Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Modern Short Story Essay

Good Essays
967 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Modern Short Story Essay
Modern Short Story Essay Early 20th Century authors often wrote about the strange things and discrepancies found in society and used irony to criticize them. Katherine Mansfield’s “A Cup of Tea” and Virginia Woolf’s “The Duchess and the Jeweller” both use irony to condemn and show inconsistencies in social classes. The short stories demonstrated how being upper class or rich doesn’t necessarily mean you are secure, generous or a good person.
A main topic found in the two stories is that money can’t buy someone self esteem if they never had it. Both main characters seem to have everything but use material things to fill their insecurity and neither of them have what they really want. The Jeweller had become very wealthy and admired. He was envied by every man he encountered yet inside the Jeweller still felt inferior and as though “…he was a little boy in the alley where they sold dogs on Sunday.” (Woolf 6) At the end of the story the Jeweller sits back and thinks of how he was tricked and is the same fool he will always be. In “A Cup of Tea” Rosemary is “[A] young, brilliant, extremely modern, exquisitely well dressed, amazingly well read in the newest of the new books,” (Mansfield 1) woman. The only thing Rosemary lacks is physical appearance. She was not the best looking female and unfortunately that flaw bothered her and was one of the reasons she was so insecure. Rosemary is also rich and able to purchase anything she wanted. The only thing Rosemary couldn’t purchase was self esteem and this showed at the end of the story when she asks Phillip the simple question of “‘Am I pretty?’” (Mansfield 8)
Both stories show how the main characters satisfy their selfish needs instead of just doing the right thing. The Jeweller is an experienced and successful jeweler and knows he should make sure the pearls presented to him to purchase are authentic. The Jeweller didn’t see what he was losing, “…he saw not the houses in Bond Street, but a dimpling river; and trout rising and salmon; and the Prime Minister; and himself too, in white waistcoat; and then, Diana. He looked down at the pearl in his hand. But how could he test it, in the light of the river, in the light of the eyes of Diana? But the eyes of the Duchess were on him.” (Woolf 6) Once he believes will get Diana and pictures himself as royalty, he quickly buys the pearls without testing them to fill his own selfish desires. As a result, he is tricked. In the other story Rosemary wants to bring home the little girl so she can show her off and play with her like a little toy doll to keep to herself. Instead of just helping the poor girl by giving her money, Rosemary thinks of her own selfish desires. When deciding whether or not to bring home the nameless girl Rosemary thinks “…such an adventure. It was something out of a novel by Dostoevsky, this meeting in the dusk. Supposing she took the girl home? Supposing she did do one of these things she was always reading about or seeing on the stage, what would happen? It would be thrilling. And she heard herself saying afterwards to the amazement of her friends: ‘I simply took her home with me,’ as she stepped forward and said to that dim person beside her: ‘Come home to tea with me.’”(Mansfield 3) Rosemary thought this would be her chance to impress her friends and show how much of a good woman she was.

One final similarity found in the two stories is the demonstration of the upper wealthy class behaving immorally and manipulative. In the Duchess and the Jeweller the Duchess uses manipulation to cheat the Jeweller and get what she desires. The Duchess enters the Jeweller’s store claiming that she only has ten pearls, she states on page 4 that those ten pearls are “‘All that’s left me, dear Mr. Bacon,’” (Woolf 4). Not only was the Duchess able to guilt the Jeweller into getting she wanted she made him believe he was getting rewarded with the gift of spending a long weekend with her daughter and becoming part of royalty class. In “A Cup of Tea” Phillip was able to manipulate his wife Rosemary by aiming at her weak spot, which was her insecurity. Phillip believes that Rosemary bringing home the little girl is not amusing and an absurd thing to do. To trick Rosemary into getting the little girl to not stay for dinner Phillip attacks very sneakily. Phillip simply states “‘Good Lord!’ Phillip struck a match. ‘She’s absolutely lovely. Look again, my child. I was bowled over when I came into your room just now. However… I think you’re making a ghastly mistake. Sorry, darling, if I’m cruse and all that. But let me know if Miss Smith is going to dine with us in time for me to look up The Milliner’s Gazette’.” (Mansfield 7) As soon as Phillip tells Rosemary all these things about the little girl Rosemary is came over by jealousy and wishes the little girl to leave. So not only does Phillip manipulate Rosemary but she then allows her own jealously to overcome her desire to help the poor girl.
In conclusion, the two stories both successfully used irony to point out the how the upper class can be envied by all but still be insecure. They both exhibited main characters who are wealthy and seem to have it all but can still behave selfishly and when they do it can backfire with opposite results then they desired. The last realization is that even the highly regarded upper class can behave immorally and manipulate others.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The development of the statement, appearances can be deceiving, is a use of foreshadowing. When Mme. Loisel sees the black satin box, it appears to be the most expensive item in the box. This is an key case of foreshadowing by Maupassant. When looking through for a piece of jewelry to wear, Mme. Loisel dislikes the bracelets, a Venetian cross, gold, and gems. She finally sees something that she likes, a necklace in a black satin box which implies the necklace is an very expensive one. Mme. Loisel “hands trembled as she took it up. Clasping it around her throat, outside her her high-necked dress, she stood in ecstasy looking at her reflection”(30). This case of foreshadowing considering the box makes the necklace seem expensive at first glance. Mme.…

    • 358 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The “Necklace” story is about greed, passion for more that what one can have. In this short story, French Writer Guy de Maupassant writes about Mathilde Loisel who is consumed with the desire to have everything that she cannot have. Despite the fact that she has a nice home and a great spouse, she is unsatisfied with everything in life. All she is a think about is riches and privileges that other people have. Her craving for riches is a steady torment and turmoil. Whenever she visits her rich friends she cannot help but overcome with desire to possess of these costly garments. Sometimes the desire even put her to tears. I think craving for these things is a way to complement for things she could not afford. She so obsessed of looking better…

    • 231 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Looking at the two and comparing them you see two woman who have forgotten what it is like to do things for themselves, who have focused so much of their energy on being a wife and a mother that they cannot remember spending time and money on themselves. In this time period that each of them take place in it must have been hard to care for a family and it must have taken a lot of energy, each lady got the opportunity to see life outside of that.…

    • 305 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Short Story Essay

    • 810 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In the short stories Borders and Two Kinds, there are strong characters who find themselves dealing with difficult expectations from different aspects of their lives. Through the experiences of the characters, one learns that true purpose and identity is found through facing adversity, not conforming to how others think they should act. The characters that illustrate this phenomenon are Jing Mei in Two Kinds, and the mother in Borders.…

    • 810 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Short Story Essay

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Both authors have used situational irony in their texts to lead the readers to an unexpected ending and to display the innocence and or, guilt. ‘The Lottery’ by Shirley Jackson used situational irony to show the guilty mother and father in the text, however Ursula Le Guin has used situational Irony in ‘The Wife’s Story’ to position the readers into an innocent mind frame of the wolves. In ‘The Lottery’, Shirley Jackson used situational irony to manipulate the audience’s thoughts on the town’s customs. First portraying the lottery game as an innocent family tradition, then shocking the audience when the situational irony is used and it shows the reverse in the story. With the assistance of this technique, Shirley Jackson has now displayed a terrible competition of where stoning family members helps grow the crops. Once Tessie Hutchinson saw that her father had won the lottery she said ‘’’I tell you it wasn’t fair. You didn’t give him enough time to choose. Everybody saw that.’’’ Tessie’s words cause the audience to gain on Tessie’s innocence and also the audience thinks differently about the lottery game and why Tessie was not happy with winning. The situational irony causes the audience to contemplate the reasons why Tessie is gloomy with winning.…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Short Story a&P

    • 938 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Everybody makes hard decisions through life that mature them. In John Updike’s short story “A&P” Sammy, a nineteen-year-old clerk working the checkout line at the A&P grocery store, decides to quit his job because he stands out for his decision and fallows it thought. The story focuses on the observation, through Sammy’s point of view, of three girls that come to the store wearing bathing suits, and the reaction of the people for the commotion the girls cause. These bathing suits reveal not only the girls’ flesh, but also Sammy’s personal character. Sammy is a good observer but careless at his job; however, at the end of the story he faces the first step of maturity.…

    • 938 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Wife of Bath Tale

    • 368 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The three stories show characters with immoral values and selfish greed. They all had a scheme to get what they wanted, deceiving others. In the “Wife of Bath’s Tale” the knight immoral act lead him to descover moral values. The knight comes to the crossroads and have to choose between life or death than to marry the old woman.…

    • 368 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A&P short story essay

    • 551 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In the short story "A&P" author John Updike describes in detail what a boy's infatuation with the opposite sex can lead him to do. John Updike goes into great description about the setting. He also makes it a point to be very vivid when he uses characterization. He gives the characters names that subtlety describe their personalities and lets the reader make assumptions and accusations on Sammy's motivations for his quitting his job at the grocery store.…

    • 551 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The purpose of this essay is to fast-forward a few years and get you thinking about the college application process. Every college or university that you apply to will ask you to make a personal statement in the form of an essay that must be submitted with your application. The essay you write could be based on a single prompt or a choice of prompts, however your essay response will become an extension of your personality providing the college or university with a profound look at you as student and a person.…

    • 507 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Resolution: Turns out that a talking monkey had stolen her name name, and thus taking…

    • 481 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Necklace and The Proposal are two pieces of literary work that parallel each other in ways that include theme, content, and form. While both stories are similar in those perspectives, their only difference seemed to be the style in which the author chose to deliver the story. The Necklace is written in short story form while The Proposal is written in a one act drama form. The theme of each story delivers the same theme of accepting and respecting one another in a unique way. The authors of each literature piece opted for a dramatic presentation of social challenges that people face regarding status and the choices made.…

    • 2509 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Essay and Short Story

    • 2080 Words
    • 9 Pages

    HSC STUDY BUDDY Belonging Creative Writing Perfection?/Perfect Chaos. The steel door slid closed behind Jian with a quiet susurration, sealing the room with a series of soft mechanical clicks. The hideous moans of the Misbegotten that perpetually polluted the air faded.…

    • 2080 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    My Short Story Essay

    • 334 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Fridays and Saturdays were my least favourite days of the week. The Friday morning always started out well but then it got worse throughout the day. By lunchtime, I usually had enough homework to last me another week! That wasn’t the worst part though. At the end of the day, I had to walk to the train station, catch the 5:05 train to Castle Hill and get the bus to my employer’s house. I stayed there until the next night, enduring an earful of screaming and wailing, struggling to get the little ones in bed and get at least a few pages of study done. When my employer finally arrived, I was free to leave! But every time, I was left emotionally and physically scarred from my job. It felt like their lives were my lives and I had to be a part of it. That’s right. I was a babysitter, and I’d gotten so attached to my exhausting duties that I couldn’t leave them.…

    • 334 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Finally, there were also great differences in the stories. While they both experienced love, they loved two completely different things. They were both wealthy and used it to their advantage but Anthony’s wealth quickly diminished. Anthony spent his money on parties and alcohol to fuel his love of spending, “Here’s to alcohol, the rose colored glasses of life.”…

    • 522 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The adage says that “history repeats itself.” Criticisms of today’s society apply to societies that came centuries before. Satires from the 18th century criticize political events happening in the 20th Century. Many techniques of satire also transcend time. Geoffrey Chaucer’s “Canterbury Tales,” which many accept as the first modern satire, is laden with irony. Irony is “the expression of meaning using language that normally expresses the opposite” (Brown 1417). Although Jonathan Swift and Flannery O’Connor lived and wrote in different time periods, they both criticized their societies using irony.…

    • 1336 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays

Related Topics