Savior Sibling Research Paper
A child is born with a fatal disease and has very limited options for a donor. The parents must decide what to do. Some parents take the chance and wait for a donor to help their child, while others choose to make a baby using in vitro fertilization (IVF) to act as a donor match for their child, however, for numerous reasons, having a savior sibling isn’t the best choice.
First off, having a savior sibling is not ethical. When parents undergo the surgical process of making a savior child parents are discarding embryos. According to the Catholic Church, the process is parents throwing away perfectly good embryos just because they are not a match to their other child. Another aspect of it being unethical is it is morally wrong, and families …show more content…
The savior sibling is not made out of love, but just to save a life. Some families that tried to have a savior sibling but turned out not to be a match were prepared to even terminate their pregnancy. However, parents have children for all different kinds of reasons. For example, to benefits to the couple’s marriage, to continue on a family name, or to simply provide a playmate for an already existing child. Another thing to consider is that the savior sibling has no consent over what is done to them, they simple just have to go along with what the parent decides. This leaves the savior siblings who don’t want to provide a live-organ donation helpless. The only hope these children have under current law is if the government exercises the parens patriae power, the government authority is to intervene in parental actions to protect the child. Many more reasons support how savior siblings are only used as means to an end, but these are only a few.
There may not be many options on saving a child, but having a savior sibling is not the best option. Having a savior siblings is not ethical, can damage the welfare of the child, and is simply just used as a means to an end. Hopefully in the future, people will see how damaging having a child to save another can
First off, having a savior sibling is not ethical. When parents undergo the surgical process of making a savior child parents are discarding embryos. According to the Catholic Church, the process is parents throwing away perfectly good embryos just because they are not a match to their other child. Another aspect of it being unethical is it is morally wrong, and families …show more content…
The savior sibling is not made out of love, but just to save a life. Some families that tried to have a savior sibling but turned out not to be a match were prepared to even terminate their pregnancy. However, parents have children for all different kinds of reasons. For example, to benefits to the couple’s marriage, to continue on a family name, or to simply provide a playmate for an already existing child. Another thing to consider is that the savior sibling has no consent over what is done to them, they simple just have to go along with what the parent decides. This leaves the savior siblings who don’t want to provide a live-organ donation helpless. The only hope these children have under current law is if the government exercises the parens patriae power, the government authority is to intervene in parental actions to protect the child. Many more reasons support how savior siblings are only used as means to an end, but these are only a few.
There may not be many options on saving a child, but having a savior sibling is not the best option. Having a savior siblings is not ethical, can damage the welfare of the child, and is simply just used as a means to an end. Hopefully in the future, people will see how damaging having a child to save another can