Preview

Personal Narrative: Why Christianity Is Unbelievable

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
3198 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Personal Narrative: Why Christianity Is Unbelievable
Why Christianity is Unbelievable: Part 1: Historical

I've been studying Christianity for over 20 years. In my youth, I jumped into it with enthusiasm and blind faith. Growing up in the buckle of the Bible belt, it seemed to be the right thing to do to seek a responsible path to adulthood.

In 1984, I received a degree in Theology and began teaching at a Bible college in St.Paul, MN. I taught there for six years, but I quit my job and changed occupations once I began to believe that Christianity was a fabrication. My discoveries are not revelations. Knowledge that Christianity has mortal problems is well documented for those willing to take the time to look.

I'm going to start a multi-part series on Why the Christian Story is Unbelievable.
…show more content…
6. Was the event required in order for subsequent events in history to exist?

Could Christianity have made it into the 2nd century without Jesus having actually been raised from the dead? Of course it could. All it takes is for someone to believe that it happened. As Richard Carrier points out, Rome could not have continued as it did without Caesar crossing the Rubicon, bringing his armies into Italy. For proof that he did, we have his own hand writing in his book The Civil War. We have hostile witnesses – Cicero. We have coins that were minted. We have contemporary historians talking about it. However, all that is required for Christianity to continue is the propagation of a story. Whether the resurrection happened or not does not keep it from propagating. You just have to get people to believe. Christianity fails the sixth criteria for historical proof of the
…show more content…
Therefore, when we are told that a man, who was stone cold dead for nearly 3 days, comes back to life via divine intervention, we have a right to require the highest proof of the event. However, I have shown that Christianity, in my opinion, cannot show the highest form of proof for the resurrection. In fact, it has the lowest form of proof – 2nd and 3rd hand stories recounted by either unknown or questionable individuals- Or, by people who were not witnesses of the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    WRSP 510 Book Review Paper

    • 5244 Words
    • 15 Pages

    full time ministry for the last 25 years, the lesson is clear. I, as most Christians I suspect, do not…

    • 5244 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    However this opinion may not necessarily be true. The base of many theories of resurrection is the bible, which suggests that talk of physical resurrection of Jesus is logical as there is recorded evidence through the accounts of Luke, Matthew, Mark and John. These accounts can be seen as evidence that theories of resurrection are logical because they are classed as eye witness accounts. Matthew reported that Jesus appeared to the disciples and said "peace be with you". They came up to him, took hold of his feet, and worshiped him.' (Mathew 28 V9) Mark also says that Mary saw a man in the tomb and he said 'You are looking for the Jesus of Nazarene, who was crucified. He has risen!'(Mark 16 V6) but Mary was too scared and didn't tell anyone. Another source of evidence was Luke's statement when Jesus appeared; 'They gave him a piece of cooked fish, which he took and ate' (Luke 24 V41-43). Then finally John said Jesus appeared to Thomas, saying 'put your finger here; see my hands. Reach out your hand and put it into my side' (John 20 V27). These accounts support a Christian materialist view that Jesus' resurrection was physical as he could eat, be touched, walk, speak and breathe. They are considered as evidence as they are written historical accounts. The evidence must be reliable; would they risk their lives for made up stories?…

    • 2689 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Should the resurrection of Jesus be considered one of the "signs" of the Gospel? Why or why not? This by far is a very controversial debate and is tossed to and fro with the theological community. The Gospel of John does not state that the resurrection is a “sign” even though the event was miraculous in and of itself, there is no biblical evidence to back up the event as a sign. The purpose of the resurrection was not to prove that Christ was who He claimed to be rather it was necessary. A sign like raising Lazarus was not for any purpose except to help those who doubted as Thomas did to believe. [1]The apostle Paul went so far in emphasis as to argue that if there is no resurrection, there is no Gospel. All that we teach and preach today would be pointless if it had not been for the resurrection, unlike a “sign” that was not necessary for our salvation. I am not saying this because of the importance of Christianity, I am simply pointing out a fact of the difference in the two. I have never been asked this question before nor have I thought about a possible argument to back up the theory. On studying and researching into this question I would have to say I am leaning toward the fact that Christ resurrection is not a sign or miracle base on specific verses in the Bible itself. Not to say that right because it is an opinion, however as I stated above, Christ didn’t rise again as a sign to help those who did not believe. I have read that the eighth sign was called the “book of glory” being the resurrection of Christ [2] instead of the miraculous catch of the fish. [3] Leon Morris says this, the miraculous catch fish in chapter 21 would certainly qualify, except for the fact that this lies outside the public ministry of Jesus. That being said I can understand both points of view and although I lean more toward it not being a sign, the argument presented makes good sense in the fact that the catching of the fish was not public.…

    • 398 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Three opposing arguments will be examined for the resurrection of Christ. Many arguments have been made against the resurrection throughout the years, but the three most popular theories will be explained. After the opposing arguments are explained, four arguments for the resurrection will be presented to refute those claims.…

    • 1763 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    I'm sure everyone has wondered in their lifetime, “Is there really a God?”. I know I have! There are many religions like Buddhism and Hinduism, but most people believe in Christianity. Christianity follows the teachings and miracles of Jesus Christ with the belief that He is God. There are many branches of Christianity. I'm writing this to tell you about why I am a Nazarene Christian. The things I will be covering are wildlife, the spread of Christianity, and the planet Earth's perfect tilt.…

    • 532 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Evil and wicked, Hollow and empty, as deep as a shallow well with tasteless, vile water lifted by the bucketful to splatter across the page.…

    • 137 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Beliefs: - There are many Christian beliefs; here are some of the most common beliefs that Christians have. - Christians believe that god created everything, from the turtles in the sea, to the air we breathe, everything seen and unseen. - Jesus is the Son of God and that Jesus and God are one together - Jesus Died after being crucified, he was buried in a tomb and then disappeared Jesus had disappeared from the tomb and was found alive (Christians call this the Resurrection) After Jesus died he was taken up to heaven where he would be with God the Father. All people can receive salvation in the name of Jesus Christ.…

    • 1171 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    HOW DID THE LIFE OF JESUS MAKE AN IMPACT UPON THE WORLD OF HIS DAY? HOW DOES THE LIFE OF JESUS MAKE AN IMPACT UPON TODAY'S SOCIETY?…

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    REL 1310.47 November 10, 2014 Review Essay Is the Bible true? Whether you are a Christian or not, it is likely you have asked yourself or someone else if the Bible is really entirely valid. William C. Placher is the author of the article “Is the Bible True?” In the article, he explains how the Bible is true no matter how it is interpreted by anyone who proceeds to read the Holy Book.…

    • 1475 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    E.F. Schumacher’s A Guide for the Perplexed was written in an age where theology and namely God have been taken off from a pedestal and set aside for other things to become kingdoms. In this text Schumacher attempts to show Christianity as the foundation of life and its principles for understanding, knowing yourself, and knowing God. Schumacher is able to accomplish this through taking the arguments for faith and Gods existence and breaking them down and explaining the accuracies from the “levels of being” to the “Four Fields of Knowledge”. He also encounters several theories and beliefs as to why to disprove Christianity, namely God. He uses several methods and themes throughout the text but I have chosen three of which to…

    • 2581 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Christian Apologetics

    • 335 Words
    • 2 Pages

    For the first time, I was on my own, flying cross-country to spend two weeks in Colorado, not for a vacation I might add. I was to attend a Christian apologetics course sponsored by Summit Ministries. The coursework was grueling, intense, and mind stretching. My living quarters were a small, rickety, 100 year old (and counting) hotel with paper thin walls shared with 99 other students. I left my sheltered home-school and was introduced to the modern, secular world of weird people, graphic videos of abortion, and the persecution of Christians in Sudan through science, history, theology, and philosophy. We were taught about the chain reactions that develop in a nation caused by unwise decisions, and looked at problems our country faces today and studied them using the Bible.…

    • 335 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The “minimal facts approach” to the resurrection question is an approach that focuses on the lowest common denominator of agreed upon facts. For the most part, all facts presented within this approach meet two criteria: “they are well evidenced and nearly every scholar accepts them” (Habermas & Licona, 2004, p. 44). This approach only considers strongly attested historical data. So strongly in fact, that they are almost universally granted by nearly every scholar, both the skeptical and believing. The basic premise of this approach follows the presentation of five facts. Acceptance is almost universal for the first four facts whereas the fifth fact, although it has a preponderance of evidence in its favor, does not enjoy the same consensus.…

    • 986 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Jesus, life myth or truth

    • 2892 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Many eyewitnesses can and have proclaimed Jesus as really a man and a man who walked on earth. These include those such as author and scholar Lee Strobel, Blumberg, gospel writer John Mark, ancient Historian “Thallus” and John McCray an author, publisher, and apologetics major. Thus the reality that Jesus can be proven through archeological, biological, chronological and biblical evidence. Biblically, scripture is the most sound proof for Christ as a real person, When it comes to lineage, he is part of one, When it comes to archeology and literature, there is more proof in the bible to prove that Jesus is real than any other person to ever have According to prophecy, Jesus is the man to have fulfilled all the (351) requirements stated earlier.…

    • 2892 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In thinking of what I have learned through this course, I am forced to admit I have always known the importance of being an active witness. I was not raised in church and developed “unbelief” in God through my teenage years. When I was saved, I was radically saved. The Lord became real to me and I told everyone I knew what the Lord had done for me. So excited was I about my newfound salvation and faith in God, I believe that I may have turned off some of my friends. One friend in particular was under such conviction that his internal struggle was very plain outwardly on his face, and yet he would not take the final step of surrender; possibly because I had been too excited and frightened him off.…

    • 3220 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    I arrived at NYU as a practicing Buddhist. Some of my first college friends were people who, mysteriously, seemed to be compassionate and intelligent people despite their Christianity, a contradiction that intrigued me. I continued to beleaguer them with questions and probe them for ideas, and soon I began to realize that much of their compassion and integrity was drawn precisely from their faith, and I became even more fascinated. Finally, one of these people (the person who, unbeknownst to me at the time, would six years later agree to become my wife) convinced me to read a gospel with an open mind and an open heart—to let Jesus speak for…

    • 6207 Words
    • 25 Pages
    Powerful Essays