Top-Rated Free Essay

Assess the View That Ethnic Differences in Crime Are the Result of the Way in Which the Criminal Justice System Operates

Better Essays
Assess the view that ethnic differences in crime are the result of the way in which the criminal justice system operates In the early phase of post-war immigration, there was an assumption that members of ethnic minority groups were no more likely to be offenders or victims than the majority white population. It was also assumed that the criminal justice system treated all ethnic groups fairly. According to a major investigation into police and immigrant relations in 1972 ‘black people were more law-abiding than the general population’ and there was little evidence against Black and Asian immigrants with regards to an increase in crime rates (Layton-Henry, 1992). During the next 10 years, however, relations between the police and the black community deteriorated and evidence mounted of increasing racist attacks. The media pushed the idea that certain ethnic groups within the UK were more likely to commit crimes and end up in prison as a result of this. In 2000 a nationwide study presented the following statistics that appeared to prove that some ethnic groups were more likely to offend: The white population of the UK made up 94.5% of the total population but only made up 82% of the prison population. The black population made up 1.8% of the UK’s total population but made up 12.1% of the prison population. In contrast the Asian representation in this study showed that they made up 2.7% of the UK’s total population and had a prison population of 2.8%. 'Members of ethnic minorities are no more prone to crime than other sections of the population, but are over-represented in crime statistics.' Many members of society assume that ethnic minorities are more prone to being involved in criminal activity, than white Caucasian people. This is reflected in official statistics, and we will now question the validity of such claims. Researchers Lea and Young accept that policing policies and police racism exaggerate the black crime rate. However, they do believe that there has been an increase in the number of crimes committed by blacks and that this is the result of unemployment and discrimination. They find it hard to understand how “left idealists” such as Gilroy can argue that the disproportionate number of black males convicted of crimes in Britain is caused by police racism. They are even more critical of Gilroy’s claim that such black crime as there is, results from a continuation of “an anti-colonial struggle”. This is not plausible because most first generation immigrants appear to have been law-abiding and most of the victims of black crime, are themselves black. Becker suggests that there is really no such thing as a deviant act. It only becomes deviant when others perceive it as such. Possible effects of labelling ethnic minorities can lead to assumptions being made about certain classes or ethnic backgrounds. The underachievement of Afro-Caribbean boys in school could lead to teachers naturally assuming that any such individual in his or her class would be pre-disposed to deviance. Such a belief may affect their treatment of such children, which in turn would back up the idea of the “self-fulfilling prophecy”. If a child is labelled as deviant, they will behave to fit their label. Many theories of deviance are based on official statistics provided by the government. These statistics tend to show two main trends: some social groups appear to be more involved with crime than others, namely ethnic minorities. They appear more likely to commit crimes than white people. Sociologists such as Merton and Miller have taken these statistics at face value, and gone on to explain why these groups appear to commit a disproportionate amount of crime. Crime rates in Britain remained low until the 1950s but have increased rapidly since then. Some sociologists have affiliated this rise in crime rates with the continuing influx of immigrants into the United Kingdom.

In addition to using statistics on the ethnicity of those individuals who are involved with the criminal justice system, we can call on two other important sources of statistics than can demonstrate a more direct light on ethnicity and offending. These are victim surveys and the self-report studies. Victim surveys ask individuals to say what crimes they have been victims of, usually during the past twelve months. While victim surveys are useful in helping us to identify ethnic patterns of offending, they have several limitations. Firstly, they rely on the victims' memory of event. According to Ben Bowling and Coretta Philips, evidence suggests that white victims may 'over-identify' blacks, claiming the offender was black even when they were not sure. Self-report studies ask individuals to disclose their own dishonest and violent behaviour. Based on a sample of 2,500 people, Graham and Bowling found that blacks and whites had very similar rates of offending, while Indians, Pakistanis and Bangladeshis had much lower rates. Self-report studies indicate that there may be police bias against ethnic minority delinquents. Policemen are five times more likely to arrest or stop a person of an ethnic minority on suspicion of drug related crime, than they are to stop a white person. These claims back up the idea of “the canteen culture” whereby police officers are openly racists when off duty. Marxists argue that crime is widespread in all parts of society. Snider argues that many of the most serious deviant acts in modern society are corporate crimes. She claims that corporate crime cost much more in terms of loss of money and loss of life than crimes such as burglary and robbery. She believes that these crimes are generally assumed to be mainly committed by members of ethnic minorities. They are severely over-represented in the media. Some researchers argue that the greater likelihood for ethnic minority groups, particularly Black ethnic groups, to be criminalised (arrested and imprisoned, for example) reflects their greater involvement in crime. Other researchers argue that ethnic differences in criminalisation stem from institutional racism within the criminal justice system. Institutional racism (also called structural or systemic racism) is any form of racism occurring specifically within institutions such as public government bodies, private business corporations, and universities (public and private). The term institutional racism was coined by Stokely Carmicheal of the Black Panther Party, who, in the late 1960s, defined institutional racism as “the collective failure of an organisation to provide an appropriate and professional service to people because of their colour, culture, or ethnic origin”. In the UK, the inquiry about the murder of the black Briton Stephen Lawrence concluded that the investigating police force was institutionally racist. Sir William Macpherson of Cluny used the term as a description of "the collective failure of an organisation to provide an appropriate and professional service to people because of their colour, culture or ethnic origin", which "can be seen or detected in processes, attitudes, and behaviour, which amount to discrimination through unwitting prejudice, ignorance, thoughtlessness, and racist stereotyping, which disadvantages minority ethnic people". The Stephen Lawrence Inquiry Report by Macpherson, and the public’s response to it, was among the major factors that forced the Metropolitan Police to address its treatment of ethnic minorities. More recently, the former Metropolitan Police commissioner, Sir Ian Blair, said that the British news media is institutionally racist, a comment that offended journalists, provoking angry responses from the media, despite the police association welcoming Sir Ian’s assessment. The Macpherson Inquiry analysed and assessed claims of racism against the Metropolitan Police. Its report suggested major changes in the ways the Metropolitan Police handles members of an ethnic minority. In May, 2010, London’s Metropolitan Police Service faced a racism case as a senior black officer claimed he was side-lined. A top black officer sued the Metropolitan Police for race discrimination amid claims that senior police covered up a damaging report alleging racism in the ranks. In conclusion, I believe that ethnic differences in are crime are one result of the way the criminal justice system operates, however there are other reasons for these ethnic differences.

(P.S. I’m sorry I haven’t used Item A but the AQA website isn’t working for some reason and I had to get the question off of Jason)

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    An Ethnic minority background increases your chances of arrest and conviction, some people argue that police racism in itself results in higher suspicion against black people in general. According to official statistics there are significant ethnic differences in the likelihood of being involved in the criminal justice system. Black and Asians are overrepresented in the system. For example black people make up 2.8% of the population, but 11% of the prison population. Contrastingly whites are underrepresented…

    • 3004 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Assess sociological explanations of ethnic differences both in offending and in victimisation Intro: I will explore and evaluate the explanations that sociologists offer for the ethnic differences in offending and victimisation Define key words (crime, official stats, ethnicity) · What are you going to be exploring, re –write aim? · What theories will you need to do this? · Who supports the statement? And why? E.g. · Who critiques the statement? And why? E…

    • 276 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Assess the view that ethnic differences in educational achievement are primarily the result of external factors. It has been found that someone’s ethnicity can have an effect on their educational achievement, as in 2006 73% of pupils of Indian origin gained 5 A*– C passes at GCSE compared with 56% of white and 47% of black pupils. It has been found that African students tend to underachieving in the educational system compared to others, with them being below average reading ability and tend to…

    • 532 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Crime and Criminal Justice

    • 3565 Words
    • 15 Pages

    [pic] CJA/204 – March, 2011 (update) College of Criminal Justice and Security Introduction to Criminal Justice CJA/204 Version 2 Course Syllabus Program Council The Academic Program Councils for each college oversee the design and development of all University of Phoenix curricula. Council members include full-time and practitioner faculty members who have extensive experience…

    • 3565 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Criminal Justice Systems The world is what it is today because of the criminal justice systems that are created around the world to enforce the law for the greater cause of accountability and responsibility in the whole world as a community. Criminal Justice system is the term used to explain and understand all of the agencies whose goal is to control crime. It consists of police, courts, and corrections agencies, which act to enforce the law, adjudicate suspects, and deal with convicted offenders…

    • 1375 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The stages in how the criminal justice system response to a crime, is through the police, the court system and the form of correction fitted for the crime or crimes. Yale Law Journal states, "Police officers patrol the streets, investigate cases, and makes arrests. Prosecutors handle the adjudication — dismissing charges, negotiating pleas, and taking cases to trial" (cited by Abel,2017, p. 1732). There has to be a crime that has occurred, whether seen by a witness who reports to the police or the…

    • 341 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Criminal Justice System

    • 2002 Words
    • 9 Pages

    The Relationship between the Media and the Criminal Justice System The modern mass media, an all-encompassing body to which contemporary western society stringently relies upon as a source of information, is the major outlet to which the masses are able to readily and easily access news and current events, regardless of the location or the time in which it occurs throughout the world (Mutz, 1989). Whilst strictly, the media may only suggest an opinion for an individual to uptake, constant reiteration…

    • 2002 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    The criminal justice system in England and Wales is formulated on the basis of some basic aims and targets. The main target of this system is to reduce the prevalence of crime and ensure the speedy trial of the culprits. The main steps involved in the criminal justice system include the policing, court trial and corrections (Davies, Croall and Tyrer 2005). The initial investigation and collection of evidence is carried out by police. After that, the suspect is presented in the court for trial and…

    • 1111 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    “Criminal investigations, in the standard case, are oriented towards cracking unsolved crime, identifying perpetrators, launching prosecutions, proving guilt at trial and bringing offenders to justice” (Paul Roberts in Tim Newburn et al, 2007: 95). How are criminal detection and/or investigation moulded and shaped by political, social and/or cultural forces? Criminal detection and proceedings never exist or function independently, the system, as a whole is an inherently complex network of interacting…

    • 1652 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Criminal Justice System

    • 2147 Words
    • 9 Pages

    What are the essential functions of the Criminal justice system? 2000 Words Throughout this assignment I shall outline the structure of the criminal justice system, which is built up, of several different institutions all of which are preventing the growth of social immorality in society and to stop miscarriages of justice. There are a number of essential functions, which the criminal justice system has to perform in order to maintain its position in society so that individuals are safe and are…

    • 2147 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays