Research Paper
Wood vs. Aluminum
The decades old debate over aluminum vs. wood bats will probably exist as long as the choice is available. Baseball was played with wooden bats for a great number of years. In fact, even with the advancements in aluminum bats, it’s the professionals who use wood bats and the amateurs who use the all-mighty aluminum bats. So, the question is which is better, wood or aluminum?
Aluminum bats are used in most Little Leagues because they are lighter and easier to swing, thus allowing a harder and faster hit than with heavier wood bats. Aluminum bats also have a more easily adjusted weight distribution. Since wooden baseball bats are solid, the bulk of the weight sits in the barrel, so the center of gravity has to be further away from the handle. This causes the bat to feel heavier near the end.
In Major League Baseball, only wooden bats are permitted. Baseball has been a beloved American past-time for well over a century and the sport is notorious for stubbornly keeping to its traditions. Used since the 1800s, wooden bats are seen as a tradition in themselves and it's not likely that baseball will let them go any time soon. Many argue that switching to aluminum bats in the major leagues would result in a homerun slaughter-fest that would become boring after a while. There is something to be said about the skill it takes to swing and drive a ball with a wooden bat as compared to the lighter, easier to handle aluminum bats.
Aluminum bats are also more durable than wood since they don't splinter or break. In an average season, any single baseball player can go through dozens of wood bats yet keep the same aluminum bat from beginning to end. For this reason, many amateur and little leagues opt for metal bats. While the initial investment is higher, aluminum bats will likely last a season or two, while wood bats are known to splinter and break fairly regularly.
The most obvious difference between wood and aluminum baseball bats is that wood bats go "crack" when they hit a ball while aluminum bats go "ping." Aluminum bats have a larger sweet spot is up to 5 - 7 inches and have a lot more "pop" due to the elastic properties of the metal. For wood bats, the sweet spot is maybe 2-3 inches.
Bolger 2
Bibliography
1. "Baseball Bat Debate: What's Better, Wood or Aluminum?" Baseball Bat Debate: What's Better, Wood or Aluminum? N.p., n.d. Web. 27 Aug. 2013. .
This website helped me find my project. It tells me how to do my project, but I made my own twist on it.
2. "The Free Automatic Bibliography and Citation Generator." EasyBib. N.p., n.d. Web. 27 Aug. 2013. .
This website helped me access all of my websites I used for this project. It also helped me organize the websites and put them into MLA format.
3. "Intel ISEF Document Library." Intel ISEF. N.p., n.d. Web. 27 Aug. 2013. .
This website has the rules and guidelines for my science fair project. It also has forms that I need to sign so I can be eligible for the county science fair.
4. "Science Fair Project Guide." Science Fair Project Guide. N.p., n.d. Web. 27 Aug. 2013. .
This website helped me set up my project. It helped me from setting up my question, to drawing a conclusion.
5. "Science of Baseball: Aluminum vs. Wooden Bats | Exploratorium." Science of Baseball: Aluminum vs. Wooden Bats | Exploratorium. N.p., n.d. Web. 27 Aug. 2013. .
This website showed me the history of wood and aluminum bats. It showed me the science on both bats and how the controversy began.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
As a result, the manufacturer conjured the idea of “composite” metal, which is a softer and more flexible metal then the normal aluminum used in bats from the past. The baseball would basically bounce off this new type of bat with higher velocity. The composite idea took off, and soon players all over the world loved the feel of this now material as it struck a baseball. Climactically, the new Demarini bat was a better performer on the baseball field than its counterparts; with the exception of the Easton…
- 683 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The process of creating the perfect wood bat is often overlooked when one watches their favorite baseball player blast a home run over the four hundred foot fence. It is astonishing how people make a simple tree into a four hundred foot home run hitting machine. The creation of the perfect wood baseball bat is much more complicated than one might think. The bat goes through an abundance of processes before its capabilities are showcased on television by major leaguers. The creation of the flawless wood baseball bat begins with the selection of the lumber, changing the splits into billets, and turning billets into branded and varnished ball crushing machines.…
- 635 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Multiple elements come into play when you compare wooden bats to aluminum bats. Wooden bats are more solid and heavy than aluminum bats. Aluminum bats are hollow and are much lighter than wooden bats, making an aluminum bat swing faster. Though an aluminum bat would sting a little more than the wooden bat when you hit the ball. Investigate the differences in each bat’s sting and distance when hitting the ball.…
- 176 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
In my experience of using a wooden bat balls I hit were not hit near as hard, not hit as far, and if you did not hit the ball square the player would know it. If you do not hit the ball on the barrel of the bat with a wooden bat it stings your hands and may break the bat training the player to hit the ball on the barrel of the bat. If I hit a ball out of the ball park by ten or twenty feet with a metal bat the ball probably would not go out with a wooden bat. One of the toughest transitions for players in college baseball to the professional level is the switch between metal to wood; therefore it would better prepare them for professional level if the so choose to play at that…
- 828 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Baseball has been around since 1846 and wooden bats have always been the tool of the trade. There is much debate as to whether players should use wooden bats versus aluminum. Traditional wooden bats can make players feel connected to the historical game. As well, there are a few benefits to using wooden bats opposed to aluminum. Here’s a list of 5 baseball wood bat benefits:…
- 527 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
My research revealed three main points to me. One being that metal bats have a larger “sweet spot” than wood bats. The “sweet spot” of a baseball bat is a place on the bat where the ball leaves the bat with the greatest speed and the player's hands feel very little vibration from the impact. This is because a metal bat’s barrel can hold a uniform shape longer than a wood bat. This larger “sweet spot” provides a better chance for the ball to not only be hit but hit harder.…
- 274 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
In asking the question what materials improvement for sports had made the biggest impact in the last century, the baseball bat is an obvious choice. First off, the word impact to me means the something had a measurable effect on something. The new composite baseball bat, instead of the wooden bats,has had a positive impact in the world of baseball. These composite bats are composed of glass, carbon and Kevlar fibers placed into a plastic mold. This new material is anisotropic, meaning they are designed to bring out stiffness and strength (Mussill). These new bats allow player to hit the ball harder and farther. This has made the game of baseball much more of a spectator sport. The excitement of home runs and line drives has expanded the numbers…
- 149 Words
- 1 Page
Good Essays -
Most of, if not every, high school baseball players dream to play college baseball at the Division-1 level and make it to the major leagues. Using these bats will put these players on the fast track to completely those goals. Pitchers are also going to benefit from these new bats. Balls that went for homeruns will stop before the wall and turn into routine fly balls. Hard hit line drives that were too much for fielders to handle will turn into outs. Teams will focus on a small-ball aspect of the game rather than rely on the long ball.…
- 274 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The terms hardwood and softwood refer to the density of wood, how hard it is, and how much weight it has. A dense hardwood like oak or maple has high energy content per cord, so it releases more heat and produces long-lasting embers. Hardwood is the best type of firewood for long lasting warmth and cooking but can sometimes be hard to ignite and split (http://www.firepit-and-grilling-guru.com/best-firewood.html). This is helpful information because if someone needs to know what firewood to burn for specific necessities, the best hardwood will narrow down their choices. Hardwood has some difficulties, but overall it’s a great wood to burn.…
- 1163 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Call an expert to remove it by hand. If this isn’t an option for you then try a couple of techniques to keep the bats from hanging. Tape or staple aluminum foil or metal flashing to the area where they are hanging. The bats will try to hang on it but wont be able to grip onto it. Also when they give off their high frequency pitch it will reflect right off of the aluminum and deter them from landing. Battery operated motion lights sometimes do the trick. The bats fly in and the light kicks on. Bats can be sensitive to light and when it flashes in their eyes they will turn around and fly else where. Another thing you may try is cleaning the areas where the bats are hanging with ammonia. Not only will it clean off the urine staining it will get rid of the odor. Bats are attracted to there odor they leave behind.…
- 225 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
The first prototype is made of aluminum alloy. Although titanium is the ideal material for any space project, but the cost is much higher than aluminum. Also aluminum is much lighter than titanium, however it has less strength. Its main advantage is the ability to handle extreme low temperature, which is the…
- 701 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Second, Aluminum is the material most commonly used for baseball bats from little league through high school and college. Because aluminum bats are lighter, more durable, and easier to swing than wood bats of equal size, those make them ideal for younger players learning the mechanics of a good swing. Also, aluminum bats allow the ball to “pop” off the bat with greater speed, which compensates for a lack of strength and accuracy in younger players who are unable to duplicate their efforts with wood bats.…
- 511 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Before the 1900s, tin was commonly used to package household foods. Since it protected the foods inside, and it could be bent with ease, it was regarded as an inexpensive, easy and health conscious way to keep foods fresh. Some of its disadvantages, which lead to its defeat to aluminum, included the fact that it could only be rolled thicker than aluminum; it became brittle when warm, reducing its malleability greatly, and the tin foil created a strange aftertaste, which was undesirable to many.…
- 665 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
bats in volleyball, and you don’t use nets in softball. The balls used in volley ball are…
- 1346 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
Wood has been an important construction material since humans began building shelters, houses and boats. Nearly all boats were made out of wood until the late 19th century, and wood remain in common use today in boat construction. Elm in particular was used for this purpose as it resisted decay as long as it was kept wet.…
- 534 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays