Preview

Unit 2 Analysis Of A Political Cartoon

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
826 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Unit 2 Analysis Of A Political Cartoon
Part Two: Analysis

The first source shows a poster advertising free trade and technical classes for adults during President Roosevelt’s New Deal. It occurred in 1936 around the time of the United States depression. This poster was created to encourage people to get an education to reduce poverty and to create jobs.
The ideological perspective shown in the source is modern liberalism because there is government contribution in the society to benefit the country. This is a collective perspective because the program is funded by the government to benefit society as a collective. Roosevelt created social programs during the recession to create jobs and maintain equality. His ideas were inspired from John Keynes who also was a modern liberalist.
…show more content…
I believe this cartoon is saying that both tax and rebate can’t jumpstart the economy. You either need tax OR rebate. This cartoon is linked to Keynes economic theory because he believed that tax rebates when the economy is poor would help stimulate the economy and taxes when the economy was good would prevent spending and overheating.
The main idea represented is not clear because it doesn’t show which battery is the ‘right’ one to use. It just states that you need either tax OR rebate. Assuming that in Keynes theory that rebates would help jumpstart the economy, and taxes would prevent overspending, we can say that this image is a collectivist because it supports government involvement. The government controls fiscal policies to prevent recession and by raising taxes or rebating taxes, it will benefit the society as a
…show more content…
Keynes believed that classic liberalism itself was unstable. You need government intervention to straighten some issues out.
His ideological perspective is closely linked to modern liberalism because they both encourage and endorse social programs and have government control some aspects of the economy. If classic liberalism was left alone with no government control, society would go into recession and there is no way that it can come out of it unless government is there to take control. You need social programs to help the recession by creating jobs and express confidence in the economy.
Keynesian economics supports the principles of modern liberalism. It somewhat rejects private property, economic freedom and competition. By creating social programs, some private property will be changed over to public property. As previously stated, social programs would also take away competition for other businesses. Taxes are used to fund these programs and an increase in taxes would lead to less economic freedom. It supports individual rights and freedoms because the social services would provide the programs that would improve the lives of the citizens. For example, free public healthcare would relate to the right to

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    During both the Progressive era and the New Deal era, policies as well as programs were being created in an effort to assist the American public, specifically those living in poverty. Throughout the early 1900’s Roosevelt had strayed away from the typical laissez-faire policy and decided that the people would need to be guided by the government. “Wilsonian Progressivism” had also aimed at assisting the public with his “New Freedom Program” which consisted of antitrust legislation, banking reform as well as tariff reductions. After the stock market crashed in 1929, America had fallen into a Great Depression resulting in the unemployment of millions. Newly elected Franklin D. Roosevelt decided to present his New Deal policy which focused on three methods of helping America: relief (immediate action to temporarily lessen the suffering), recovery (executive and legislative initiatives intended to get the economy starting), and reform (permanent programs used to reduce the possibility of another economic disaster). Both the Progressive era and New Deal era policies and programs had similarities and differences in their approach to helping the American public.…

    • 980 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Any political cartoon, whether contemporary or historical, represents a snapshot of an artist's perspective. In this Assignment you'll look at four political cartoons drawn during the Jacksonian era. Answering the five questions…

    • 1116 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Poli 330 Week 3

    • 594 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Liberalism is tricky to define since it is divided into classical and modern liberalism. Classical liberalism states that the government should take control of an institution in order to ensure that it continues to be of service to the people, free of charge. Classical liberalism does not see any need for the government to enforce law and order and subjugate its citizens under the iron rule of law and order. In a classical liberalist government you would have Lower taxes and more economic freedom. With that also comes lack of government regulation which would…

    • 594 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Great Depression DBQ

    • 844 Words
    • 4 Pages

    As expressed in document C, Roosevelt utilized his knowledge of Keynesian Economics to come up with many new programs that would help the American people get through this hard time. Some of these programs included: Works Progress Administration which provided long term government jobs building schools and other public works projects, Federal Emergency Relief Act which gave immediate help to those that needed it in the form of cash payments, and the Civil Works Administration which provided temporary jobs repairing roads and bridges. The cartoon shown in document E represents the new idea of social security that Roosevelt promoted. This would be a new means of gaining money for the elderly and would turn out to be a genius idea that would allow the retirement of extremely hard workers instead of the constant working and struggling to survive until death. Document H, expresses how Roosevelt's New Deal is just beginning and that it is far from over with. This response was effective because this promoted more positive changes in the future. In document G, new laws allow workers to create unions so that they are able to take action like demanding wages. Through the Square Deal, the government got involved in labor and management issues and workers were greatly benefited because they could now form unions and stand…

    • 844 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It helped farmers, trade unionists, the elderly, the disabled, dependent children, the unemployed and many others who had been passed over in the social and financial shifts that occurred in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. By providing social safety nets, opportunities for work and help for the needy, New Deal not only transformed America’s economic policies, but it also influenced the nation’s political and cultural outlooks. Under Roosevelt’s aegis, Congress unleashed an era of an activist, centralized government, and, at the same time, gave its stamp to a liberal Protestant mindset that sought, unironically, the best of all possible outcomes in this best of all possible worlds. What gave political credibility to liberal forces in American during the quarter-century following the Second Word War was their ability to argue effectively that the expansion of the welfare state and the adoption of the principles of Keynesian economics were not only compatible with economic prosperity but essential to it. The postwar liberal program was based on the interdependency of social justice and business…

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hoover Roosevelt Dbq

    • 435 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Comparatively President Franklin Delano Roosevelt was a liberal. Originally FDR wishes to balance the budget, thus he passes the Economy act in 1933 (Doc D) this cut the wages of government jobs by 15%. When his attempt to balance the budget backfired FDR finally came to accept the Keynesian theory, which states the government spending is one of the major parts of the economy. During his attempt to balance the budget FDR caused the Roosevelt Recession (Doc E). After he became…

    • 435 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    John Maynard Keynes was a journalist, financer, and English economist, best known for his economic theories. Traditional economists believed that capitalism could recover by itself, the government does not interfere, during the Great Depression. The traditional economists argued that this way has always worked in times before. The economy was not getting any better, however. People started to turn to Marxist ideas. Marxism is the belief that the transition from capitalism to socialism is an inevitable part of the human society. John Maynard Keynes explained that capitalism could last under new conditions if certain traditional policies of the capitalist governments and banks were changed. The Keynesians claimed that the way to save capitalism was the government had to run a sufficiently large deficit to make up for any shortfall in spending by the private sector. As a result of this, unemployment would turn into “full employment”, which meant that there would be enough unemployment to keep trade unions in…

    • 451 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    New Deal Dbq

    • 595 Words
    • 3 Pages

    After the devastation of the Great Depression, Franklin D. Roosevelt developed a new plan. This New Deal was aimed toward short and long ranged relief, recovery, and reform for the suffering American economy. His program embraced such progressive ideas as unemployment insurance, old-age insurance, minimum-wage restrictions, conservation and development of natural resources, and restrictions on child labor. Many acts of administration were passed by Congress in order to improve American society and the depressed lifestyle.…

    • 595 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Modern liberals believe that the state increases the level of positive freedom in society. Not everyone in society has access to the same resources as would be available to the wealthy. For example, opportunities available to the wealthy (e.g. university) would not be open to the less fortunate if it weren’t for student finance help provided by the government. The same can be said for health care, which if it weren’t for the Liberal Democrats, would be privatised by the Conservative Party, leaving the poorer section of society less able to tap into this resource. Modern liberals believe that the welfare state is an example of positive freedom, giving the poor access to resources such the NHS (health service), education, and opportunities such as employment.…

    • 911 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Franklin Delano Roosevelt has tons of ideas that he thought would benefit everyone and possibly take us out of the depression. Not everyone agreed with his ideas and supported him but his ideas did help extremely. Roosevelt made the federal deposit insurance corporation and civil works administration for the first new deal and then the social security act and the Fair labor standards act in the second new deal that was later to come. Although there were many more acts and things that he did to get American back to normal, these four I believe made a huge change and are still used today in our everyday life. The federal deposit insurance corporation was basically insurance for banks up to 100,000 dollars! During the depression banks were starting to close down because they were loaning money out before the depression that they did really have, so when everything went wrong and everyone decided to get their money out of the bank the banks didn’t have all the money that the people believed was rightfully theirs! Roosevelt made sure that wouldn’t happen again by giving the banks insurance. Another part of the new deal was the civil works administration, which employed thousands of public workers. Now that the depression was happening tons of people didn’t have jobs, no one had money and no one knew what to do next. Roosevelt decided to give these people jobs…

    • 473 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Liberalism In Cuba

    • 845 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Liberalism has been created and molded through many time periods, with the assistance of various great thinkers and valid viewpoints. Depending on who is asked, liberalism may have many different levels to it for them. Factors that could have shaped their view of liberalism may be their heritage and where they live or have lived. Being specific to the quote, the first section of it more referring to welfare capitalism, while the second part is largely modern liberalism. There are two distinct principles of ideology presented in the source; the first ideology given is a view that embraces more of a free-market economy, little government involvement. The second part of the source expresses more of a command economy ideology. That includes…

    • 845 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The basic components and goals of a liberalist government are the progressive ideas of an individuals liberty and equality. An individual is more important than the state as well as being rational and capable of making their own decisions which helps the individual be independent. People aren't afraid of change due to the possible progress in political affairs. Another component is that economic inequality is not bad because economic freedom is more important than economic equality. Franklin Roosevelt established the Social Security Act which established a federal pension and unemployment insurance system. It also met the goals of ideology as it still exists today.…

    • 341 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    This soon changed based on the teachings of Adam Smith who wanted to lift the working conditions as well as spread wealth among more people. From the ideas of Smith, Classical Liberalism formed which valued individual’s freedom with a limited government. People were wanting limited government because they wanted a say in policies and issues that would effect their lives. The next government reform was the Jacksonian Democracy which opened voting to all white men, which at the time was the highest number of people eligible to vote then anywhere else. Utilitarianism made it so it maximized benefits for all people including the minority. This reform focused on what made the best sense for everyone and not just one type of person. The last reform was Chartism which focused on political rights for the working class. Chartism brought up many issues with the industry life and working class people. People wanted laws to help with the issues like unsafe working conditions, over crowding, and child…

    • 752 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In 1933 when Franklin D. Roosevelt had become president, the United States had been at its lowest point of the Depression. Twenty-five percent of the workforce was unemployed, half of the citizens who had home mortgages had failed to pay back their loans, Americans had lost nearly $2.5 billion in bank failures, and the entire banking system had appeared to be on the verge of collapse (Keene, p.662, 666). Roosevelt had empathy for the common people, and he devoted massive legislation to fix the economy and better the lives of these people. He was quoted as saying “I pledge you, I pledge myself, to a new deal for the American people,” during his campaign (662). In the end, the New Deal and its programs were a success in helping promote economic recovery and lift the weight of the Great Depression from its victims.…

    • 1602 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The 1930’s were a time of despair, poverty and distress and those who lived during this time believed it would be better to die, than to continue to live this way. When Franklin D. Roosevelt came into office in 1932, the United States was in the most disconsolate moments of the Great Depression. However, he brought with him a promise, a promise to make things better through a series of reforms he was planning on implementing known as the New Deal. In the first one hundred days following his inauguration as president, FDR, had already put into place a variety of programs, all with the goal to briskly improve the lives of those that had been most affected by the Great Depression and boost the economy. Through these programs FDR hoped to create jobs, lower the amount of people living on the streets, and most of all, uplift the spirits of the American people which had taken the biggest hit of all. The New Deal was a success because even though many minorities were overlooked, the overall population was influenced in a significant positive manner through job creation and governmental aid despite having negative effects in other areas of the country.…

    • 1398 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays