Preview

Analysis of Brower vs. Dominy argument in Encounters with the Archdruid

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1472 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Analysis of Brower vs. Dominy argument in Encounters with the Archdruid
In the third section of John McPhee's Encounters with the Archdruid, the author observes the discourse between conservationist David Brower and Commissioner of the Bureau of Reclamation, Floyd Dominy, on the merits of dams in the southwestern United States. Brower "hates all dams, large and small," while Dominy sees dams as essential to our civilization. The Glen Canyon Dam and Lake Powell, which Dominy created, are the main issue of debate between the two men.

Floyd Dominy graduated from the University of Wyoming in 1932 and, after an unsuccessful stint as a teacher, became a county agricultural agent for the federal government in Wyoming's Gillette County. This was the time of the Great Depression and also a great drought in the American Midwest, which quickly garnered the name of the "dust bowl." Frustrated by the lack of water available to farmers in his county, Dominy orchestrated the building of many dams in Gillette County, providing water to thirsty farmers and their livestock. Rewarded with a job in the Bureau of Reclamation for his efforts, Dominy became the Bureau's director in 1959 and oversaw the construction of Glen Canyon Dam on the Colorado River.

Completed in 1962, the 710 foot tall dam built out of 4.9 million cubic yards of concrete has a reservoir (Lake Powell) that has a maximum capacity of 27 million acre-feet and is the one of the largest reservoirs in the world. Lake Powell has become a popular water recreation site and provides homes with about 1 million kilowatts of hydroelectric power and 8.23 million acre-feet of water and irrigation per year. Dominy views the dam as a great asset, both to provide utilities and to provide recreation - "Now people can fish, swim, water-ski, sun-bathe. Can't you imagine going there with your family for a weekend, getting away from everybody? But Mr. Brower says we destroyed it." (174)

David Brower was born in 1912 in Berkeley Hills, California. When he was young his father used to take him to the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    The infamous Dust Bowl of the 1930s was one of the most horrific and devastating environmental crises to hit twentieth century North America. The Dust Bowl was a period of unyielding dust storms which inevitably caused major agricultural, ecological and irreversible damage to the American and Canadian prairie lands. The Dust Bowl lasted from 1930 to 1936, in some areas the drought lasted until 1940. The Dust Bowl of the 1930s was mostly a man-made disaster. Some critical factors that played a role in the cause of the dust bowl are: decades of extensive farming without crop rotation, agricultural advances, the great depression, and deep plowing which destroyed the grasses which ultimately damaged the soil and dried it up. The Federal Government had an extensive role during the Dust Bowl which ultimately aided in creating the dust bowl, exacerbating and lastly aiding victims of this crisis. The Federal government did not see the underlying and future problems of deep plowing the Great Plains which consisted of 100 million acres on the other hand the Government did a excellent job in addressing the crisis and aiding the hundreds of thousands Americans who were vastly affected by this environmental crisis.…

    • 1106 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The relationship between the Amerindians and the United States have been one of turmoil, war, and neglect. Treaties have been broken, lives have been lost, and genocidal acts have occurred. Presidents have forcefully removed Amerindians from place to place until they were forced onto reservations. Culture has been destroyed and religious artifacts decimated to create metropolises. But is the Dakota Access Pipeline another hit to the Amerindians? The purpose of this essay is to explain how the Dakota Access Pipeline is not only a finical benefit to the United States but the environmentally savvy one.…

    • 689 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many people would most likely feel conflicted if a very large pipeline was being built through their back yard. Some would even take action. In the article, “Native Americans Celebrate pause of North Dakota Pipeline, Vow to Fight on,” the author, Dave Thompson, claims the Native Standing Rock Sioux Tribe feels the same way about their sacred land. However, through growing efforts the Native people of the local region of the pipeline’s construction to discontinue this pipeline they are making progress in halting the continuation of the pipeline. The author provides the readers with mostly fact used to inform the audience of the article…

    • 591 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One recent autumn evening while I stood in line to comment at a public hearing about a proposed natural gas pipeline through Virginia, I befriended an inspirational environmental advocate by the name of Bear Redstar. Bear grew up in a Lakota family as a part of the Dakotas’ seven Sioux tribes. Bear’s initial exposure to the destructive potential of a pipeline occurred while he worked as a welder for ExxonMobil on the Trans-Alaska Pipeline, where he witnessed the steel pipe rupture and release crude oil into the environment. Upon his return home, he advocated alongside Native American community members against the Dakota Access Pipeline. A few months ago Mr. Redstar, moved to Roanoke, Virginia, again facing the trouble of a pipeline. He and I were at the public hearing to warn the Appalachian community of the risks associated with a pipeline.…

    • 199 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The progress that supports this include salmon successfully living in the San Joaquin river counters McEwen’s belief that salmons will be unable to survive in the revitalized river. The idea that the plan is a boondoggle has also been rejected since it clearly benefited many people. Furthermore, recent results of the restoration program display how the farmers were not greedy because they gave up their water and farmland for the recovery of the San Joaquin river. These few points depict the inaccuracy of McEwen’s expectations of the project and show how the San Joaquin is developing so…

    • 849 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Saving the Native Americans land, Bill Mckibben writes “ Why Dakota is the New Keystone” that incorporates a great deal of culture, pride, and courage. Mckibben goes in depth about Native Americans defending their land against an oil company that could cause them harm to their basic necessities. He also uses strong points of word choice, pathos and tone to paint a detailed picture of what is happening. With using these techniques he is able to so strongly deliver his message easily.…

    • 608 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    ' ' 'David James (Dave) Pelzer ' ' ' (born December 29, 1960 in [[San Francisco]], California)"California Birth Index", www.ancestry.com : "David J Pelzer , December 29, 1960,…

    • 1582 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    In the novel Encounters with the Archdruid, author John McPhee sets out to portray environmental conservationist David Brower in three different environments with a different adversary in each. In preparation for writing this novel, McPhee shadowed Brower over the course of a year. McPhee also strategically paired Brower with people whose opinions differed greatly from Brower’s in order to extract Brower’s argument and to recognize the changes in his argument. David Brower, head of the Sierra Club, was responsible for halting copious legislation that would have been harmful for the environment. He is widely regarded as the “most unrelenting fighter for conservation in the world” (McPhee 87). McPhee uses this notion to his advantage, by building…

    • 1194 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Yuma's Water Issues

    • 1833 Words
    • 8 Pages

    However, there were people who were also abusing the water usage wasting the water for no good. Also, the people who worked in agriculture got payed very little and a lot of people were getting employment. They would have to sometimes work overtime because of the dams overflowing and having to repair them. The Bureau of Reclamation built a levee on the California side on the dam that was topped by a rail-line. Beforehand, they had also gained the cooperation of the Southern Pacific railroad who agreed to deliver cement directly at the dam site. There was a lot of flooding in Yuma and also the flooding caused a lot of damages in the the town. The floods would cause to drop the nutrients on the palin before it recedes and the developers would have a lot of problems to regrow them because then it would cost more money and they would have to get other things too, to create the dams and canals. The flood would wipe out Yuma and leave it a big mess. The floods were messing up the Yuma project. The earthquake messed up Yuma. The crops used to be bad and the plants did not get a lot of water or not the same amount of water and that was making the fruits and vegetables get bad for just dry out. They had just finished the Imperial dam and that made things with water much better than it was before, that was part of the Yuma project. The Laguna dam was the first dam on the Colorado River. The idea of that was to raise the water higher so the gravity can take over with it so it would not overflow. We used 2.27 of direct effect 0.18 of indirect effect and 0.36 induced effect of water in 2014 and that was all on mostly cropping and agriculture. Yuma had a total of 20,744 people with employment in agriculture and that was affecting the economy. The Colorado River irrigated in the Yuma…

    • 1833 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The finished dam contains enough concrete, 4.5 million cubic yards, to build a two-lane highway from Seattle, Washington to Miami, Florida. More than 8.5 million pounds of dynamite was used to blast the foundation for the dam and 8 miles of tunnels through the canyon walls. Why did they build the Hoover Dam?The main reason for building the Hoover Dam was to supply the electrical power necessary to transport 4.4 million acre-feet—over a quarter of the Colorado River's average annual flow to California. Soon, the dam also would supply water to Las Vegas, whose revenue would be used to finance…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first two chapters provide insight into the importance of aquifers and how groundwater use/reliance in the US has skyrocketed. He then goes on to expose specific cases of key rivers and aquifers being badly misused all around the United States. After depicting each case study in detail Glennon goes on to suggest problems that have gotten us into this mess. Such as: sprawling population growth, a wasteful attitude regarding water, Tragedy of the Commons (unlimited access to CPR) and legality that encourages exploitation. With his point soundly made Glennon wraps up with a call to action to both concerned citizens and…

    • 592 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    May I invite you to a time travel into the future? Join me in visiting the Glen Canyon in the year 2030. After some major technological breakthroughs, the United States cover all of their electricity needs with renewable energies, such as solar and wind energy. The Glen Canyon dam was torn down five years ago, and Lake Powell is drained. Just as you predicted in your essay 'The Damnation of a Canyon,' nature is gradually cleansing 'the re­pellent mess’ that emerged from the water, and is reclaiming the land. Plants, animals, and fish return. Everything is healing. Why is not everybody happy? Why are people loudly protesting to get the Glen Canyon Dam back?…

    • 516 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The once untamed Colorado River was set to be cultivated in 1931 by the Bureau of Reclamation. It was to be tamed by the Hoover Dam, the biggest man made thing in the whole world. The place of this great achievement was in between two hulking masses of sedimentary rock at Black Canyon, Nevada. The dam intentionally had its purposes, for example its production would supply jobs in the time of the Great Depression. As well as, curb the rapid floods that frequently deluded Southern California(?). Then in return the Dam would reply with a clean source of electricity to neighboring states as well as distribute water. Though, some unanticipated effects the Dam caused are still marked vaguely into the canyon years later. Despite that, the Hoover…

    • 1083 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to John Wesley Powell, 20 inches of rain annually was necessary to grow crops in regions like the Southern Great Plains, and that was the minimal. The average rainfall between the five states the Dust Bowl hit the hardest, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Texas, Colorado, and Kansas, was 17 inches of rain. From 1931 to 1940 in Dalhart, Texas, only one year reached Powell’s minimum rainfall average. This absence of rain distressed farmers. Some left in hope for a better paying job and better life, one with clean lungs. Most stayed however and fought out the storm. They would sleep with washcloths over their noses and try to lie still, careful not to stir up the dust on their sheets. Cattle would run in circles until they fall and breathe in so much dust that they die. This decade was one of great…

    • 661 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Johnstown Flood

    • 1335 Words
    • 6 Pages

    You may be wondering how the dam burst in the first place. Well according to McCullough there were many factors. The dam itself had many internal flaws, like the fact that it sagged a bit in the very middle of the dam where it needed to be the strongest, it would not have been noticeable to the regular eye though. The dam was part of the South Fork Hunting and Fishing Club, which was a prestigious summer, mountain club. It had members such as Andrew Carnegie and Henry Clay Frick. The dam created a lake for the members of the club to go boating (which was very rare, especially in the mountains), but when the dam was being rebuilt for this club many things were overlooked. For example the fact that there was no way of controlling the amount of water it held, this meant that once they raised the level of the water there was no way to go back. There were also many small leaks that were overlooked, passed off as, “springs that came from near the ends of…

    • 1335 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays