Preview

Chinese Immigrants In Canada

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1063 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Chinese Immigrants In Canada
The Racism of Chinese Immigration in Canada
Nowadays, Chinese immigrants are all over the world, and they work across various industries to serve the country and the public. However, not many can imagine how difficult of a condition the Chinese immigrants were forced to live in in the late 19th century. The racism summarized in the television broadcast “Chinese immigration: Not welcome anymore” causes me to think deeply about humanity, especially why the Chinese immigrants were treated with inequality and abandoned after they served the country. This will be made clear through the acts of injustice, prejudice, and dehumanization revealed in the video.
In 1880, the Canadian government brought thousands of Chinese laborers to build the Canada
…show more content…
More explicitly, the Canadian government treated the Chinese workers as slaves. They did not care about the health condition, the work environment or the safety. From the television broadcast, Eve Savory says:" Something likes one in ten died due to malnutrition, exhaustion, accident and murder"(Savory, 1997). I cannot understand why the Canadian government was indifferent of those poor Chinese workers, and it makes me feel resentful. The Chinese workers worked at the west side of Canada Pacific Railway project, which is "Not only was the land in this area was mountainous and rocky, making the work difficult and dangerous, workers were often in short supply" (UBC, n.d). This frustrates me that the Chinese workers were doing the most dangerous and difficult job without necessary supplies. I cannot see any difference between the Chinese workers and slaves, poor living environments and poor health conditions, and the fact that both workers routinely endured dangerous work environments and lacked any safety equipment. The Chinese workers may not have been in captivity by the Canadian government like the slave owners were in custody of the slaves, yet for all that, the Chinese workers were enslaved by the Canadian government. Therefore, the dehumanization of the Chinese workers by the government reveals how it …show more content…
More categorically, "Even before the CPR was completed, many among the white population feared that the unemployed Chinese workers would not only take jobs away... by bringing their wives and children to settle in Canada (UBC, n.d). According to the television broadcast, Eve Savory says: "So in 1923, Canada has past an extraordinarily racist law known as the Chinese exclusion act"(Savory, 1997). I cannot agree what the Canadian government did and it makes me feel sympathetic to chose Chinese workers. Before the "Chinese exclusion act", they still have slightly chance to reunite with their families if they could save enough money to pay the head tax to the Canada government. However, the "Chinese exclusion acts" reject their hope completely. They never had any chance to bringing their wives and children to them and even may not have chance to see them again. This makes me remember there were has another group of Chinese workers suffering in same situation in New Zealand history. In comparison, the New Zealand government also have some relevant anti-Chinese laws to treat the Chinese immigrants (Te Ara, 2012). Such as poll tax, denied all the permanent residency requires from Chinese and stop Chinese to naturalisation. The similarity of those Chinese immigrants is they were rejected by the local society when the government no longer need those cheap laborers.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Canada is a country built on immigration, mainly British at first, but from all over the world afterwards. Chinese immigration to Canada dates back to the period of the gold rush when they were recruited to mine. In the 1880's, the Chinese population increased after Canada joined the confederation and extra labour was required to build a cross-country railway. Due to the poor economy in China, many Chinese were willing to migrate and work for low wages. The Canadian government seized this opportunity and allowed the companies working on the Canadian Pacific Railway (CPR) to import Chinese immigrants. With a drive for completion a significant number of Chinese were recruited. In order to control this increase in immigration, the Canadian government implemented a policy imposing a head-tax on Chinese immigrants entering Canada. The head-tax was a discriminatory piece of legislation, which was enacted by the government due to public pressure, and which led to severe discrimination of the Chinese people, thus violating present day human rights codes.…

    • 1788 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In part two, Chang investigates white supremacy and the forced allotment onto the indigenous people. The author informs the reader about the politics behind the allotment that eventually caused racial issues among the people. This part of the book emphasizes the significant connection between land and identity during this time for White…

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    , 1999. [ 2] Paul Yee, Saltwater City. A n Illustrated H istory of the Chinese in Vancouver [M ] . Vancouver : Douglas and M cIntyre, 1988. [ 3] , . : [ M] . : , 1993. [ 4] Pierre Berton, T he Last Spike[ M] .Toronto: McClelland and Stewart, 1971. [ 5] Wayson Choy. T he Jade Qeony [ M] . Vancouver: Douglas and McIntyre, 1995. [ 6] Edgar Wickberg. From China to Canada: A History o the Chinese Communities in Canada[ M] . Toronto: M cClelland and Stewart, 1982. f [ 7] Peter S. Li. The Chinese in Canada[M ] . Toronto : Oxford University Press, 1988. [ 8] Wayson Choy. Paper Shadows : A Chinatown Childhood [M ] . Toronto: Penguin, 1999. [ 9] Karen Romell. [ 11] . Op en Sky [ J] . Step Magazine1990( July / August) . : : [ J] . , 2004, ( 3) : 116- 123. [ 10] Edward W. Said. Cultur e and Imp erialism [ M ] . New York: Alfred A. Knopf, 1993. [ 12] Marty Chan. Wayson Choy[ EB/ OL] . http: / / www. 136. 159. 250. 102 / gauntlet / eg / features / stories / wordfest / choy . html. [ ] : [ A] . . [ C] .…

    • 945 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Was Ludicrous Justified

    • 695 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Firstly, the reason the actions of the authorities had been indeed justified, is due to the fear of a communist revolution much like that of Russia’s in 1917, overthrowing the Russian emperor Tsar Nicholas II and his entire family from the power. The fear of Canada becoming a communist country had irradiated from many political figures, this is because a communist nation lacks creativity, rights, and has reduced incentives to work hard. Communism is considered to do more evil than good, it gives everyone an equal opportunity regardless of the effort one puts in over another, it also lacks andy type of creativity as everyone works the same, and…

    • 695 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Immigration is a major component in Canadian history. It makes Canada the diverse, multicultural and welcoming country it is today. Although it was not always this way, throughout the 20th century Canadian immigration took many turns, some for good and others not so much. Canada stood with mostly unrestricted immigrations laws in the beginning of the 20th century besides the Chinese Head Tax that was put in place in British Columbia. It was raised to $100 in 1900 and $500 in 1903.…

    • 576 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    There were many problems faced in the building of the Canadian Pacific Railway. For one the Chinese workers wanted money. At first they only got paid $1, but soon the government changed that to $2.50. Also it was hard for the Chinese workers to adapt to their new environment so they ended up getting many diseases. Also the Chinese workers argued a lot because they had to work in very dangerous environments. There were many accidents that happened when they were constructing the railway. The last issue they faced was the time change because all the provinces had different time zones. So the workers found it hard to work on the Railway because the sun used to come out on different timings.…

    • 122 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Others voiced their concerns and fears to the provincial government over the possibility of Asian domination in British Columbia (Roy 2003: 90). With many cabinet members expressing similar points of view, the provincial government quickly thought to prohibit any further immigration of Japanese. However, because of Japan’s military ties with Britain, and because Canada was a British subject at that time, completely banning Japanese immigration to Canada based on race was not favourable as it would “embarrass Britain” and its ties with Japan (Roy 2003: 83; Roy et al. 1990:…

    • 4603 Words
    • 19 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Exclusion Act was then passed to stop Chinese Immigration and with an ability, cut them…

    • 989 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It all began with the Fraser Gold Rush in 1857 and the Cariboo Gold Rush in 1861 (Chan, 14), many foreigners came to strike it rich in Canada. The majority of the miners were of the Chinese race (Chan, 13), much to the dismay of fellow Caucasian miners. Within just two years of the Fraser Gold Rush, the town of Victoria, British Columbia, has grown in population from just 300 to 4461, with the Chinese population at about 1580 (Chan, 15). This issue pertains to rights and laws that are relevant to the everyday life of the many Caucasian individuals, as many felt that the Chinese people were taking over all the jobs and eventually, their town. Anecdotal evidence often provides a deeper look into an issue, in this case, the story of Chin Wong. Chin came to Canada in 1911 at the age of twenty to find a job (The). He returned to China at the age of 40 to get married (The). He married late because he came from a poor background and the five hundred dollar head tax was almost impossible to pay off and put him in great debt (The). He returned to Canada within a year to avoid repaying the head tax and got a job in Whitehorse, Yukon Territory (The). He worked hard and was paid poorly, but at least he was starting to earn his keep (The). In 1947, when he made enough money, he paid one thousand dollars to get his wife and son to come to Canada (The). This was one of the many tales that revealed the hardships and…

    • 1198 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Chinese Exclusion act was a significant event for Canada because it gives Canada an example of what should not happen again. This was a terrible time for the Chinese immigrants who wanted to come to Canada. However, this act was only leaning towards the Chinese and nobody else. This is discrimination towards the Chinese. Since this act, Canada should learn from its mistakes and not discriminate a certain race. This significant event is a stepping stone for Canada to become an even better country.…

    • 85 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    While accomplishing his goal of a bilingual Canada, Pierre Elliot Trudeau encountered enormous opposition. In 1969, the Official Languages Act was passed by parliament and bilingualism became law. According to Sauerwein, “The Act asserted both French and English had to be spoken at federal institutions” (Sauerwein 71). Trudeau’s commitment to bilingualism was fueled by his desire to give French Canadians an equal place in Canadian society. One of his chief arguments was that there was prejudice towards francophones in the employment of civil service workers. As observed by Gwyn, “in the mid-1960’s, francophones were 27 percent of the national population, but held only 10 percent of all civil service posts” (Gwyn 35). As part of the new act, bilingualism became a requirement for all civil service workers. Trudeau’s ideology was that these new rules would ensure equal treatment, but unfortunately, not everyone felt this way. For nine days in June 1976, all Canadian airlines grounded their planes. Air traffic controllers had gone on strike, worried that their jobs were threatened by this new policy. Unbelievably, this problem was only minor compared to the prejudicial nightmare Canada was becoming. “On the streets, people were buying T-shirts that showed a beaver (representing Canada) strangling a…

    • 1213 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    First of all, the number of Chinese and Japanese immigrants to Canada is different. Many people decided to immigrant to another country means they can live or study well in that country, because if this country is hard to live in, it will not have many people want to immigrant. On one hand, in 1858, Chinese…

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Migrant Workers In Canada

    • 464 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The government of Canada construction of migrant workers as persons who come to countries like Canada and pays them to do the “dirty work” that no Canadian citizen wants to do. Velasco (2013) points out that the Canadian government have constructed migrant workers to be cheap, docile and exportable labour and because of this constructed of migrant workers, many countries like Canada go for cheap labour. Velasco (2013) explains that the Canadian government have use their immigration policies to get cheap labour when Canada was in of economic help, however Canada closes this door when it comes to an economic crisis. Canadian government’s construction of migrant workers have allow the Canada to decline, as Velsco (2013) explains that Canada refuses…

    • 464 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    As one of the economic super power nation, the United States of America is a place where many immigrants leave their homeland to come to. Among all these immigrants group, Chinese immigrant is a huge percentage throughout history and the first group of Chinese immigrants into American dates back to between 1849 and 1882. During that period of time, Chinese citizens felt civil disorder, poverty, and suffering in their homeland under Qing dynasty in 1840s. In order to escape the absoulte monarchy, they got opportunities to coming to American for build railroad as well as the gold rush in California. Unfortunately, when this group arrived American society, they faced much difficult issues with the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882. However, Chinese improved their communities and united…

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In the early 19th century, the United States began to re-think about its stance on immigration. As the numbers of immigrants increased, questions about the leniency of the American government on immigration were raised by the “Progressive Movement”. Consequently, the United States began to employ a closed door policy of immigration. Chinese male immigrants, who had been coming in masses, inspired the implementation of the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882, which forbade further immigration of laborers of Chinese descent. This act forced prohibited Chinese males from bring over their families and destroyed possibilities of citizenship for Chinese immigrants by making them permanent aliens. Furthermore, in 1907, adding to the isolationist stance of the U.S., the city of San Francisco attempted to remove Japanese students from white schools and put them in segregated schools with Chinese students. The Japanese government was infuriated by with this comparison to the Chinese; this led to the establishment of the Gentleman’s Agreement. This was an informal agreement stating that the Japanese government would restrict further immigration of their people to the United States and, in return, Japanese children in San Francisco would be able to attend school with white children. Over the next half century, further restrictions on immigration were implemented, many based on racist assumptions that immigrants were inassimilable and could not be Americanized. However, we see examples in Nisei Daughter, where the children like Monica and her siblings became Americanized and came to detest the strict Japanese culture their parents were raised in. this contradicts the assumption that immigrants would not assimilate.…

    • 1605 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays