Compare and contrast Achilles and Gilgamesh. Are they villains or heroes?
Two oldest and greatest poems "Gilgamesh" and "The Illiad" begins with description of the protagonist works. Both main characters in the poems are very young, strong, brave, endowed with extraordinary beauty and indomitable energy. Each of them is a model of selfless friendship. We see that in poems the death of a friend pushes both of them to decisive action, leading to the end of poem.
There is no doubt that positive hero should have great physical strength in order to perform miraculous feats. And asking who is the stronger Gilgamesh or Achilles is pointless. They both are equal. Nevertheless, with Gilgamesh can complete only Enkidu, who for this purpose was established by the Council of the Gods. All other heroes are inferior to Gilgamesh, not because he is victorious in the battles with the lions and bulls, it is because he tackled with impossible task. How a person must possess the courage to act alone against the host of supreme gods? Is it comparable to self-will, the determination, the power of Gilgamesh and Achilles? The First is against the will of Gods, the second let to the faint of heart Agamemnon take away his concubine. First with his friend overpowered monster Humbabu and celestial bull, the second comes out the winner in a fight with inferior in strength Trojan, and it was because of the supreme Gods of Achaeans the outcome of the match was a foregone conclusion even though the armor that Achilles wore in the battle was made by Hephaestus. However the main thing is - the first administers the feat in the name of the human race and the second - in the interest of Agagemnon.
As for beauty of Gilgamesh, it is confirmed by his life circumstances. Ishtar is not immediately drew attention to the beauty of Gilgamesh, but in the moment of inner satisfaction after completed feat He washed his matted hair,...
Please join StudyMode to read the full document