Top-Rated Free Essay

A Hanging The short story, “A Hanging” by George Orwell,

Better Essays
A Hanging The short story, ?A Hanging? by George Orwell, poses many problematic and significant questions. Of these questions the one that intrigued me the most was, how does the narrator?s emotions and feelings change throughout the story, and how does this change affect the theme of the story? These questions are significant in general because they are very important to the theme and major conflict of the story. These questions are also important to the story specifically, because it shows how the narrator develops as a character and how this change also affects the theme of the story.

I feel that the narrator?s emotions change from the beginning of the story to the end in many aspects. In the beginning of the story the narrator is very professional and wants to perform his job to the best of his abilities. Evidence of this is found in the story, where he talks about how he and the other magistrates followed behind the prisoner and descries it as a procession (pg 439). This gives it a very professional tone. Also, when the narrator discusses the dog coming out of nowhere and ran around them, he says ?a dreadful thing happened? (pg 439). He says this as if the dog is a problem because it distracts the guards from being able to do their job. Furthermore, in the beginning the narrator describes the prisoner in a very methodical manner, just describing him factually showing no feeling whatsoever towards the prisoner this adds to the narrator being portrayed as professional.

The narrator changes throughout the story immensely, he becomes more and more guilty and compassionate towards the prisoner as the story goes on. He begins to change as soon as the prisoner stepped carefully around the puddle on the ground (pg 440). Once this occurs, the narrator begins to include some of his feelings and thoughts, which he previously didn?t include because he was very professional and didn?t include his emotions and feelings. After, the prisoner steps carefully around the puddle the narrator says, ?I saw the mystery, the unspeakable wrongness, of cutting life short when it is in full tide? (pg 440). This is the first hint of the narrator showing that he is compassionate to the prisoner and demonstrates how the narrator doesn?t agree with the job he has to do. This also marks the first time in the story that the language changes when the narrator says that it is wrong, it is the first moral question and language that arises in the story. The narrator goes on to say that ?with a sudden snap, one of us would be gone-one mind less, one world less? (pg 440) this implies that he is empathetic towards the prisoner and that he is torn emotionally between the job he has to do and how he feels about it. This is a dramatic change from the narrator?s previous feelings or lack there of towards the prisoner because he now shows that he has a heart and became compassionate towards the prisoner, this is a day and night difference from how he originally felt and showed in the beginning of the story.

These changes in the narrator?s emotions and feelings have a big affect on the theme because the narrators change is basically one of the main themes of the story. It shows the narrators development as a character. And it is a major tool that author uses to get his underlying message across, that the death penalty is wrong because even the guards are against executing these prisoners.

Other people reading this story may say that the narrator goes from questioning himself in the beginning to joining the group at the end. Evidence of this intense conflict in the story is when the narrator questions himself as he talks about the unspeakable wrongness of cutting life short (pg 440). Then he joins the group in the end when he has a drink and laughs with all the other guards (pg 441). Another opinion that might be raised regarding this story is that the narrator emotions change with all the other characters emotions. The evidence for this in the story is evident when the narrator laughs with all the other guards at the end of the story (pg 441). This is because his emotions change along with the other guards since they all laugh together to cover their real emotions that they don?t want to show to their fellow co-workers.

Although some people have these different opinions, I still believe that my opinion is more valid because the narrator?s emotions and feelings do change from indifferent at the beginning of the story to caring and compassionate toward the prisoner at the end. Also, I feel that the opinion that says the narrator went from questioning himself to joining the group is partially valid, but although the narrator joins the group in the end he has changed greatly from the beginning and has changed as a character. Also, I feel that the opinion that says the narrator?s emotions change with the other characters emotions is less valid because the other guards emotions do not change nearly as much as the narrators do, and they show far less emotions towards the prisoner too. This is irrefutable and there is adequate textual evidence from the story to back up my opinion. Also, I think that my opinion is the most legitimate because although it includes inferences, they are backed by evidence from the story and the narrator?s context.

In conclusion, I feel that the narrator?s emotions and feelings change throughout the story, from being indifferent in the beginning to being caring and compassionate towards the prisoner in the end of the story. He changes from being an employee with no reservations about his job to a person who has serious issues with what he does for a living. Also, I feel that this change is one of the main themes in the story and Orwell uses this change to force his underlying message to the reader, that the death penalty is wrong.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    carry out orders by authority. George Orwell 's "A Hanging" is a descriptive essay about capital punishment. The setting of this essay is placed in an early twentieth-century prison in Burma, a country ruled by the British Empire. Considering that George Orwell was an imperial police officer in Burma, it is highly probable that this essay is related to his own experience. The essay, presented through the eyes of the narrator, examines primitive human nature. Orwell develops his essay through characters…

    • 1018 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    impact on you because of its effective style. Discuss how the writer’s style adds to the impact of the content. “A Hanging” by George Orwell is an influential, autobiographical essay, in which the subject of capital punishment is powerfully examined. The essay is based on a prisoner’s execution in a Prisoner of War camp in Burma during the Second World War. In the essay, Orwell is a prison guard for the camp and carefully illustrates his views on capital punishment. The structure of the essay is…

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the article " A Hanging " written by George Orwell, the main idea is that warden and jailer in Burma should give prisoners a good time and mood to die or even not to die but with other punishment. Before the hanging, prisoners are alive like us. Each time they avoid the puddles and screaming in front of the gallows, the author feels an unspeakable wrongness. The author wrote this story with a emotional tone. He tried to pursaude us in a tone and mood but not actual detial. " I saw the mystery…

    • 400 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “A Hanging” by George Orwell (Literary Analysis) “A Hanging” is a short story about the death of a prisoner who gets hanged. The writer, George Orwell was motivated by as a head police in Burma to write this story. Orwell utilizes a mixture of literary components, devices, and gadgets to pass on his disproval of the death penalty. He makes a dreary climate, in the first person perspective, and develops irony about the corrections officer's state of mind toward the prisoner’s death, to show that everybody…

    • 838 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Dr. Jeffery Mack English Composition 1 August 24, 2014 George Orwells’ “A Hanging” is a very descriptive piece. It starts off going into a detailed description of the weather, jail cells, and the inmates. The description goes so far to even mention that the man who was going to be hanged jumped over a water puddle. This shows me that even though it shouldn’t matter because he’s about to die it is just a natural instinct. When Orwell starts to describe the weather it sends out a dark uneasiness…

    • 916 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    George Orwell A Hanging

    • 954 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Examine Your Response: A Hanging George Orwell's “A Hanging”, was originally published in 1931 in The Adelphi, a British magazine. Aimed toward highly educated, politically aware people in England, Orwell's narrative essay questions the morality of British Imperialism by describing an execution he witnessed in Burma, while serving in the British Imperial Police. Orwell's humanization of the criminal and horror over the events he witnessed clearly show his implied thesis concerning the value of human…

    • 954 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Hanging Orwell

    • 749 Words
    • 2 Pages

    A Hanging 1. George Orwell's writing "A Hanging" provides his firsthand account of the hanging of a Hindu man who represents the last moments of natural life. a. The significant observation i. The man, on the way to the gallows, deliberately avoids a puddle in order to insure that his feet do not get wet. 1. Orwell found this to be very interesting ii. The man shows how he is still conscious and a living creature 2. Therefore, Orwell’s theme revolves around the inhuman nature of the extraction…

    • 749 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    day one after the other watching their fellow men die because of capital punishment. George Orwell's text “A Hanging” uses a variety of rhetorical devices including similes, characterization and juxtaposition to convince people of the wrongness of capital punishment. WS1: The use of similes in “A Hanging” are almost always a description of the dehumanization of the people in the prison. One example Orwell uses at the beginning of the passage is when he compares the manner in which the guards…

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In A Hanging by George Orwell, the topic of social injustice and capital punishment are brought to attention. Capital punishment, in Orwell’s eyes, is wrong and unfair. Orwell believes that the living conditions and their routine way of living are socially unjust. Imagery is what Orwell uses in his essay to create sympathy for the way he sees prisoners being treated in Burma. The living conditions that the prisoners are forced to live in are described as miserable. “Each cell measured about…

    • 463 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    George Orwell orchestrates his essay, “A Hanging”, with the intent to evoke a feeling of animosity from readers towards capital punishment. His detached point of view, depicting the animal like treatment the prisoners endure, yet never revealing the reason for their captivity, allows readers to focus on the justice of the punishment instead of the abomination of the crime. It’s not who the author is, it’s who the author isn’t. By having a detached point of view, Orwell is able to establish his credibility…

    • 615 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays