Preview

The Pros And Cons Of Gentrification

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
887 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Pros And Cons Of Gentrification
Gentrification, when wealthy individuals buy and renovate houses in poor neighborhoods, a word often associated with the displacement of poor residents of run-down urban neighborhoods. Gentrification has its pro’s and con’s, so naturally the supporters list the positives, while non-supporters do the opposite. In “Go Forth and Gentrify?” by Dashka Slater, the author explores the positives of gentrification for the community, newcomers, and longtime residents. Dashka Slater, a journalist who often appears in the New York Times, Sierra, and San Francisco Magazine. Mother Jones, a liberal magazine, published “Go Forth and Gentrify” in July 2007 encouraging home buyers to buy houses in poor urban neighborhoods. During this time housing prices were decreasing and the housing bubble was about to burst. Many families lost their homes to foreclosure and had nowhere to go. As a suggestion, Slater urges readers that it is alright to move into a poor neighborhood because the home buyer will positively impact the neighborhood. …show more content…
Slater reminds readers that poor neighborhoods were once thriving but when the white middle class left the city for the suburbs the neighborhoods became impoverished. She includes the fact that though gentrification does have its downsides, the newcomers often bring money and jobs to poverty stricken neighborhoods. The neighborhoods also improve once gentrified, the author uses an example of her own neighborhood. She explains how the neighborhood’s property value tripled and how better businesses moved into the neighborhood. In the article she urges readers to move into poor urban neighborhoods and gentrify. To conclude her article she includes testimonial-like stories of gentrifiers and their contributions to their

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Best Essays

    Professor of Urban Affairs and Planning at Hunter College, Peter Kwong once said, “Living in this gentrification environment is much more difficult for residents. Actually, what they’re doing is killing the indigenous culture.” This process of gentrification that Kwong is referring to is defined as the purchasing and renovating of low-priced properties, usually by higher income individuals, in often deteriorated urban neighborhoods. The result is an influx of wealthier residents, and in effect, higher property prices. Gentrification applies to many different aspects of society, especially in urban communities. It is important to analyze the complex process…

    • 3731 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Better Essays

    Plozano. "People 's World." Chicago Gentrification Is a Global Issue » Peoplesworld. N.p., n.d. Web. 04 June 2013.…

    • 1463 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The class has broadened my thinking process quite a bit now since the beginning of class. The Oral presentation on gentrification in El barrio has changed my outlook on how communities in the united states are being manipulated to change because of the area they live in and how that area is in need of change but not for the betterment of the people that live in that community but for the investors and other people that are trying to move in to change the demographics of that community. These kind of communities are hurt the most because sometimes the property is valued more than the culture that is being asked to step aside.…

    • 712 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Growing up in East Austin, one would be accustomed to seeing rundown neighborhoods inhabited mostly by African American and Hispanic working-class families. In the past few years though, the view has drastically changed. Now brightly colored two-story homes housing affluent Caucasian families occupy the once dilapidated areas. The previously desolated lots are now the future sites of lofts and condominiums. The recent changes in East Austin are a clear sign of gentrification. Gentrification is the extremely evident process of displacement. Revitalizing a derelict neighborhood favors the entire community, not just the ones with money. However, revitalization and gentrification are two different matters; gentrification favors one class over another. The gentrifying of East Austin is a precarious process that is reaping negative effects on the preexisting community. While the middle-class is being attracted to the working-class area, established residents are inescapably being squeezed out. Pumping new life into the fading heart of a community through gentrification may be beneficial to some, but at what cost? The recent interest in a once forgotten area is not benefiting the current residents; instead, it is displacing them and erasing the community identity.…

    • 1010 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    I intend to discuss the inequity for individuals and communities affected by gentrification and then discuss democracy and equality in just takings' cases. Other issues that will be explored are the government's use of eminent domain in cases where the government needs to use an individual's land for public use. Particularly, where the government desires to build public buildings or support an industry in that area. The inequities would be in the government's abuse of power in those…

    • 1897 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Gentrification, a silent and gradual process that can change a neighborhood completely has displaced a vast amount of people within different areas. What is gentrification exactly? The classic scenario of gentrification is when low working class neighborhoods are transformed into a more attractable and expensive place more suitable for middle class families; a drastic change in standard living. Gentrification has been occurring all throughout the world and has been spreading rapidly, leaving many people without a home. Gentrification has happened since ancient times; in Britain in the third century large villas were being replaced by small shops. Gentry a word derived from genterise an old French word that means “gentle birth.” From Manhattan’s Lower East Side now to Harlem, many places have and are undergoing gentrification. Gentrification has its positives and its negatives which are beneficial to both sides, the old and the new residents. Do the pros outweigh the cons, are the old lower class residents being purposely moved out of an area in order to make a more prosperous? According to several articles and perspectives it all depends in which eyes we view gentrification from either the old residents who feel that the cons and greater than the pros or the view of the homeowner and the government whose intentions are to better the area and make living conditions better. In my opinion gentrification is beneficial in the greater sense that it is helping many people and the neighborhood grow by creating new and better opportunities that were not offered before.…

    • 1447 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gentrification Community

    • 407 Words
    • 2 Pages

    They are unable to investigate if their services are needed in this new particular area, so the decision will be made without the necessary facts that are necessary for the success of the business venture. There is many questions that needs to be explained considering that gentrification supposed to be changing the dynamics of the community in a positive way. So in what way does gentrifying communities have a positive impact on small businesses? Or is the purpose of gentrification to help the economy and to bring demise of the small businesses? In this paper I will follow-up on the changes that occurred after the documentary “My Brooklyn” by Kelly Anderson. There will be interviews with different store owners, and these proprietors will rationalize with us their different experiences as they give an insight from the incidents they have witnessed as a result of gentrification. They will notify in what way their business diverged from the past to…

    • 407 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Some people believe gentrification will benefit poor residents. For example, with higher class people moving in more businesses will open up. If poor residents decide to stay in a gentrified neighborhood they will see “new job opportunities emerge” (Gillespie). As poor…

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    "Poor renters living in areas 'rediscovered' by wealthy and middle-class people find themselves in a constant struggle to avoid being displaced" (Newman). Gentrification is the cause for poverty in lower class society. Because individuals aren’t able to afford the cost of gentrification their becomes a wide variety of major concerns for this topic. It is often argued gentrification improves the economy, reduces crime and brings generating income but this is only an opposing view in this matter. These authors clearly state it does does not improve the economy but affects the wellbeing of owners social aspect of society within displacement, poverty, crime, health and racial…

    • 106 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Gentrification

    • 4785 Words
    • 20 Pages

    Kotkin, Joel. “For Retailers in Some City Centers, Gentrification is a Four-Letter Word.” New York Times. NY, NY. June 27, 1999. Pro Quest.…

    • 4785 Words
    • 20 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gentrification causes poor residents to be put out, and wealthy residents to move in. Some people just have low-income and have to live a certain way to get by in life. Wealthy people don’t need to live any certain way because they have the money to get by. Gentrification comes and raises the rent and displaces the low-income and poor people, so the wealthy people can come live in their new and improved homes. Gentrification has no reason to raise the rent because the poor need places to live and the wealthy has plenty of places to live.…

    • 496 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gentrification In America

    • 589 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Gentrification has always be a controversial subject in which it particularly deals with pushing out the blacks, and moving in the whites. Although many people believe this is how gentrification works, it is actually much more complex. In modern America, gentrification is more of an inconspicuous act in which the lower class is pushed out, rather than just a specific race. Although the majority of the lower class happen to be African Americans and latinos, it is focused upon the removal of the lower class, and rise of the middle and upper class. Gentrification is a constant cycle throughout cities especially in New York, towns such as Williamsburg, have been severely gentrified by middle class and upper class New Yorkers. While gentrification…

    • 589 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Benefits Of Gentrification

    • 1403 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Gentrification is a process of the city development. It usually means some middle and upper middle class people start to move into a relatively poor community. The community will be then reconstructed by opening more good restaurants, coffee places and big grocery stores that meet these people’s needs and preferences. For those poor people who have been living in the community for a long time, they have to worry about the living cost in this upgraded community and many of them are not willing to see the gentrification happen in their community. However, if you look at the gentrification problem in a more comprehensive perspective, it is not hard to find the gentrification will not…

    • 1403 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Socialization

    • 765 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the paper “The Code of the Streets” by Elijah Anderson, it summarizes and presents us the issues of the poor inner-city neighborhoods. Anderson distinguishes these inner-city neighborhoods by splitting it into two groups. These groups would “decent” and “street” residents. Although they live in the same vicinity of these inner-city neighborhoods, they hold different ways of living and different values. These two types of groups interact with each other and sets values for themselves on how they will carry themselves as they grow up into adults.…

    • 765 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The term ‘gentrification’ has myriads of interpretations from different geographers, and sociologists. Ever since, there has been protracted debate on its methodology, consequences and whether it constitutes a dominant or residual urban form. The term ‘gentrification’ was first coined by the Marxist urban geographer Ruth Glass (Glass, 1964) to describe the influx of wealthier individuals into cities or neighbourhoods who replace working or lower-classes already living there by using London districts such as Islington as her example. On the other hand, Smith and Williams (1986, p.1) define gentrification as “the rehabilitation of working class and derelict housing and the consequent transformation of an area into a middle-class neighbourhood.” Whilst Hamnett (2003, p.2402) builds on Glass’s definition of gentrification as a process involving class connotations and offers a more comprehensive definition incorporating economic views when he defines gentrification as a “social and spatial manifestation of the transition from industrial to a post industrial urban economy based on financial, business and creative services, with associated changed in the nature and location of work, in occupational class structure, earnings and incomes, life styles and the structure of the housing market”. Smith (1987) supply side (which focuses on investments within urban structure) and offers his ‘rent-gap’ theory of gentrification whereas proponents of the Feminist perspective consider the notion of patriarchy, changing gender relations and feminisation of labour markets. (Dutton, 1998, p.32) Therefore, with the myriads of interpretations by various authors (simultaneously enlarging the gentrification literature), it is evident that gentrification means differently to individuals depending on which school of though one ascribes to. Curran (2008, p.537) correctly points out the sentiments of this author that vast literature on gentrification…

    • 2527 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays