Preview

The Yes Side Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
489 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Yes Side Analysis
The book Taking Sides written by Glenn L. Koonce questions “Is There Support for Arming Teachers in school?” The author includes both side of the stories, the yes side is written by Nirvi Shah, and Trump spoke on behalf of the National School Safety and Security Services, which supported the no side. Both of sides have great support for their ideas, for example Shah says that the school officials are usually the first responders to the situation, while they cannot do anything to aid, because they are not armed. While Trump says that well trained law enforcement officer should tackle on bad situations that involves guns. They both have good arguments on if the school staff should be armed or should they just really on well-trained officers for …show more content…
He has point that all the school officials are the first responders to the bad situation but they cannot do anything without a gun. Some school districts are allowing the teachers to carry a concealed weapon, where the police station is not close enough for them to respond quickly enough. Schools are just trying to just handle a bad situation until the help arrive. Some of the schools staff said that they would rather attack the intruder rather then let the situation get worse. They forget that if they were to die by the intruders gun, the rest of the people they were suppose to protect are now vulnerable. If a bad situation were to raise the, school staff that is present would be able to control the situation with a gun. The author is trying to support that the teachers should be armed, while he is giving reason why they should not be, like he said that practicing shooting is important, but the school staff might hurt the students they are trying to protect. The schools that are located within one mile of a police station are defenseless for five minutes until the police arrive. The teachers that would be selected to carry a concealed weapon would also put on major responsibilities on

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    This Article is about gun violence within our schools. This article aims to address this issue by looking at the cause of the problem. First it points out the lack of morals and values in young adults and children. One of the main causes given is the acceptance of American violence. Last, this article looks at our nations failed gun control laws.…

    • 497 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    This took place at Taft Union High School near Bakersfield, California. This school shooting started because the student was a victim of bullying and he wanted revenge. The student came to school and shot one student and missed another. He called the student who was bullying him, and the came out of hiding and apologized, but the teacher, Ryan Heber, interrupted and he came face to face with the 16- year-old student, who was armed. Heber wasn’t sure with this if the student was either, going to put the weapon down or continue shooting. While the student was distracted, Supervisor Kim Fields took the rest of the students so they could escape. Finally, the shooter surrendered and the police took the student into custody. Friday, the next day, school was cancelled due to the situation, but counseling sessions were held that morning for teachers or students who wished to attend. Before Heber spoke to the shooter, the student who was shot in the process was in a critical, yet a stable condition. Kern County Sheriff, Donny Youngblood said “The name of the student wasn’t released, and is debating whether he will be charged as an adult or not.” KDET reported “Heber is a well-known and liked science teacher and was a graduate at Taft and with the situation the Heber family will be there for him with emotional support.” The Taft shooting was the latest school shooting in the U.S., and it launched a big debate whether teachers should carry weapons to protect themselves and others in case of another shooting. Immediately after the shooting, parents went to the school to pick up their children and express concern about the school security. A parent reported “We’re going to protect our students a lot more, and it goes to show that there is one bad apple out there.”…

    • 454 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Arming teachers will also increase the operating cost of school districts that are already short on funding. We hear each year that schools are being forced to cut back programs for the students or the salary of teachers. By arming teachers we would add to that cost by requiring firearm training for those that are authorized to carry a firearm. Additionally will the school district use their own range as law enforcement does? Who will have the qualifications to operate this range? If teachers don’t have their own range there will still be added costs to use a range to train or qualify teachers and staff. Adding more costs to school budgets will only decrease the level of education that children receive by cutting educational things out to make room for arming teachers.…

    • 325 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Despite the numerous parents and staff that are in favor of the new transition of teachers with guns there are a few that are not as adaptable with this change as others are. Teachers such as Ms. Moffis that stated, “Traditionally in this area, schools have already been a very safe and welcoming community,” referring to teachers having guns in the classroom, she added, “Nobody’s ever thought about needing that kind of thing at school.” This coming from a town that is well versed in handling guns within their own community and training their children at an early age the proper understanding of firearms.…

    • 411 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The author’s view is that Guns when legally carried should be permitted on campus. He largely holds these views because of the lower risk of rape or other violent crime. In this article he uses the story of Amanda Collins who has a concealed carry permit and was unable to defend herself from rape. He also lists some studies that he believes prove that allowing guns on campus greatly lowers the defendants chance of being injured or killed. Specifically, he lists a study done by Gray Kleck, that states only 26 of 200 people used a gun to defend themselves from rape in all 26 cases preventing the…

    • 109 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The issue regarding arming teachers in schools has been a really hot topic lately with the numerous shootings in schools and on campuses. Many schools are asking themselves if they should go through with training teachers and staff and some schools have started doing so. Even though most schools have not allowed teachers to carry a concealed firearm, some teachers like Kelly Blake, a teacher of agriculture at Fleming School in Colorado, reports that she “wants her students to be protected at all times.” Other teachers along with Blake have looked at the arming teachers situation like this as well because they feel like they have the right to bare arms and protect themselves. Along with giving…

    • 318 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Concealed Carry Case Study

    • 1549 Words
    • 7 Pages

    The New York Times author, Dave Phillips, creates an article titled Grappling with Guns on Campus. Throughout his writing, he states several interviews with people in relation to the school who actively has a problem with or without the concealed carry law in Texas. For example, he writes, “I (Professor Lisa Moore) love what I do. I consider teaching and learning to be a sacred vocation. We want to do everything we can to promote it. I don’t see guns as a part of that. So, no, I won’t be allowing guns in my office.” Professor Moore is strongly against allowing firearms on campus locations, because she believes weapons do not matter when it comes to the subject of schooling. Author Phillips writes again, “It’s not that I’m (Huyler Marsh) afraid of getting attacked all the time. It’s more like a fire extinguisher or a seat belt… If I call 911, it might be ten minutes before they get here.” Despite two opposing viewpoints, it is always better to be safe than sorry, because no one knows what another person will…

    • 1549 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Biden heads a panel to Obama for more control on the guns. Just because we have gun control, it won't keep people from buying guns from individuals. Teachers and staff at Harrold, Texas, school are carrying concealed guns. Teachers see their job not only as a educator but as a protector. People talk about putting armed people such as cops, around the building,…

    • 399 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The issue of policing schools has been widely debated across the country. As a high school student myself, I believe policing schools would be extremely beneficial and would enhance the safety of schools everywhere. The article “Does America Really Need More Cops in Schools?” by Susan Ferriss states, “The only way to stop a bad guy with a gun is with a good guy with a gun," National Rifle Association executive vice president Wayne LaPierre said after a young man shot his way into his former grammar school on December 14 in Newtown, Connecticut, and killed 20 first-graders and 6 educators.” The recent attacks on schools has raised many red flags concerning the safety of students. With this being noted, it is time school officials took action in effort of halting these vicious attacks.…

    • 731 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Imagine the feeling of safety as if it is constantly within our control or ability, people that are in possession of a concealed weapon are aware of the responsibility and the results of what can happen when using a concealed weapon. Safety of teachers, all other employees and students at a learning intuition can greatly improve if the staff could be armed with concealed weapons. Also we must remember that all citizens of the United States have the right to carry and own a weapon as guaranteed by the second amendment of the constitution of the United States of America. Safety and security could be greatly improved with teachers and faculty carrying concealed weapons on campus, therefore, the teachers and faculty increase security; the safety of the students can also be achieved.…

    • 945 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    What message does it send if we suggest through armed school personnel that our minds are not enough? “Clearly our students and staffs need to study, work, and play in safe surroundings; chances of having any breach of security need to be diminished. However, classroom teachers are not called to perform such duties.”, Lloyd E. Sheaffer. The students need to know that they are safe and with guns on campus they fear they are not safe. Kids also have a conscious too they know when something's up they will not feel safe with their conscious telling them they have guns around them. Today's teachers build emotional connections with their pupils; they encourage feelings of trust and confidence. Guns and other excessive security measures do not make kids feel safer and they increase their perception that they are unsafe," she said. If they have to go through metal detectors or pass by an armed guard, they believe they are not in a safe…

    • 334 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Many people, including the state governor of New Jersey Chris Christie, believe that having firearms on school campuses will be nothing but a disturbance to both students and teachers. "I am not someone who believes that having multiple armed guards in every school is something that will enhance the learning environment,” he explained, "you don't want to make this an armed camp for kids."(Portnoy) This is the most valid argument for the opposition of armed guards in schools because kids/students are the main focus of the issue. One of the most important things regarding education is whether students are able to go to school in environment where they feel safe. In some situations many students may be uneasy in the presence for firearms where they will simply be a distraction. But there are times when extreme situations call for extreme measures, and the protection of students across the nation calls requires extreme measures. Superintendent MaryEllen Elia of the Hillsborough County Public Schools in Florida said in a release to the lobby, “Let me tell you that I wish this wasn’t necessary. I wish we didn’t have to consider any of these strategies but the world has changed since I was in school. It changed again on December 14th.”(Byrd) Placing armed guards in schools is an action that people across the board are opposed to, but even Elia believes “We have a role and a responsibility.” that we should not “wait around hoping our students and staff are safe.” (Byrd) By reacting to the killings that have taken place across the nation Florida and many other states are taking steps in preventing more lives being…

    • 2012 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    A gun does not prevent a person from causing a horrible tragedy. Guns can easily be used inappropriately and possibly even land in the hands of the wrong person. Teachers do not have similar proper training and experience like police officers do. They will not know how to react on the spot if a future shooting occurs. Many can agree that guns are used for protection, but that might not be the case when it comes to school…

    • 1072 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Arming Teachers

    • 469 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The issue at hand here is “Is There Support for Arming Teachers in Schools?” This issue is argued by both Nirvi Shah, and The National School Safety and Security Services organization. Nirvi Shah believes yes there is support for arming teachers in schools, while The National School Safety and Security Services organization believes no there isn’t. Shah believes yes because there are already teachers who are armed in some districts. Shah’s argument is basically that the law passed in Utah has caused school shootings to end in Utah. Shah interviewed Mr. Dorn, the Georgia school safety consultant and Mr. Dorn stated “Sandy Hook didn’t look anything like Columbine. Columbine didn’t look like Pearl, Miss.,” Shah states that “Ms. Sorenson, a 13-year teaching veteran, is among those bolstered by the fact that there haven’t been school shootings in Utah since the law changed.”…

    • 469 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many big gun free zones have been attacked by terrorist and many people have died. The most common gun free zones to attack are schools and that is because they have the worst protection. "Eliminating or restricting firearms for public self-defense doesn't make our citizens safer; it makes them targets," political commentator and former US secretary of Education William J. Bennett wrote for CNN after the elementary school massacre. "If we're going to have a national debate about guns, it should be acknowledged that guns, in the hands of qualified and trained individuals subject to background checks, prevent crime and improve public safety" (Jackson). Many people do agree with this because of all the school conflicts. Some people do not think that arming teachers and students to protect themselves from threats is a good idea. The US secretary of education thinks that arming the staff will make children safer, and by denying anyone the right to conceal and carry makes that place a bigger target for brutal attacks because no one can stop it. "At the present time, assailants can, and do, target these students knowing full well that their victims are not permitted to carry protection," Deal said, "even those who are weapons carry license holders, because they are either going to or coming from a campus where no weapons are allowed" (Bluestein). Targeting defenseless people is a coward’s…

    • 1809 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays