Preview

The Moral Challenges Of Driverless Cars Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
697 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Moral Challenges Of Driverless Cars Analysis
Hi everyone,

For my summary I chose an article called 'The Moral Challenges of Driverless Cars' by Keith Kirkpatrick. I picked this article because my aim is to do my thesis on the ethics of self-driving cars, and Kirkpatrick gives a good general introduction to the topic. In doing so, he highlights potential issues, as well as the likely benefits that drive the development of self-driving cars.

I like the topic because it is a practical ethical problem which has real world implications. And given that large companies such as Google and BMW and working on such technology, with Google saying that they aim to have self-driving cars on the market within five years, it is a pressing issue.

Link to article below.

Cheers,

Stephen

Summary:
…show more content…
Given that such technology is a recent development, philosophical work on the topic is in its infancy. However, due to the rate at which technology advances, this issue is timely, and Kirkpatrick gives a good overview of the ethics of self-driving …show more content…
As such, we will eventually reach a stage where we must decide how to program self-driving cars to respond to an unavoidable accident. In such events, drivers are typically faced with a split-second choice involving at least two less than desirable outcomes. However, with self-driving cars, we are forced to explicitly determine the rules by which such cars will act when confronted with an accident scenario, which is the crux of the ethics of self-driving cars.
In terms of programming, Kirkpatrick offers an example of possible rules which a self-driving car could be programmed to follow. Namely, self-driving cars could be set to prioritise the safety of its occupants. Or, they could be programmed to choose the course of action that has the most likelihood of resulting in the least amount of harm for all those involved in an accident. For example, faced with a wayward pedestrian, a self-driving car could discern that the likelihood of injury is lowest for al involved if it swerves into a telephone pole in order to miss the unprotected

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Alex Davies, the author of the article “Congress Could Make Self-Driving Cars Happen-or Ruin Everything” has written to show how much congress really is included in the creation of these new automated cars. The new technology in development “permeates so many parts of society: public safety, privacy, the environment, liability and insurance law, employment, urban planning, and more.” The technology being engineered is so new that no one agrees on how the finished product will work or how to know when a car is equipped to fully run on its own. The article talks on how urgent it is to companies engineering the cars to have some sort of government guidelines approved quickly. This is so important because the engineers designing the cars are unable…

    • 230 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The transition itself to self driving cars could be costly and dangerous. Self driving cars would be very expensive, so not every person could afford to own one. The danger of the switch is that self driving cars have to take into account the cars that are still operated by people: “‘autonomous drive vehicles are a wonderful idea, but the transition from driver-operated to driverless is likely to be filled with accidents.’ For instance, while approaching a traffic light, a self-driving car calculates that if it speeds up a little bit, it will be able to pass through the light, but the driver in the car in front decides to stop because he thinks he won’t make it on time. What do you think the result will be?” (Ramirez). The most controversial part of self driving cars however, is how the computer inside the car will decide whose life is more important in the case of an inevitable accident. “the cars will be designed to avoid accidents, but ‘If it happens where there is a situation where a car couldn’t escape, it’ll go for the smaller thing.’ But what if the smaller thing is a child?” (Spangler). It is very difficult to determine whose life is more important, and even more difficult to program a car to…

    • 847 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In " Will your driverless car kill you so others live?" author Eric Schwitzgebel argues that driverless car may make crucial desions when in conflict, that may risk your life. He targets the audience, by putting them in this type of situation, discussing the dangers the cars would bring to its passsengers. Schwitzgebel contradicts his argument by stating that self driving car may actually be useful for young teens who can not keep their eyes on the road.…

    • 78 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Senior transportation editor at Business Insider, Cadie Thompson, in her article, The 3 Biggest Ways Self-Driving Cars Will Improve our Lives, published in June 2016, addresses the topic of driverless cars and argues that they will have an overall positive impact on our world. Thompson supports her claim by utilizing a lot of data and statistics to back up her statements, and also by establishing her credibility through her use of language. The author’s overall purpose is to discuss the benefits of driverless cars in order to make the audience more aware and open to this topic. Thompson employs a scientific tone in her article in order to emphasize the ideas presented.…

    • 360 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Every Self-Driving car will have a 360 viewing camera and sensors to make the car safer. High end sensors and cameras are going to be put in these vehicles. The sensors for example will show the driver what it sees. It makes out the farthest to the closest objects;cones,lights, accidents, pulled over cars,etc...The cameras and…

    • 1525 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Many popular name brand car companies expect driverless cars to be on the market by 2020, and for all cars to be driverless by 2025. The idea of a car that can drive, navigate, and park itself was an idea only to be heard of in the movies, but now it is in it’s final stages of testing. The self driving car is currently in production of prototypes to be demonstrated to the public by popular name brand companies like: Tesla, Mercedes Benz, BMW, and more. With the introduction of a driverless car, the lives of many drivers will become much easier and create a positive effect.. The self driving car consists of an advanced programmed computer, as well as many sensors that help guide and calculate smart decisions for the car to make. A car that drives…

    • 1454 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Self Driving Dbq

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Anyone can hack into the systems, causing peculiar incidents like two cars constantly bumping into each other. The incidents would be part of a statistic. Document D’s statement on the self-driving cars’ speed is unsatisfactory. The reason is that people drive faster than twenty miles per hour during commuting hours, and it would worsen commute. On a common day, it takes, at least, thirty minutes or less to go across the Bay Bridge. With the self-driving cars, it would slow down the traffic on the popular commute areas. Therefore, self-driving cars will take years to develop the ability to be as fast as humans in the ability of…

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “Avoiding Crashes with Self-Driving Cars,” by Samuel Minick, he proclaims that self-driving cars can prevent the car from drifting if the driver is distracted or tired. He states how the car can provide an extra set of eyes whether it’s parking or checking for a blind spot. Minick’s main argument is that self-driving cars can do multiple things, sometimes things that humans can’t even do. Minick explains the benefits to having self-driving cars and the things that it is capable of. He also clearly states that the cost can be an issue with the new sensors and technology; however, it reduces the number of accidents greatly and allows the public to travel independently. Minick agrees with McFarland and Rockall’s claims because Minick believes that self-driving cars are able to do many things: Parallel Park, be an extra set of eyes and check for other vehicles approaching. They would also all agree on the fact that even though the self-driving car technology is known to be extremely expensive, it would allow people to travel and ensure less…

    • 1065 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Self-Driving Cars Are Bad

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Although they may reduce the number of accidents they won’t prevent them completely. There is no legal procedure for how a traffic accident case will be handled. When a car accident occurs involving a self-driving car than who will be at fault, the owner of the vehicle, the car manufacturer, the software developer. There is really no way of determining who is at fault. We know that the car's sensors can pick up traffic signals such as stoplights and road signs but they cannot detect human signals. For example, if someone was directing traffic using hand signals the vehicle’s sensors could not detect the movement and actions of the traffic director, which could lead to car accidents and pedestrian injury. There is no backup system if the main system in the car were to fail. There would have to be a way of switching from self-driving mode to manual control mode. Meaning in the event of a system failure the driver will have to take over and depending on the situation and the reaction of the driver could depend on the outcome. For example, the car could be idling out of the driveway when the system fails, or it could be driving 70 miles per hour down the freeway. The driver could react calmly and carefully and pull over off the road or away from others or could panic and cause the car to go out of control which would cause an…

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    One of the biggest arguments with self driving cars is safety and what if one of the cars malfunction. There are many new models of cars that are self driving and there have been very few accidents. People will say that there are very few accidents because there are not many of them on the streets. Self driving cars can be dangerous but…

    • 440 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The subject is being researched and developed calling them autonomous vehicles exclaiming the need to ensure the passengers are safe when driving by removing the human error of being distracted. Yet, the major issues preventing it will not be easy to overcome. Unless all cars would be autonomous no amount of sensors, cameras. or computer programming will be able to cope with other driver’s instincts and actions. Concerning cost more technology will come at a larger cost, of which many will be unable to afford. (The self-driving function is stated by) Even still, an autonomous car can crash, or get cashed into just as any other would, only you'd be helplessly along for the ride. The reaction time or decisions made by a car in certain situations may not make sense. To serve as a point think of a natural disaster, flooding could prevent the car from going a certain path or leave it damaged and stuck. If the car is programmed to follow the road what will happen if its blocked, or what if a family wishes to drive through the uncharted woods? Another example is provided by Durbin as he said how “There are still some situations in which humans outperform computers. At a four-way stop, for example, a driver can crane his neck, scan for traffic in any direction and quickly determine the speed of any oncoming vehicles. So far,…

    • 1469 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Self-driving cars would elevate the already serious effects of terrorists. Driverless cars would make it possible for the car to be loaded with explosives and used as a moving bomb or to automatically drive and cause a serious crash because they could be hacked and are not human controlled (Goodman). Safety is always a major concern with cars, whether they are driverless or not. Driverless cars would not be efficient because they could do more harm than help.…

    • 453 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Technology world is changing everyday; especially with cars. People are making a way to make cars driverless. Driverless cars are not the best cars for many reasons in my opinion. For example, they cost too much, they are not safe, and they bring out too many legal issues.…

    • 266 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Self-Driving Cars

    • 3778 Words
    • 16 Pages

    The development of the self-driving car has been in the works for some time and is just the latest in a long history of automotive innovation. Over the years, automakers have introduced many new automotive technologies that have made driving safer and more convenient. Automakers will continue to develop new technologies that offer increased safety and convenience. One of the newest technologies that exist today include a system that keeps a car in the lane and warns the driver when they are veering out of the lane. There is also an advanced cruise control system that matches a car’s speed with the vehicle in front of it. Another system alerts the driver if there are obstacles near them when they are backing up. And there is also a system that parallel parks a car by itself. (Silberg, Wallace, 7)…

    • 3778 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Self-Driving Occupations

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages

    We see this technology evolving at a fast pace with fierce competition amongst many big-name companies. Many are researching and implementing the latest technology or submitting a patent for that design. Technology is great for society but with safety in mind that must be the main priority. Personal safety is one of the main uncertainties when it comes down to employing self-driving vehicles on our roadways. The potential for injuries that will be talked about are whiplash, concussions and other injuries from vehicle accidents. Once the safety measures are in place and functions as intended we will start to see companies using these vehicles to help with cost saving measures. Drivers will be replaced and jobs lost, though this will be a large issue amongst those effected there will be benefits which will be saving money and limiting accidents. We will likely see a great deal of resistance for mass quantities of self-driving vehicles but with deaths and injuries on the rise each year on our road ways we need solutions to help lower statistics. Self-Driving vehicles may be the answer to those problems. Driverless vehicles are designed to reduce the overall risk for traffic accidents by various sensors and features. Many vehicles already utilize some form of driver assistance on the roadways, technology will only build on this foundation that has been laid. With more and more states allowing autonomous vehicles driving on their roads don’t be surprised to see a driver less vehicle heading in your…

    • 775 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays