Just Do What The Pilot Tells You Essay

Crispin Sartwell is a believer in humans being, at the core, extremely evil. He believes that people just need the right motivation to commit evil acts as he explains in the writing “The Genocidal Killer in the Mirror.” Theodore Dalrymple is a British physician who believes in personal ideas, but he thinks following authority is better for everyone’s welfare even when one does not agree with the authority. He explains his reasoning for this thinking in his writing “Just Do What the Pilot Tells You.” Sartwell would contrast with Dalrymple’s ideas because he believes people follow authority too willingly, while Dalrymple believes people should follow authority willingly for the good of whatever situation they are in. Sartwell gives many examples on how different people in different parts of the world killed others just because they were told to by
In both writings, Sartwell and Dalrymple both give examples on how people can be motivated into doing evil things. Dalrymple does this by commenting on an experiment that was conducted by Stanley Milgram. This experiment was created to prove that people will do what they are told even when it comes to causing great harm to another person for virtually no reason. In the writing “Just Do What the Pilot Tells You,” Theodore Dalrymple admits that “By a series of clever manipulations, Milgram proved that it was obedience to authority that led people to behave in this fashion.” Although Dalrymple suggests that Milgram manipulated his subjects, he still admits that obedience led the subjects to commit awful acts. Sartwell shows how people can be motivated into doing horrible acts for others with the example of the Rwanda Hutus. The Hutus were offered cars and houses to kill the Tutsis. This shows how average people can be coned into doing other peoples dirty work with the right