This is a topic that effects me directly and is a source of nearly endless frustration. As an employed white male, I do not qualify for financial aid. I am not “ethnic” enough nor am I poor enough. I am currently going thousands of dollars into debt while certain minorities are fixing up their Hondas with tax dollars I have contributed. I feel it is unfair for me to meet society's standards, achieve higher-than-average grades, and go in debt while many illegal aliens get a free ride to college.
While I do understand the reasoning behind such practice, I can not agree. Sure, some illegals are paying income tax. Mostly all pay sales tax. They are contributing. Still, there is a reason they are called “illegal” aliens. I do not understand being able to partake in the benefits of being a United States citizen when they are not in fact a US citizen.
I believe they should achieve citizenship, then apply for financial aid and leave money for those of us who seek higher education AND follow the law. Depending on local, state, and/or federal guidelines, some felons are not allowed to apply for financial aid. How is this any different than being in the United States illegally?
I'd like to conclude by saying that there are always exceptions to rules and extenuating circumstances. Still, this issue is rather cut and dry. The word “illegal” means illegal. It is against the law. If someone is breaking the law, they shouldn't qualify for financial aid, much less take the place of someone who qualifies legitimately.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
There is a conflict between Federal and State law regarding the eligibility of undocumented students for in-state tuition rates. Section 505 of the Illegal Immigration Reform and Immigrant Responsibility Act of 1996 prohibits illegal aliens from receiving in-state tuition rates at public institutions of higher education. State and federal grants are awarded only to U.S. citizens or eligible non-citizens. To apply for a federal or state grant, one must complete the Free Application for Federal Student Aid (FAFSA), which requires the student’s social security number. Federal student loans are also not available to undocumented students. Most high school seniors rely on federal money as most of their financial aid for college. Students see their peers receiving federal financial aid and do…
- 1347 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
In 2017 we still do not have any clear answers to these concerns. There are several states that have enacted their own version of the DREAM Act however; it is not supported nationally at this time. The ten states currently providing undocumented students with the opportunity to receive in-state tuition for college provided they attended and graduated from the state’s primary and secondary schools pay the same college tuition as the other state residents. They are California, Illinois, Kansas, Nebraska, New Mexico, New York, Texas, Utah, Washington and…
- 1091 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Denying DACA students the opportunity to attend college while also excluding them from states scholarship funds creates an unfair barrier to a higher education and better future. In defense of these bills the state of Missouri claims that the money they will save by denying these benefits to DACA students will reduce immigration to the state, and allow other citizens to benefit from state aid. Though these benefits to the state do not, and can not outweigh the costs to DACA students that are denied access to a higher education. With the help of private donors, the University of Missouri Kansas City was able to secure funds to cover the difference between instate and out-of-state tuition to Juan Sanchez and twenty other admitted DACA students. However, this funding only covered one semester, DACA students are forced to find another solution to pay this amount of money or quit school. The article concludes with Peleger stating “DACA beneficiary students in Missouri are confronted with a new reality: Give me your tired, your poor, your huddled masses yearning to breathe free – but first, show me your legal…
- 1477 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
After the failed effort of the DREAM Act, the undocumented youth began organizing themselves and formed a grassroots movement (Arco, 2014). “The pressure from the grassroots movement and the persistent legislative failure to act caused President Barak Obama to pass the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) policy in 2012” (Arco, 2014). DACA is a deferred action policy that provides legal accommodations for some youth and young adults who were brought as children to the United States (Richard, 2013). DACA is designed to provide two year permits that will assist those who qualify for this deferred action from…
- 3053 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays -
There is always that one student that has a strong work ethic and when things get exacerbated they keep working and just do not quit. These students are students who are eager to learn who want succeed, but when it comes to the end of their high school career, what happens? There are approximately 65,000 young adults that are undocumented and graduate each year from high school ( “The DREAM Act Immigration Access to Higher Education.”). These students want to achieve something prominent for themselves they have the grades and the qualifications so that they can attend college. The main obstacle standing in their way is citizenship or residency. This complication prohibits them from being able to apply for government financial aid. Tuition is not only higher but triples to being in state, so that they can feel assuaged. There are many speculations of why people migrate to this country, whether it is illegal or not. One of the main reasons that they migrate is so they have a better life and so do their children such as being able to have a better education. Although there are many undocumented people in this country, immigration is one of the main reasons that our country’s economy is functioning. The DREAM Act not only helps students to go to college and be successful, but it also helps sustain the economy of the United States, but will take several years for the process of the DREAM Act to become a reality.…
- 1477 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Born and raised here in the U.S. many students, and parents for that matter, are currently struggling with the bills, loans, and the stress of trying to stabilize a healthy future for themselves by pursuing an education. When a law like the California Dream Act is passed, it makes those who have done nothing but follow the rules of our legal system, feel as if the right as a legal citizen is being pushed aside. The money to fund the education of these illegal immigrants has to come from somewhere, causing a bigger whole to burn in tax payer’s pocket; when the money can easily go elsewhere to legal students in dire need of it. The state of California has always portrayed itself as the “free” state and allowed equal opportunity to everyone, to the point where now legal citizenship does not seem as if it really matters anymore. The California Dream Act may seem as if it is the answer to our educational system but when better dissected we see that with limited funding, we are defying the rights of legal citizens by providing for the education of the undocumented immigrants and bearing the expense of increased taxes and tuition.…
- 1675 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Felons are citizens just like use, they make mistakes, but they are trying to get rehabilitated back into the world. Right or wrong, a felon is felon and ‘’an estimate 5.3 million felony conviction barred from voting, while in Vermont and Maine allow felons to vote while in prison’’. Felons when they get out they should be free as use, they did the crime and they paid the time.…
- 856 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
They should have the same privileges to education, to work, and to stay in the country. DACA is a program that protects undocumented immigrants brought into the U.S. as children. It helps them have privileges they would not have had without this program. These children have a chance for a better education and more possibilities. DACA gives them the chance to enroll in college and legally secure jobs (US…
- 576 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Going to college is a great step in life for a lot of us, but things now-a-days keep getting more expensive and many families don’t have the finances to afford it. We come to the one and probably the only option that is financial aid. Financial aid helps more than two thirds of the students, and some of them don’t use it the way they’re supposed to; some abuse the financial aid system and lie on the application so they can get money. Thanks to financial aid students have the opportunity to study in college and be able to earn a degree, but there are students that take advantage of it. I believe that financial aid system should be reconstructed as well as more security procedures should be added to the applications.…
- 490 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
One of the most significant challenges I face as an undocumented first generation college applicant is financial need. I am the first child of my family to be enrolling into a college this fall. Financially speaking my family is considered to be middle or lower-middle class. Although we make ends meet the strain of college tuition is an impending force that will soon become a large issue for my household. Likewise, the fact that I'm undocumented excludes me from many scholarships making paying for college all that more daunting. College tuition is not something that my parents have had to think about before. Yet, with the end of my high school career approaching and the start of my college career beginning it is apparent that my family will…
- 610 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
"Supporting undocumented students in their pursuit of college, career and citizenship." Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA). Curran & Berger Law Frim. 16 Dec 2012. Reading…
- 2002 Words
- 9 Pages
Better Essays -
Illegal immigrants do not have to problem receiving the benefits given to them by taxes, but they have a problem paying their own taxes. Taxpayers pay a total of 12 billion dollars for school education for students of illegal immigrants. Illegal immigration has given the United States a bunch of people who will not only take money from Americans, but also their jobs. From 2008 to 2010, it was estimated that 7.7 illegal and legal immigrants were employed, and in the time period many Americans were also losing their jobs. It is said that illegal immigration helps the economy, however, illegal immigrants receive around $25,000 in government support. For illegal immigrants who do pay taxes, they still only pay around $10,000. This leaves a $15,000 deficit, which is not very good for our economy. I am pretty sure if the government made all illegal immigrants reimburse for the benefits given to them, many of these illegal aliens would not want to come live in the United…
- 991 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The undocumented immigrants improve the economy in many ways. Families don’t deserve to be torn apart. This is a country of immigrants. The government should change their minds and let undocumented immigrants become equal…
- 413 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
As I was a teenager I had friends who were siblings, but they were undocumented. They came to United States with their parents when they were around five and six year-old to visit their relatives. They overstayed in US and find a job to support their daily needs. Now, their parents are working as caregivers in a private nursing home. Their family now has a stable and better life and the siblings are now both in college, one is in a community college and the older one is finishing her studies in Arizona State University because she got a full scholarship. Now, my question is answered; the government or any other organization, association, or even private individual are giving undocumented people benefits. In this case they have given employment that could be offered to an American and scholarship that could be given to an American student. They even have this “TIN number,” I wasn’t sure what “TIN number” is, but I was told that this number was given to them as a visitor and can be used to open a bank account. I am not envious of…
- 3007 Words
- 13 Pages
Powerful Essays -
In 2008, a BYU professor decided to talk about welfare to a class of his students. He first asked the students if they agreed on welfare. Many agreed on it, so the professor decided to try an experiment. This experiment would change many of the students' perspective on welfare. He first said that a quiz would be given the following week. When the day came, he handed out the test, and said that the test would be graded a little differently. The students, who studied, did well on it, and the students who didn't study did poorly. However, the professor figured out the class average, and gave all the students the average. The class average was a B minus. The students who did poorly on the test were very happy; however the students who did well on the test were very angry. The professor told the students that this was an example of welfare. He asked if this was fair. Was it or not? It was not fair. That professor was trying to teach the students something about the welfare system. Illegal immigrants are usually like homeless people, and don’t like to work. They usually just get on the welfare system, and literally make us work and support them.…
- 591 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays