Preview

Monstrous Philosophy the Modern Prometheus, Paradise Lost, and Victorian Protestant Culture

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1484 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Monstrous Philosophy the Modern Prometheus, Paradise Lost, and Victorian Protestant Culture
Monstrous Philosophy
The Modern Prometheus, Paradise Lost, and Victorian Protestant Culture

Though separated by over a century, Mary Shelley and John Milton were philosophical companions, their challenging views considered controversial and heretical in their respective periods. Together they are the most prominent literary voices of the Enlightenment philosophical movement, emphasizing the romantic ideals of human goodness, compassion and free will in stark contrast to the harsh cynicism of a Calvinist society. John Calvin was an influential theologian and philosopher contemporary with Milton, who argued that humanity is depraved and salvation can only be attained through predestination, and free will and good acts cannot change whether one goes to heaven or hell because God has already decided their place. Though Milton was a Presbyterian Protestant and a supporter of the reformation, he was also an outspoken and advocate for human rights and religious tolerance. Mary Shelley was the daughter of vilified feminist and atheist academics, and a scandalous free spirit who criticized and threw off the rigid moral confines of Victorian society.
Human life was a cheap commodity in these times, the wretched were discarded into asylums or workhouses. Executions were humiliating public displays, and men like Galvani were permitted to experiment on the corpses in grotesque spectacles. Life was nasty, brutish and short in the words of Thomas Hobbes, a Calvinist philosopher who argued that all people are inherently evil from birth and therefore must have goodness beaten into them. For much of antiquity child rearing was an exercise in brutality and neglect. The modern notion that “it shouldn’t hurt to be a child” would have been a totally foreign concept in these times, and childhood was seen as an unfortunate condition best to be purged as quickly as possible. “Nature versus Nurture”, the concept that one’s upbringing influenced an individual’s mental wellbeing

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    The argument presented by Thomas Hobbes in chapter 13 of Leviathan, is that the state of nature is a state of war of all against all. Such a view had previously been discussed- earlier versions of the argument appear in other significant works- however it is Hobbes account of a state in “continuall feare of danger and violent death”1 upon which I will focus on and critique in this essay. There are many reasons why many seem to regard Hobbes argument as the most accurate portrayal of a pre-civilised society, many believe it to be so straightforward and seemingly correct that to object it would be to ignore a necessary truth. Secondly, those who accept Hobbes’ view of a human nature that is so egotistical and unforgiving, would seemingly too agree to the assumption of a gloomy, unbearable state of nature. In this essay I shall argue that such opinions are not logically justified as Hobbes’s argument holds its foundations solidly in assumption alone, an assumption that was heavily moulded on his surroundings of a savage Civil War. Hobbes’s argument lies solely on the grounds that human beings are intrinsically wicked and self-centred beings an argument that cannot be completely validated and therefore cannot be a ‘necessary truth’. Yet despite holding such a bleak outlook on the human condition and its simple invalidity the work of Thomas Hobbes still shapes the political word today2 and it continues to impact our understanding of human nature and interactions. In order to justify my critique of Hobbes I will begin by presenting both his original argument and a brief view of some modern interpretations before cross examining their conclusions against that of other social contract theorist such as Locke and Rousseau as well as rational logic to present the argument that the state of nature is most certainly not a state of war of all against all.…

    • 3361 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Unit 1 Specimen Paper

    • 1602 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Total for this Section: 60 marks Ideas about the nature of children have changed over time. The modern view is that children are fundamentally different from adults – innocent, inexperienced and vulnerable. Thus modern childhood involves segregation: children’s vulnerability means they need to be shielded from the dangers and responsibilities of the adult world. Childhood has become a specially protected and privileged time of life. Yet children were not always viewed in this way. Until the 17th century, childhood was regarded as a brief period (up to the age of about 7), after which the individual was ready to enter the wider world. Some sociologists argue that we are now witnessing a further change in the nature of childhood, and that the differences between childhood and adulthood are once…

    • 1602 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The history of childhood is a subject of controversy. Since serious historical investigation began into this area in the late 1960s, historians have increasingly divided into two contrasting camps of opinion, those advocating "continuity" in child rearing practices, and those emphasising "change". As there is little evidence of what childhood was really like in the past, it is incredibly difficult for historians to reconstruct the life of a child, much more the "experience" of being a child. In so many ways, the history of childhood is a history that slips through our fingers. Few Parents have left written records of how they reared their children, and fewer still children have left us their story. It is largely because of this lack of evidence,…

    • 3947 Words
    • 16 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein novel is about man trying to conquer the knowledge of the world and nature. This endeavor ultimately leads to his failure. In this novel there are references to a work by John Milton called Paradise Lost. In Paradise Lost God creates a man Adam and a woman Eve; Satan later tempts them to eat the forbidden fruit of knowledge and they do (Dudczak). Once they eat the fruit they are cast from Paradise forever (Dudczak). Mary Shelley uses this allusion in her novel to show her opinion of Enlightenment as she herself was a Gothic Romantic. Shelley believed that trying to conquer nature would only lead to failure.…

    • 111 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein and John Milton’s Paradise Lost have many similarities. This may be due to Mary taking influences from Paradise Lost to add to her story. Paradise Lost is the same as Frankenstein in design by defining man’s place in the universe. They both describe the forces that threaten humankind.…

    • 724 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Children Dbq

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Identify the various assumptions about children in early modern Europe, and analyze how these assumptions affected child-rearing practices.…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In early modern Europe, various assumptions were made about children and how to raise them. Some families went with detachment, tender love, or cruelty. All of these assumptions, more or less, affected child-rearing practices.…

    • 950 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the early modern masterpieces, John Milton was known for his unique ability to write in multiple languages and multiple styles of literature. One of his most famous pieces of literature was Paradise Lost. Milton was a man of deep faith, most specifically the Protestant faith. It was because of his faith that he had no fear of expressing his views on religion and the individual; he did this even when they were not in line with what was the popular view. Today we can see that Milton had a significant influence on the American mindset in his day, in ours, and he will continue to influence those in the future.…

    • 983 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hobbes was an English philosopher who had a pessimistic view on human nature. He wrote the Leviathan, in which he stated that men lived in constant warfare because of competition for the better…

    • 541 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    That men are sinister in the State of Nature could be promoted as a headline to Hobbes’s magnum opus, Leviathan. In the state of nature, men are not magnanimous beings. A notion similar to the first sin, yet different from a philosopher like Jean Jacque Rousseau. It has always been taken for granted that there are wicked and virtuous humans, yet for Hobbes, humans are innately wicked. These notions, however abstract and contradictory they may seem, are demonstrated in this short paper; Hobbes’s chapter 13 of Leviathan is abridged in this paper. First, the inclinations that drive men to behave in a wicked way are outlined step by step. Then Hobbes’s reason for having a common power is established. Generally, this paper is a reflection on Chapter 13 of Leviathan with explanation and commentary.…

    • 1395 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The western idea of childhood is presented as a social construction, aimed at highlighting a lacking in physical and physiological development. This conception is not consistent with previous ideologies, nor does it reflect a universal truth. This essay argues that historical advancement has little to no influence on childhood conceptions, as ideologies are shifted by contextual factors rather than the progression of time. Childhood ideologies have experienced little change, as reoccurring conceptions arise with a fluctuating community environment. First, this essay will consider an individual’s cultural origin, and how it affects their perspective and conceptual outlook. Following this, it will explore how the financial welfare of a community may lead to the imposition of childhood responsibilities, and hence an ignorance to youth. Finally, it will demonstrate how geographical location determines an individual’s conceptual standpoint towards romanticised childhood. This essay will be focusing on the universal development and differences in childhood conceptions, as opposed to observing individual examples due to a…

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    John Locke Research Paper

    • 480 Words
    • 2 Pages

    He believes that people who can’t agree will end up in war which causes destruction in mankind. Considering that Thomas Hobbes was around his mid-50s when the English Civil War happened. Hobbes must have been traumatized by the violence making him believe that people are corrupt and are selfish and horrible. Despite Hobbes thinking, I believe it's wrong for him to judge all of humanity based on a certain event that occurred devastatingly in his life. He should have seen the positivity in people rather than the negativity.…

    • 480 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Statius Early Childhood

    • 229 Words
    • 1 Page

    The very first Roman poet to examine early childhood was Statius who lived during the time of Emperor Domitian (81-96 A.D.) In his writings Statius writes of his joy in the presence of a boy child in his household. Further examination reveals that the baby is not Statius' son but his slave. This boy was termed in Roman times as 'Verna' meaning 'house-reared'. It is probable that the child is the offspring of Statius' own household slaves. This makes the boy strict property, to be shaped and dispensed with according to Roman law. Let me translate: the boy's early years would most likely be spent ministering to his owner's sexual desires. As shocking as this is to modern sensibilities, adult-child relations in past civilizations are not…

    • 229 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sociology

    • 531 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Childhood has not always been controlled in pre-industrial times; Aries argues that childhood is socially constructed and that ‘the idea of childhood did not exist’ soon after being weaned, the child entered wider society on much the same terms as an adult. Childhood has changed overtime as it says in item 2B “Aries describes a medieval world in which, if children were not actually the equal of adults, they nethertheless mixed freely with adults in work and leisure. Little distinction was drawn between children and adults.” Today we can tell “childhood” is a lot different, where the adults are more in control of the children for example they may have control on their free time, routines, games, programs etc.…

    • 531 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    TMA01

    • 1118 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Childhood studies has a major impact of the lives of children, studies shown from the sixteenth century to date allow us to understand the changes that have been put into place to support and guide the lives of children today. Historical evidence from the sixteenth century provides us with ideas about the nature of children and how they were seen as sinners even whilst in the womb. This was known as the 'Puritan' view, historian childhood studies showed this to be in the form of whipping, canning and other forms of punishment. Further to this view came the 'Romantic' view, that showed children to be seen as innocence and goodness when seperated from the adult world. The 18th century Jean-Jacques Rausseau (1712-1778) published a treatise 'Emile, or on education' (1762) 'where he argued that children should be allowed to develop at their own rate in natural surroundings shielded from civilisation and the adult authority that corrupted then an turned good into bad' - (An introduction to childhood studies and child psychology chapter 1 -p11). The legal definition of a child is anyone under the age of 18 and the difference between an adult and children is differentiated by children being smaller, biologically and psychologically more immature.…

    • 1118 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays