Preview

Private Policing: Similarities Between Public And Private Security Sector

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
858 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Private Policing: Similarities Between Public And Private Security Sector
There are many similarities, as well as differences between public and private policing; however, despite differences public and private police tend to mirror each other to a certain extent (Nalla & Newman, 1990) Private policing serve as many roles in the community. Some of the major components of private policing are the alarm systems, investigative services and security guards. “Public police act on behalf of the government and society to enforce laws, maintain the peace, detect crime, respond to emergencies, assist victims of crime, and provide assistance in prosecuting offenders.” (statcan.gc) Private police are seen to be concerned with the protection of personal and corporate interest while public police represent the interests of the …show more content…
Private securities have the ability to pick and choose the tasks and duties that are performed. This is one of the main advantages that private policing has over public policing. Private security perform duties such as securing gated communities by checking for residency or employment; dress such as T-shirts and bare feet in businesses that require appropriate attire; and behavior such as loud music and obscene behavior. This is also referred to as "profiling", which public police has often been accused. “Unlike the public police, private police are not hampered by their regulatory actions by probable cause. Private policing usually operates behind the traditional and legal boundaries where the public police cannot lawfully cross unless by invitation or probable cause. This leads to the private policing sector having a "broader enterprise than public policing, with a wider range of functions." (South, 1988, …show more content…
Also, many of the laws that protect us from police abuse do not apply to the private sector. Constitutional safeguards that regulate police conduct, interrogation and evidence collection do not apply to private individuals. Information that is illegal for the government to collect about you can be collected by commercial data brokers, then purchased by the police.

We've all seen policemen "reading people their rights" on television cop shows. If you're detained by a private security guard, you don't have nearly as many rights.

Another major benefit with the private providers of security is their flexibility. They can, and will, perform most tasks they get paid to do. Their customers can demand a lot from them, since they are directly answerable to the paying clients and their needs. The private entrepreneurs are also forced to 'do right' by the market. If they fail, they will lose their money. Public police do not have the negotiation factor and are paid on salary, no matter how they perform or how efficient they are in performing their

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Good evening Richard, great response. I agree with your response. Before 9/11 private security was not as helpful as they are now. After 9/11 private security are now well known. Almost every businesses hired private security companies to provide security service for their assets. Private security officials do more than just providing security for private businesses assets, they also provide the best customers service. Many private security agencies officers are well trained in many field such as investigation, CPR, Self Defense, Verbal Judo, fire armed and more. Private Security officials knows the community they work in very well, they can also spot out things out of the ordinary. They know the people within that area as well because they…

    • 160 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    There are different licensing requirements and legal authority that govern private security in each state. These differences govern every aspect of behavior that private security must follow. They include training courses as well as registration. Also discussed in this essay is the legal authority of security guards over the legal authority of public law enforcement officers.…

    • 744 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    In past times, the private security industry was utilized as a means of backup to public law enforcement in resourcefulness and manpower. History dating back to the 1800’s shows that the police departments were few and far between and found to be commonly corrupt which created the necessity for private security. The people of these times had to utilize vigilante justice to enact some type of law enforcement. There was a need and a demand for private security. It was not until 1851 that the first national private security and investigation service was established by Allen Pinkerton (Ortmeier, 2012). After this, many individuals implemented other forms of security. For example, in 1853 August Pope had the first burglar alarm patented, and in 1858, Edwin Holmes produced the first central station burglar alarm (Ortmeier, 2012). Also, in 1958, Washington Brinks designed the first armored carriage for safe transportation of valuables.…

    • 1277 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    to be searched by police officers and are less likely to be treated as law­abiding citizens, but this…

    • 1143 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Chapter 1: American Policing

    • 4688 Words
    • 19 Pages

    The most important lesson of chapter 1, tells how the American police service have changed over time, and why it cannot be understood properly if it is examine alone. For example, in a crime scene, an officer has to gather his information from the witness otherwise he or she would never solve the crime, however, in working with the communities make their job a lot easier to find suspects. Many cases are still out there unsolved because they law enforcements can’t do the job alone. At the beginning of the 20th century, cities were staggering under the burden of machine politic, corruption, crime, poverty, and exploitation of women and children by industry. The police was less involved because during this…

    • 4688 Words
    • 19 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Private and Public Police

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In the relationship between private and public police, private police are different. Private officers do not work for us; but they do offer their services for corporations, they basically focus on the corporation that hired them. Private police has three times more than public police does. The private police care less about the due process, civil rights, and the public safety. “Private police dwells on the protection, immediate deterrence, and commercial enforcement”. (Private Security and the Law, 2004).…

    • 801 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The methods and legal limitations vary by the agency toward completing these goals. Public police attain more authority toward making arrests and detaining possible suspects, but they are under control by the government and the laws. The guards are powerless in certain situations without requesting the public police at the scene to assist with arrests, questioning, and detaining an individual, but the government and the laws do not limit private security as much as public police. The differences make the agencies useful and essential for most situations. The public police can concentrate on other aspects of public protection without spreading the agency thin to protect retail properties, private communities, and public special events because of the use of private security. The two agencies complement each other and possess frustrations. Individuals in both agencies work well, and the agencies can complete a wider range of goals when working together. Both agencies possess a love and hate…

    • 1495 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The United States government and the police must have a relationship because the laws and how the American criminal justice system is set up and ran. The rights of the people are established by the government and in most cases have to be carried out and enforced by local police. The local police vary from size throughout the United States. As the government set out to make new laws, it is the police who have to make sure that laws are being followed. The police also have a professional obligation to the public and the first component of the Criminal Justice system is the police, and different levels of policing focus on different levels of crime. The United States government has policing on the federal, state, and local level. A local law enforcement agency can run from a huge local police department to a small local police department depending on the number of people living in the community or jurisdiction of that police department. Next, would be policing on the state level, this would be your state troopers. The state police are mostly seen on the highways, but they have other duties that go beyond jus t regulating our highway. Last would be federal police agencies, federal agencies have the responsibility to enforce the laws that are only on the federal level, but unlike state and local police, federal agencies have nationwide jurisdiction. Overall the Government makes the laws for these different police agencies to enforce, the relationship between the government and police seems to be an up and down situation. The police system is not perfect and at times those imperfections in the system show because of this it makes it hard for policing around the United States. Throughout the years because of the corruption and wrong doings in some police agencies for the most part the government has to take a neutral stance in the way they follow up on police misconduct and wrong doing within…

    • 469 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The U.S. government and the policing organizations relationship is one where the policing organizations have rules and guidelines set by the government that they must follow in order to run an organized system. The government has impacted the policing organizations…

    • 437 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Fire and police protection is just one of many areas in which the market fails to give us an adequate quantity of output and desirable price. I do not know much about fire departments to know whether or not there are any that are not run by the government. I would think volunteer fire departments are not, but I am still not really sure. As for police protection, there are security companies that are not run by the government. These security companies provide security officers in a variety of places that help protect customers, citizens, etc. There are rules and regulations they have to follow by law just like any other company would, but they would not be considered government employees.…

    • 405 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Police History Policing

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The relationship between the government and police organizations affects police practices on a daily basis and at all levels, local and national. The Federal Government sets standard that need to be followed. An example of a Federal ruling regarding policing has much to do with the Miranda Rights. A criminal named Ernesto Miranda was let free based on Supreme Court Rule. In Miranda v. Arizona (1966), the Court overturned his conviction and ruled that police officers had to advise suspects of their right to remain silent and their right to an attorney before being interrogated (Walker Katz, 2011). Since then, the Miranda Rights have been a national standard that affect policing on a day to day basis. Conclusion…

    • 791 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the United States today, the average citizen is unaware of the corruption that goes on in our Criminal Justice System. Law enforcement and Police Officers are abusing their power. If this goes unnoticed it could grow larger and cause bigger problems in our country. The United States Criminal Justice System is one of the best in the whole world. In other countries there is little or no policing. Police officers in the US are well-trained and it is hard to reach their position without a strong education. A huge quality of a perfect Police Officer is a perfect control of temper because a quiet determined manner has more effect than violent action. But everyone isn’t perfect and there are Police Officers out there that abuse their power and create a dangerous environment for the people around them.…

    • 1326 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Policing Then And Now

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The history of policing can be traced back a couple of thousand years, when there were no rules, a lot of conflict and no specific structure on what is right or wrong. Some of the laws that were enforced were done so in the name of religion or politics; the outcomes of some of those punishments were cruel and callous. Before policing was established, your everyday citizens took the law into their own hands (Grant and Terry, 2017). Policing back then was done by your community and if they felt you were guilty, you were punished. Eventually, America began to establish its own policing system, modeling after the English.…

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The influence this has on the public can often be frustration, especially in a bad area that sees police acting on government agendas. On the other side of the coin, ideally the government is an extension of the U.S. society. Therefore the government should be pushing for police to provide a better service to and for the people. It is America’s society that creates a need for policing and their actions affect the decision made by the government, which in turn is represented in the courts system and in laws. It is a circle of influence, each having both a positive and negative affect on the other. Lastly, a big influence on society from the relationship between policing and the U.S. government is the laws passed to protect citizen rights from abuse by the police. The government holding a higher authority than officers helps to make sure those that uphold the morals and laws of American society are subjected to those same laws and in some cases even higher standard than an ordinary citizen.…

    • 359 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Elements of Government

    • 339 Words
    • 2 Pages

    There is one important difference between private and public governments when it comes to law enforcement, and that is how they enforce their laws. “Only public governments have the…

    • 339 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays