Negal What Is Like to Be a Bat

Only available on StudyMode
  • Download(s) : 45
  • Published : February 13, 2013
Open Document
Text Preview
In his famous paper “what is like to be a bat”, Nagel states that we cannot understand the consciousness from the scientific point of view. He illustrated his point by provide the argument that subjective characters is a mental property and this property will make the objective study of consciousness is impossible. He also takes the example of how bat feel the world as a point to illustrate this point, that our observations or understanding of consciousness is subjective in terms of our own consciousness. I agree with his argument since I think that the consciousness and any particular experience are not divisible and consciousness is consist of our subjective point of view, therefore it is impossible to understand it’s natural reality and meaningless to focus on it objectively . In this article I will present those Nagel’s points and state the reason why I agree with him. Nagel used the term subjective character to describe one of property of our consciousness. In his paper, the definition is hard to understand directly. However, by his definition we can know that for an organism to have consciousness is for itself to feel like to be itself, which means such consciousness is only working for that organism and associated with that organism is a basically property. This term is saying that our consciousness is a subjective experience of our self only. For example, feeling happy is a mental activities and it is subjective. Everyone may express themselves by saying or showing that they are happy but the exactly feeling for a person will never be experienced by anyone else. Such a feeling is working on you and “happy” itself is a part of consciousness which is saying that if you want feel all the same that someone else feels, then you must have all your consciousness the same as that person. In order to make this term clearer Nagel introduced the example of what is like to be a bat. He argues that we cannot know what a bat experiences for some reasons. First, he...
tracking img