Preview

The Effectiveness Of Year-Round Education

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1609 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Effectiveness Of Year-Round Education
iSearch Policy Research:
The Effectiveness of Year-Round Education

In 1904, the first year-round school in the U.S. was opened in Bluffton, Indiana for the purposes of increasing school building capacity and student achievement (Glines, 1995). Over the course of the 106 years since, the issue of year-round schooling and its effectiveness still provokes a strong reaction from parents, educators, and students on both sides of the aisle. The opponents of year-round education state there is negligible benefit to the year-round calendar, but the proponents cite the advantages of year-round education, stating it gives students a considerable competitive advantage over their peers. Whose opinion carries more validity? Is year-round
…show more content…
Because children were often needed to assist with farming during the summer months, this calendar was established and coincided with the needs of our agrarian nation (Research Spotlight n.d.). However, times, as well as our nation, have changed immensely since the traditional school calendar was implemented and within the last decade there has been a major effort throughout our nation’s school districts to change their calendars to a year-round schedule. The “year-round” title associated with the modified calendar is actually a misnomer, as the year-round schedule is not an extension, but actually just a reorganization of the traditional school calendar (Year-Round Schooling 2004). Palmer and Bemis (1999) state that year-round schools are defined as ones that “reorganize their calendar such that blocks of instruction and vacation are spread throughout the year to make learning more continuous. Such programs do not add instructional days to those required of students, but simply reallocate the approximately 180 school …show more content…
Although the opponents of the YRE calendar cite their reasons for their viewpoints, many of their opinions seem unfounded or ineffective when looking at empirical data comparing the traditional vs. YRE calendars. In the continuation of my research, I will be looking for more recent reports of information in regards to the effects of YRE calendars, and I will be looking to see how the trends of schools implementing the YRE calendar continues now that the President and Education Secretary have both endorsed the ideas. Additionally, my further research will look for ways this policy may advance itself, including but not limited to, increasing the hours in a school day, dramatically increasing the number of days schools are in session, or even opening schools for remedial sessions on Saturdays, a recent proposal by the Education Secretary. It is I my opinion that it will take a mix of different strategies to strengthen and increase the effectiveness of our education system, and year-round education is just one stepping stone of

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Some schools around the country are going to, or are already, year-round schools. I can see that this is beneficial to student, but I can also see that there are some things that don’t sound too appealing. While year-round schooling is good and all, it still has people that don't like it and wouldn’t use it. Year-round school is debated back and forth for a couple of reasons. There are nice things about it, and not so nice things about it. Some people like year-round school, while some people don’t.…

    • 362 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The traditional schedule for school is outdated because in the old days, it allowed for children to help harvest crops during the summer. Now, the long summer just enables kids to be lazy and easily forget what they learned at the end of the previous school year. If a year round school year were to be implemented, kids would not be able to be as lazy and breaks would not be so long as to let kids forget a whole bunch of their school curriculum.…

    • 358 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Schools should be year-round because of many factors like the fact that year-round schooling can generate strong feelings. A 1994 report, “Prisoners of Time,” argued that “a departure from the traditional school calendar could better meet the needs of contemporary society and result in increased student achievement.” Research has also shown that year-round schooling does have an effective on students. Reviews of existing literature on this subject generally contend that the achievement of children in year-round schools is as good as, or slightly better than, that of their peers in traditional schools (Palmer & Bemis, 1999; Kneese, 1996). Another example would be a study on six elementary schools where year-round schools posted overall-test-score increases that was higher than those of traditional schools (Kneese, 2000). Schools should also be year-round because the common belief is that after a long three-month summer break, students are forgetting what they learned the previous year and teachers are wasting valuable time trying to review everything from the previous year. A review of 39 studies that has been conducted showed that students test scores drop over summer vacation and that mathematics…

    • 786 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Over all public schools, there are only 4% that operate on a year round calendar. In that 4% there are 2 million students learning under a year round basis. Besides, year round schedules mitigate education loss from the previous school year. It also tarnishes the tradition of summer break, according to “Should You Give Up Summer Vacation?” by Laura Kelsey. Evidently the year round calendar is a prime solution to alter failing grades and help struggling students catch up. For instance, some students are overwhelmed with work and drama that occurs in school. With that in mind, year round schedules have more spread out recesses eradicating the overwhelming school environment. Simultaneously, year round calendars lessen memory loss between long breaks. Thus helping students retain and understand their curriculum. Lastly, studies show that American students are less proficient in academic topics.…

    • 245 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    were satisfied with their child’s school experiences (Shields 9). For over 100 years, most schools have adhered to a traditional summer vacation schedule which stemmed from our primitive technological resources and advancements. However, as technological growth was made schooling throughout the year became more practical and thus the concept of a year-round schedule was introduced. With year-round schedules now becoming ever more prevalent and traditional schedules becoming slowly obsolete, a debate has sparked between the merits of the two. This debate has involved comparing the different advantages and disadvantages of the two schedules. While a traditional summer vacation may…

    • 631 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    "Short breaks are always replenishing and students as well as the teachers can resume their schedules with renewed vigor, a fresher mind and great zeal."(Year-Round School Advantages and Disadvantages).…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The traditional 3 month long summer break is a problem for today's youth. Year-Round school is a system where students will go to school 180 days just like the traditional school system but instead it is throughout the year and not just September-June. () The traditional school system was created in the nineteenth century. The country was mainly agricultural at this time. Farms were ran by families and children needed…

    • 457 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Furthermore year round schools is not a good idea. Having year round schools is not a good idea because it could interfere with family trips, it could also interfere with the time the student has to relax, and would trouble the schools…

    • 333 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Would a year-round school schedule improve students’ academic performance? There are many debates on whether schools should extend their educational calendar to a full year. While year-round school schedules have their share of benefits, there are also negative outcomes. People often claim the more the better, but what really matters is the quality, not quantity, of education. Year-round schooling should not be organized because students may develop health issues, wouldn’t be prepared for college, and students may miss out on other opportunities during the summer.…

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Did you know that there are 3,181 year-round schools in the United States alone? In the articles called Year Round School vs. Traditional Schedules in Public Schools by Grace Chen and in the paper Should School Be Year-Round? Published by ReadWorks both help to explain year-round schools. There are several new and interesting approaches about year-round school, and there are also some positives and negatives of year-round school.…

    • 897 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When most student are asked about year-round school they think it means giving up their summer, but that’s not exactly right. Year-round school doesn’t necessarily mean giving up summer vacation. There are variety of calendars school districts follow. The current school year is based on an outdated agricultural model, when families need to use their children to help them with a harvest. Most families aren’t like that anymore. It’s time to update the school calendar to reflect modern society. Year-round schooling calendar would be beneficial to students.…

    • 342 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As grades go down teachers, parents and educators are wondering how to solve this problem. One answer they have come up with much research is year around school. However, the potential benefits of year-round school are very little and are outnumbered by the cons. The raising utility bill, scheduling complications and ironically no academic improvement are some of the many negative outcomes of year round school. True, year around school has a lot of benefits but with all the pros comes all the cons, and because of this year round schooling should be banned in all public schools.…

    • 972 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Did you know that only 3,181 schools are year round, in the United States, compared to 98,817 public schools? The article “Top 10 Reasons Why Year Round School is a Good Idea,” talks about all the reasons why schools should switch to year round schooling, including overcrowding, vacations, more frequent breaks, and brain drain. Year round schooling is not positive for schools.…

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Our school is considering going to a year round schedule, while currently, students have core classes on A or B days for the entire school year or a full semester. The school board has to make a decision on, if they want to keep the current schedule or change it.…

    • 484 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Year Long School Year

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages

    As modern society advances at astonishing rates, it is a common occurrence that many mandated policies are rarely reviewed, and often become outdated. One of the best instances of this could be depicted by the modern school year. The school year was optimized for a different time, and as such, needs to be changed. The change to an all year school would allow for improved learning, greater knowledge, and an increased number of breaks throughout the school year. The need for change in the school calendar is very crucial, and be beneficial for multiple purposes.…

    • 557 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays