Traditional education is based off the idea that a teacher lectures students about subjects that do not have any bearing towards them or understanding of the subject. Information is almost being fed to the developing minds and this information is being taught by an individual who is teaching off their own experiences as well as the written criteria. "Books, especially textbooks, are the chief representatives of the lore and wisdom of the past, while teachers are the organs through which pupils are brought into effective connection with the material. Teachers are the agents through which knowledge and skills are communicated and rules of conduct enforced." (18) This quote reflects that the information in a text book can only do so much and teachers are the ones who are supposed to fill in the gaps and explain why things happen the way they did. Traditional education is seen as one sided and John Dewey did not agree with this being the best method of learning for developing minds. An example would be a teacher explaining how important it is to recycle and use less paper products to save trees, but students have no idea how many trees are being torn down or what they are doing by recycling. Recycling means nothing to the students because they have no experience with recycling. This method of teaching can be inaccurate due to the quality of the teacher or the one sidedness of the teacher 's experience.
John Dewey believed progressive education is a better method of learning. Progressive learning is learning from ones own experiences. Students would retain information from their own experiences and then thirst for knowledge about those experiences they have encountered. "As an individual passes from one situation to another, his world, his environment, expands or contracts. He does not find himself living in another world but in a different part or aspect of one and the same world. What he has learned in the way of knowledge and skill in one situation becomes an instrument of understanding and dealing effectively with the situations which follow." (44) This type of learning helps students relate past experiences to their education. Once again going back to recycling, if you show a student and explain how many North American forests are being cut down for lumber and paper products and show the complete process they will be aware of how important our earth is to our survival; therefore, the students will now want to recycle actively. Progressive learning is based off students first hand experiences and if they can experience or witness the act or process they have a much better chance of retaining the information.
In summary traditional learning is seen as the biggest form of education and can be inaccurate do to the level of instructor; however, John Dewey 's progressive model of learning is valuable to all types of education because an instructor does not even have to be present for a student to learn because they have past encounters to refer to and make decisions based off those. Experience and Education made good observations; consequently, experiences in life are the best forms of education.
Work CitedDewey, John (1938). Experience and Education. New York: Macmillan Publishing Company
Cited: ewey, John (1938). Experience and Education. New York: Macmillan Publishing Company
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
According to Hirsch, European Romanticism, has been a post-Enlightenment mishap, a mistake He says we need to correct. (Hirsch, 1996). Hirsch argues that we cannot blame the media, the breakdown of the family, poverty, racism, underfunding of schools or any other external factor for the unsuccessful education system. Hirsch believes the primary cause of education's failures is a philosophy of education derived from Rousseau and John Dewey. This philosophy, known as "progressive education," is based on the romantic ideal that each child has an innate, instinctive tendency to follow his or her own proper development (Hirsch, 1987). It would seem that according to progressivism the content of education is irrelevant; that students should be allowed to study whatever they are interested in. What is most important is the developing of desired skills such as problem-solving, decision making, critical thinking and other higher order thinking skills. This is one of the fundamental points of progressive education.…
- 1932 Words
- 8 Pages
Good Essays -
Schools tend to believe that only certain topics are appropriate for an academic environment. While other topics may not be traditional, that does not mean they are without merit. Graff agrees, when he writes, “We assume that it’s possible to wax intellectual about Plato, Shakespeare, the French Revolution, and nuclear fission, but not about cars, dating, fashion, sports, TV or video games” (381). Graff’s point is that even if a student’s knowledge is not traditional, it should still be recognized as important. If educators would attempt to use what knowledge a student does possess, and channel it into traditional academics, students may be more receptive and better able to learn traditional subjects.…
- 688 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
John Dewey wanted to enhance socialism throughout the United States through educational reforms. He believed that learning should be doing instead of conventional styles. He was the first to introduce the field trip into modern education, it allowed the students to interact with the environment and this technique vastly enhanced their learning. John Dewey was all about experimenting, especially when it came to the education system. He opened two Progressive schools throughout his life, these schools were all about experimenting new, socialistic, methods.…
- 468 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
As it stands right now, I am faced with a dilemma based on the methods in which I have taught in the past, and the new methods in which I feel are more suited for todays learning environment. Our social and educational community is divided on whether traditional or more modern methods of teaching are more successful. In my opinion, every method in teaching is the same. They deliver a message to the students and are generally retained and modified for their use. With this being said, there are obviously pros and cons to either approach to instruction.…
- 659 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
But, David Foster Wallace and Derrick Jensen have also given their knowledge of what the “real education” is. In “Walking on Water” by Derrick Jensen, he brings us into his school life. He uses his experience, like the three horrible lessons he learned when he was a student, to show that he is on the side against the traditional education system. He emphasizes that schools should not kill children’s creativity. Moreover, the real education is about self-discovery. Besides, the article “This Is Water” by David Foster Wallace is the commencement speech, lectured at Kenyon College. He states that we should focus more on finding our right way of thinking, like how to cognize others to not be arrogant. Also, Wallace argued avoiding default setting is important. After I had read Jensen and Wallace’s article, I learned that a “real” education is not about teaching lessons from the books or how to get good grades in the college. In “Walking on Water,” a “real” education is more about being creative, learning to discover yourself; and in “This Is Water,” it is about…
- 1371 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
In the Essay My Pedagogic Creed the author John Dewey lets us know that learning begins at birth and from one person being born in the world, society is getting educated from that. He says that true education is the result of a child's experiences and what his environment demand of him.With education one can emerge from their original narrowness and find that they belong to a particular group. In Summerhill, the whole school was based on this idea of freedom. Attending classes was optional, students had a say in what the school did and teachers were not allowed to yell at students. Sounds good right?…
- 471 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
John Dewey was an American philosopher, psychologist and educational reformer whose ideas have been influential in education and social reform. Dewey is known as the founder of the progressive education movement. He argued that it was the job of education to encourage individuals to develop their full potential as human beings. Dewey 's educational theories were presented in a variety of books he authored. Several continuous themes ring true in most of Dewey’s books. They include his frequent argument that education and learning are social and interactive processes, thus school should be considered a social institution where social reform can and ought to take place. In addition, he believed that students thrive in an environment where they are allowed to experience and interact with the curriculum so all students should have the opportunity to take part in their own learning. He was especially critical of forms of memorization learning where repetition of facts and information was exercised. He argued that children should learn by experience. Rather than just gaining knowledge, Dewey believed that students should develop skills, habits and attitudes necessary for them to solve a wide variety of problems. Dewey’s legacy of the importance of experiential learning remains to this day. There are a number of schools across the United States that follow his theories and methods of…
- 950 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
An education is the sum of all of the knowledge and skill that one obtains over time. Traditional classrooms fill students with key information that they transfer onto an answer sheet. An alternative style of teaching is to allow the students to formulate their own thoughts with minimal direction. Neither of these teaching methods provide students with an optimal education, but a mixture creates an ideal education by allowing students to analyze information in two complementary ways. Up until this point in my life, I have had a quality education because I have had the opportunity to experience this combination of learning styles as a student in both a traditional classroom and a discussion based learning environment.…
- 823 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Dewey, John. The School and Society; Being Three Lectures. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, 1899.…
- 4574 Words
- 19 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The progressive education movement aimed to make schools more effective agencies of society. During the 1920’s education focused on scientific techniques while progressive educators focused on human development (1/30/02). Dewey is also known for his book The School and Society. In this book he explains how the ideas of different people and society are connected to education.…
- 499 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
“Letter by letter; syllable by syllable, the child learns to read and in good time can convey to all the domestic circle the sense of Shakespeare” (Emerson 191). The teacher presents one way for her pupils to learn and that is the only correct way. The students have no room to be creative and to imagine new possibilities for completing a task. The teacher sees the student’s way as wrong. This forced method of teaching does not work for a student. He cannot focus and understand what the teacher explains so he gives up. He breaks down. He cries and hates school. This student has zero say in his education, so he has a false view of true learning and hates it. Providing students an opportunity to actually become involved with how they learn allows them to feel excited about learning. Sitting in a desk all day does not appeal to the learning style of most students, but they are sadly stuck with it in the modern learning environment of public…
- 684 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
References: “I believe that education, therefore, is a process of living and not a preparation for future living.”…
- 702 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
[63] Michael Glassman. 2001. Dewey and Vygotsky: Society, Experience, and Inquiry in Educational Practice. Educational Researcher, 30 (4), 13.…
- 5640 Words
- 23 Pages
Powerful Essays -
John Dewy was an educator and a philosophy. He began his teaching career in 1884 at the University of Michigan. In 1894, John Dewey started an experimental primary school at the University of Chicago based on the principle of learning through doing. Dewey believed that students should focus on interaction with the present. Dewey began to investigate the mental development in children and how effective is the educational system. Dewey philosophy of nature is that human experiences are not without challenge and individual must live well with the process of change.…
- 502 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Democracy in its most basic form is a government run by the people. But what would become of the government if the people were ill-informed and ignorant? John Dewey, the father of experimental education, argued that for a democratic government to succeed it must entail a thorough and relevant educational system, a democratic education. All too often formal education simply teaches general skills and has unchanging subject matter predetermined for all students. Dewey argued that an education which adequately prepares the student for life outside the classroom cannot be reserved for the elite few. Instead, he envisions a high school which properly upholds a democratic government by presenting students with relevant problems; one which uses observation and gathered information to develop social insight and interest: a true democratic education. John Dewey’s argument that the success of a democracy is dependent on a formal education can be seen in today’s world through examples of people rising over social boundaries though an education, but can also be refuted by the notion of a formal education stifling creativity; in the end however, the success of a democracy is not based on the institution but instead upon the individual.…
- 1327 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays