Preview

Military Services Act 1917

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
541 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Military Services Act 1917
Military Services Act, 1917

Was the Canadian government justified in enacting the Military Services Act in 1917? There were many perspectives on this issue like, Francophone vs. Anglophone, this generation’s view or the generation living in that time or war, age, social status. My opinion is that conscription was a necessary to get people to fight for Canada to get alliance Support, economic gains, and nationalism.

Even though Canada was on the way to becoming an independent county it was still tied closely with Britain. When Britain became under attack by Germany, Canada was called upon to fight on Britain’s behalf. Many Canadians were recent immigrants from Britain and were ready to fight when “Mother England” needed help. Canada was fighting not only for the mother country but civilization itself. When Canada joined many people enlisted because they believed it would be over in just a few weeks. Canada’s Prime Minister Borden had promised to send 500 000 troops which was a huge number considering the entire population of Canada. Borden agreed to such a higher number because he thought that the war was a way for Canada to “prove itself” to the world. When it did not end as quickly as thought and the troops suffered huge losses the number of people enlisting dropped. Borden was being pressured to maintain the number of troops he
…show more content…
There was a huge increase in employment. Manufacturing increased and the economy did very well because of it. There were lots of jobs and work to be done relating to the fight, like building bomb shells and ammo for the war. Women saw an increase in employment too as they got to do many of the men’s jobs when they were off to war. Demand for wheat increased and wheat prices went up in Canada. Food production, especially wheat, doubled. WWI had accelerated production, mining, and forestry all of which was

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    When WW1 started in 1914, Britain controlled Canada’s foreign policy. As the war raged, Canadians disagreed over Canada’s future role in the British Empire. But some people sided with the Conservative Prime Minister Robert Borden, who wanted Canada to remain in the British Empire. His government used Propaganda to keep Canadian patriotism at a high pitch, during the War. To maintain the strength and numbers at the front lines, Prime Minster Robert Borden passed the Military Service Act in July 1917. The act introduced Conscription-forced military service. The conscription divided Canada, but it made little difference to the war effort. In 1919 , when Canada had to go the peace conference held in Paris, Robert Borden argued that Canadians’ wartime record give them the right to sit independently because even at that time Canada was still controlled by Britain. And Canada also signed the treaty by itself. Robert Borden did make huge difference in Canada’s identity by taking that small step and he made the world realize that we can be an independent country too.…

    • 297 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Before war, Canada’s “tinpot navy” had 350 sailors and 2 warships (the Niobe and the Rainbow). When Canada first entered the First World War in August 1914. Within two months, Canada sent a contribution of 30,000 men. As the great world war continued, Robert Borden managed to get 100 000 more volunteers. He had Sam Hughes lead the military and Borden provided them with weapons, ammunition, uniforms and food. Although the weapons and the uniforms were not the best, they got the job done and saved Canada money. While some were off the war, Robert had to get the rest of Canada into “war mode”. Since Canada had to provide food for the Canadian and British military, Borden had to make sure food at home was not going to waste. Everyone had to stretch the life of their food and find ways to preserve them so that they are good for a longer period of time and the army would be able to eat. Although war came as a surprise, Robert Borden displayed phenomenal leadership by organizing a strong military and getting Canada into "war mode" quickly. As a result, Canada was a part of the winning side of…

    • 1033 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    1914 was a drastic year not only for Canada, but also for the entire world as it experienced the beginning of the Great War. Economies fell drastically, lives were lost, families were separated, cities and towns were destroyed etc The war lasted for four years and these were four important years for Canada for towards the lapse of the fourth year, Canada had gained recognition all over the world. Canada had started emerging as a much stronger nation. When the First World War broke out in 1914, Canada was a much different country than it is today. At that time, Canada had a small population of eight million people. Still, more than 620,000 men served in the Canadian Expeditionary Forces. Within the first two days of the war, the Canadian forces had started organizing themselves under Sir Sam Hughes, the Minister of Militia and Defense. He appealed to the people of Canada, "I call for volunteers - volunteers, mark you. I have insisted that it be a purely volunteer contingent."…

    • 951 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Canada And Ww1 Unit 1 Essay

    • 3661 Words
    • 15 Pages

    2. Why did Canada become involved in a war that originally did not seem to concern her? Why did Canada automatically enter the war when Britain did?…

    • 3661 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The War Measures Act is often talked about is not unheard of to most Canadian citizens, however, not many people know what the act truly meant. The original War Measures Act was separated in to many sections however the most important sections were 2 – 6. The contents of the sections are what follows: Section 2, all acts and things done or omitted to be done prior to the passing of this Act and on or after the first day of August, A.D. 1914, by or under the authority of or ratified by his majesty, the king in council, any minister or officer of His Majesty’s Imperial Government, the Governor in Council, any Minister or officer of the Government of Canada, any other authority or person, which had they been done or omitted after the passing of this Act, would have been authorized by this Act or by orders or regulations hereunder, shall be deemed to have been done or omitted under the authority of this Act, and are hereby declared to have been lawfully done or omitted. Section 3, the provisions of sections 6, 10, 11 and 13 of this Act shall only be in force during war, invasion or insurrection, real or apprehended. Section 4, the issue of a proclamation by His Majesty, or under the authority of the Governor in Council shall be conclusive evidence that war, invasion, or insurrection, real or apprehended, exists and has existed for any period of time therein stated, and of its continuance, until by the issue of a further proclamation it…

    • 1120 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Pro Conscription Dbq

    • 340 Words
    • 2 Pages

    • It wasn’t necessary. Canada wasn't in any threat of danger, they had already sent many soldiers, and they needed men for their own country in preparations if they ever got attacked.…

    • 340 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Vimy Ridge Failure

    • 771 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The war helped with showing the other countries that Canada didn’t need to be supported by bigger countries and that they could support and “fend” for themselves. Canada was laughed at before in it’s effort to win a…

    • 771 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    With the war overseas, American companies stopped producing the goods of American life and created goods needed to fight a war. The increase in production helped to rebuild the nation after the Great Depression. This economy also decreased unemployment, achieving what the programs of the New Deal had intended to do. With many men off to war, women were brought into the workplace and a new trend began in the American industrial society. Women took up jobs in industry that had once been reserved for men. They worked in the factories as riveters, welders, and heavy machine operators. "By 1945, women made up 36% of the nation's total workforce." (http://us.history.wisc.edu/hist102/lectures /lecture21.html)…

    • 527 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    how did war change canada

    • 1338 Words
    • 6 Pages

    The act of warfare has never been and will most likely never be celebrated and perceived as a beneficial act for humanity. In most instances throughout history, the act of war has represented loss of life, a loss to great for any wartime triumph to overcome. Despite the negative connotations that warfare implies, a nation which goes through a major war can often emerge positively transformed. The Second World War represents a colossal juncture in Canada’s history as a nation. The war propelled Canada into the latter part of the twentieth century and the beginning of the twenty-first century as one of the prodigious, western industrialized nations. From an economical standpoint, the Second World War ignited Canada’s ascension into a fully modern and mechanized country. Furthermore, the war changed the social landscape of Canada, fully transforming the roles of women and evolving the immigration policy, which eventually lead to Canada becoming one of the most culturally diverse and interracial nations by modern accounts.…

    • 1338 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Women's Roles During Ww1

    • 295 Words
    • 2 Pages

    World War 1 was a pivotal event that affected Canada in many ways. Not only for the men that fought for their country, but also for the thousands of women that contributed behind the soldiers of the front lines. It was a heavy change for them; going from dependant housewife to being employed at some of the largest industries and factories. World War 1 was centered on Europe and began in the summer of 1914 (Wikipedia). That summer changed the lives of many families in Europe, and all over the world. Men were forced to leave their homes and families behind and fight for their countries. In result of the men’s absence, women had the opportunity to take the available jobs. It was a major step in the history of women,…

    • 295 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    For the first few years of World War I, the CEF relied solely on volunteers. (Valiante, “The Legacy of Canada's WWI Conscription Crisis”). However, the longer the war progressed, the more casualties increased, and the less men volunteered. The Prime Minister at that time, Robert Borden, had seen the decline in volunteers, and once he had returned from a trip to the trenches he became convinced that conscription was the only way to do soldiers justice (Jones, “Conscription”). The Military Service Act of 1917 was issued on August 29, 1917 and became law (“War on the Homefront”). The majority of French-Canadians and pacifists who have implored the government to not enforce conscription were infuriated. The results of the Conscription act culminated in riots and protests that required soldiers to bring order to chaos, and many searched for ways to be exempted from conscription (Canadian War Museum, “Recruitment and Conscription.”).…

    • 290 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Canada Prepares for WWI

    • 986 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Before the war had begun, Canada’s main focus was not on becoming stronger by building the military, but on developing the country in other ways such as promoting immigration. Almost all of Canadian soldiers were volunteers, which illustrates how Canada did not have a real army before the war began. Canada had a regular army of just over 3000 people out of over 600 000 Canadians that served in the war (Swettenham, 1). Canada’s small military power is also demonstrated when compared to other countries. By 1914, Britain had a regular army of almost 245,000 troops (“British...” par. 2); France had an army of 777,000 regular troops in 1914 (“French...” par. 1); Russia, the largest of them all, had 1,400,000 soldiers when they entered the war (“Glossary...” par. 1). Taking a look at these numbers shows just how small Canada’s army of 3000 was. The most significant country to compare to Canada was Germany, as the North German Confederation and the Canadian confederation were both created n 1867 (Swettenham, 1). Compared with Canada’s regular army of just over 3000 soldiers, Germany had a huge 856 000 soldiers only in their regular army (Swettenham, VIII). Germany was much more devoted to building a large army that challenged Britain’s great army, while Canada was not committed to…

    • 986 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Conscription Crisis of 1917 is that there is a depleting amount of soldiers who are fighting and even less who are enlisting. This year was one of worry and despair. After the recruiting effort in Quebec failed Canada turned to its only unused option; conscription (Wikipedia). Conscription is the horrid act of a government forcing individuals to go to war. After countless years of discrimination Canada is now forcing French Canadian to enlist, although Prime Minister Borden promised not to result to this. To make matters worse they are making conscientious objectors (people whose religious beliefs went against the war) go to war (The History Archive). After countless protests and outcries from the people this so called democracy did not listen (The History Archive). They also did not consider the families that would be torn apart and the men who had not chosen this to be their fate. Although war efforts are looking bad conscription should never be the choice.…

    • 941 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    War Measures Act

    • 1216 Words
    • 5 Pages

    With great power comes great responsibility; that famous quote from Spiderman perfectly describes the war measures act. The war measures act was created in 1914 and gave the government the full power to do anything in order to maintain peace and safety for all Canadian citizens. It was only used three times in Canadian history before it was replaced by the Emergences act in 1988. It was invoked during World War I from 1914-1920, World War II from 1941-1945 and once again during the October crisis in 1970. The question is was the war measures act necessary, or was the Canadian government over reacting over nothing? Still after 40 years since the war measures act was used Canadians and the world are debating on the answer to that question. The war measures act is very controversial because it gave the government in charge the power to remove rights form citizens. Although removing citizen’s rights is wrong the war measures act was 100% necessary and it did its job by keeping Canada safe during the hard times of war/ terrorism. Throughout this essay it will explain how the war measures act protected Canada, strengthened Canada as a nation and saved millions of lives. The war measures act protected Canada and should be given the proper respects it deserves.…

    • 1216 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sociology

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages

    For the sake of national unity, Prime Minister of Canada Mackenzie King of 1935- 1948 did not want to repeat mistakes that had occurred in the past (Quinlan, 50). As World War 1 unfolded Mackenzie King was forced to change his views on conscription (Quinlan, 50). Canada’s military had let in new troops and prepared them for war, during this time they believed conscription would not be necessary (Nelson, 42). The first military conscription divided the country (The diary of William Lyon Mackenzie King). On September 3rd, 1939, Britain and France declared war on Germany following the invasion of Poland by German troops. Mackenzie King held a special seating of Parliament with a vote directly following the debate in the House of Commons; a referendum was the elite alternative to his dilemma. “Are you in favour of releasing the government from any obligations raising men for military service?” this was what Mackenzie King had come up with. After the vote, 82.3 percent of voters, voted yes in Ontario, In British Columbia 79.49 percent vote yes. In Quebec 72.4 voters said “Non” (Quinlan, 50). This was when Mackenzie King found himself in the same position as Borden during the World War 1. Mackenzie was forced to decide between French and English voters. Firstly, for the first time being, Mackenzie King did not enforce conscription, “Not necessarily conscription, but conscription if necessary.” (Quinlan, 51). Furthermore, Mackenzie King had just made his first general tough decision that did not initialize conscription just yet but had to send men to war under the NRMA draft. Lastly, there was an election and Mackenzie made promises that he could not keep. This tells us a lot about Mackenzie and his contribution to the war.…

    • 1219 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics