KASPIL2/V24
Dr. Arleigh Dela Cruz
Performance Task #3 November 30, 2012 Bro. Armin Luistro, FSC
Secretary, Department of Education Dear Bro. Armin,
As a student from De La Salle University and a concerned citizen of the Philippines, I would like to raise up some issues that I have noticed in some history textbooks being produced and used in primary and secondary schools. When I was in Elementary and High School, I was made to believe in inaccurate things about the American and Japanese occupation of our country. These things were straightened out by my professor in De La Salle University and I believe that the children who still use these textbooks have the right to be taught what is correct.
It is commonly misinterpreted that Americans are kinder, benevolent and more humane than the Japanese. I oppose this statement and believe that it is only an assumption because the Japanese occupation was shorter and was during the World War. The Americans killed countless Filipinos in a war that they started on a land that they acquired illegitimately from the previous colonists. Spain turned the country over after they lost the war which means that they have no right to negotiate with the Americans regarding the ownership of the Philippines. The wrongdoings of the Japanese were much condensed and was more well-documented compared to that of the Americans. To support this argument, there are definitely more materials including books, videos, articles about the Japanese than the Americans. Both have contributed to our current culture but the atrocities made by both were unevenly documented and mentioned in the textbooks.
The Filipino-American War is also forgotten by our students today. As stated earlier, the Japanese occupation during the World War was documented better thus giving publishers more information to include in their textbooks. Little has been mentioned about the Filipino-American War. I only remember being only taught where, how and who started the Filipino-American war and immediately jumping to the Japanese occupation. During the Japanese occupation, the Americans were on our side only because they get resources from us and they defended us because we are part of their colony. Their support during the World War was shown but not in detail. Some of their “support” cost us Bataan due to their Battle Plan Orange and other cases as well. Nonetheless, their support made their image better in the students eyes which causes them to perceive that the Americans were more humane.
It is also a misinterpretation that we should be thankful to the Americans because they contributed education to us. First of all, we didn’t ask for it. They came and colonized us a short period after we won our freedom from Spain. As stated in the second paragraph, our country was illegitimately acquired from Spain which we defeated before they dealt with the Americans. As humans, we develop and can improve on our own without other people’s help. It’s just that some are more developed than others. What they did was to westernize our culture and to educate us just because we were a part of their colony. We shouldn’t really be thankful for something that was enforced. And besides, that does not offset the atrocities that they committed during the war and their colonization.
I truly believe that you would understand the premises and I sincerely hope for your positive response.
Sincerely,
Philip Cheng
De La Salle University - Manila
Petition signed by:
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
The ping pong balls stack on top of one another with no space between them.…
- 665 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
After reading both introductions from Dr.Loewen’s Lies My Teacher Told Me and Dr. Schweikart’s 48 Liberal Lies About American History I would have to agree with Dr.Loewen. Schweikart made accusations that facts, true facts, were missing from our textbooks and that the facts that are being placed in our textbooks are unimportant, and have nothing to do with how America’s future will look. Whereas Lowen made the point, that I fully believe, that “These books are huge”(Loewen 3). I mean don’t get me wrong I love reading. I enjoy reading about our nation’s history. I just enjoy reading about it without all the banners and highlighted words. I agree with Loewen, these textbooks are making learning about history boring.…
- 119 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
Even before the Philippines were annexed by the U.S. there was tension between U.S. troops and Filipinos. One U.S. sentry shot a Filipino who was crossing a bridge. The situation deteriorated and eventually we entered into a war with the Philippines. It would take two years to settle this dispute, as compared to the four months needed to defeat the once powerful Spain. Though the U.S. had better arms, the guerilla warfare employed by the Filipinos left the Americans outmatched. Between 200,000 and 600,000 Filipinos died in the war, most from sickness and disease caused by the…
- 735 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
James E. Loewen's book Lies My teacher Told Me is a book that should be read by everyone at some point in their lives. According to James W. Loewen, students hate history classes and when they have to take history, the students think it's boring. They repress everythingthey were taught. James W. Loewen spent a lot of time studying 12 history textbooks; he observed high school history classes and interveiwed high school history teachers. Ths is how he knows that the textbook leave out conflict or real suspense (pg 13). In his book he tells us what the textbooks lleft out or distorted about events that took place in history. He asks the question "Why are history textbooks so bad? (pg14). Nationaism is one reason; they want us to be proud of America…
- 1398 Words
- 6 Pages
Powerful Essays -
While I sit in my US History college course, the only thing I am indebted about is the academically stimulating Professor, who sanctions quality analytical dialogue. If I was required to sit through this class, accepting the fabrications and omissions of the materials, I would have opted for a great amount of “sick days”, along with a lower grade. Upon analysis of the obligatory text, however, I am incessantly reminded of why I so abhorred the subject of history since age ten. I guess I’m just not the type of intellectual, whom likes to be fed a load of bullshit, and then told to swallow it holding a coerced smile, while dutifully citing it as a deliciously satisfying meal of facts. The American history academia is overflowing with emblematic propaganda, heaving with histrionic melodrama, in which teaches pupils to think as simple-minded, white-centric citizens. Here, you will read a comprehensive elucidation on precisely why this is so apparent.…
- 2636 Words
- 11 Pages
Best Essays -
The Japanese were trained from a young age to be militaristic, playing with objects that promoted violence, and were taught that Japan is to be a supreme power and that all others were inferior. Japanese culture dictated how Japanese soldiers were to act, leading to honor suicides and kamikaze attacks. There were few Japanese POWs during the war because the majority would kill themselves before being captured. Japanese viewed Americans as weak and immoral because they did not follow the same honor code. The Japanese dehumanized Americans just as Americans were dehumanizing them. Japanese soldiers were noted for beheading Allied troops, looting homes, and practicing forced labor. These were all justified by their idea that any non-Japanese were subhuman and that they should be treated as such. The Japanese leaders were able to have total obedience to their command and total allegiance to their country from their…
- 548 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The concept of bushido, and honor was deeply engrained in Japanese culture. Not only were soldiers expected to fight to the death and to never surrender to the enemy, they also dehumanized their opponents. The Imperial Japanese Army had since the United States had entered the war, began propagandizing the enemies they faced. The book War without Mercy gives various examples of how the Japanese public saw and exemplified the United States. The book takes note of one article referred to as “The Bestial American People”. The article refers to the “real meaning of American individualism … in fact, the Americans desired to destroy ‘the divine state of Japan’ simply to gratify their insatiable carnal desires” (Dower 1986, 243). In addition the article the book mentions also portrays Americans as sadists, killing newborns via drowning and torturing Japanese prisoners of war in manners inhumane and cruel. Specifically, the article mentions that American soldiers tortured Japanese soldiers that was characterized as “only beasts and barbarians could do such things… certainly, humans could not” (Dower 1986, 243). The Japanese public and the Imperial army would find justification in the fight against the United States, believing they were combating a nation that was threatened their way of life. The total war mentality and the ideologies the public undertook made it difficult for the United States for the majority of the war to force Japan to surrender. As the United States captured more and more territory from Japan bringing them closer to a possible land invasion, it seemed that Japan was still fighting to the bitter…
- 1817 Words
- 8 Pages
Powerful Essays -
An astounding first development of the war was Admiral Dewey’s naval victory in May 1898 in the rich Spanish islands of the Philippines in East Asia. Then in August, American troops, assisted by Filipino rebels, captured the Philippine city of Manila in another dramatic victory. Despite confusion, American forces also easily…
- 3151 Words
- 13 Pages
Good Essays -
Filipinos- During World War II, Philippines was taken by Japanese Army. Filipinos in America worried about their home land, Philippines. They wanted to join U.S, Armed Force to get back Philippines to fight for the liberation of their home land. According to page 359, chapter 10, "On February 19, 1942, Secretary of War Henry Stimson announced the organization of the First Filipino Infantry Regiment: this new unit is formed in recognition of the intense loyalty and patriotism of those Filipinos who are now residing in the United State." Filipinos were allowed to join U.S Armed Force by U.S Government. Because of this new policy, Filipinos who were members of…
- 522 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
History assignments are the biggest perpetrators of drilling and copying rather than learning. In his book, Lies My Teacher Told Me: Everything Your American History Textbook Got Wrong, James…
- 683 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Loewen states the main cause for students’ lack of awareness is textbooks. Written to meet strict requirements of page length, design, and content, it has become practically impossible to write a history textbook that is interesting and acceptable to a national audience. Loewen proves that between authors, publishers, school boards, approval boards, and undereducated/overworked teachers, American textbooks have become a parade of uncontroversial, boring bites of information to be memorized and then quickly forgotten.…
- 1016 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
They were doing so well that Americans began to fear that the Japanese would take all of the prophet from farming. The Japanese had no such intentions, however well they were doing the Japanese still were very kind to everyone even though that kindness was not returned. The Japanese people had their rights and these rights were taken away from them.…
- 473 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
It is said that “history is written by the victors” (Winston Churchill) or rather “History is a set of lies agreed upon.” (Napoleon Bonaparte). Unfortunately, today in the state of Texas both statements appear to be true. The study of history is intended to help one piece together the constant evolution of past events, religions, philosophies, politics, societies, and economics. By cutting out portions of historical information students have missing pieces in the puzzle of history and this limits many student’s potential of fully understanding the complete picture. As a result this cultivates ignorance in our complex multicultural society. There have been many historical figures that were very good at limiting information and presenting a particular ideology, this is also known as propaganda.…
- 2241 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The treatment of Japanese Americans in America did not improve immediately after the war ended. The Japanese were still kept in camps six months after the war ended and unfavorable opinions lingered on the Japanese until the 1950s. They had a difficult time recovering after leaving the camps, as they had lost all of their money and land prior to their internment. The physical and mental impact this experience had on the internees was very detrimental to their lives and trust of Americans. This era in American history is now rightfully recognized as a violation of citizens’ rights to civil liberties.…
- 655 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Recto covers a whole range of information that is relevant for this research. However, its value is in its information that it provides about the guerrilla groups, how they were formed, and the roll that the youth played in fighting the Japanese. In order to give the reader an idea of what the guerrillas were up against and why they were so determined to fight against the Japanese, I will be referencing Captain Vicente M. Agdamag who wrote, 150 Days of Hell Japanese Invasion of the Philippines 8 Dec 1941-May 1942. His real accounts of his time in the area of study during the Japanese occupation gives a very clear picture as to the horror that was going on and why they people chose to fight against the Japanese. Being a Filipino commander it makes his work even more relevant than the work would be had it been from an American who was there during that time. Because Agdamag does such a great job describing what went on during that time he also gave great accounts of the military movements, this includes both the movements of McArthur (when he was still in the Philippines) as well as the guerrillas. This military information will prove to be vital to constructing this research paper. The final key to my research is a documentary that was created entitled, Bloody War with the Japanese Invaders - The Philippines Hell. This documentary gives a great account over everything that was going on in the area well after…
- 1249 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays