top-rated free essay

Employee Legal Issue

By nmck123 Apr 19, 2013 556 Words
Week 3 Natty Mckiness
Employee Legal Issue
This week we are discussing employee legal issues. A current issue involves whether employers can refuse to hire smokers in order to save on insurance costs. Several companies have issued such restrictions and have been successful on lawsuits by employees who are smokers.

Atlantic Beach, FL (near Jacksonville) recently instituted a ban on hiring smokers. The city has implemented a policy that says it won't hire anyone who uses tobacco products or tests positive for nicotine.

"The policy, which became effective Feb.1, aims to create a healthier workforce which could boost productivity, reduce sick time and control health insurance inflation, said George Foster, the city's human resource manager. The policy does not affect current workers." (Karkaria, March 1, 2006).

Should an organization be allowed to have such restrictions on hiring employees to save money on insurance costs ie. is this legal discrimination? Why or why not? Note: Please remember that some of your classmates may be smokers, so be sensitive and kind in your remarks.

Karkaria, Urvaksh. Atlantic Beach Imposes Employee Smoking Ban. Jacksonville Times-Union, March 1, 2006. Natty,
No, I think Organizations should not have such restrictions when hiring employees. However, the other face of the coin is that by them doing so they get to save a lot of money in Insurance cost which at the end becomes net profit to the Organization. I know companies need to advocate wellness and importance of being healthy. However, this type of decisions can significantly affect workers in the area of being able to find a job to provide for themselves or their families causing a major impact on the overall economy. If people can’t get a job due to the fact that they smoke, they cannot buy things, they can’t spend money. This can slow the economy and can make an impact on Country’s Capital and spending Budget, and the way money moves with in the Country. The average smoker costs his or her employer $2,500 to $4,000 more each year in health care costs, compared with a nonsmoker, said Cathy Taylor, assistant health commissioner for the Tennessee Department of Health. Nationally, smoking is responsible for an estimated $96 billion in direct medical costs and $97 billion in lost productivity annually, according to estimates from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. ( This can be a Legal discrimination. For example, such discrimination occurs when the effect of the company’s policy or rule appears on its face to be impartial, falls more heavenly on a protected group of workers than other workers. In this case smoker vs. non-smokers which can results in limiting employment opportunities for minorities. This kind of case is called Adverse Impact. In order to make a case for adverse impact It involves the question whether or not a company policy or rule affects protected group adversely to a greater degree than it does other groups; and if so, whether there is a valid reason for employer to have such rule or policy. So, employee needs to show burden of proof and make a prima-facie case of discrimination. Smokers Need Not apply for a Job Memorial carves out plan to emphasize health focus by Emily Bregel

published Monday, January 18th, 2010

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • legal issues

    ...Issues 1.Does a partnership exist between Ed, Jake, Charlie and Bella? 2. Are Ed, Charlie and Bella also liable for the lawsuit against the firm by their client Mr Laurent.? 2. If so how far responsible are the other partners for Jakes mistake? 3.If no other partner liable, what excludes them? 4.Are there any defences to any of the membe...

    Read More
  • Legal Issues within Disability Discrimination

    ... Legal Issues within Disability Discrimination Carin E. Smalley Legal Issues in Human Resources HRCU 648 Benedict Lastimado October 22, 2013 Introduction Within my company, we have an employee that committed what our company terms a “Class A” violation this past summer of 2013. Typically, a violation of this type would...

    Read More
  • Legal Issues

    ...deadline for the public comments has already closed. I did find that it posted 12/5/2005 however, no further information was provided. I do know that under the APA the public comments period cannot be less than 30 days. 5. a. Once you have submitted your comment, what will you are legally entitled to do later in the promulgation process (i...

    Read More
  • Legal Issue

    ...Legal Issue: Respecting the privacy of user posted information Likelihood: Moderate Impact: High Ease of fix: Moderate Description Implementing communication methods such as video or instant messaging presents several legal implications and there are various areas to consider when looking at the legalities of communication methods. Some of...

    Read More
  • Legal Issues in the real world. The scheme “Get rich quick!” is popular among many. It is common to familiarize such with corporate culture which is defines as a set of characteristics that define a business. It involves employee attitudes, standards (policy and procedures), and rites and rituals. Though I believe that this is true and common, I kno...

    Read More
  • Employee Issues

    ...Workplace Discrimination Business Law Workplace Discrimination Discrimination occurs when an employee suffers from unfavorable or unfair treatment due to their race, religion, national origin, disabled or veteran status, or other legally protected characteristics. Employees who have suffered reprisals for opposing workplace discrimin...

    Read More
  • Legal & Ethical Issues for It Practitioners

    ...Legal and Ethical Issues for IT Practitioners Brandy L. Spinks Business 670 Dr. Stephens December 20, 2010 Legal and Ethical Issues for IT Practitioners For ages thinkers have written hundreds of books in an effort to understand, explain, categorize, and label moral, immoral, an amoral human behavior and the rationales behind our acti...

    Read More
  • Legal issues in employment paper

    ... Reaction Paper – Legal Issues in Employment Windy G. Nunnery University of Central Oklahoma Working in human resources, I am exposed daily to situations and questions that involve the legal issues related to employment. Although I have some familiarity with employment law, legal issues...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.