australian perspective, Critical Perspectives on Accounting, 19(2), pp. 181–198.
McLaren, M. (1990) The place of communication skills in the training of accountants in New Zealand, Account- ing and Finance, 30(1), pp. 83–94.
Milne, M. (1999) The promise of problem-based learning, Chartered Accountants Journal of New Zealand, 78(2), pp. 37–40.
Milne, M. and McConnell, P. (2001) Problem-based learning: a pedagogy for using case material in accounting
education, Accounting Education: an international journal, 10(1), pp
Morgan, G. (1997) Communication skills required by accounting graduates: practitioner and academic percep- tions, Accounting Education: an international journal, 6(2), pp. 93–107.
Muir, C. and Davis, B. (2004) Learning soft skills at work, Business Communication Quarterly, 67(1), pp. 95–101.
Neuman, W. L. (2003) Social Research Methods: Qualitative and Quantitative Approaches, 5th ed (United
States: Allyn and Bacon).
Ng, J., Lloyd, P., Kober, R. and Robinson, P. (1999) Developing writing skills; a large class experience: a teach- ing note, Journal of Accounting Education, 8(1), pp. 47–55.
Norback, J. and Hardin, J. (2005) Integrating workforce communication into senior design, IEEE Transactions on
Professional Communication, 48(4), pp
NZICA (2008) 2008 Annual Report of the New Zealand Institute of Chartered Accountants (Wellington, NZ: NZICA).
Pittenger, K., Miller, M. and Mott, J. (2004) Using real-world standards to enhance students’ presentation skills,
Business Communication Quarterly, 67(3), pp
Simons, K. and Higgins, M. (1993) An examination of practitioners’ and academicians’ views on the content of the accounting curriculum, The Accounting Educators’ Journal, 5(2), pp. 24–34.
Smythe, M. and Nikolai, L. (1996) Communication concerns across different accounting constituencies, Journal
of Accounting Education, 14(4), pp
Smythe, M. and Nikolai, L. (2002) A thematic analysis of oral communication concerns with implications for curriculum design, Journal of Accounting Education, 20(3), pp. 163–181.
Tempone, I. and Martin, E. (2003) Iteration between theory and practice as a pathway to developing generic skills in accounting, Accounting Education: an international journal, 12(3), pp. 227–244.
Thomas, S. (1995) Preparing business students more effectively for real-world communication, Journal of
Business and Technical Communication, 9(4), pp
Triebel, O. and Gurdjian, P. (2009) Identifying employee skill gaps, McKinsey Quarterly, 2, pp. 18–19.
Usoff, C. and Feldmann, D. (1998) Accounting students’ perceptions of important skills for career success,
Journal of Education for Business, 73(4), pp
Wardrope, W. (2002) Department chairs’ perceptions of the importance of business communication skills,
Business Communication Quarterly, 65(4), pp
Wardrope, W. and Bayless, M. (1999) Content of the business communication course: an analysis of coverage,
Business Communication Quarterly, 62(4), pp
Webb, C., English, L. and Bonanno, H. (1995) Collaboration in subject design: integration of the teaching and assessment of literacy skills into a first-year accounting course, Accounting Education: an international journal, 4(4), pp. 335–351.
Zaid, O. and Abraham, A. (1994) Communication skills in accounting education: perceptions of academics, employers, and graduate accountants, Accounting Education: an international journal, 3(3), pp. 205–221.
Please join StudyMode to read the full document