Preview

The Melon Grower by Alice Oswald: Decline of a Couple's Marriage

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
490 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Melon Grower by Alice Oswald: Decline of a Couple's Marriage
'The melon grower' Alice Oswald
'The Melon grower' by Alice Oswald explains the slow decline in a couples marriage. 'The melon grower' is the man, Oswald uses his care for the melons to demonstrate the mans disinterest in his wife and his lack of emotion towards her. As the poem leads on through the twelve stanzas it becomes increasingly sad and disfunctional however in parts showing a comical side. The frequent use of the pronouns 'he' and 'she' in the poem proves the disfuntion and seperation of the couple as their marriage falls apart.

The 12, 3 line stanzas are biographical. The story has been told to the author from the prospective of the wife who is clearly unhappy in her marriage. We don't know fully how her husband is feeling about the disintigration of his marriage, only of his obssessive interest in his melons.We are given a brief insight into his emotions when he was in church and he sang 'O Lord how long shall the wicked....?" and then, He prayed, with his thumbs on his eys. Were we given a glimpse of his own dispair?

In the first few opening stanzas there is a sense of seperation through the pronouns 'he' and 'she' there is no 'they' showing that they no longer spend time together. The wife seeks the husbands attention as he spends the majority of his time out of the house with his plants 'She threw a slipper at him' this domestic item contrasts with the plants and highlights the difference between their seperate lives, it is almost as if she is physically throwing the house at him in despiration.

The poem doesn't just describe the end of the friendship and communication of the couple but also the end of their sexual realtionship 'If I can sex' he said 'the flowers, very gently i'll touch their parts with a pollen brush made with rabbit hairs.' this qoutefrom stanza 5 highlights the abscence of sex within their relationship, he is more intimate with the melons.

Stanza eight shows us the passing of time, the relationship still limping

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In ‘The Farmer’s Bride’, the Farmer marries a girl without getting to know her. As the marriage progresses, the wife’s mental illness gradually develops – at first she ‘turn[s] afraid’, until she tries to run away, and will only speak to animals. This causes the farmer to become jealous, impatient and possibly mentally unstable. In the fourth stanza, the farmer describes his wife as she is to nature – ‘sweet... to her wild self’, then asks ‘but what to me?’ This short sentence reflects his inability to comprehend why she is so ‘sweet’ to nature but not to him – this is the source of his frustration. ‘Her wild self’ could be interpreted as the farmer saying she is herself in the wild, or as him calling her wild. This frustration is displayed in the last stanza, where he says ‘’Tis but a stair betwixt us’. The stairs suggest that the farmer thinks that if he can get past this obstacle between the couple, he can have a normal relationship with his wife, although in reality, it is her heart that is closed to him, not just her door. The final stanza is laid out so that it looks like stairs, for a visual as well as verbal picture. The word ‘but’ could represent his frustration – to the point that he considers forcing himself upon her. The farmer wants passion, but he does not consider love to be important anymore.…

    • 817 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The poem is written in the past tense, and tells a love story between Anyone and Noone. Only in one stanza is the present tense used, as they "dream their sleep", which is a happy ending to a bittersweet story. The women and men of the town were not concerned with anyone or Anyone. They didn't acknowledge anyone unless the other person benefited them. The children in the town were innocent, so they were able to see the love between Anyone and Noone. As time passed, the children were no longer innocent, they have grown up and become the "women and men". The cycle of birth, childhood, adulthood and decline is very apparent in each stanza. The lovers were at the top of the hierarchy, individuals who were happy and didn't blend in with everyone else. The mundane "women and men" who live a life of inadequacy and lastly, the children, who will become the "women and men" and repeat the cycle of dullness.…

    • 673 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    I sense that the speaker is a male. I get this feeling from the way he hides his pain. Concealing your feelings is often considered the masculine thing to do, and the speaker does this throughout the entire poem. He is writing about a past experience in his childhood. I sense that the poem comes from an outside perspective, yet not too far out. The speaker is not the one doing the fighting, but, perhaps he is watching it–living it–as the child of two disputing parents. The stanza "certain doors were locked at night, feet stood for hours outside them . . . " indicates to me that the speaker was a child when this took place. He watched as his father stood outside the locked bedroom door, shouting to be let in. He watched as the dishes piled up in the sink and his mother was too occupied with the fights to clean them. These are the images that the poem puts into my head,…

    • 960 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    english graphic organizer

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The words in this poem were easy to understand. The word or phrase I found impacted me was “thy vows are all broken” this indicated that the couple was married. It allows for me to feel the despair the author may be feeling.…

    • 479 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The narrator has a swirl of emotions and leaves the house, building on her jealousy for hope. She has no clue where she is going or what she is doing and then an idea hits her, she feels the urge to destroy the marigolds, to take away the hope they seems impossible and misplaced. One day the narrator stomps and smashes the marigolds the reality hits her, this had helped no one, destroying the hope of others, all that ruining the marigolds did was to bring the narrator to a realization ofher childish actions,that she was an adult, and should act like one. That she should create hope for herself and her family by being mature, sophisticated, and helping her parents, not destroy the hope that others had so dearly cared for. She realizes that the old lady had worked hard to nurture and grow her hope, her joy, her marigolds, that destroying them was wrong, and it brought no one else any hope, it just took someone's away. Her childish actions of rebellion had left her. The lines “ and they was the moment that childhood faded and womanhood began. The violent, crazy act was the last act of childhood. For as I gazed at the immobile face with sat and weary eyes, I gazed upon a kind of reality that is hidden to childhood. The witch was no longer a witch but only a lonely old woman who dared to create beauty in the midst so of ugliness and sterility. She had been born in squalor and lived in it all her life ow at the end of tent life she nothing but a falling down hut” communicate these…

    • 1027 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Summer Home - Commentary

    • 631 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The poem uses subtle metaphors to symbolise the hardships Heaney and his wife face in their marriage as can be seen in the first part, “wind off the dumps…fouled nest incubating somewhere?” Summer is not only a symbol of peace and prime of life but also of youth and love. Thus when Heaney says that “the summer gone sour”, it could suggest that the love they initially shared is now degrading. The flowers symbolise romance, and by describing them as ‘loosened flowers’, it could mean that the initial care and love is no longer strong. The flowers and the sex act are the “chrism” to heal and anoint the couple’s wounds. The word ‘taint’ means contaminated, and hence could suggest that their relationship is no longer composed of love but of lust. The difficulties between them are described as a ‘wound’, and hence to heal and anoint the ‘wound’ they have sex. Wounds leave scars and hence, arguments between them are inevitable. Heaney uses ‘cave’s old, dripping dark-’ to describe his wife’s womb, which may contain solutions to the difference between them. He also describes his wife’s breasts as ‘stoups’, thereby giving it a sense…

    • 631 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    It is a simple paragraph arrangement that is written as a story. Expecting her audience to understand who she is talking about when she mentions “He,” (Line 1) she doesn’t feel that it is necessary to explain to the reader who exactly “He” is. The way the poet decided to write this story was not preplanned, it is just a poem about a surprise party her husband or significant other had planned for her. The layout and execution of writing this is very much organic and is easy to understand. Poetry does not always have to be rhythmic or have some kind a pattern to it. The story comes straight from Kenyon’s mind as she pulls memories from it rather than planning everything she is going to write.…

    • 754 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    This poem is appropriate for Songs of Experience rather than for Songs of innocence because if it would be a song of innocence the human mind and soul would want to let the anger out in order to keep their soul clean of any bad thoughts. Innocence is a state of genuine love and naive trust towards all humankind, accompanied by unquestioned belief in Christian Doctrine. Songs of Experience deals with the loss of innocence after exposure to the material world and all of its mortal sin during adult life. This poem shows how the speaker is cultivating his anger and is seeking to destroy his “foe”. At the end of the poem we see how the hatred got the best of him. The anger grew into this poisonous fruit that when his enemy ate it he faced death. Nowhere in this poem it shows that his “foe” had any anger thoughts towards the speaker yet he was so blind by the anger that he probably didn’t even realize it since he was too busy feeding his anger. Also this is a Songs of Experience because at the beginning of the poem we see the wisdom that it has when it tells us "I was angry with my friend; / I told my wrath, my wrath did end." It’s giving us a wise advice for our lives showing that the speaker posses wisdom not “innocence”—stupidity.…

    • 591 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The poem reads to be in the form of introspection, almost as though the speaker is talking to himself. The audience is not given any hint as to where the speaker is, or if there is another individual he is addressing. The speaker is an ambiguous narrator which means he is not all-knowing, but rather vague. The poem consists of four stanzas and is metaphorical reflection of the speaker’s actions, but in none of the stanzas does the speaker criticize himself. In the first stanza he tells us how he feels differently when he is angry with a friend, which, as he tells us is a contrast to how he feels when he is angry with a foe. We are told that when he is angry with a foe, he keeps it to himself, resulting in his wrath mounting, metaphorically referred to as the growth of a plant.…

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    She ties the two poems together by giving her childhood account of wanting a dog. One day a stray approached her and she wanted to keep him so she pleaded with her father. Of course, he said no she couldn’t keep it. Yet somehow the dog ended up living with their family for several years after that. Her examples shed light on her Dad’s sensitive side as well as her Dad’s masculinity and his ability to go back and forth between these characteristics with ease. Surprisingly, I had been so focused on all the differences between men and women that I had missed the boat completely on all the similarities. When you breakdown what this essay is really about the answer is stereotypes. The ones we associate ourselves with and the ones that other people lump categorize us into. Since when did having emotions and expressing emotions become a gender thing or a race thing? Expressing emotions is simply part of being…

    • 1268 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    John Donne The Flea

    • 499 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In the first stanza he says to her ‘’And in this flea our bloods mingled be” this is in response to the flea biting the pair of them. His suggestion is that the couple are united within the flea and their…

    • 499 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Houshold Gods

    • 1074 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The second and third stanzas are from an individual point of view, they represent some of the couple’s possessions recollecting their joyful past. At first, what seems to be a musical instrument belonging to the woman grieves its disuse, stating that it has “so long been silent” and it laments over the days when her “long fingers once caressed [it].” It also introduces a passionate part of the couple’s relationship previously as it asks: “was that how at one time she touched him?” The third stanza…

    • 1074 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There is a couple in this poem; the husband who is a wood maker from a village life and the wife whose status is higher than her companion from the borough. As the husband holds the present, the leftover of the coffin, to the wife, the woman’s facial expression is pale as the sheet. The coincidental thing is that this coffin belongs to John, who also comes from the same place as wife.…

    • 297 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Silence of Women

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The basic plot to the poem is that as a couple ages, the men become nicer and the woman take over the dominant role. After years of being “silent” they cannot take it anymore and they let everything out. It shows a lot of frustration for the women over time. They also feel like they spent their whole life doing everything for this man, and now they are too old and it is too late to do something productive with their lives.…

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mushrooms

    • 624 Words
    • 3 Pages

    One of the idea expressed in this poem is that women were not appreciated within the society. It can be seen from stanza two "acquire the air" and stanza 3 "nobody sees us". Air is one of the basic need as a human being. However, as a woman,you do not have the equal right to enjoy it but have to acquire it from men, this is a little bit overstated but can fully illustrate how low women were within the society."nobody sees us" can explain that women are always ignored by men no matter how much they devote to homemaking and care of their husbands. Women spend their whole time in their family after they got married, however,men, instead of appreciate women's sacrifice, they ask for more from women,they want to take fully control of their wives.…

    • 624 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays