This essay will discuss the disadvantages of delegated legislation.
One of the disadvantages of delegated legislation is that it is partly undemocratic. Delegated legislation is not debated by Parliament. However, statutory instruments are an exception. Statutory instruments are drafted by unelected, permanently employed civil servants and are only rubber stamped by the appropriate Minister. The Queen and Privy Council are not elected but still approve Orders In Council.
Another disadvantage of delegated legislation is that it has a lack of publicity. Delegated legislation is not debated in Parliament which means that the media is not able to raise public awareness and much remains unpublished. There is no general effective way to publicise delegated legislation so this means that an enormous volume of law is passed without the public being aware of it.
Another disadvantage of delegated legislation is that it has no effective control. Not all statutory instruments are subject to an affirmative or negative resolution, this is due to many of the Parliamentary and Judicial controls being limited. Judicial controls rely on a person challenging the validity of the law which is due to limited knowledge, finance and time. Some delegated legislation is ultra vires and is never challenged which means that it remains in force.
A further disadvantage of delegated legislation is that it contradicts separation of powers. The legislative, executive and judiciary should all operate separately. No-one should be a member of more than one of the three branches of power. They shouldn’t perform each other’s duties and declare whether the law is valid or not.
Another disadvantage of delegated legislation is that there is a risk of sub-delegation. This is where the body/person who has been given the power to make law may pass this power down to another. For example, statutory instruments are supposed to be made by Government Ministers. However, in reality, they rubber stamp laws which are made by their civil servant.
An additional disadvantage of delegated legislation is the implementation and enforcement. There is a time lag to enforcement and this may result in things having to change around to enforce the new laws.
To conclude, the disadvantages of delegated legislation are that it is partly undemocratic, it has a lack of publicity, it has no effective control, it contradicts separation of powers, there is a risk of sub-delegation and it has an effect on the implementation and enforcement.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
A delegate feels that the constituents are the ones in charge and that their will is to be obeyed. I believe that this gives too much popular power to the people which most likely will not be used correctly.…
- 320 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The main role of parliament is to introduce, debate and put into practice laws that are for the greater good of society. Law making is not a sub-role or something that parliament focuses only a small amount of its attention on it is the sole purpose of its existence. To have a national organisation the size and strength of parliament that focuses solely on law making is one of its main strengths as a law making institution. However parliament is not always sitting and it could be said that this causes a delay in parliament’s ability to react to issues that require changes to the law. If there was a law that it became clear required urgent attention parliament may have to wait a number of weeks for a scheduled sitting date before this issue could be discussed and any changes to the law be made. Parliament is elected by the people and is consequently responsible to the voting public; this is strength of it as a law making institution.…
- 1245 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Tesco has a hierarchical structure. Large, complex organisations often require a taller hierarchy. The adavantages of this structure is :…
- 480 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The key solution to avoid the concentration of power in the hands of a single branch of government is to ensure that each branch remains independent from each other. The separation of powers within the government is designed to counter the opposing segments ambition. Madison makes this clear when he states, “Ambition must be made to counteract ambition.”…
- 737 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The executive influences the legislatures in several ways. Firstly, the executive will contain the government party, i.e. the party with the majority in the lower house. Because the prime minister and executive (generally speaking) are leaders of the largest party in the house, it is likely that any legislation pursued by the executive in Britain will be passed. This happens due to the party system in Britain. British political parties produce a platform or manifesto which all members of the party are expected to agree with, if not then they should not be representing the party. Therefore if the leaders of the…
- 1543 Words
- 7 Pages
Better Essays -
Legislation can also be made by a person/body to whom Parliament has given the power to make laws; known as delegated legislation. There are three main forms of delegated legislation; statutory instruments, by-laws and orders in…
- 994 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In a democratic government, functions of representation can sometimes become skewed or misunderstood. I will examine the different institutions of government including the legislature, the executive, the bureaucracy, and the courts pointing to their differences in trustee vs. delegate functions of representation.…
- 1051 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
A regulation, on the other hand, is one that is approved by a group of individuals based on an act that has already been passed. These regulations are based on the act that has been approved and served as a means to make the act a lot easier to follow and adhere to. Delegated or secondary legislation allows the Government to make changes to the law using powers confered by an Act of Parliament.…
- 1566 Words
- 7 Pages
Good Essays -
The disadvantages of having so many different groups participate in the lawmaking process is also…
- 485 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
A codified constitution is a single document that sets out the laws, rules and principles on a how a state is to be governed, and the rights of the citizens; these are collected in one authoritative document. Its adversary is an uncodified constitution, where rules, laws and principles are not in one authoritative document, but are found in a variety of sources which may be written or unwritten. I will explore both the advantages and disadvantages of a codified constitution in this essay.…
- 1151 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The Legislative power is responsible for making laws. Only they can, no other branch or power can. They can’t make any law they want though. There has to be some restrictions. The laws have to benefit the public and freedoms have to be looked out for. Taxes can’t be raised on property without the consent of the people. If anybody tries to impose a law without right or discussion from the people they will be punished. People don’t have to follow the law if it wasn’t created by the Legislative power,but instead a third party. The Legislative branch has to look out and protect the people when it comes to making laws. They have to look after…
- 595 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
There are three major views on the role of a legislator within a representative government. Each plays an important role in how our government is run today but they each differ in a few ways. In a representative democracy the people get to elect who is going to represent them in congress. The following will compare and contrast the role of a delegate, trustee and politico in our government today.…
- 472 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Delegated legislation types are statutory instruments, byelaws, orders in council, court rule and professional regulations.…
- 1329 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Another advantage of delegation is efficient use of time and talent. Delegation will help a manager use her time and the time of her employees effectively, and it will allow a manager to get even more work done then they will alone. Delegation is a way of empowering employees as well, and this is a promising advantage. Giving responsibility and accountability to employees will give them an opportunity to showcase their skills and talents; it will also provide them with the…
- 2599 Words
- 11 Pages
Powerful Essays -
It is a fact of modern political life that delegated legislation is unavoidable. This is due partly to the manner of the amount of detail involved and with which certain matters must be regulated, a degree of detail well beyond what can, with convenience, be encompassed inside statutory legislation. As noted by Keane J; “ The increasing recourse to delegated legislation throughout…
- 2856 Words
- 12 Pages
Best Essays