top-rated free essay

Discuss disadvantages of delegated legislation

By ths080127 Nov 01, 2013 405 Words
Discuss disadvantages of delegated legislation

This essay will discuss the disadvantages of delegated legislation. One of the disadvantages of delegated legislation is that it is partly undemocratic. Delegated legislation is not debated by Parliament. However, statutory instruments are an exception. Statutory instruments are drafted by unelected, permanently employed civil servants and are only rubber stamped by the appropriate Minister. The Queen and Privy Council are not elected but still approve Orders In Council. Another disadvantage of delegated legislation is that it has a lack of publicity. Delegated legislation is not debated in Parliament which means that the media is not able to raise public awareness and much remains unpublished. There is no general effective way to publicise delegated legislation so this means that an enormous volume of law is passed without the public being aware of it. Another disadvantage of delegated legislation is that it has no effective control. Not all statutory instruments are subject to an affirmative or negative resolution, this is due to many of the Parliamentary and Judicial controls being limited. Judicial controls rely on a person challenging the validity of the law which is due to limited knowledge, finance and time. Some delegated legislation is ultra vires and is never challenged which means that it remains in force. A further disadvantage of delegated legislation is that it contradicts separation of powers. The legislative, executive and judiciary should all operate separately. No-one should be a member of more than one of the three branches of power. They shouldn’t perform each other’s duties and declare whether the law is valid or not. Another disadvantage of delegated legislation is that there is a risk of sub-delegation. This is where the body/person who has been given the power to make law may pass this power down to another. For example, statutory instruments are supposed to be made by Government Ministers. However, in reality, they rubber stamp laws which are made by their civil servant. An additional disadvantage of delegated legislation is the implementation and enforcement. There is a time lag to enforcement and this may result in things having to change around to enforce the new laws. To conclude, the disadvantages of delegated legislation are that it is partly undemocratic, it has a lack of publicity, it has no effective control, it contradicts separation of powers, there is a risk of sub-delegation and it has an effect on the implementation and enforcement.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Delegated Legislation

    ...Delegated legislation in its various forms is a necessary source of law in a progressive society. Parliament simply cannot keep up with the need for law reform demanded by society. The government formed within Parliament has to fulfill the promised reforms (among other agenda) and there is definite pressure to see that these reforms are passed w...

    Read More
  • Delegated Legislation

    ...Outline the different forms of delegated legislation. (10 marks) Delegated legislation (secondary legislation) is law that is authorised but not made by Parliament. Parliament lays out a basic framework, known as the enabling Act and other people or bodies are delegated powers to make the more detailed rules. Ministers and government depar...

    Read More
  • Delegated Legislation

    ...Delegated Legislation is law made by a body other than Parliament.  Parliament gives others the power to pass delegated legislation in a parent or enabling act.   Act of Parliament (Statutes) - Primary Legislation Delegated Legislation (i.e. statutory Instruments) - Secondary Legislation      The Town Hall in Rugby - local bor...

    Read More
  • mens rea and delegated legislation

    ... Mens Rea and delegated legislation Alexandra StoicaMens rea: the guilty mind of the defendant The difference between s18 and s20 of the Offences against the person act 1861 is the mens rea required. Mens rea must be distinguished from motive. Motive can be relevant in some crimes. Intention:...

    Read More
  • Delegated Legislation - Judicial Review of Delegated Legislation

    ...Delegated legislation - Judicial Review of delegated legislation Control by the courts by Judicial Review. Judicial review Ultra vires and reasonableness, is described here Judicial Review Judicial Review is the process by which delegated legislation may be challenged, it is conducted in the Administrative court. Judicial review of cr...

    Read More
  • Delegated Legislation

    ...INTRODUCTION Delegated legislation refers to the rules and regulations, which are passed by some person or body under some enabling parent legislation. The Interpretation Act 1967 defines it as ‘any proclamation, rule, regulation, order, by-law or other instrument made under any Act, Enactment, Ordinance, or other lawful authority and having ...

    Read More
  • What Is Delegated Legislation?

    ...What Is delegated legislation? • Delegated (or subordinate or subsidiary) legislation refers to those laws made by persons or bodies to whom parliament has delegated law-making authority • Where acts are made by parliament, each principal act makes provision for subsidiary legislation to be made, and will specify who has the power to do ...

    Read More
  • Interpretation of delegated legislation in india

    ...INSTITUTE OF LAW NIRMA UNIVERSITY INTERPRETATION OF DELEGATED LEGISLATION IN INDIA Project Work (INTERPRETATION OF STATUTES) By: Nidhi Jain LIST OF CASES R.Vs. Burah (1878) 3 AC 889 Jhatindra Nath Gupta Vs. Province of Bihar AIR 1949 FC 175 ...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.