Preview

Why The Military Should Not Be Mandatory

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1034 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Why The Military Should Not Be Mandatory
“My fellow Americans, ask not what your country can do for you, ask what you can do for your country.” is from a famous inaugural address from late President John F. Kennedy (BrainyQuote. Xplore). This sentence has a lot of meaning on it. By birth, we have to have some patriotism. If we cannot love our country, then we cannot love anything in this world. People serve their country in many different ways. Some become politicians, some join the army, and some just join the social service agency. There are also arguments about serving the country. Some suggest that joining army or serving the country should be done from the early age. However, I think that young people should not be required to do public services.
Forcing an individual to serve
…show more content…
The rules and regulations of the military do not suit everyone. If a person is forced to go into the military and eventually finds out they just can’t make the grade, they end up with a dishonorable discharge that is an embarrassment for the rest of their lives. As long as the military provides free training and schooling there will always be people enough who will volunteer. The U.S. military has plenty of volunteers who sign up for duty. With enough benefits due to military service, plenty of Americans sign up willingly every year. Military service in the United States should never be mandatory. If the war is justified, enough people will join the force of their own volition.
I can see the benefits of having mandatory military service, and it is not that people will be able to "fight" for their freedom and "earn" it. The benefits are that it will teach people, make them more fit, and have a higher chance to implement true respect. However, what is the point if it is forced? By forcing something like this onto people who don't want it, we essentially remove a freedom that people enjoy, the freedom of choice. The military should be something that people choose, not something that is required, otherwise it will end up like public school, and people won't value it -they would hate
…show more content…
Basically, many countries in the world like Singapore, Norway, Germany, etc., have required military or civil service for all young men and sometimes women after their secondary education. In Germany, for example, young men are required to do a nine month paid training with the military, or if they cannot due to medical conditions, a nine month paid community service job (Ricks 646). After that, they can pursue a free college education subsidized by the country or job training. I think this is a very good system because, being a future American, I am appalled that people here are in such a weak position at that critical age going into adulthood. They drop out of high school or college, they have unstable jobs, and they put themselves in a position where they lose all the opportunity they have to make themselves successful in life or useful to the world. Not to mention many Americans are extremely individualistic, materialistic, and superficial.
Mandatory service is not service, it’s slavery. When you are not willing to do it don’t do it. Enforced community service teaches nothing .You take a bunch of students and make them do something they might or might not want to do. We already do that with school “for their own good” and just look at the dropout rates. Have we ever tried to force someone to do something ? Do they do it as well

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    In Edward Freeland’s letters to the editor of The New York Times, he stated that “men do not act like brutes or devils without reason. ”1 During what would become known as “the largest civilian insurrection in American history”, the New York Draft riots highlighted a bleak and tumultuous time in this nation’s history.2 What motivated the rioters to do what they did has never been one concise answer. In his writings, Freeland set out to analyze the causes and consequences of the riots by investigating the relationships between class, race, and education in American society. Throughout American history, mandatory conscription has been utilized in times of war to ensure American victory and preservation.…

    • 1361 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 1967 when I enlisted in the Marine Corp we did not have the draft, the Marine Corp never used the draft but the Army did. Around, the spring of 1967 the Corp decided it needed the draft to fill all the slots open. So they started to drafting, we then had a lot of men starting to call their congressman about the way they were treated and wanted them to change the Corp. The quality of the Marine Corp started to fall so after a few years of the draft they dropped the draft, then the quality came back I feel that if you want to be in the military then you should enlist. With the job market the way it is today we should have a large group of people waiting to join. I see in the news that people want their men and women back and protesting they don’t want them to go to war, who does. But we take an oath to protect and honor the constitution of the United States of America. When called we will protect our nation no matter what. So why are these people crying about their family members going overseas let’s look at it like this, it’s a job you get paid to do a service for the country. It is an honor to do this, be proud to serve and protect we learn, and we grow when in the military many men and women have become adults fast, even if they didn’t want to they have to. Does this make them a better person I think so, if some turn out bad or misguided they would have been misguided anyway. So is it time to reinstate the draft I say no. Maybe the politicians should, be drafted and serve their country instead of trying to place people where they do not want to be. Give the military men and women more pay and respect them for what they do. When we came home from Vietnam we were spit on and called names, these men and women deserve more, honor them do not humiliate them. I have spoken to my children about going into the military, but they…

    • 1195 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Have you ever taken the time to think about how you feel about the draft? Do you feel it is the government’s right to tell you to serve in the military? In times of war there is always the possibility of a draft. Drafting for military purpose has dated back to the Thirteen Colonies and could still be used today. Although it has been in existence for a very long time the draft has been used in 5 major wars: the Civil War, World War I, World War II, the Korean War and again for the Vietnam War.…

    • 1802 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    If the draft is brought back, the military would obviously never be weak in terms of numbers. Also, despite the increased wage towards the support of troops, cost would be preserved from the savings of other budgets being cut. And last but not least, it is the duty of a U.S. citizen to defend their country when in need. The reinstatement of the draft would be a great benefit towards the country of the United States of America. This has created a large debate over a military draft. This topic of discussion has been contemplated and deliberated since military forces were created. There are two sides, those for and those against. The debate over the draft is endless. Many realistic points can be made from either side of the argument over the draft, but the most logical and simple solution is to reinstate the…

    • 611 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I do not agree with the reinstitution of a military draft. In 1973 the military draft was lifted in the United States and with good reason. The United States should not rely on a draft to fill military vacancies but rely on recruitment. It is true that the military offers incentives and luxuries that some civilians could not afford otherwise such as food, shelter, and medical care. However, they are just that, incentives. The military is an option and should remain that way. Many enlist for different reasons, some with economical reasons, others with strong political urges, but they enlist out of their own desires, beliefs, and more importantly, free will. Some see the military as a way of life; others see it as the only way to educate themselves in a society where education is valued so highly. With rising tuition costs, many enlist in the reserves as a guarantee for their degree. College is costly and even with the aid of tuition assistance and can leave a graduate drowning in debt. These are all choices all college bound 18-25 year olds make and some just do not have the luxury of choosing.…

    • 503 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    My first reason that we should not have drafts is that it violates human rights. We have the right to serve and if we don't want to then we simply don't have to. If we where to have a draft then you would be forced to serve even if you don't want to. Drafts take away are freedom to…

    • 805 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “Serve Or Fail,” Dave Eggers argues that "colleges should consider instituting a service requirement for graduation.” He claims that 4 years college are too long, student usually waste many time, and to be volunteer is a good idea to kill time better than killing time on the meaningless activity like football. Furthermore, he states giving a opportunity to college student to service is a chance to let the kid meet society earlier. He introduced a bill like more than 90000 students at 14 state run universities required to them to have 25 hour community service in one year that can create more than two million volunteer in one year, and it can provide benefit from getting involved. In addition, the author argue that the service requirement…

    • 270 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    I do not believe that the United States should institute in the practice of requiring people to serve in the military. While it would be very loyal to the United States, I think people should have the rights to choose their own career and not be forced into something they have no interest in. Also with so many people being forced into the military for one or more years, other jobs would not have people to fill up positions, important jobs such as police officers, doctors, teachers, or even people in entertainment. Which would really change up the economy.…

    • 244 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Military Draft Essay

    • 1924 Words
    • 8 Pages

    When the Civil War broke out and men were needed to serve in the war, the government used conscription, the mandatory induction of men into the military.1 Though some people use this word just like the word draft, the two concepts are different. Draft is the process to determine who will be chosen to serve; it’s like a lottery. Currently, men ages 18-25 have to register with the Select Service with the possibility of serving in the military,2 but conscription itself was abolished in 1973.3…

    • 1924 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When people are in the army in america then they are wanting to they are not forced. Our army has the tendency no matter what battle to distinguish itself from any other people. In addition, the concept of freedom means different things to different people, depending on the…

    • 330 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Essay On Military Draft

    • 1775 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The controversy surrounding the military draft has since its inception to its repeal in the nineteen-seventies; however the vitality of the draft remains because United States may need more than a volunteer army, it requires everyone to serve, and higher trained and educated people are needed to run new technology. The first reason is the military may need more than a volunteer army to defend the nation in a national emergency. In the U.S. constitution the government has the right the raise and maintains an army as long as the conflict is still going on. The draft was then repealed but is still in effect. The last reason the U.S. may need more than a volunteer army is because the United States may need it to maintain the security of the nation. The second reason the United States needs the draft is because everyone needs to serve their country. Every male eighteen to twenty-six must register for the draft because it is still a law even since it was repealed. It offers a lot of benefits to those who comply to the laws if the draft is used. There are very severe penalties for not registering at age eighteen. This may be considered not a draft even though they must register at eighteen. Not all American males will be drafted for many different reasons. Would the new draft require women to register also? The third reason…

    • 1775 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Military Draft No More

    • 337 Words
    • 2 Pages

    But the primary reason people volunteer and continue to serve is service to our country.…

    • 337 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Essay On The Drinking Age

    • 574 Words
    • 3 Pages

    All men have to sign up for the military draft at age 18 in case it is ever brought back into practice. People went off to fight for our country at 18, away from family and friends, in foreign territory with the uncertainty of life. A person risks life and limb in war, but they can’t come home and have a drink? Going off into war has serious consequences mentally, physically, and emotionally. This is a major life event if one chooses to do so. Why should a person be able to risk their life, but not be able to buy a drink on a weekend?…

    • 574 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Pipec

    • 288 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Mandatory military service is a very old form of public service. In most countries practicing mandatory military service one joins the service age of eighteen years or after competing high school studies , before joining the universities. The period of the service varies from one country to another with some serving for only six months whereas in other countries one has to serve for two years . After the service one usually has the choice of either joining the national army or continuing with the civilian life.…

    • 288 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I think the reintroduce of the draft should not be the solution for the lack of recruits albeit it could be a possibility to deploy good-educated, healthy, young people. The draft is an obligation and therefore in my opinion an intervention in the liberty rights of young persons. Nevertheless, the alternative should not be to increase the perks and advertise to get more volunteers because this strategy pushes young people to become recruits because of another motive.…

    • 1253 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays