Preview

Whiteness As Ambivalence

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
603 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Whiteness As Ambivalence
“How did Jew become white folks in the United States?” offers some valuable perceptions on the dynamics of race in the U.S. Moreover, the principal categorizations which have assigned Jews into the white race category helped to form the way in which various American Jews have created their own racial identities. Author Sacks explains these make up through the examination of her own multi-generational family make up. She describes how Jews had to deal with the double standards of racial mindlessness and assimilation with respect to being white in the U.S. Nonetheless, the same way Irish American was treated during the mid-19th century followed by other groups such as the eastern, central, and southern Europeans and later the Jews reaffirms the …show more content…
Yet, one of the most noticeable points that the author also hedges upon is the major aspect of "Whiteness as Ambivalence,”. While it is fascinating, to understand why Jews were not recognized as whites in America at first in the United States is not anything new given the history of the US how far it has come in terms racial equality. For example, the author discusses her own experiences and talks about her Jewish parents and grandparents living in New York during the period when Jews were not considered as white folks. Even though Jews just makes up three percent of the American population, they have mostly had a bigger representation in businesses, and governmental sectors. The American Jewish group, apart from witnessing severe assimilation issues coupled with anti-semitism sentiments from the “White race” during the early twentieth century give this group lot of clout to organize in other words become stronger as a society. Nevertheless, in order for the Jewish population to be accepted as “Whites Folks” they had to actually work extremely harder to bond and find their place in American society. Moreover, apart from the factors mentioned before are all reasons as to why Jews were able to overcome these steep hurdles, but two major factors that helped to drive Jews from not being recognized as “White Folks” to actually becoming “White Folks” is directly linked to the availability of GI bill and the ability to get an sound education and forming a very close knitted Jewish communities in order to establish a good support system to

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    This article ‘Germans Americans: Paradoxes of a model minority’ discusses about their immigrations and the problems associated with it. First of all, in May 1917, was against the fact that bilingual schools of Indianapolis state were singing star Spangled banner in German translation even though they were had the least number of ethnic groups. Germans almost did not exist. Benjamin franklin said that they were trying to make people German instead of adapting to the language or culture they lived in. As time passed, many immigrants started moving to US from southern and Eastern Europe.…

    • 630 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The relationship between African Americans and white people in the United States has been one of contention and struggle for equality that follows a relatively unique timeline. This subordinate-superordinate relationship based on race which manifests itself in all sectors of life according to sociologists stems from the way in which different ethnic groups were introduced to the society in addition to the ways in which the groups interact. These theories are used to make sense of the racial or ethnic relationships over an amount of time. We have been briefly introduced to race relation cycle theory in the previous unit’s readings focusing on racism. With this reading, Benjamin Ringer and Eleanor Lawless dig deeper into the sociologists thinking in terms of race relationships.…

    • 518 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Being Jewish anywhere in the world was hard in the 1930s and 40s. Almost all know about German jewish hardship, the systematic slaughter of millions of jews in death camps across Hitler’s empire, but what many do not understand is that anti-semitism was incredibly strong in the United States as well. However, in a time when almost none stood by their side, Franklin Delano Roosevelt seemed the only world leader who cared. However, his cabinet did not share his welcoming attitude, and attempted to sabotage him. Although Roosevelt demonstrated that he did care about saving the Jews, his administration perpetrated systematic denial of Jewish entry to the country. Because he did not do enough to investigate this until it was too late, he is…

    • 1216 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In her book "How Jews Became White Folk", Karen Brodkin examines the question of how Jews came to be regarded as White. She does this by first explaining how Jews were racially categorized prior to this time, and how they were considered to be inferior to the white race. Whiteness is and has always relied on continually renegotiated interpretations; that has more to do with ones social class rather than skin color. The argument that Brodkin presents is that the claim of whiteness are extended to certain races or ethnic groups at certain times, and that the past experiences of these groups cannot wipe away such indisputable social facts.…

    • 608 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    1) Using two racial groups [of color], demonstrate how oppositional dichotomies of race define racial stereotypes. Oppositional dichotomies of race is like the idea of polar opposites. It is a unit made up of two parts that compliment each other and are essential to one another. To think about it simply and without race, it is like left and right or light and dark. Left and right depend on each other because without one of them, the other can’t exist; this same idea can be applied to racial stereotypes.…

    • 340 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Whiteness studies incorporate aspects such as the cultural, social and historical factors relative to the people identified as the white citizens in the United States. These studies exist around the idea that white privilege is in fact alive in our social world. Meaning the playing field isn’t level between different races and that white individual’s benefit from it. Whiteness Studies were popular in the mid-1990s. During that time there were numerus studies that surrounded whiteness. The authors of those studies were inspired by the concepts of post modernism and society’s racial history including the philosophy of white superiority. Some argue that the principles of the ideologies were specifically intended to justify the concept of racial…

    • 442 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cultural Baggage

    • 577 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In the article “Cultural Baggage” published at The New York Times magazine on May 3, 1992, the author Barbara Ehrenreich assess and weighs hers and other people’s cultural and religious background. By listening to an exciting friend about her cultural legacy, Mrs. Ehrenreich abruptly understood that she hasn’t defined one. However, she impliedly denotes some English heritage. In the 60’s and 70’s era, she witnessed ethnical and cultural awakening. These celebrations carried on her some guiltiness about her Anglo-Saxon roots. While as a child, she ate ethnic foods that didn’t represent her owns, but her mother encouraged her to “Try new things”. She liked the idea of being Irish descendant, but displeased of their ancestral savage behavior. As motherhood arrived, she wanted to married a man with Yiddish roots in order to provide their children with a solid heritage. Sadly, it did not work out because her kids knew that their grandparents did not honor their Jewish traditions either. Consequently, she realizes that nobody at home follows any religious line. She also remembers that her mother never mentioned any learned way to do house work. Nevertheless, she learned from her parents that anything new is better than the old ones. The aphorisms “Try new things, Think for yourself and Always ask why” were her only heritage, and thus passed along to her children. She calls this lacking of heritage the race of “none”.…

    • 577 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Initially cast concurrently as exploitable laborers and as morally corrupt scapegoats for the social ills of the day, much like the Chinese before them and the Mexicans yet to come, immigrants from southern and eastern Europe were also remolded in the aftermath of WWII, notably as the civil rights movement took shape; the general social perception regarding people of Italian, Irish, Polish, Jewish, etc. descent shifted from one about criminality, deviance, and congenital racial inferiority to nearly the opposite as white neoliberal projects worked to suppress black power and intellect and to reformulate themselves under a new post-war sociopolitical order. Where for years white ethnics had been viewed by nativists “as racially inferior, fecund burdens on the state” (Perry, 101), they were “whitened” in the process of black subjugation (Pedraza 36-39), and the illusion of successful bootstrap-pulling was created regarding these people in such a way that suggested a demonstrably false premise of equality (Perry, 74). By manipulating the circumstances that create social stratification, including but not limited to targeted legislation and public rhetoric, neoliberal agendas once again effectively weaponized a group of people once subjugated themselves, violently erasing their ethnic and cultural underpinnings in a chilling effort to homogenize the white front against those people it considers its negations. Importantly, in ostensibly contradicting itself by allowing (even creating) such an apparently substantial paradigm shift, the system effectively refreshed its camouflage once again without updating any of its fundamental tenants, especially those of personal responsibility and adherence to family values. This allows for the ongoing reification of the process, which is constantly reconstructing…

    • 1383 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    World War II was a terrible time for the Jews. Close to six million Jews died over the course of the War in Europe. This meant America had the largest Jewish population in the world. After the events of World War II, Jews didn’t know where to turn to; the once great sanctions of Judaism were in need of guidence with no one to lead them except for the dominant reform judaism in the United States and eventually Israel with the more conservative view on Judaism. While rebuilding Judaism in post-World War II America was widely accepted by most Northern Americans, the South however did not accept Jews because of their determination to end Jim Crow laws. The South grew more anti-semitic as the Jewish community fought for equal rights for all. In…

    • 369 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Whenever the economy is in a down fall and wages are being depressed, land prices start rising, and consumer products become inflated politicians all too quickly blame the ethnic minorities for the community’s problems (87). According to Gibbs and Bankhead in order to be considered an American and superior to others, they had to have bleach blonde hair, resemble models, tanned lifeguards, and look like they had just stepped out of a magazine or off a billboard. If they were not considered to be a “real” American they were going to be discriminated…

    • 1415 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Herzl proposes that we shall release the banner of the so called “New Jew” and let our voices permeate across the globe. It is time we fight back with honor and integrity to establish the legitimacy of the Jewish people, and await their new revival. However, this national movement cannot be managed without a gestor, but it cannot be one single individual rather it must be a union of several persons, a body corporate. The body is to be called the society of the Jews and will have to put forth its labor in science and politics. Herzl is in hopes that this movement will open up a general discussion of the Jewish question, Herzl desires that the discussion around a Jewish State will not take the form of inflammatory rhetoric and sentimental vindication, but meaningful debate and politics (Herzl, Pg. 427). The Society of the Jews will be the nucleus of the public organizations by its ability to disseminate information that is needed to find out whether or not the Jews desire to emigrate to the Promise Land. Lastly, Herzl touches on public opinion and its prominence in establishing where the Jews ought to…

    • 941 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    What does Fredrickson mean by “the burden of ‘otherness’”? Summarize the ways in which racial categories and definitions of “whiteness” have changed during the course of American history.…

    • 639 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    “Whiteness does not stand alone. It draws part of its meaning from what it means to be nonwhite”. (Phillip C. Wanderer, 2009). “The roots of racial classification emerge from the naturalistic science of the 18th and 19th centuries”. (Phillip C. Wanderer, 2009, p. 30) “During this time, scientific studies extended the classifications of humankind developed by zoologists and physical anthropologists by systematically measuring and describing differences in hair texture, skin color, average height, and cranial capacity in various races”. (Phillip C. Wanderer, 2009, p. 30) Racial classification was a way of being able to separate the whites from the nonwhites. For European immigrants, racial identity was not always clear. “The process of becoming white and becoming “American” involved a whole range of evidence, laws, court cases, formal racial ideology, social conventions, and popular culture in the form of slang, songs, films, cartoons, ethnic jokes, and popular theater suggested that the native born and older immigrants often placed the new immigrants not only above African, and Asian Americans, but also below white people”. (Roediger, 2009, p. 36). Because of this immigrant workers wound up in between races. The literal in between’s of new immigrants suggests what popular speech affirms: The state of whiteness was approached…

    • 942 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The White Racial Frame

    • 912 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Feagin defines racism as a consistent problem that has lingered in American society since the founding of the country. There are many things that can be held accountable for this issue. Feagin’s min idea is that there is a different state of mind between the races, especially in the United States. History has proven to repeat itself as far as racism goes. There have been many changes that have pushed this country in the right direction as far as abolishing racism, but many problems are still very much alive. We have made significant changes, such as abolishing slavery, getting rid of racism in numerous aspects of legality, and outlawing public displays of racism to level the equality in everyday life. According to Feagin, this issue is called the white racial frame. By this, he means that the white population in America still has very racist ideals, but has managed to believe differently. Since the percentage of people who are in control of the money and power in this country still remains mostly white, many things that still go on are in favor of the white population. Feagin believes that since the white population has talked themselves in to believing that racism has been defeated, it is nearly impossible to progress to achieve full equality in this country.…

    • 912 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hyphenated Americans

    • 2367 Words
    • 10 Pages

    References: Steinberg, Stephen. The Ethnic Myth: Race, Ethnicity and Class in America. January 16, 2001. Boston, MA: Beacon Press.…

    • 2367 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays