Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Ethical Dilemmas

Good Essays
507 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Ethical Dilemmas
The Truth and Reconciliation Commission, however, also had its fair share of disadvantages. The main disadvantage was that many of the victims simply did not feel that justice had been conducted. The horrible reign of apartheid had lasted for a period of 45 years, and now the TRC was asking them to simply forget the wretched past. In the meantime, all the perpetrators of crimes from the era where walking away scot-free. To me, it just does not seem fair that these villains of such hate crimes can just walk away, and leave all their crimes unaccounted for. In addition, the blacks were not even able to receive any monetary form of compensation for all their years of segregation and ill treatment. Moreover, the TRC was asked to only look at the crimes that occurred between the years of 1960-1994, while in reality the Africans have suffered from white suppression ever since the earliest explorers. What happens to all the injustices that occurred in the hundreds of years before 1960? Also, the TRC experienced numerous difficulties and problems in their beginning phases of operation. As Tutu states, "Our meetings for the first year or so was hell. It was not easy to arrive at a common mind as each of us tried to stake our claims on the turf and establish our particular space." The early commission members "were as diverse a group of South Africans of that size that you could ever hope to assemble. We were Colored, Indian, African, and white, the entire racial spectrum in our race-obsessed society." All this diversity led to numerous voices and opinions on how the TRC should be run, which lead to many governing conflicts in the early stages. Given the racial turmoil that South Africa faced in the early 1990s as it finally rid itself of apartheid, I truly believe that the Truth and Reconciliation Commission was the best way possible to address the crimes of the past and prepare for a peaceful future. I believe the TRC made the best of a horrible situation. There was no other way possible to address both sides, while at the same time alleviate the victims and condone the perpetrators for their sinful acts. I would have loved to see the apartheid felons pay for the crimes they committed, however given South Africa's poor economic status, lack of an adequate judicial system, and poor overall education. Individual trials against all crimes committed would have been impossible. The best South Africa could hope for was to let "bygones be bygones, " and this is precisely what the TRC aimed to accomplish. After all the years of racial injustice, the recent removal of apartheid has signified the need to start from a "clean slate," and concentrate on unifying all the people of South Africa to contribute to the nations future success and well being. For as Tutu so elegantly states, "God wants to show that there is life after conflict and repression - that because of forgiveness there is a future."

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Dbq On African Americans

    • 665 Words
    • 3 Pages

    He believed that Government policy had created an atmosphere in which “violence by the African people had become inevitable” and that “unless reasonable leadership was given…to control the feelings of [the]people”, “there would be outbreaks of terrorism which would produce…hostility between the various races.” No other way was open to the African people, to fight “in their struggle against the principle of White Supremacy.” He refused to acknowledge the decree that the ANC was an “unlawful organization” and said the acceptance of such a decree would be “equivalent to accepting the silencing of the Africans for all time”. Mandela was not a violent man and did not resort to violence lightly, but it seemed to be the only way to accomplish the ANC’s goals, as “all lawful modes of expressing opposition to this principle had been closed by legislation.” Mandela did not want an “international war and tried to avoid it to the last minute”, but also stated that his ideals were “worth dying for”. It was degrading for the African people to be thought of as a “separate breed” and “the fight against poverty and lack of human dignity” “was real and not imaginary.” To say differently was demeaning. The enforcement of apartheid lead to terrible conditions for blacks and “to a breakdown in moral standards” resulting in “growing violence.” Mandela and the ANC leaders were attracted to communism for the simple fact that “for decades [the] communists were the only political group in South Africa who were prepared to treat Africans and human beings and their…

    • 665 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    South Africa Dbq

    • 1371 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In 1651, Dutch settlers first arrived in South Africa looking for slaves and goods, at the time they were known as Afrikaners. The Berlin Conference controlled the European colonization and trade in Africa by dividing the country into sections. The African efforts to resist European imperialism failed because they were unable to withstand the advanced weapons and other technology possessed by the Europeans. In 1948, a new system of racial segregation called Apartheid was founded, which caused whites to be superior and non-whites to be looked at as inferior, even though whites made up less than ten percent of South Africa’s population. During Apartheid, the African National Congress was formed, in response to the Sharpeville Massacre of 1960, and led by Nelson Mandela. The Afrikaners fiercely supported the Apartheid because they felt it was necessary for their self-preservation, some of the members of the ANC believed in violence to end the Apartheid because the excessive government violence towards them, and the United Nations condemned Apartheid because they felt it was oppressive.…

    • 1371 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    But other truth commissions have been less generous than South Africa’s. The Chilean Commission, for example, focused only on the disappearances and not on Chilean human rights abuses, although the El Salvadorian commission had a very broad mandate to address ‘serious acts of violence’ (for a comparison of the two see Ensalaco, 1994). The Northern Irish Victims Commission, not strictly a truth recovery process but which was set up as part of the peace accord, published a Report entitled We Will Remember Them, which completely excluded victims of state violence (for an account from the Chair of the Commission see Bloomfield, 1998) One response to control on the truth recovery process from above is to have community-based processes. However, these are mostly localized and focus on truth recovery in a particular neighbourhood or group, and thus tend to be quite deliberately partisan. One notable exception to this was Guatemala’s Commission for Historical Clarification, better known as the Recovery of the Historic Memory Project (1999). This was set up by the grassroots and civil society in Guatemala under the aegis of the Catholic Church as a popular response to the weakness of the state’s own truth commission. The Report was launched in 1998 to great controversy – the co-ordinator of the project was assassinated two days later. The project addressed country-wide cases of murder and managed to be popularly…

    • 6971 Words
    • 28 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Desmond Tutu, a South African priest, found apartheid wrong based on religious grounds. Tutu disapproved of apartheid based…

    • 299 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ask anyone that was alive between 1948 and 1990, what life in South Africa was like. They will most likely mention the concept of apartheid and describe it with vivid, graphic details. They will put in the picture the millions of victims and the thousands of families that were separated, the children who experienced gory scenes that people in this century generally only see in films. They will tell you about the difficulties that they faced raising children in a time that only seemed to get worse day after day. They will share with you the stories of what scarred their lives, what torments them until this day, and what dehumanized their characters. Yes, they were alive, but the only thing that kept them alive was the thought, the optimism, the clinging to hope of one day finally reaching a point where all the suffering would cease. Unfortunately, these citizens of South Africa would have to feel agony, let tears drip down their face, and shed blood for several years to come.…

    • 1420 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Desmond Tutu Cruelty Essay

    • 1818 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The Path of Peace Cruelty takes shape in many forms. In South Africa, cruelty was displayed toward blacks during apartheid. The system of apartheid began in South Africa in 1948, when the National party came to power. It established a system of discrimination similar to the Jim Crow era in the United States. Apartheid was a law that prevented black South Africans from having the same rights and freedoms as white people(History page 1).…

    • 1818 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    A man with very humble beginnings, Archbishop Desmond Tutu was able to transform the country of South Africa through his application of his church work to social issues. However, Tutu’s lasting impact reaches much farther than just South Africa. Tutu will be remembered by the whole world as a man who would not stand for social injustice, and as a man whose compassion had no limits. There was never a time when Tutu felt that the opposition was too strong. Most famous for fighting against the cruel regime of the apartheid, Tutu was one of the most integral figures, if not the most, in the process of ending the harsh racial segregation in South Africa. It was because of Tutu’s high position in The Anglican Church, that he was able to have such a large audience for his varying opinions on what he felt was wrong the world. What sets the former…

    • 1525 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    invictus summary

    • 374 Words
    • 1 Page

    Reconciliation was an important matter for Mandela during his commandment, this was showed in a part were a black officer, who requested for help at his sector, denies to cooperate with the help of white men even though Mandela had authorized it. Madiba, as black people call him, stands by the phrase “forgiveness liberates the soul, that’s why it is such a powerful weapon” making clear that he believes that both cultures don’t have to eliminate and discriminate each other but to merge.…

    • 374 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    To me, apartheid was the most dehumanizing, humiliating and racist period of time for me and my fellow peers in South Africa and I wasn’t going to let these people get away with what they were doing but it was going to be a long struggle for freedom again. The struggle was mentality tough for me since most of my fellow peers look up to me as there leader for freedom in this beautiful land, but there was a slogan I remember and still use today that wanted me to lead us black South Africans back to freedom ‘who will watch the watcher’ I knew that if I did this for my fellow peers they will support what I was doing for this country.…

    • 802 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In Wilson’s work, I see that a nation which has experienced civil and political unrest has to use a multidimensional approach in the process of rebuilding itself. For instance, the South Africans employed the use of Truth and Reconciliation commission, religious leaders and the legal framework to restore peace and unity among all the human races involved. This perfectly worked well for them after the citizens committed themselves in realizing the new South Africa nation.…

    • 332 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Truth and Reconciliation Commission (TRC) was a body assembled in South Africa after the end of Apartheid. In May 1995 the TRC was put into place by the Government of National Unity, in an attempt to bring healing to South Africa 's apartheid past. Archbishop Desmond Tutu was the Chairperson of the TRC and Alex Boraine was the Vice Chairperson.…

    • 1866 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    South Africa is a proud nation that can claim to be one of the most influential nations on the African continent. Its economic power, technological advancement and standard of living is unrivaled by its brother African nations. However, all of this is plagued by a brutal system of racial repression that dominated much of its history. South Africa was a stunning example of a modern nation where a minority had such a great deal of power over a staggering majority. The word Apartheid is Afrikaans for separateness. This separateness was South Africa’s legal system of racial segregation that was enforced from 1948 until 1994. The way this system worked was that citizens where broken down into four racial classifications and received benefits or restrictions based on this. The four groups where; White, Black, Colored and Indian, where the White’s held absolute power and authority, which was enforced by the constitution. Under this system almost everything was segregated including health care, education and public amenities, where the standards for whites and non whites were in sharp contrast. Because of this terrible treatment of non whites, blacks and other racial groups became quite disenfranchised with the ruling party of South Africa. In 1950, the National Party created a Colored Affairs Department and one of their first acts was to strip blacks and coloreds of their voting rights in Cape Province. Four voters challenged this act’s validity but it was upheld in court by a two- thirds majority. This obviously set the precedent for the stripping of natural rights and freedoms for non whites in South Africa.…

    • 968 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    1. The Human Rights Violations Committee (HRVC)– who conducted interviews and documented all the stories and horrendous experiences of the apartheid victims who until this time, had not been given this opportunity to be…

    • 4164 Words
    • 17 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The committees that were introduced to the TRC all had a main aim, and that was to help the victims gain closure and the perpetrators to be sentenced. This helped aid the process of living through the terror that was caused by apartheid and helped them remember the past as something that they were given rehabilitation…

    • 1876 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Mun Position

    • 2792 Words
    • 12 Pages

    Whereas it was resolved that the objectives of the National Conference on Racism were to promote understanding of the nature, meaning and manifestations of racism in South African society, devise a common programme for the elimination of all forms of racism and make preparations for the United Nations 3rd World Conference against Racism, Racial Discrimination, Xenophobia and Related Intolerance due to be held in South Africa in August / September 2001;…

    • 2792 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays