top-rated free essay

Animal Testing Oral

By nfisher55 Feb 26, 2013 827 Words
Most of us can easily say that animal testing is evil, barbaric and should be banned, but when in reality, when faced with an actual choice, how many of us would honestly choose to potentially endanger a human’s life over an animal’s life? Animal testing should not be banned for several reasons. Firstly as human beings, it is in our nature to value human lives above animal lives. Whether it is wrong or right all species feel an inexplicable loyalty to their own species, making human life of greater value than animal life. Secondly animal suffering is minimised during animal testing Thirdly, animal testing concerns animals that have been specifically bred for this purpose.

Those who argue this claim human life is of greater value than animal life. In justifying this claim it is usually argued that human beings are the most intelligent, creative and adaptable creatures on the planet and that they have a level of consciousness and self-awareness that exceeds that of any other animal. Relatedly, it is claimed that human consciousness and self-awareness means that human beings have a greater capacity to suffer than any other species. This argument is used to justify the use of animals other than human beings in animal testing. This argument has been put Dario Ringach, who, on September 12, 2012, on the Internet site Speaking of Research, argued, 'A human mother that is contemplating death due to cancer, will suffer beyond her physical pain when thinking that her children will grow up without a her, that she will never see them marry or have children of their own, that she will leave her spouse alone to take care of the family. It is her cognitive abilities that allow her to suffer in ways other animals cannot. Thus, if we agree that suffering is morally relevant, the type of suffering this mother experiences must count too. And because such suffering is enabled to beings with the cognitive abilities that allow them to pose such questions, one must conclude that human cognitive abilities are morally relevant too. Animal suffering is minimised in animal testing

It has been claimed that there are protocols in place which ensure that animals used in testing are treated in a way that minimises their distress. The Internet site notes, 'The people who work in laboratories - scientists, vets, animal carers - are human beings like everyone else and have no desire to mistreat animals. For many of them it is their primary responsibility to look after the animals, and they work with laboratory animals because they are animal lovers. Many are also actively involved in developing scientific methods to reduce the need for animals or replace them entirely.' It goes on to claim, 'Good science and good animal welfare go hand in hand. If an animal is suffering stress or pain it could affect the results of the research. So it makes good scientific sense to house animals in the best possible conditions and make sure they get the best possible care from skilled and experienced carers. What animals need is not always the same as what people think they need, so scientists are studying which environments different animals prefer.' In a letter published in The Age on December 9, 2012, Johannes Manning claimed, 'I am a retired vet and am one of those who benefit from having ''electric shocks to my head'' while undergoing treatment for Parkinson's disease (a treatment developed in monkeys). From the footage I saw, the monkeys [used in tests] looked healthy, had plenty of space, were in the company of other monkeys and showed normal behaviours.'

Many of the animals killed in animal testing have been specifically bred for this purpose it is noted that many of the animals used in testing have been bred for this purpose. Those who argue in favour of animal testing further note that these creatures would not have been alive at all were they not needed for animal testing. It is also noted that they are bred and reared under humane conditions. The Australian Association for Laboratory Animal Science also states, 'While some research requires that dogs and cats are used, the vast majority of laboratory animals are rodents specifically bred for research. Nearly half of the dogs and cats needed for research are also bred for that purpose. Since state laws and local policies prevent many animal pounds and shelters from providing dogs and cats to research facilities, animal dealers are the primary source for the other half of the animals scientists require. Many are against animal testing mainly for the cruelty towards the animals, but in fact the animals that are tested on are minimized on harm and when faced with the facts, many more animals are slaughtered to create food. When barely anyone is against the slaughtering for food, even though they live in terrible shelters and aren’t treated with care, why are people against animal testing? Thank you for listening

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • animal rights

    ...1.0 INTRODUCTON Animal Rights Movement is a serial movement which seeks an end to the rigid moral and legal distinction drawn between human and non-human animals, an end to status of animals as property, and an end to their use in the research, food, clothing, and entertainment industries. Animal Rights movement is sometimes called the animal...

    Read More
  • The Basic Principle of the Animal Rights Movement

    ...The basic principle of the Animal Rights movement is that nonhuman animals deserve to live according to their own natures, free from harm, abuse, and exploitation. Advocates of animal rights try to extend the human circle beyond our species to include other animals, which are also capable of feeling pain, fear, hunger, thirst, loneliness, and k...

    Read More
  • Animal Testing

    ...million animals are killed in U.S. laboratories. Animal testing is something that happens all over the world and are used in the “name of science” by private institutions, cosmetic companies, government agencies, and scientific centers. Animals feel just as much pain as humans do. The only difference is that they do not have a voice. Million...

    Read More
  • Animal Testing

    ...101-05 14 Nov. 2011 Animal Research: Is it right or wrong? The discussion of whether or not animal dissection and research is necessary as teaching tools and is morally correct has been dominated by two different views. On the one hand, some may argue that this violates animal rights, and how there are better ways of going about research an...

    Read More
  • Animal Testing Should Be Banned

    ...Animal Testing Should be Banned Name College Experiments on animals has been done all around the world since many years ago throughout the history. There are reasons behind these experiments; such as gaining knowledge about the animals themselves, education, research and developments for the benefit of human being. In the last reason fall ...

    Read More
  • Animal Testing Outline

    ...Animal Testing. General Purpose: To persuade. Specific Purpose: To persuade my audience that animal experimentation for the human profit is unethical and other alternatives should be found. Central Idea: Alternatives solutions are the best way to prevent animal testing cruelty and lawsuits. Introduction: I. I have a riddle for the class: Wh...

    Read More
  • Animal Testing Is Wrong 1

    ...Animal Testing is Wrong Millions of animals are used every year for a wide variety of scientific and medical purposes. Some of this scientific research is to learn about and improve the welfare of animals, but most of the animal experiments are unfortunately conducted for human benefits. An estimated eight million animals are used in painful ex...

    Read More
  • Ethics of Animal Testing for Medical Purposes

    ...Animal Testing for Medical Purposes, is it Ethically Correct? This paper will discuss animal testing for medical purposes. It will begin by defining the process of animal testing and go through some of its history. It will discuss whether the testing of animals for medical purposes is just or unjust and evaluate which types of testing are ethi...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.