Conflict of Norms and Legal Reasoning in the European Union Law

CONFLICT OF NORMS IN EUROPEAN UNION LAW AND THE LEGAL
REASONING OF THE EUROPEAN COURT OF JUSTICE
A thesis submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy by Gerard Martin Conway

School of Law
Brunel University
December 2010

ii

Abstract: This thesis examines the topic of conflict of norms in European Union
(EU) law and the legal reasoning of the European Court of Justice (ECJ), arguing that the framework of conflict of norms provides conceptual insight into justification and the role of value choices in legal reasoning. After examining the theory of conflict of norms, which seems to have been relatively under-studied generally and especially in EU law, it examines three particular aspects of norm conflict resolution in the legal reasoning of the ECJ and EU law: conflict of interpretative norms, especially the opposition between conserving and innovative interpretation; conflicts of human rights norms, looking in particular at the idea of a hierarchy of rights and of specificationism in the articulation of rights; and conflicts of competence norms. It concludes that the scope exists for a fuller justification of the choice of norms in the legal reasoning of the ECJ and generally in EU law and offers a perspective on how the values articulated by the EU suggest particular approaches to norm conflict resolution by the ECJ in its decision-making in these fields, in particular, a greater resort to lex specialis and originalist or historical interpretation, in contrast to its current method.

iii

Summary Table of Contents
Notes and Acknowledgments…………………………………………………………......x
Table of Abbreviations………………………………………………………………......xii
Table of Treaties and Legislation……………………………………………………...xvi
Table of Cases…………………………………………………………………………...xix
Chapter 1 – Values and Conflicts of Norms in EU Law and the Legal
Reasoning of the European Court of Justice – Introduction and

Bibliography: Press 2008). Press 1989). Press 2002). Press 2007). J. Bengoetxea, The Legal Reasoning of the European Court of Justice (1993). B. Bercusson, European Labour Law (Cambridge Univ. Press 2nd ed. 2009). I. Berlin, Four Essays on Liberty (Oxford Univ. Press New ed. 2002) (original edition 1969). P. Bobbitt, Constitutional Interpretation (Blackwell 1991). R. Bork, The Tempting of America: The Political Seduction of the Law (Simon & Schuster 1990). I. Cameron, The Protective Principle of International Criminal Jurisdiction (Ashgate 1994). P. Craig, EU Administrative Law (Oxford Univ. Press 2006). P. Craig & G. de Búrca, EU Law (Oxford Univ. Press 3rd ed. 2004). P. Craig & G. de Búrca, EU Law (Oxford Univ. Press 4th ed. 2008). D. Davidson, Subjective, Intersubjective, Objective (Clarendon Press 2001). A.V. Dicey, An Introduction to the Law of the Constitution (Macmillan 1885). J. Dickson, Evaluation and Legal Theory (Hart Publishing 2001). S. Douglas-Scott, Constitutional Law of the European Union (Longmans 2002). B. Driesser, Interinstitutional Conventions in EU Law (Cameron May 2007). R. Dworkin, Taking Rights Seriously (Harvard Univ. Press rev. ed. 1978). R. Dworkin, Law’s Empire (Harvard Univ. Press 1986). R. Dworkin, Freedom’s Law (Harvard Univ. Press 1996). R. Dworkin, Justice in Robes (Harvard Univ. Press 2006). JH. Ely, Democracy and Distrust (Harvard Univ. Press 1980). N. Emilou, The Principle of Proportionality in European Law: A Comparative Perspective (Kluwer 1996). J. Finnis, Natural Law and Natural Rights (Clarendon Press 1980). N. Foster, Foster on EU Law (Oxford Univ. Press 2006). L. Fuller, The Morality of Law (Yale Univ. Press revd. ed. 1969). K. Goldman, S. Berglund & G. Sjöstedt, Democracy and Foreign Policy, the Case of Sweden (Gower 1986). P. Goodrich, Reading the Law: A Critical Introduction to Legal Method and Techniques (Blackwell 1986). RM. Hare, Moral Thinking (Oxford Univ. Press 1981). C. Harlow, Accountability in the European Union (Oxford Univ. Press 2002). HLA. Hart, The Concept of Law (Clarendon Press 2nd ed. 1994). F. Hayek, The Political Ideal of the Rule of Law (National Bank of Egypt 1955). D. Held, Models of Democracy (Polity 3rd ed. 2006). R. Higgins, Problems and Process (Oxford Univ. Press 1994). F. Horn, Reservations and Interpretative Declarations to Multilateral Treaties (TMC Asser Institute 1988).