Preview

Yann Martel's Life Of Pi: Book Vs Movie

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
767 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Yann Martel's Life Of Pi: Book Vs Movie
Life of Pi Book vs. Movie Persuasive Essay Based on the award-winning novel of the same name by Yann Martel, Life of Pi follows the remarkable story of a young man named Piscine “Pi” Molitor Patel who finds himself lost at sea after his family’s cargo ship sinks in a storm. But Pi is not alone on this journey and he must survive in a congested life boat with four animals from his family’s zoo, a hyena, an orangutan, a zebra, and worst of all, an adult Bengal tiger named Richard Parker. In breathtaking 3D and containing spectacular visuals, director Ang Lee brings the story to life on the big screen. Although Lee does his best to stay true to the story, there are clear differences between the film and the novel. These differences consists of character …show more content…
The differences that are poorly portrayed in the movie comes to show that the book is worth reading rather than watching the movie. There are many instances when the movie misrepresents Pi’s character. This is clearly displayed through the moment when he is feeding the tiger. In the book, Pi’s father, spontaneous, brings Pi and his brother, Ravi, to the tiger cage to “teach them a lesson” about anthropomorphizing the zoo animals. He has starved Mahisha, a 550 lb. Bengal tiger, for three days, before, in front of the children, he has a keeper drop a goat into the cage. The tiger chases the goat around and, of course, rips it apart. Pi’s father then walks his sons around the zoo and explains how each of the animals could kill them if they’re not careful. In the movie Pi’s brother pests him out for trying to feed Richard Parker, the new tiger, a hunk of raw meat out of his bare hand. His father makes him watch Richard Parker pull a goat through the bars and eat it. Pi’s father then scolds Pi about looking into animals’ eyes and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Why is it that when a book gets it’s own movie that there are several differences between the book and the movie? Some people argue that the book is always better than the movie. There is a reason for this. Firstly, in most book to movie adaptations small details are changed or are just not included. Secondly, the movie often takes short cuts and doesn’t touch on certain aspects that were described in the book. Lastly, when reading a book you are free to make your own subtext and fill in the blanks with your imagination. The movie adaptations of books have always lacked the detail that's in the book, some things are completely cut from the movie to maintain a well paced story, and it fills in the gaps for us making the experience less unique.…

    • 573 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Ever read a book, and then seen the movie? The book is usually better right? That’s most likely because of the differences. The book is more descriptive most of the time. Events in the book are missing from the movie. Or the movie adds some in.…

    • 219 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In How to Read Literature like a Professor, Foster also talks about allegories. The relationship between the tiger and Pi can be considered an allegory. A lot of the time spent on the boat is the classic fight of good vs. evil. Pi, seen as a naive child who could do no wrong, takes the role of the good character. Richard Parker represents the savage “dark side” and takes the role of evil. As the story progresses you see that each could not survive without the other. Richard Parker showed Pi that he could not have survived by being the sweet faultless boy who could not kill and eat a fish. Pi showed Richard Parker that he is inferior to Pi by training him and getting him food. The battle between the two at the beginning digressed to a mutual realization that good cannot always conquer evil and evil…

    • 1658 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One thing in particular that the book does much better is making use of complex metaphors and themes, such as: the river for life, and oneness with nature, that string themselves together as you turn each page of the book, while in the movie the metaphors and symbolism are represented in a much different way through picture. In the book, both themes regarding the river are very vivid and clear, as they use strong imagery of nature to draw pictures in the minds of the readers. In the movie both themes are represented and referred to much less because of the lack of narration.…

    • 1118 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Life Of Pi Analysis

    • 899 Words
    • 4 Pages

    He planted a goat into the tiger exhibit and it very quickly reached down, snatched it up, and ate it. His dad said after, which you can find on page forty two of the story, “Tigers are VERY dangerous, I want you to understand that you are never, under any circumstances, to touch a tiger, to pet a tiger, to put your hands through the bar of the cages, or even get close to a cage.” Without that example, Pi and his brother may not have been able to learn that lesson. Our next example from his childhood is that Pi was always a very open-minded child, and he was always very optimistic and excited (Sparknotes.com). This could have affected how Pi stayed alive and his will to live. Without that kind of optimism, his life could have ended long before he would have ever seen shore. Before Pi was stranded on the lifeboat he had been…

    • 899 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Fish Bowl Responses

    • 1526 Words
    • 7 Pages

    4. Besides his family and possessions, Pi lost, but also gained many things from his time stranded at sea. After being at sea for so long and experiencing the thigs he did, Pi lost his mental stability. In the beginning of the book, Pi has his head on straight and is focusing on surviving and staying alive. However, as time goes on, Pi begins to lose hope and become more and more insane. When Pi encounters a Frenchman and talks to him, he believes he is talking to Richard Parker and has completely lost his mind. This is shown when he says “I laughed. I knew it. I wasn’t hearing voices. I hadn’t gone mad. It was Richard Parker who was speaking to me! The carnivorous rascal” (Martel 246). Pi really has…

    • 1526 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Everything he has learned as a zookeeper's son could not prepare him for his this. It may seem like becoming dominant over a 450 pound. male tiger would be his greatest task but it isn't. In order to do this he must defeat his own fear if he wants to survive. Pi asks the Gods for the courage to save his own life and the life of Richard Parker. Pi is surprisingly compassionate towards Richard Parker: He feeds the tiger on a regular basis and talks to him. As he tames the tiger he builds a close relationship with Richard Parker and believes he will not survive without his company. Pi is overwhelmed by the relationship they have developed and feels he owes this to the faith he had in himself and in the power of religious…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Yann Martel's Life Of Pi

    • 686 Words
    • 3 Pages

    At least twice in Life of Pi, Pi Patel faces difficult circumstances and is able to emerge unscathed by dint of a type of storytelling.…

    • 686 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Yann Martel's Life Of Pi

    • 807 Words
    • 4 Pages

    “It’s a question of brain over brawn,” (Martel 26) or rather in Martel's story it is a question of purpose over sheer nonsense. Organization is the main stage in all decent or better books. The author can use organization to their advantage but it can also cause a disadvantage. In, The Life of Pi, by Yann Martel the main character, 16 year old Pi Patel is an abnormal teen with even more abnormal daily activities. Pi’s life is constantly changing in his though his practice in Christianity, Hinduism, and Islam. Pi also show a special interest for zoology, most likely stemming from the fact that he grew up in the zoo. Growing up in the zoo taught him many important lessons. Lessons like feed a goat to a lion, and saying the most dangerous animal…

    • 807 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The book “Life of Pi” is supposedly meant to be a story about a boy, who was stranded at sea after a shipwreck, and how he dealt with starvation, crushed hopes, and a Bengal tiger. However, if the story is taken at face value in this way, the entire point of the book would be lost in the illusionary story that Pi is trying to pass off as the truth. Simply believing in everything that Pi says detracts from what Richard Parker is truly meant to be in the book, and what he actually signifies to Pi. I argue that the tiger is not an actual being, and is actually meant to symbolizes Pi’s most primitive animal instincts.…

    • 1636 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Pi has ethics. He knew how to observe and conform to the accepted principles of right conduct being part of not just his family, but also his family as part of the whole community. His ethics governed his behavior towards the tiger even in a most undesirable situation of being cast away. He is honest, just, truthful and very much concerned about the things that surround him.…

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    As the final chapter of Part Two comes to an end, Pi breaks into tears, crying the following words: "Richard Parker, a companion of my torment, awful, fierce thing that kept me alive, moved forward and disappeared forever from my life." In the world today where civilization exists, the idea of an innocent sixteen-year-old boy surviving his ordeal with a feral Bengal tiger lies beyond our concept of reality. However, it cannot be denied that the relation between Bengal tiger and Pi is depicted with great amount of detail that makes it consistent and plausible, due to the author 's awareness that the intricate relationship will serve as an important role throughout the story in literary aspects. In the novel Life of Pi written by Canadian author Yann Martel, a relationship develops between a Bengal tiger and Pi, who are stranded on a lifeboat after a horrific shipwreck Richard Parker and Pi seem to be full of opposites as the ordeal at sea begins. Nevertheless, there are specific intentions of the author in placing these two living beings on the lifeboat which become apparent as the story progresses. The developments in the relationship are significant to the novel as a whole, as they effectively convey the author 's message and themes, and contain symbolism that has great importance.…

    • 1117 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Life of Pi

    • 2423 Words
    • 10 Pages

    In the beginning of Life of Pi, the author opens up with a detailed description of the sloth, the different types, the speed, and the wittiness. It survives by being slow and because of its slowness; it allows algae to grow on its body that acts like a camouflage with the surrounding moss and foliage. The book starts out in first person with the main character, Piscine Patel, talking about his name which means "pool" in numerous languages. He found it weird that his parents named him Piscine but neither of them ever took to the water. It was Pi's uncle, Mamaji, who was the enthusiast of water. Mamaji had taught Pi how to swim. "I lay on the bench and fluttered my legs and scratched away at the sand with my hands, turning my head at every stroke to breathe. I must have looked like a child throwing a peculiar, slow-motion tantrum." I find this quote to be not only funny but descriptive and vivid. It is lines like these in the book that you could see this boy doing and it makes you smile if not laugh a little. Pi Patel then talks about his country of India and his city that he lives in of Pondicherry. Pi lives in Pondicherry, India with his mother, father, and older brother, Ravi. Together, the family owns a magnificent zoo that is home to hundreds of animals including tigers and zebras. The foundation of the book describes the zoo and Pondicherry wonderfully and detailed. The author, Yann Martel, describes the place and you can see it all, the town, the zoo, and the nature of the whole scenery. He makes the reader smell, see, and feel what Pi smells, sees, and feels; emotionally, physically, and mentally. I would have started this book out the same but this description of where he lives and his surroundings and the day-to-day conversations he has is a little boring. It seems over the top, and it takes up too much space in the book. Pi is also having a religious conflict. He was brought up a Hindu but explores all sorts of religions in his childhood such as Christian,…

    • 2423 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    When Piscine first enters the life boat, he has not fully grasped the side of himself which is needed to survive and come of age. “…I was so obviously out matched by Richard Parker that it wasn’t even worth worrying about” is what the narrator says on page 149. At the beginning of Piscine’s adventures, he often has to fight and evade Richard Parker as at that point they have not learned to cooperate with each other. During Life of Pi, Richard parker is a character created by Piscine within his mind for which he blames for the actions he is not willing to accept he committed due to their inhumanity. Piscine creates the story with the tiger in order to cope with his own trauma. In Life of Pi the colour orange symbolises survival, therefore because the tiger is orange it is these action which are needed to survive, the survival instinct. If one comes to realise this part of them they become empowered. They grow and become stronger. Yet because Piscine and Richard Parker are seen as conflicting the reader comes to realise Piscine has not realised that part of himself, and in order to come…

    • 1239 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Life of Pi Essay

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Life of Pi was a story about a boy Indian boy named Piscine Patel was stranded at sea for 222 days after his ship which was going to Canada with his family sank. The story starts with him growing up as a child and practicing on his own accord many different cultures such as Hinduism, Islam and Christianity as this is happening the amount of money the zoo makes compared to the work they do coupled with his fathers will to stay with the times, forces his father to make the decision that they will move to Canada. They are not treated to well on boat and he is even thrown off the boat as bait for the tiger, after that it is just an everyday struggle for him to survive with no food and a Bengal tiger onboard. Pi Patel who was once a vegetarian now does everything he can do to survive including eating fish, drinking blood and whatever else he can find. My opinion is that Pi is a very smart and straightforward individual that would have been very successful in his life if the crash had not gotten in his way, I also think that his experience changed him a lot he went from being an average boy to someone who had suffered massive trauma and is now a hardened and scarred individual.…

    • 770 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays