Mongol Terror, Mongol Peace Dbq

Only available on StudyMode
  • Download(s) : 720
  • Published : February 1, 2011
Open Document
Text Preview
Nigel Lewis
November 17, 2010
2nd Period
DBQ: The Mongol Terror, Mongol Peace
Although many Mongols conquered peoples of Eurasia viewed the invasion as negative during the 13th and 14th centuries, many viewed this intrusion as positive
According to Carpini and William of Rubrick, they both have positive things to say about the Mongols. I say this because document 1 states that the Mongols pay their lords more respect than any other people, and would hardly dare lie to them (Doc #1). I think this document is mainly positive because of the fact that the writer states that the Mongols are people that show good respect to their gods and lord. On the other hand they are extremely arrogant toward other people and feel that anybody that is not part of the Mongols is below them (Doc #1). Now document 4 is also positive because they mainly talk about Karakorum, the Great Kahn. Karakorum was a large orda close by the city walls (Doc #4). Karakorum was a great place with many palaces which are like churches. One of their palaces sits so high up that the Khan himself feels that he can be seen by everyone. So my point of view behind why I think documents 1 and 4 are positive is because both writers talk about how great their city and the people in it are. Based on Guyuk Khan Writings I can tell that it is negative because the Guyuk Khan is talking about accepting peace and surrendering their fortresses. The bad thing is that if the people decide not to believe the letters and agreements, they will have automatically wished war upon them (Doc #3). Based on document 6, the Taters spared no one, slaying women and men and children, ripping open pregnant women and killing their unborn babies (Doc #6). An additional document from women of that time would be helpful to understand and see if the Mongols were as badb as they say they were. As soon as one Tater would enter a village or quarter, everybody became struck by fear because the Taters would continue to slay them one...
tracking img