Preview

Hegemonic Masculinity In Canada

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1009 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Hegemonic Masculinity In Canada
Masculinity and the ideals of manhood are not universal; place and time are factors of masculinity and hegemonic masculinity is no different. According to R.W Connell hegemonic masculinity is the one form of masculinity in society that has the most authority and influence on boys and men of that society. This form of masculinity sits at the top of the masculinity hierarchy and as a result those who attempt conform to hegemonic masculinity not only gain an advantage and privilege over other forms manhood but also over both genders (Connell, 171). However, because hegemonic masculinity is an unattainable ideal, men often go to extremes to confirm their masculinity to themselves and other men in their lives. Using the articles "’Talk About Strenuous …show more content…
The first is the ideal of the “self -made man”. This form of masculinity according to Stacy Lorenz and Geraint B Osborne, is idealized by the middle class and it incorporates characteristics such as “industrious, sober, religious, compassionate, morally upright and responsible for his own welfare and that of his family” (129). The other form of manhood is idealized by the working class in Canada and is one where their masculine identity is formed in their leisure time. This masculine ideal is characterized by “such activities as drinking, gambling, fighting, and blood sports” (Lorenz and Osborne 129). Men utilize these individual masculinities together by applying the characteristics of the “self made man” into their career and family life and by applying the “leisure manhood” characteristics in their social life. Therefore, forming a theoretically, cohesive masculine identity. Boys and men learn to incorporate these two forms of masculinity through “fraternal orders, fire brigades, militia companies, and sports clubs” (Lorenz and Osborne 130). Essentially, hegemonic masculinity is taught and learnt in spaces of male comradery, and male mentorships (fathers to sons, coaches to players and male peer …show more content…
These narratives reinforce the link between masculinity and violence as it forces men to feel that their manhood is threatened by women. Therefore, breaking the narratives and starting new ones where feminism can be viewed not as a dividing tool women use for a power grab but a uniting tool used to shed light on the harm hegemonic masculinity can cause resulting in progress for both genders. To break the link between masculinity and violence boys and men need to be taught that emotions, and being gay are not anti-masculine but that masculinity is a malleable and one ideal should not be the standard but that they can make masculinity their own. Overall, to reduce the negative impact of toxic masculinity on people of all genders campaigns like the White Ribbon which is “the largest effort in the world of men working to end violence against women” (White Ribbon Campaign 188). This campaign works to reduce the negative impact of toxic masculinity for people of all genders as it forces men to face and challenge their perception of masculinity and to counter the serious issue of violence against

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    “Boys will be boys,” a commonplace phrase that constitutes a diffusion of responsibility away from the male perpetrators of aggressive attitudes and behaviors, supports a dangerous rhetoric that a young male transitioning into adulthood will perform acts of aggression, display a detached and uncaring disposition, and develop attitudes of intense homophobia and sexism as part of a biological norm of that stage of adolescence, a stage of life comprising a larger and larger part of young man’s life, ages 16-29. Kimmel challenges this rhetoric, arguing that there is an underlying culture of entitlement (as the gaining of equality by other groups such as women and minorities are perceived as a threat to privileges that the white man “deserves,” a zero-sum game of status) that is supported by a culture of silence (of refusing to bear witness to other men’s transgressions, which is perceived as support) and a culture of protection (in which communities shield “their” guys from the harsh implications and accountability) which allows these behaviors and attitudes to persist. Kimmel argues that…

    • 598 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The article written by Michael Messner explores what are some true contributing factors that prepare a young boy in male-hood leading up to masculinity. He analyzes how creating the male masculine identity for a young boy can be a result of participating in organized sports. He conducted his research starting out with interviewing 30 male athletes who mostly played baseball, basketball, football, and track. Each interviewee was retired and had at least been an athlete for 5 years.…

    • 571 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hegemonic masculinity is defined as the condition in which men are dominant and privileged, and this dominance and privilege is invisible. This means that men are in the dominant social position and women are in the subordinate social position. A good example of hegemonic masculinity would be found in Super Bowl Commercials. The article “Hegemonic Masculinity in Super Bowl Commercials” by David Mayeda analyzes the impact hegemonic masculinity has on society. According to Mayeda “football is a sport event, in which only men are allowed to participate, where violent collisions are celebrated, and where most of the audience is male. The article discusses how hegemonic masculinity was first developed by theorist Raewyn Connell. Connell used the…

    • 240 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The author, Christina Hoff Sommers, 2003 article entitle “Men-It’s in Their Nature” vividly discusses cultural rearing and social assumptions regarding semi-outdated preconceived notions of stereotypical male masculinity and its impact on an ever evolving modern society. She uses several types of rhetorical elements which are hyperbole, comparison/contrast, and paradox in this article.…

    • 654 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Connell maps out a hierarchal structure of social relations to organize/define masculinity: hegemonic/subordinate/complicit/marginalized. How accurately do these tiers reflect masculinity as it is made manifest today? In politics? Sexual(ity) relations? Mass media/popular culture? For instance, is “gayness in patriarchal ideology” always to be considered what is “expelled from hegemonic masculinity”…

    • 451 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    What does it mean to be a “man?” Unfortunately, in American culture this is all too important of a question. According to sociologist, Michael Kimmel, being a (white) man entails having much anger, violence, and entitlement, which he describes further in his book: Angry White Men. These actions are also displayed in the 2007 film, The Departed, which follows the story of two white men on their journey to take on the Irish Mob along with the Massachusetts State Police Department. But, where do these actions come from? In this paper, I will be arguing that men in today’s society act out while trying to fulfill the ideal masculine role that is shaped by American society’s social expectations and social institutions including the family,…

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    These traits vary by location and context, and are influenced by social and cultural factors. It is important that we understand that behind the bravado and the tough guy posturing, there is human complexity in each man and boy: for some men and boys, the abuse they suffered as children; others their problems in relationships or their fears and vulnerabilities are stuck behind the stereotype they think they should be. Behind the guise is the real boy and man, the results of a sensitive, caring emotion filled man. Boys and men at a very early aged are taught to be tough, and told to “be a man”. Fathers, family members and TV shows are telling boys what they need to be at an early age. Making it hard for us to see behind the guise. “Many cultural analysts would argue that if you want to understand the meaning of something in society, look at its representation in the media”. Men are shown as something they are not able to uphold. Men are expected to be tough and strong throughout the media. Men think that women need strong, emotionless men to provide for them. I believe women, society and social media will not let men let go of this ego they are suppose to uphold. Women make it hard for us to examine mas because they like what they see in magazines and movies, This is all shown throughout the media and does not help us examine…

    • 524 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Summary of Masculinity

    • 468 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In this essay called “The High Cost of Manliness” written by Robert Jensen, a journalism professor at the University of Texas, in Austin, he tells us that “if we could get rid of the whole idea of masculinity, we have a chance to create a better world for men and women.” He states that it’s not easy to be a man in our society, especially with the demands that come with the dominant conception of masculinity, which is where men are perceived to be tough, competitive and aggressive and must show those qualities in order to prevail as a “real man.” He mentions that DNA does play a big role in a person’s behavior and that our genetic endowment is influenced by culture. The guys that don’t meet these expectations and who are caring and show compassion toward others are often called sissies, fags, or even girls. Jensen states that culture also seems to be linked to a recurring intellectual fad called “evolutionary psychology”, which creates a gender difference between men and women, and thus making it necessary to choose which gender distinctly shows more masculine characteristics than the other. For example he reminds us of the 9/11 World Trade Center tragedy when male firefighters rushed into burning buildings, risking and even sacrificing there lives to help save others, and recognizing this as a sign of strength and masculinity, who is to say that women wouldn’t have done the same if put in that same situation. Jensen explains that the reaction to rush in a burning building to help those in need by those firefighters was “simply human” and for society to automatically assign these type of human qualities to a specific gender is “misguided and demeaning to the gender that is assumed not to possess these qualities.” Yes there are obviously physical differences between men and woman such as size, and reproductive organs, but he says when you think about it, men…

    • 468 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Exploring the construction of hegemonic masculinity, we go through a contradicting state of the definition of manhood. Although contradictions appear, it is socially adapted and able to reside without conflict. Take manhood as this, “We think of manhood as a transcendent tangible property that each man must manifest in the world” (Kimmel, 1994). Meaning that manhood is merely an idea which is drilled into a man’s head by society, “Gender, we said, was an achieved status” (West and Zimmerman, 2015) in other terms, manhood is a socially agreed upon idealization of how men should act or who they should be. In West and Zimmerman’s “Doing Gender”, Hegemonic masculinity is accomplished by the unavoidable categories of sex and gender and ways we act upon them; collaborating together in a socially constructed standard of how to be.…

    • 1536 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    He argues that most girls are doing way far worse than boys .furthermore; he explains that Black male and Latino learners are disrespected and disregarded at colleges and universities. Likewise, African, American and Latina women are also under respected this is because of construction of masculinity. He argues that the boys aspire some form of construction of masculinity that drives them to behave in a weird and unexpected manner toward girls. However, he does not condemn the boy for having such behaviors. He argues that the streets are to blame since they offer the male adolescents an alternative method and routes towards manhood. This leaves them with no other option but to develop masculinity to survive and penetrate through the streets’ corners. As a result, the male adolescent boys ends up defending themselves from rival gangs earn their living through illegal activities and show masculinity to achieve their…

    • 574 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    robs paper

    • 958 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The American culture embraces masculinity through many aspects of their everyday lives. The way they conduct work in the work place, the principles of teaching young adolescents in school, and the largest factor, the mass medias pervasive involvement. Masculinity is defined by physical capability, financial independence, authoritarian values, and male dominance. These qualities are not completely supported by all men, but a large amount of society do embody these masculine ideals and notions. These notions do not embody the homosexual male community; they have an entirely different perception on what notions capture the essence of masculinity in the U.S society. In the institution of family, a masculine man is the bread winner, the engineer of a home, a strong provider, and a father. In the current U.S society, some of these standards have drastically changed. Many men are no longer the financial provider, but are “househusbands”, a new terminology being used to describe a husband who is a stay at home father while the wife works.…

    • 958 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Masculinity In Canada

    • 291 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Geoffrey Canada wrote in his book Reaching up for Manhood, "The image of male as strong is mixed with the image of male as violent. Male as virile gets mixed with male as promiscuous. Males as intelligent often gets mixed with male as arrogant, racist, and sexist." In this way many people define the masculinity and try to conform boys in these stereotypes which negative influence on boy’s development and behaviors. This image of masculinity started in antiquity and is still predominate in our days. Gender roles are distributed when babies are born by their parents then by the society. All these roles restrict men to behave like women and reverse. To have healthy society with healthy men we need to reexamine our attitude on the male education.…

    • 291 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Path to Manhood

    • 1265 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In “Manhood: The Elusive Goal”, Mark Gerzon argues that masculinity, or the "masculine code of conduct" is exemplified by smoking, drinking, and violence- acts that would be generally frowned upon in society. Mark Gerzon, attended Harvard University and was considered to be a best selling author by his senior year, due to his book "The Whole World is Watching: A Young Man Looks at Youth Dissent". Gerzon generally writes about topics dealing with men and masculinity in regard to modern day society. In "Manhood: The Elusive Goal", Gerzon reflects back on his own personal experience during his adolescent years, and how he wasn't considered to be masculine enough since he didn't conform or follow social protocol to becoming a man. He states that young boys are influenced by media and the rest of the world around them to be tough and hard, quick to use violence, and be wary of women. While pondering the questions, what is manhood and how does one achieve it, Gerzon concludes that since there are no defined rites of passage to manhood, a man must prove not what he is(a man), but instead what he is not, "anything that is feminine."(10). By using logical, credible and emotional appeal, as well as real life examples, such as sports and media, Gerzon successfully persuades his targeted readers- society in general, that there is no true defined rite of passage to manhood, and that the pressure put on young boys by society is harmful and ultimately leads to their downfall.…

    • 1265 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Men and boys also suffer from things like domestic violence. Those who are abused, are told that they’re ‘weak’ and need to ‘man up’. Things like this tells men, not only that they should act a certain way, but also that treating people badly is okay if their different. Which leads to bullying. This is done by implying that ‘like a man’ is better than being 'like a woman'. Men who are abused by their partners are seen as jokes. This is because a lot of people have the idea that men need to be ‘strong’, ‘manly’ and ‘unemotional’. Because being anything close to a woman is apparently an insult. And contrary to popular belief, feminism fights for men too. Feminism is about equality, not one gender being better than the other. Men are assaulted and abused because of sexism. They are laughed at for wearing skirts or dresses. But do you know who mostly does this to them? Its other men. Men are the ones insulting other men for being ‘weak’, because that’s being ‘like a…

    • 821 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Guyland Paper

    • 1269 Words
    • 6 Pages

    In Guyland, Michael Kimmel chronicles the journey of young males and the issues they face while trying to exert their masculinity and prove themselves to their peers. Based on interactions among North American males between the ages of 16 and 26, Kimmel has found that at an age where young men had previously prepped for a life of work and committed relationships, they are now living in “Guyland” where they spend their time drinking, playing video games, and having immature relations with women. Kimmel explains that these young men are “frighteningly dependent on peer culture” and “desperate to prove their masculinity in the eyes of other boys.” (30) These young men live in constant fear that they will not measure up to the ideals of masculinity, which are wealth, power, status, strength, and physicality.…

    • 1269 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays

Related Topics